Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: dahlberg on April 10, 2011, 01:19:17 PM
-
I think this will be the sunday project.Its a fiddle tune but sounds it works pretty well on melodeon as well.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxLOslP1uxk (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bxLOslP1uxk)
-
Can't play it.. I don't have a tractor. ;D
-
Its a fiddle tune .....
Not a song at all, then. :(
-
For Dahlberg, it is probably a "låt," which can be a "song" or "tune" in his language, which does not distinguish as pedantically, so let's give him some credit for participating in a forum in a foreign language, right?
Dahlberg, thanks for posting this "bra låt"!
-Andy
-
Yes - you're right Andy. I should have been a bit more tolerant, so apologies to all.
It's just that calling pieces of music 'songs', when they are clearly not, is something which I dislike intensely, especially as it seems to be coming commonplace among some native English-speakers (principally some inhabitants of Youtube) who really ought to know better. I know that language evolves all the time, but this particular piece of linguistic mutation is one which I wish could be killed off and buried for ever.
A few days ago I even came across Shostakovitch's 2nd piano concerto* described as a 'song'. Arghhh!
* One of my favourite concertos of all. Such joyfulness and energy! And it gets called a chuffing 'song'.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WzVBnLhIf6c
-
A few days ago I even came across Shostakovitch's 2nd piano concerto* described as a 'song'. Arghhh!
Isn't that the one with Drunken Sailor? That's a song, isn't it? ;D
-
It's just that calling pieces of music 'songs', when they are clearly not, is something which I dislike intensely, especially as it seems to be coming commonplace among some native English-speakers (principally some inhabitants of Youtube) who really ought to know better. I know that language evolves all the time, but this particular piece of linguistic mutation is one which I wish could be killed off and buried for ever.
I totally agree, Steve, it irritates me as well, and I suspect that it is a result of the influence of pop music, in which everything is a "song." However, I think that the Germanic languages blending of "song" with "piece"/"tune" might go back to a much earlier time in history.
Personally, I love the French way of referring to traditional tunes as "morsels" -- indeed they are tasty!
-
Conversely, the younger members of my band call anything musical a "choon" ???
-
Conversely, the younger members of my band call anything musical a "choon" ???
Well I-tunes contains songs and tunes....and you download 'tunes'. So it's easy to make that assumption.
-
Conversely, the younger members of my band call anything musical a "choon" ???
Well I-tunes contains songs and tunes....and you download 'tunes'. So it's easy to make that assumption.
But they were already called choons (by some) before I-tunes existed, so I-tunes was only going with the flow.
-
Nine replies and only one has acknowledged the music (two if you count the tractor comment). ???
Nice, er, piece, dahlberg, nicely played.
I enjoyed the "mise en scène", too, a familiar scene for Canadians. Though I was a bit disappointed when I saw him take off the gloves, for some reason, but then it became clear that he is unable to play wearing a hat, so perhaps removing the mitts is not surprising. Perhaps he needs to feel cold to play. Which would explaing why he wanted to sit in that metal shovel bucket - my backside was shivering just looking at it. ;D
-
Nine replies and only one has acknowledged the music (two if you count the tractor comment). ???
Well I did call it a "bra låt" -- a nice tune.
I agree re: getting shivers at watching him sit down on. Here in VT we tend to confine our winter box-playing to the indoors!