Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: uofdoboe on April 10, 2011, 11:41:56 PM
-
For some reason this week, the idea of making the big jump and getting a CBA has been popping into my head over and over. I'm relatively new to the melodeon world and by no means a great player but I've so far been able to crank out tunes at a decent standard. My playing opportunities mostly center on a local irish session and the tunes of the month that I challenge myself to, though increasingly I have an interest in french music as well.
I suppose my primary complaint is that, even now that I have a certain level of facility on the box (I can sight-read a melody with no problem), and even knowing a bass line for a tune, when I start a new tune it really ends up being more of a puzzle-solving exercise than a music-making one. I find increasingly the limitations of the box (ex, wanting a pull chord on a push note, or reworking a melody line so you can get the harmony you want) take the focus off of making MUSIC and onto working around the limitations of the instrument. To say nothing of the harmonic limitations of having so few chords. Coming from a number of other instruments (ex piano, woodwinds), I recognize this as the instrument getting in the way of the music. If my musical interests were more tightly focused (ex, only playing irish, english, etc) I think this would be less of an issue since specific boxes are perhaps best suited for specific traditions. I hope this makes sense?
What are people's inputs on the CBA as a step in the right direction towards solving this? Obviously it's back to square one on learning fingering patterns, it's a much larger beast, it's not a very traditional instrument in my current musical circles. (I live in the states where the B/C/C# would be even more unheard-of, I'm not going down that road). I find the unisonoric nature VERY appealing now that I'm familiar with the melodeon, and the same goes for the apparent ease of transposing.
Anybody ever been at this cross-roads?
-
I've actually thought of doing the reverse CBA to melodeon. But I don't think I have the brain power to deal with the diatonic systems. I have played folk music on a small CBA 48 bass at local sessions and it seems to fit in well as it has just three rows and looks a little like a small diatonic. With just two reeds voices it is easy to carry at twelve pounds or so. Also it won't overpower the other players.
I have been studying the melodeon players here since I have developed some habits of playing the CBA which need improvement. The bellows with a chromatic instrument need less attention while playing in order to produce a recognisable tune. However I think working to develop some more musical techniques with the bellows will improve my performance. Also having so many bass notes available requires a light touch to play well with others.
You will have the melodeon background to help. With the three row CBA you will need to learn three fingerings for common keys. One for both A and C another for both D and F and finally G and B . Still much less to know than with a melodeon. With a five row you can just move around the keyboard with the same fingering to transpose.
Also the CBA is not very popular here in the states so it's difficult to find good used ones. In any case having a little CBA to play is fun.
-
I find the CBA to be a facinating instrument. I play a C#/D for the Irish type material but use the CBA for other music to more utilize the bass side. I started with a C griff but later changed to B griff, one button board side being a mirror image of the other. I can't say that one system is more intuitive than the other but for some reason the B griff works for me. The C griff is a four row french style with 80 bass that I should part with. The B griff is a three row Russian made box, it's somewhat crudely made but I love it.
I would recommend you at least try the CBA although I don't necessarily think of it as an Irish box.
I am stateside so if you want to send a PM I can talk at greater length about my CBA experience.
Good Luck
-
I'm taking the plunge myself and my new box should arrive shortly. My semi-tone box is great for my Irish sessions, and I will always be playing it, but I'm hankering after an instrument with a wider range, particularly on the bass side. Chromatic playing in Trad can be plain gorgeous, (think PA masters like Phil Cunningham, Lynn Tocker, Karen Tweed et al), and I do think CBAs have a bright future, especially now that manufacturers are making them smaller and sexier !
In France, it's been associated with musette and Jazz, mostly, but there's a new wave of Trad players that showcase the instrument beautifully. (Like Florence Gourion, Dominique Rivière and Sébastien Lagrange).
-
.. and Grenoble's Patrick Reboud.
A brilliant concept. You can construct a complete CBA on three rows, but that expansion to five is more interesting. Importantly rows 4 and 5 are simply mechanical lever extensions of 1 and 2. Now because of the total symmetry of the button layout, there are only five fingerings
1. A diatonic scale Start on your note - drop back to row 4 if its on 1, and 5 for 2
Related dorian and aeolian="relative" minors, and the myxolydian/blue7th are same buttons
Pentatonic related minor, and pentatonic major are same buttons (Chinese, Ionian)
Blues scale is same buttons (minorpentatonic) - plus one note (b5th
2. Harmonic minor - Russian, Baltic, Klesma, jazz
Flamenco/Spanish, that 'Balkan' dorian#4 and several jazz scales are same buttons
3. Melodic minor - the important jazz lydian dominant, and altered scales are same buttons
4. Whole tone scale - rarely used but very simple pattern
5. Diminisheds - trivially cross fingered ZZZZZ-wise along any 2 adjacent rows and great for coming down by a #
Against this it's big and weighs a lot. And you'll be playing with your fingers rather than your arm - so less 'attack'. I would advise anyone 'starting off' and interested beyond simple folk tunes to consider this system. For this old dog - too heavy - and too much to unlearn. :|glug
-
I think your observation that learning a tune on the diatonic is like 'working out a puzzle' is very accurate. Especially when your are trying to employ the basses and take advantage of the reversals on an ADG three row like I'm doing. I do enjoy doing that but it feels very different than picking up my english concertina and playing a tune I've never heard before from the music. I wouldn't have a prayer doing that on the diatonic (not to say that it couldn't be done). On the english concertina I can 'feel' where to go with my fingers much easier than with the diatonic. On the diatonic it feels like I have just memorized a sequence of finger movements and buttons when I learn a tune. The result of that is if I get lost just for a moment on the diatonic I often lose the tune completely because I can't 'hear' where to go to pick it up again. Having just started playing the CBA I can tell you that it feels much more intuitive as far as knowing where to reach for the next note. I've been playing melodeon a couple of years now and I can do it better on the CBA already. The left hand side, however, is a whole different story. I can't find much of anything over there yet with any speed at all!! I don't think there is any question that the CBA is more versatile for a large variety of music than the diatonic but it's a steep learning curve to get to the point where you can pop out lively dance tune on it. Much easier to do that on the diatonic.
-
Not so much a puzzle for me, but a language. I'm finding it interesting that a 3-row quint box really does have a different way of being played than the two row. My 21 button, eight bass has felt very intuitive to me for years. I was listening to Jacques Lavergne's AMTA recording, and he really takes advantage of every option that the three-row gives him ... its not simply a 2-row plus another row.
I seriously considered going the CBA route when I started listening to Patrick Lefevbre. Nothing to apologize for in his playing ... plenty of lift, plenty of rhythm. And the small CBAs really have a very sweet sound.
http://www.saltarelle.com/videos/bourroche/Bourroche03-seb3.m4v.SWF
-
Anybody ever been at this cross-roads?
I bought my first CBA more than a year ago, and I learned both CBA and melodeon alternating: a month on melodeon then a week on the CBA then two months on melodeon then two weeks on the CBA, and so on. I used to love the "puzzle-solving" nature of playing the melodeon until I tried to play the tune Jump at the Sun in G minor on a GCF Hohner Corona with accidentals on the chinward-end recently. Suddenly, I've lost interest in "puzzle-solving" any more. I have a small and light (5.5kg) 5-row, two-voice, 60-bass CBA with perfect sounding hand-made reeds, which is so easy to play. After trying to learn 5-finger style, I play the CBA with 4 fingers (many tunes only with 3 fingers). I have learned the last 4 ToTM tunes in three days in 12 keys in two octaves. I really enjoyed learning the melodeon during the past two years, though. I've bought a mid-size but heavy (11 kg) 4-voice, 96-bass CBA, but definitely that was an error: never buy an old and heavy CBA, it's really disappointing.
-
Choosing the right key for a tune is part of the puzzle. ;)
-
I bought a 3-row CBA a little while back but somehow couldn't get into it. I dunno, it just wasn't fun in the same way that a diatonic box is. I love the feel of diatonic boxes, the bounce and the energy that they effortlessly throw at you. I can't imagine myself ever doing truly unisonoric.
-
I bought a small, second-hand, low-end B system CBA some while back. I really enjoyed learning how it worked and actually found that the RH fingering started to come naturally fairly quickly. With the button layout being so logical, it seemed that you didn't have to think so much about where the next note would be. Thus, onamentation and simple variations seemed to happen almost instinctively.
I certainly found, within my limited experience of it, that it lent itself far more easily to some sorts of tune than others. Waltzes and jazzy stuff seemed particularly well suited, whereas as I didn't make much progress with more familiar folk tune styles.
Some time later, I managed to break one of the plastic keys, then losst a tiny screw trying to sort it out. So, I haven't touched it since. One part of me would like to try again, preferably with a better, fully functioning, instrument. However, I'm not really sure where I'd want to take it (even less so than with the melodeon). So, given that there's only so much practice time available, it feels like a better idea to keep trying to learn the diatonic side of things.
-
I bought a 3-row CBA a little while back but somehow couldn't get into it. I dunno, it just wasn't fun in the same way that a diatonic box is. I love the feel of diatonic boxes, the bounce and the energy that they effortlessly throw at you. I can't imagine myself ever doing truly unisonoric.
That's similar to my experience. I had a Zero Sette 5 row 120 bass that had all the notes you could ask for, was very pleasant to play and sounded great but I just couldn't get into it, it felt more like "operating" some equipment rather than playing an instrument. A chromatic accordion solves all the, (for want of a better word), problems of a diatonic and everything is laid out for you on a plate but it's just a bit too clinical and....well....boring. :-\
...or maybe I'm just a musical masochist...
-
I had a Zero Sette 5 row 120 bass that had all the notes you could ask for, was very pleasant to play
...or maybe I'm just a musical masochist...
You definitely are, I have a heavy CBA as well, but it is definitely not pleasant to play.
All of you guys should try a light high quality CBA: they are really fun to play.
In my world playing in a number of keys is of paramount importance: frequently I am expected to play the same tune in four keys depending on the band's requirements.
-
After many years of playing melodeon I bought a CBA. My discovery was some of us are just push/pull minded. It seemed counter intuitive to move a finger when a bellows change not only got the note wanted but also set up the next few notes in a great finger pattern together with the correct bass. Piano and PA keyboards are also logical but for me the large jumps (less so on CBA) were uncomfortable and fraught with the danger of missing. Practice may eventually have overcome the problem but I was totally at home on a diatonic from the moment I picked it up.
If a CBA suits your mental process uofdoboe then it is certainly more flexible than a melodeon and the Youtube clip above is the best playing I have seen of a CBA
-
With the disclaimer that I've never tried a CBA (though I have picked one up), when I read comments to the effect that the system is counter-intuitive, or that it couldn't be got on with, I always want ask, OK, but how long and how hard did you try to master the thing? I've read a few analogous comments about (e.g.) the B/C system - "bought this box because I wanted to try B/C, couldn't get on with it, so here it is for sale, only played three times..."
Without singling out any of the posters to this thread, because for all I know you may have put a lot of time into our attempt, it seems to me unrealistic to expect that a new system will come automatically just because it has buttons and bellows and you are already proficient on the melodeon... In fact, coming from the melodeon we will probably find the CBA more difficult than someone who has never played an accordion of any sort. Oder?
-
All of you guys should try a light high quality CBA: they are really fun to play.
In my world playing in a number of keys is of paramount importance: frequently I am expected to play the same tune in four keys depending on the band's requirements.
but, but, but ... melodeons come in all sorts of keys!! >:E
-
but, but, but
.. presumably referring to the need to lug 3 melodeons around to cover your band's favourite keys (as many do) ???
CBA is a very different beastie, but as I tried to explain above once you've mastered say the G diatonic scale (and that's not rocket science) you can play in all its 7 modes, and in the other 11 majors, and their modes as well. All same fingering! I think that's got something going for it?
-
but, but, but
.. presumably referring to the need to lug 3 melodeons around to cover your band's favourite keys (as many do) ???
CBA is a very different beastie, but as I tried to explain above once you've mastered say the G diatonic scale (and that's not rocket science) you can play in all its 7 modes, and in the other 11 majors, and their modes as well. All same fingering! I think that's got something going for it?
I know ;) ... just being a >:E
-
With the disclaimer that I've never tried a CBA (though I have picked one up), when I read comments to the effect that the system is counter-intuitive, or that it couldn't be got on with, I always want ask, OK, but how long and how hard did you try to master the thing? I've read a few analogous comments about (e.g.) the B/C system - "bought this box because I wanted to try B/C, couldn't get on with it, so here it is for sale, only played three times..."
Without singling out any of the posters to this thread, because for all I know you may have put a lot of time into our attempt, it seems to me unrealistic to expect that a new system will come automatically just because it has buttons and bellows and you are already proficient on the melodeon... In fact, coming from the melodeon we will probably find the CBA more difficult than someone who has never played an accordion of any sort. Oder?
Actually responses to this question seem to be split between, as you say, "couldn't really get on with it", or those that found it quite easy and quite logical but for some reason or other prefer diatonic boxes.
-
. To say nothing of the harmonic limitations of having so few chords. Coming from a number of other instruments (ex piano, woodwinds), I recognize this as the instrument getting in the way of the music. ?
What are people's inputs on the CBA as a step in the right direction towards solving this?
As you appear to be a competant piano player the obvious choice would be a piano accordion as you will be familier with keyboard, different keys, right hand chords etc etc.The continental is a close relative of the piano accordion & a distant relative of the various loosely termed, 'diatonic' boxes. The continental works just the same as a piano keyboard the difference being that the black & white notes are arranged in a much more compact form that is , once mastered , easier to finger at speed & easier to play right hand chords on as the required notes are easier to reach. BOth the piano box & the continental box are suited to any type of music b oth traditional/folk and classical, & of course music of various national flavours. Both come with varying numbers of either stradella and/or free bass or a combination of both enabling elaborate left hand rhythm & harmony as required.
All 'diatonics' including the BCC# are better suited to traditional/folk stuff due to the inherent limitations of the sook and blaw systems which e.g. limit possible right hand chords eg on a BC its impossible to play G & D together & same goes for G&A. Also most semitone boxes unless sporting stradella bass have left ends varying from fairly useless ato comparitively limited. Most of us on this forum get enormous satisfaction finding ways round some of the inherent limitations of the diatonic systems whilst accepting or even enjoying the fact that the limitions provide unique party tricks that would be difficult to replicate on a 'one way' box.
if you find it difficult to live with the joys of the diatonics ;) and to engage in a more theoretical approach to making music the choice between piano & continental would seeem more appropriate
george
-
Anybody ever been at this cross-roads?
I bought my first CBA more than a year ago, and I learned both CBA and melodeon alternating: a month on melodeon then a week on the CBA then two months on melodeon then two weeks on the CBA, and so on. I used to love the "puzzle-solving" nature of playing the melodeon until I tried to play the tune Jump at the Sun in G minor on a GCF Hohner Corona with accidentals on the chinward-end recently. Suddenly, I've lost interest in "puzzle-solving" any more. I have a small and light (5.5kg) 5-row, two-voice, 60-bass CBA with perfect sounding hand-made reeds, which is so easy to play. After trying to learn 5-finger style, I play the CBA with 4 fingers (many tunes only with 3 fingers). I have learned the last 4 ToTM tunes in three days in 12 keys in two octaves. I really enjoyed learning the melodeon during the past two years, though. I've bought a mid-size but heavy (11 kg) 4-voice, 96-bass CBA, but definitely that was an error: never buy an old and heavy CBA, it's really disappointing.
Miki,
If you play Jump at the Sun in a key that the GCF was designed for (like Dm ) can you get as much lift and bounce out of your CBA as you can the GCF? I cannot. I wish I could and maybe someday I will but it's not even close now.
Michael
-
can you get as much lift and bounce out of your CBA as you can the GCF?
I cannot get any lift and bounce on neither the CBA neither the GCF, I am still in a phase when I am struggling with the accordion and I have not time/energy for making music. (:)
-
Nice little duel between 2 CBAs and two diatonics
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyeGgoJgpFU
Basically they are all jamming on A minor (same notes as C major scale) and its related scales - and did I hear a little bit of tune in there?
-
i can offer fifty cents on this one since i played PA for a few years to a standard that did not meet virtuoso-improvisatory-stand-on-your-head quality, but did meet a very nice standard of being able to play un-improvised tangos, musette waltzes, eastern european stuff, etc, and being paid to do so to lend color at art openings, weddings, and such, and a couple of months in a play set in 1930s nazi germany; followed by serious years studying bisonoric two-row irish box, which was followed by and concomitant with bisonoric anglo concertina; and am now about 18 months into self-taught study of CBA and crazy about it. i always found the vertical ergonomics of the PA layout really hard for accurate arpeggios and scalar runs, and find the CBA button layout a brilliant improvement........
first, there definitely IS a substantial "puzzle" aspect to cba. you must learn the note pathways, which are not in sequential scale order, and then if you have a 4 or 5-row, meaning that (on a C-system) the fourth row is the notes in the first row and the fifth row adds the notes in the second row, you must get comfortable with having and availing yourself of the extra options. (or not. you can just default to the first three rows and diverge only on a very limited basis, but.....)
it's just a question of which puzzle is a better fit for your personal brain pathways. for whatever reason, the two-row accordion puzzle has never really truly-ooly become automatic for me, while the arguably more complex anglo concertina puzzle became very comfortable after 2/3 years of trying all the various combinations this way and that when learning a tune. [i think part of it is, i hate the physical awkwardness, and to me, stilted phrasing, of yanking the box back and forth, and love the phrasing subtleties you can get on the lighter, smaller concertina, and it is coloring how i perceive the "puzzle."] the cba puzzle was a steep learning curve for three to six months, but super fun once i started to get the note pathways into my head and hand. granted, i already knew the basses from PA, and my both-hands-together chops are not as advanced as my right-hand-alone proficiency at present. but i am doing right-hand practice of mozart's "rondo alla turk" and complex chromatic runs in musette waltzes, along with irish reels at a nice relaxed speed on it and loving it. i dunno how i would do with multi-voiced chordal pieces, but don't really like that sort of music or arrangement anyway...
like pa, the cba will not give you the phrasing of a one-row bisonoric or a two-row being played "on the row" like in D on a c#/d. but it WILL phrase every bit as traditionally and folkily as the many other traditional folk instruments that do not have a push/pull component. in irish music, players of flute, uilleann pipes, and whistle, have to learn by years of listening, where to break the phrase or a group of notes or "lift off" or release, in order to sound like they are playing traditional dance music rather than overly legato classical. they don't have a "one-row push-pull" sound and they sound great......you can do exactly the same on cba, or PA. actually, i don't find much difference in the sound of a cba being played with traditional attention to phrase breaks, versus a two-row bisonoric being played "across the rows" a la, say, key of D, A major, or e minor on b/c box....
i will say i have seen a few posts here and there from folks saying, cba for sale, i tried it and can't get the layout patterns, so, there's that issue of, which puzzle is right or awkward for your very own personal brain?
-
i guess i should add that i hated the size and bulk of PA, and a huge factor in my taking to cba is that with cba you can clear the 30-note treble minimum needed imho to effectively play irish and many other world folk genres, and even get 34 in there, in a box the same dimensions and weight as a small 26-key PA, and only a tad bigger/heavier than a saltarelle nuage. and bass-wise you can get 60 (all 12 tones) in a box the dimensions and weight of a 48-bass pa. it's glorious, i tell ya.....
-
a huge factor in my taking to cba is that with cba you can clear the 30-note treble minimum needed imho to effectively play irish and many other world folk genres, and even get 34 in there, in a box the same dimensions and weight as a small 26-key PA
I love the potential small size factor of a CBAs, too. My 60-bass Cooperfisa Perla 300A's height is only 31cm, has 5 rows with 37 treble notes (low G to high G in 3 full octaves) all for (a tiny bit less than) 6 kg. IMHO even 80 bass-buttons (16 x 5) could be fit, which would make bass accompaniment in the keys of B, C# easier. You may ask why B, C#(Db)? A number of my piper friends have flat-pitch Uilleann pipes set in B and C# and when we play together these are the preferred keys, that is Irish tunes played in D on a concert pitch set are played in B or C#, "G-tunes" are played in E or F# (Gb). Practically, the only reason I've finally chosen CBA is that I am expected to play a tune in a number of keys: an Irish "D-tune" in D,C#,C,B,Bb an Irish "G-tune" in G, F#, F, E, Eb. A Hungarian or French "G-tune" in G, A, Bb, G#, or F.
-
Practically, the only reason I've finally chosen CBA is that I am expected to play a tune in a number of keys: an Irish "D-tune" in D,C#,C,B,Bb an Irish "G-tune" in G, F#, F, E, Eb. A Hungarian or French "G-tune" in G, A, Bb, G#, or F.
I don't think there is the slightest doubt that the CBA is the best choice in this situation.
-
whilst agreeing about the v ersatility of the continental chromatic, particularly if using one set of fingering on a 5 row, it is worth remembering that for those who wish to stick to the sook and blaw system none of the aforementioned keys are problematic on the British Chromatic box.
The choice of continental makes great sense but it is ,alas, only a distant rlative of the melodeon whereas the British Chromatic belongs firmly to the same family and dcomes complete with with the built in idiosyncracies those of us with less sense enjoy so much!
george ;D
-
none of the aforementioned keys are problematic on the British Chromatic box.
George, I've been listening for a long time your words in favor of British Chromatic. Are there any 2-voice BCC# model that is not heavier than 6 kg, and has 60 or 80 basses? I do not remember correctly, how many fingerings shall I learn on a BCC# to play a tune in all the 12 keys?
-
none of the aforementioned keys are problematic on the British Chromatic box.
George, I've been listening for a long time your words in favor of British Chromatic. Are there any 2-voice BCC# model that is not heavier than 6 kg, and has 60 or 80 basses? I do not remember correctly, how many fingerings shall I learn on a BCC# to play a tune in all the 12 keys?
5 scales . steve klinksacale advertise the crucianelli sc14 72 bass as 'lightweight' but don't give the actual weight or number of voices. I am not recommending one of those as I have never tried one, perhaps some of our Scottish melnetters have?
The casali 48 bass (useful 12x4) is very light & is 3 voice. Difficult to find but they do come up on ebay occasionally . Lightest of the lot is the 2 or 3 voice hohner trichord but only 1`2 stradella bass. Should be possible to graft on a 8x6 piano acc bass end without too much difficulty.
george
-
If you're Welsh like me it most notes per buck. 4 1/2 octaves over 34 buttons, British Chromatic.
-
This one might be worth a look - again, 4x12 stradella bass:
http://www.eaglemusicshop.com/details1.asp/ProductID/5497/sid/152/crucianelli-three-row.htm
Doesn't say what the weight is.
-
I'd be taking a serious look at This Hohner Nova II (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/3688?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) if I was in the market.
5 rows, 72 bass.
And for the hard of Googling: 17 tons (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/4381?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) according to Mr Ryall.
-
This one might be worth a look - again, 4x12 stradella bass:
http://www.eaglemusicshop.com/details1.asp/ProductID/5497/sid/152/crucianelli-three-row.htm
Doesn't say what the weight is.
this is thje one I mentioned, imported by Steve Clinkscale, - has anybody tried one?
george
-
This is really a therapeutic moan for me,.... so don't read it unless you really want to.
I came back from last night's session feeling DEPRESSED about playing our instrument. I've been playing for years off and on, and STILL I can't fluently join in even on tunes I know... keep fumbling to find the notes, even though I have been practising the pull-minors systematically to try to get them into my head and fingers. I'm sure that if I had been playing a sensibly designed keyboard for this long, I would be happily joining in and improvising.
So I'm very grateful to Uofdoboe, Waltzman and Ceemonster and Miklos for articulating these issues.
The one row and two row melodeon is great for the associated traditional music, as can be heard in the current Joe/Boat TOTM. But why do we struggle with this silly keyboard when trying to play music from a wider range, with more unusual harmonies, accidentals and key changes? My 2.5 row has most notes push and pull, but without a logical arrangement, and even the octaves are fingered differently. Then every key has a different pattern of chord directions. So I am sharing the frustrations of other writers in this thread. On other instruments, fiddle, recorder, piano, intuitive (puzzle-free) playing comes so much more readily.
And I agree with them that there is no necessary loss in foregoing the push/pull. Other instruments don't have what is sometimes thought of as "built-in" rhythm. They have to create their own phrasing. And sometimes the push/pull feature is undesirable, creating unwanted discontinuities.
It's really encouraging to read that after transferring to the CBA people are already finding intuitive playing coming to their fingers.
But then, something has kept me playing the melodeon, whereas I did not persist with the PA, which I played before, though much more fluent with it, thanks to childhood programming with the piano keyboard.
And then we have the phenomenon of extensive enthusiasm for the diato in France, even though CBA was widely played there. Why are there so many diatos in france with 18 basses and three rows??? Why don't they get small CBAs instead.
What is it about this [swearword] instrument that gets us into obsessive playing, practising, (and writing to Melnet) but then obstructs our musicality in the moment of playing and improvising.
I'm split really. Despite the frustrations and depression, I have enjoyed coming back to the melodeon this last few months..... and I'm resistant to shelling out all the cash needed for one of the Salterelle CBAs... and starting from scratch again with a new system.
They say a problem shared is a problem halved. So thanks for reading if you have been.
A bientot
-
Sounds like you should try to get a small cheap CBA, like a Hohner Amati. They often go for as little as £200. (:) And yes, I do wonder the same thing. I tried playing CBA because I thought that I would be able to do more with it... but instead found it very dull. Push and pull runs though me now, I can't get rid of it!
-
Hello Jack, IMO the matter of bellows control is the issue with diatonic
accordions. that push pull system can really bury rhytmn into your bones
and when it does it feels like magic in your playing. then I think improv
just shows up on its' own. the morris playing is just that[push pull] till
you have that shake thru you and don't want to stop:0) Single button or
scale playing till the cows come home. I also believe that it is not quick
or easy.I think years go into. The melodeon is not a simple instrument.
I thought it would be when I started. cross rowing and pushing and pulling..
Nothing like it. You become your own drummer, your own musical machine.
Like alot of players on the forum..2cents worth
-
What is it about this [swearword] instrument that gets us into obsessive playing, practising, (and writing to Melnet) but then obstructs our musicality in the moment of playing and improvising.
I'll take a stab at this. I think the answer is rhythm. I personally am much more satisfied by accurate and interesting rhythms than I am by complex harmonies or complicated melodies. Because of it's lightness combined with economies of finger movement it is much easier to create interesting and lively rhythms on a DBA than on a PA or CBA. It takes years and years of playing a PA to even get close to what you can do with a relatively short practice time on a DBA. Most PA players never even get close. CBA has a little bit better finger economy but is still quite heavy by comparison.
-
I found the comments from JackHumphreys very interesting and admit to sometimes feeling the same way. On another post Anahata talked about the Lego blocks of music and I found that thought very helpful. Sometimes I play pieces on my 3 row diatonic and feel very good about my performance level but when faced with a simple piece that somehow doesn't have the same lego blocks my performance feels very disappointing and its depressing.
I think the bottom line is to be focused on what your trying to achieve and not to move the goalposts and make yourself miserable. Of course, easier said than done!
My two cents
-
This is an interesting discussion. I adore struggling to learn the melodeon (though I wish it came a little more naturally to me!!) but I wouldn't mind playing a box like the one Dom Riviere is playing in this video (:)
Apart from the inherent charms of the instrument, melodeons are light and can be quite cheap - both important qualities for me. If I wanted to play a CBA that I could actually pick up, I would still be waiting.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWay7VQ_lZM (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWay7VQ_lZM)
-
Jack, I think the real nub of the matter is how your brain works. I have tried keyboard and CBA, bought and sold both. Neither suit my brain pattern. My PA and CBA playing friends can't get any reasonable tune out of a melodeon. Yes there are limits to a diatonic but the joys are there too. If you want to play in many keys you either have to learn many patterns on a B/C type diatonic or join the MAD group and have many boxes. I belong firmly in the latter group and love it ;D ;D :||: :||:
-
Prefer this version Juker...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Qt-ohf6jUo&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL
-
ooh yes, I totally agree with you on that! This is one of my fave recordings.
-
And for the hard of Googling: 17 tons (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/4381?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) according to Mr Ryall.
HOW MUCH?! :o Jeeeesshhh...
-
And for the hard of Googling: 17 tons (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/4381?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) according to Mr Ryall.
HOW MUCH?! :o Jeeeesshhh...
My flabber is well and truly gasted :o
-
[I'm resistant to shelling out all the cash needed for one of the Salterelle CBAs] well, you wouldn't really need to....the hohner novas are more than responsive enough for dance-based world folk music. i wouldn't say that about bisonorics; with those, one does want hand reeds. but generations of stone-virtuoso pros have done brilliantly at folk music on unisonoric hohners and weltmeisters, PAs and CBAs, and there is a reason for that, which is that they serve extremely well. i don't mean a five-thousand-dollar blue-chip one wouldn't be nice, but it is mind-boggling how lovely and playable my hohner nova ii 60a is, and it cost a grand. yes, one bass button has fallen off. so what. the reeds are german hohner reeds and they feel and sound great, for a grand. i also have a weltmeister 72-bass five-row that i got on ebay as new-old overstock or something, about six years ago for $750, half the then-price of $1500 for that model, which now goes for $2400, and that box too is wonderful. I let it sit in a closet in a case until starting cba in earnest about eighteen months ago.
I do highly recommend going for a four-row over only three. you "can" play lots of stuff on three, but four is brilliant, facilitates french musette, django swing, tango, jazz, all kinds of stuff.
in terms of the push-pull "sound" or "feel," that is just personal preference....i am finding i like the bisonoric feel a lot for less "notey" music, such as polkas and slides, but like the unisonoric a lot for the complex, fluid, flowing "notey" music, such as in irish, the east galway/tipperary composed tunes by paddy fahy, sean ryan, paddy kelly, paddy o'brien, etc.....
-
i wouldn't say that about bisonorics; with those, one does want hand reeds.
Do you mean hand made? Rubbish :P
-
either have to learn many patterns on a B/C type diatonic or join the MAD group and have many boxes. I belong firmly in the latter group and love it ;D ;D :||: :||:
the BC type diatonic family includes the BCC# which only requires 5 scales to play 12 major keys. The 3 row continental requies 3 scales but a 5 row continental can manage 12 keys for one set of fingering ( but learning the 3 sets is recommended). On the other hand it would take a great many 4th aprt boxes to cover all 12 keys.
The cjhoice between continental chromatic and so called 'diatonic' boxes is for many down to one si;mple thing. Are you a natural push/pull person! In many years of teaching would be box players I have found that whilst many take very naturally to the push/pull box there are those who never will as long as they have a hole in their backsides.
george
-
ooh yes, I totally agree with you on that! This is one of my fave recordings.
Moi aussi!
This is one of the clips that convinced me to take up the accordion. Lovely sound.
-
I used to beat myself up for not playng CBA. SInce I'm into so mnay different styles of music, I thought the only rational approach is to have one instrument for as much as possible.
Fortunately, none of this is very rational, and I'm finding comfort with so many instruments. Of course, it's easy to say as owner of several good PAs.
I think, if one is startinbg out cold on boxes, a CBA is the way to go. I think the various DBA/concetinas/whatever are like unseemly personlaity traits we acquire over our life span: they're not optimal, but we have some comfort with them.. :|glug
-
In theory the continental chromatic makes a great deal of sense particulary to those with classical training who feel they must play everything exactly as written & on which they can play anything from god save the king to Beethovens moonlight sonata. For someone without any piano keyboard experience it is a very good choice.
On the other hand the majority of 'diatonicists' are into it for the fun of it and a great many of us are either poor or non readers who judge the efficacy of what they are playing by what it sounds like which may or may be not what the composer intended. Similarly the lack of certain notes or the wherewithall to produce obscure chords in the written musicis seen as a matter for experimentation and faking ( there are of course those ( often from a classical bacakground) that torture themselves because they can't play the 'correct' bass chords which is probably because there arent any 'correct' bass chords on tunes composed for fiddle, flute etc.
Of course all of this can be done on a continental or piano box ,and I play both, but the lifelong challenge of the diatonics is for some reason far more satisfying - and they are much more portable & less knackering to play for long periods
george
-
I'd be taking a serious look at This Hohner Nova II (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/3688?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) if I was in the market.
5 rows, 72 bass.
And for the hard of Googling: 17 tons (http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_246/products_id/4381?mrSid=824342b4a6a4d46c4952ff4b290c60bb) according to Mr Ryall.
If only it was 1 ton lighter it would be a lot easier to shift :-)
Ian
-
In theory the continental chromatic makes a great deal of sense particulary to those with classical training who feel they must play everything exactly as written & on which they can play anything from god save the king to Beethovens moonlight sonata. For someone without any piano keyboard experience it is a very good choice.
Of course not all classically trained people turn to CBAs ;) I have played the piano since I was 5, trained classically to a relatively high standard but have push and pull running right through me.
-
I was only refering to those of a classical disposition who felt they had to play everything exactly as per the dots & not to those with a 'classical' background who are happy to accomodate the idiosyncracies of the sook an blaw box
george ;)
-
i disagree with many if not most of your generalized premises here, gg.
i have piano background, and have embraced cba like a long-lost relative.
i have ear-learned all of my irish tunes for the last seven or so years, and am experiencing no obstacles to this with cba.
i have no interest in playing classical music, and i think cba is an ideal instrument for world folk music from scandinavian to eastern european, not to mention blues, ragtime, tango, paris musette, and jazz from classic swing and chromatic.....this is true for many, many cba players. they're not all at the conservatory....
-
I never intended to infer that the continental box was not suitable for folk/traditional music, continental muisic , jazz or whatever. Indeed I was advocating its efficacy for a wide range of music . In refering to those of a classical disposition I was not refering to 'classical music'in the brahms & Beethoven sense but to those who have learned with the classical approach via exams & grades , some of whom struggle with sook an blaw boxes that may not have all the notes required eg for some right hand chords as written. The fact that I sometimes recommend the continental to those who have no previous piano keyboard background does not infer that it is not recommended for those who do! Indeed for those who do not wish to go up the 'diatonic' route the continental has a lot to offer.
george ;)
-
i'm thinking, why not drink life's vintage to the fullest and play both. though it does seem that cba is claiming increasing amounts of my attention.
the first link below shows the wonderful cba virtuoso and composer maria kalaniemi playing CBA; the second is a link to her playing diatonic.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ap-lOUCV3Gk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6uaqFwTM6Q
-
Well yes, but not many can manage that! I was going to give it a go, but found CBA a little dull if anything... plus I couldn't get my head around this unisonoric business.
-
Yeah, to be fair, I am only maintaining the CBA while improving (a bit) on the melodeon, my excuse to myself was that the overall benefits to being a better musician and performer would justify it but I could be kidding myself... And trying to drink life's vintage or even life's pint of mild on both instruments is keeping me up late. Still, for now it's the melodeon. I don't know about one instrument being boring but I do think it's horses for courses, the playing style will be completely different which I think is much more important than what chords you can get etc. Finally if the unisonoric thing is tricky how about the free bass option? (ha ha, can of worms and maybe not suited to a melodeon forum)
I would LOVE a proper free bass box. Seriously.
-
I wish! At the moment though, no. I've got another project on the go, which isn't free bass but is close and really don't have any money to spend at the moment :(
-
.. there's a link to the fairly expensive Pigini Mythos higher up in this thread...
Would like to hear it but couldn't find the link. ???
-
Would like to hear it but couldn't find the link. ???
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6641.msg84589.html#msg84589
See my "17 tons" link - a bit obscure, and there's no sounds to listen to, just the Music Room listing showing the price - a Pigini CBA at £39000.
-
My final comment about CBAs - there's a link to the fairly expensive Pigini Mythos higher up in this thread. I have heard one at least once - Professor Owen Murray of the Royal Academy of Music plays one. It is one of the most amazing musical instruments I have ever heard, it does everything you would hope that a very expensive musical instrument would do but the sound also fills the room in a way that I cannot understand, it is like magic. I don't just mean in terms of volume, it was hard to explain. But Owen Murray apparently gave his last public performance in Canterbury earlier this year so I probably won't be hearing that one again. Whether it's 39k's worth of goodness, who knows. Amazing though. Anyway enough from me about that other kind of instrument, I need to learn more about melodeons.
Could it be the Professor who created the magic and not the instrument?
-
Could it be the Professor who created the magic and not the instrument?
Hands up the musician who hasn't bought an instrument because it sounded good when the other guy played it :||:
No hands then ;D
-
I played with a half chromatic accordion at a Slovenian festival a couple of years ago. This is the type of box that Johnny Pecon and Lou Trebar played in Cleveland, Ohio when they did their act at Janez and Lojze.
The treble side is unisonoric chromatic but the bass side is bisonoric like the Steirische harmonika. The fingering of the treble side was totally foreign to me but after a few minutes I was able to get "Edelweiss" and "Glas Harmonike" out of the thing.
Pecon and Trebar usually played chromatic accordions with Stradella bass, but they played their "trick" Steirische harmonikas as Janez and Lojze.
Sometimes they played chromatic accordions that looked like piano accordions. The black piano keys were fake. If you looked closely you could see two rows of buttons, the white piano keys actually formed the third row of buttons.
There are so many different types of accordions. I enjoy learning about each of them.
-
the playing style will be completely different which I think is much more important than what chords you can get
Here is a video showing a small size CBA:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSMJ201RirM
Do you know what make is it?
BTW: Even the 96-bass CBA on the left side seems to be of a manageable size.
-
Maybe someone can read the label on the front. The first word COULD be Maugein (The descender is in the right place)
So I found this http://accordeons-maugein.com/documents/dauphin-export.pdf (http://accordeons-maugein.com/documents/dauphin-export.pdf)
But plastic covered... and still heavy. Even the 48 bass is 5 kg.
Of course that player is very tall and big, so he will make any accordeon look small.
I did find a bargain Piginin Peter Pan on a french auction site..... But, I'm enjoying the diato so much at the moment, thanks to Melnet mostly, that it would seem silly to divert energy into learning a new keyboard (or two new keyboards, one each end).
-
The first word COULD be Maugein
But plastic covered... and still heavy. Even the 48 bass is 5 kg.
Thank You, Jack, you are right; this is a model following the "bois massif" design
http://accordeons-maugein.com/instruments/personnalisation/files/10_6.jpg
The model "Dauphin" has 60 basses for "only" 5 kg.
Of course that player is very tall and big, so he will make any accordeon look small.
Sure, the guy at 0:59 on the right side is not short, definitely.
-
One point against learning the CBA is a distinct lack of learning materials. I've been searching for ages on the internet for books, videos, anything that'll show me even basic fingering for scales. There's one rubbish gif image of some fingering patterns somewhere around but I ended up chatting to Eddie Hession who plays for the Budapest Cafe Orchestra and got him to play me some scales which I wrote down and you can download here if anyone wants to try them: http://craptiger.wordpress.com/ (http://craptiger.wordpress.com/)
I'm working on a free bass version so PM me if anyone wants that.
My next mission is to get some videos and/or scores with fingering for some simple folk tunes up there. If anyone is up for helping me out with this by sending me links to videos of them playing so I can see if what I'm doing is right, then write it down that'd be brilliant.
-
Craptiger - I agree on the frustrating lack of CBA methods out there. There's actually quite a quantity of french tutors (although many of them are vintage) to technically there's no shortage, just very limited options for non-francophones. The Anzaghi method the obvious exception - I'm working through it now but it does feel very dated.
I also just purchased the Florence Glorion method for CBA - it is folk music focused, unlike Anzaghi who is more classical-focused. The Glorion method looks much more up my alley but it is in French. I'm translating it page by page for myself which slows things but I like how she progresses.
Finally, I did start a wee blog about my own rank beginner struggles self-teaching the CBA: www.cgriffplay.blogspot.com (http://www.cgriffplay.blogspot.com). I posted Anzaghi's fingerings for all major, minor, and chromatic scales a few weeks back. They make a lot more sense than the "rubbish gif" to which you're referring. Maybe it'll be helpful. Anzaghi (and most all tutors, I've been told) confine themselves to three rows for all scales and build the student's core competancy on three row technique in general. I notice your scales utilize four rows which -=from my impression=- isn't wrong but just not typical of beginner scales.
-
Hi all
Just to share my limited experience - I have been teaching myself CBA for the last couple of years and am using a series of books by the very famous Meddard Ferrero. While living in France for a few years, every accordionist I met recommended his method. I have completed the first book, which takes approximately a year and about to start on book 2. It is a series which ultimately takes you to a virtuoso level! It's serious, lots and lots of excercises and scales and the fingering is clearly marked always. Yes it is in French, but there is very little text, so shouldn't be a big problem. I am loving it and can only recommend his method (no thumb of course!) and after my first year I am able to play simple folk songs and to work out my own fingering patterns.
I have recently recorded my first simple tune and put it on You Tube - have a look if you want, my channel name is 'PEHEDIC' and the tune is Mon Amant de St. Jean. Sorry, I don't know how to do a link!
-
Here's your link arty http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jsT5G9mSrbc AtB mory
-
I think what puts me off getting the Florence Glorion book is the fact that it's 58 Euros! Bit of a gamble considering I don't speak any French at all and it might not suit me. Anyone up for posting a couple of scanned pages? Are we allowed to do that? Can be random pages, but would be good to get an idea of what it's like.
I've also tried the Anzaghi method but gave up mainly because it seemed ridiculous trying to twist my wrist in order to play from 4th to 2nd finger on 1st and 3rd rows respectively (hope that makes sense, thumb being 1st finger, 4th being ring finger). I can't help thinking it's pointless to struggle with learning on 3 rows when you've got 5 on the box! I'm learning so I can enjoy playing tunes, I don't want to wait 5 years till then.
I've posted a tune, kind of, on YouTube too. It's a box I was trying to sell (still hasn't sold btw) and if you skip to about 1min 40 I play both sides.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEwex9mmslU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEwex9mmslU)
(only been playing for about 18 months so it's not great!)
-
I'd be grateful if someone could explain to me the differences and pros and cons of B griff versus C griff.
(I noticed some nice cheap Black Diamond starter models.... but only in B griff)
Hello Craptiger.... I also live in Bristol.... sending you a PM.
-
I think what puts me off getting the Florence Glorion book is the fact that it's 58 Euros!
...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEwex9mmslU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OEwex9mmslU)
(only been playing for about 18 months so it's not great!)
You do not need any tutor book, definitely. You are great, just play music the way you like.
-
Thanks IK for the griff info. Very helpful.
-
(I noticed some nice cheap Black Diamond starter models.... but only in B griff)
They will have some C griff as well later in the year - sometime early summer, I think.