Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: gawski on July 07, 2008, 08:51:31 PM
-
Has Hohner ever manufactured a 10 treble button/4 bass button accordion?
Does any manufacturer still make them?
-
Yes, here's one that has just sold on eBay.
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=150265037219&ssPageName=STRK:MEDW:IT&ih=005 (http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=150265037219&ssPageName=STRK:MEDW:IT&ih=005)
Plenty more like this about. They usually come in C or G and occasionally D.
-
And even less occasionally in (German) B!
-
And here's a current listing in the more modern colour....
http://cgi.ebay.com/Old-Hohner-Button-Accordian_W0QQitemZ140247591402QQihZ004QQcategoryZ16218QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
-
Picture 3 shows the key stamped in the bottom of the keyboard but I can't make out if it's a C or a G.
-
That one was in G according to the description - I was not being facetious - just saying that a few did come (ex works) in Bb as well. I reckon that they reduced the choice (bit like Henry Ford) to C for the 1140 & Terzett before discontinuing them altogether when they moved the job Eastwards?
Regards, Bruce
-
No, no, I wasn't implying facetious behaviour at all, at all. Just pointing out the markings on the active item which doesn't state the key in the description.
My main workhorse box which I use for Zydeco is a Marc Savoy Acadian in B flat. It's a great key for growling the blues but I also like playing English trad on it.
Needless to say it's been barred from the session by all the D/G players. Perhaps I'll join a brass band. :-\
-
Don't worry Rees! We'll all be happy to sit and listen (time out) when you play the four-stop in a session.
Our NW Morris side like an occasional change of sound, so we play 4-stops in C. They still growl in a disturbing manner, but can be played loud - unlike the extremely air hungry G tuning. After all, if it's good enough for Ed Rennie ...
-
I think Hohner stopped making the 10 row, 4 bass button accordions quite a few years ago..but they certainly exist, especially in North America, which seems to be the graveyard [or museum] of antiquated forms of button boxes, you can usually find a few for sale on ebay...it's a gamble as to what condition they're in, pictures don't tell the whole story [although they do help]...Being fond of the single row format, I've gambled a number of times and been both pleased and disappointed, but when the gamble involves less than $100 or a bit more $, I don't mind. The nice thing about these boxes [for me] is that they have more harmonic possibilites on the left hand [i.e. a C box has C, F and G chords] than the 4stops so much in favour at the moment [which only have the 1 and 5 chord on the bass side], and you can "pump" the bellows harder than with 2,3,4 row accordions...they're much lighter, although limited in scale. There are many brands other than Hohner that come up on ebay, mostly made before the 2nd. world war, of varying degrees of quality...Hohner usually has the advantage because the bellows has a wooden frame that attaches to the body rather than just a piece of cloth that is glued to the body, which will tear away over time...that said, the variety of single row instruments made in the old days is amazing, as is the individuality of sound achieved by all of the companies producing them...one thing to watch out for...some of the older single rows have an old-fashioned chord format on the bass side which you may or may not like..in the case of a C box you might have a C chord, a G chord, an A minor and an E major chord [no F chord]...some of the single rows from the former East Germany still keep to this format...anyhow, the single rows are out there, just takes a bit of time to find them ..or else look to the the Italian duo bassi system, which is similar, but quite a different story...
-
Another nice feature of the Hohner 4 bass is that they are really loud probably because the reeds are mounted flat.
-
And here's a current listing in the more modern colour....
http://cgi.ebay.com/Old-Hohner-Button-Accordian_W0QQitemZ140247591402QQihZ004QQcategoryZ16218QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
Yes, a bit more modern but maybe not the "most modern". When I was looking at buying my first melodeon in about 1991, I noted that Hohner listed the Pokerwork two-row in D/G and a "one-row version in D/G". The one-row version (with the four basses) looked very similar to the usual Pokerwork, just one row of buttons treble and bass side. I'm guessing that the "second" set of basses had a D-push, allowing at least some possibility of hitting a D-bass with the all the notes in the D scale arpeggio. How they handled the C#, I don't know.
I quickly realized that buying a two-row with 8-basses was a good thing and now I'm thoroughly glad that I did. But soon after, I was at a dance event and a woman who was with Spruce Hill Morris in Philadelphia showed up with one of the one-row/4 bass models. But I never played it or even asked her how it worked for her.
So, they are certainly around and at least some of them may be the "Pokerwork baby brother" model from (I'm guessing) the 1980's. The model dropped off Button Box's advertised list in the US soon after 1991 or 2 or so. I also have the strong suspicion (but no factual evidence to back it up) that all these one-row/4 bass Hohner models were German made. I don't ever remember seeing one being played for Morris or in a session in the UK.
-
I've occasionally played my one-row in G for morris in the UK.
-
I've occasionally played my one-row in G for morris in the UK.
Do you have a one-row, four-bass in G? If so, is there a C# anywhere for playing in D? How are the basses arranged?
Thanks, BH, NC USA
-
Treble side is just a standard G scale, no accidentals. Bass has G/D and C/C so the only C# is in the D chord.
-
Speak for yourself, matey, maybe you've got a special jazz model, mine doesn't have the Dmaj7 option...
I really ought to sell it, it's not really earning its keep.
-
OOps! sorry, no C# in the D chord, just the usual F#. :-[
-
Treble side is just a standard G scale, no accidentals. Bass has G/D and C/C so the only C# is in the D chord.
__. OK, so you have to treat the C# like any single row in G -- either skip it, pull something wild on the bass side, or a harmony on the treble side .... or ... something else? :)
BH, NC USA
-
Yes, except there's nothing wild to pull on the bass, none of the bass chords contains any note that isn't present on the treble side. I mostly stick to tunes that don't modulate. I suppose you could vocally interpolate a C# if the mood took you, but you'd have no good chords to play with it. One-row is as one-row does, I guess.
-
Hmm..I do play a single row G pokerwork. There is no C# to be found, but it may be "implied" by playing the nearest note appropriate to the melody. One may have to shut down the left hand chord-bass accompaniment in order to sound the right note, so what? The limitations of the single row force one to be inventive and to break the rules a bit. The emphasis I see in most of the younger players is on melody and embellishment, perhaps because many of them learned their tunes by reading music, not by ear in a traditional setting where people were dancing to the music...it's become listening music rather than dance music [or a weird combination of both, where changes of key give the dancers a "lift", or incredible fingerwork, triplets, etc. impress and bedazzle]...For drive, chordal invention [odd combinations of bass and chords that fit the music] I'd take a single row anytime...but ,I would go out of business as a professional musician [unless perhaps I still lived in Nfld., but even there the Irish Virus has taken hold]...plus I would drive all of my guitar playing accompanists crazy [who would usually choose to play all of the wrong chord patterns , mostly dating back to Planxty and Bothy Band recordings that have nothing to do with what I play]. V
-
Thought about my previous post today...frustration with accompanists trying to back up single row music is understandable [the patterns we've heard in contemporary Irish music don't translate if the box player uses the left hand, which I do]...but then so is the bewilderment of the accompanist, because there are no minor chords. On a D box, one has D,G, and A chords. To play in Eminor [triad of E,G,B] one needs to pull to get those notes, leaving G or A chords as harmonic options....one might think of the E and G notes as part of an A7 chord, and the B as part of a G chord...which involves a lot of jumping about on the left hand buttons, or doing weird suspended chords [G bass, A chord or the reverse or perhaps at endings a suss of G and A chords]...in any case it can be done, but the tonality requires a whole re-thinking. I will say that recordings from the 20's and 30's seldom included minor chords or modulations, and they sound great [perhaps it's just the spirit of the old time players shining through] but of course things do change and progress...each generation develops its own set of ears. I do play lots of Irish music and use all kinds of embellishment and often change keys and enjoy doing so, but on the fiddle, not the single row [although modulations are possible, but this post is already too long, save that for another day].