Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: jolo on July 08, 2008, 01:54:07 PM
-
I have bought a new Hohner Morgane D/G after playing Castagnari Dony/Lilly for several years.
I have to admit that the Morgane is so much easier to play and sounds and looks great. Anyone contemplating a change
of Box, I would suggest you try one out. Happy to answer any questions.
I had to buy new but anyone with a second hand one, I would be interested in having a second box
Jolo : :D ::)
-
I have played a D/G Morgane since January and I am really delighted as well. Good looks, good sound, easy to play. There are a few details that are a little disappointing, like the fingerboard made of an aluminum plate covered with sticky-back plastic, and the straps that are on the short side, but overall it is an excellent value for the money in the sub-$1000 category.
-
Received mine yesterday and so far, I'm delighted.
It was a toss up between a Dino and a Morgane.
What finally made up my mind was a trip to a local Morris festival.
There was a side playing there using three matching Dinos........but when another side lost their musician, they asked me to play for them using my old pokerwork.
That's when I realised that for me, you simply can't beat the sound of a Hohner, especially outside, playing for Morris.
To me.....you can pay an awful lot more for an instrument, and it will sound and look beautiful, but do they have that cutting edge tone that sounds like sunshine?
Phil
-
Nothing beats the sound of a Hohner, old or new!
They all have that little je ne sais quoi that cuts above the rest...
Everyone I met who tried my Morgane were impressed with its playability and sound properties, especially the rich deep basses.
-
Having tried a Morgane for the first time yesterday I am in two minds about them.
I would really like to buy one (being a fan of Hohners for 32 years) but I find the fingerboard really uncomfortable with some nasty sharp edges and a very square front edge. Has anyone else found the same or is it just me?
Is the front edge a solid capping that could be routed into a more thumb friendly shape and the edges softened?
Surely Hohner must be aware of the problem.
Any thoughts or ideas anyone?
Martyn
-
We've all passed on our thoughts about the sharp edges to Steve Proctor at Hohner UK. He reckons about 18 months before any changes are made in the production line.
Mind you that was over a year ago so maybe soon.
I'll make a note to keep nagging him.
-
I never found the edges of the fingerboard to be a problem, I guess someone with minimal woodcrafting skills could round off the edges and re-finish the thing. The fingerboard is a bit clunky but I like the buttons, and the action is very nice for an instrument in that price range, IMHO.
-
Had the Morgane for about a month now, but have hardly played it....recently had an operation for a hernia.
Today was its first real test, playing for my Morris side at a practice.
Result.....compliments from the side as to the quality of the sound...( not necessarily complimenting the musician I might add)
Secondly...I found the left hand side a bit heavy after playing nothing but a pokerwork for years....maybe down to lack of playing and just having had a flu jab though.
Buttons and action appear amazing. Bass sound is really deep. Tuning sound much more dry than my old pokerwork though.
Decided that I don't like the case much. It's almost as heavy as the instrument. Also, once the instrument is in the case there's no room for anything else like food, drink, sunscreen, mobile phones etc. Ordered one of those gig bag things.
On the whole, I think I've come to the decision that this is amazing value for money. A lovely instrument.
-
I played a Morgane for the first time at practice last week. I liked the sound, on the whole, and the action is nice but the case is heavy and clunky when compared with the Pokerwork - not nearly as comfortable on a single strap, the way all Border is played! The fingerboard is a near disaster for me (small hands) and as cumbersome as I found the Cairdin to be. BUT, if the fingerboard were rounded off a little and the reed treble banks could be interchanged with a Pokerwork set as required, you'd have a box for all Morris and ceilidh applications. It really only falls short on clever concert pieces, that I can't manage on my Costalotti!
Rob
-
Got a GC off Rees a couple of weeks ago so I hope I can join the discussion ;D
I've found it an excellent box for the money, I love the deep basses (okay they're a fifth lower than a DG), well constructed and a great tone (not as loud or as wet as a pokerwork I think). In my opinion the comfort and playability are far better than on any new pokerwork (or other cheap box) I've tried. As has been noted in this thread there are a few sharp edges which should be improved and the straps are a bit crap but actually work quite well. Not keen on the air button: I find it very easy to miss with my thumb so it taking a bit of effort to learn how to use it.
Certainly well worth the extra cash to get one of these instead of a pokerwork.
-
I've not played a Morgane yet, but I have got a G/C pokerwork and the lower pitch makes it quite a different animal from the D/G pokerwork and in my view much better, so if you want to compare Morganes & Pokerworks I'd suggest doing so at the same pitch to make it a fair comparison.
-
... so if you want to compare Morganes & Pokerworks I'd suggest doing so at the same pitch to make it a fair comparison.
From the sound of the box I'd agree but the playability (which I was really trying to compare) is not really affected by which keys the boxes are in. If I'd got a new pokerwork I'd have to sort out the keyboard and the left hand strap before I could play it comfortably - no need to do this on the Morgane (and it's got a nice wood finish :)).
-
<snip> the straps are a bit crap but actually work quite well. <snip>
First thing I did was to replace the straps with longer, better quality ones, but hey, it comes with "free" straps which can be used right off the box!
Certainly well worth the extra cash to get one of these instead of a pokerwork.
Yes, definitely! At least for the looks. And the mushroom keys are much easier to use.
-
I wonder if Theo or Rees could give us a summary of the internal changes from the Pokerwork to the Morgane? I appreciate that the Morgane action is improved, although it was always on the cards to make a better keyboard to strap onto a Pokerwork, after all it's only held on with two long screws! Are the reeds in the Morgane the long type, still? I would really love to get the best of both worlds - right now I only get the Pokerwork out to play Border - it's almost a part of the kit list! If you could get the German Pokerwork sound out of a Morgane that would be great! Do the reedblocks interchange? I'd take Derek's new box apart for a look, but he's bigger than me...
I saw Pip's comments on his two Ericas and wonder whether they sound like the Morgane now he has Italian reeds in them. Not really a Hohner any more, then. Why keep the s**t action and put ordinary reeds in? I love my Castagnaris, but only with the top reeds dry tuned. If I want tremolo, I want the whole Hohner sound! Perhaps I should just persuade everyone around me that the C/F club is the only way to go - or strike out alone with the Bb/Eb!
Rob.
-
I wonder if Theo or Rees could give us a summary of the internal changes from the Pokerwork to the Morgane?
I think they are both currently in Suffolk facilitating the making of one-row melodeons - lucky s**s
Simon
-
I've just had a poke about inside a Morgane.
The treble reed blocks are almost identical to the Pokerwork/Erica but are not immediately interchangeable.
Hohner have cunningly swopped the fixing method to the other end of the reed block so a bit of simple carpentry would be required in order to install the blocks.
I didn't get round to trying the bass blocks but would imagine they would also fit with a bit of fiddling.
Otherwise, it's pretty much the same internally although the exhaust hole for the air button is larger on the Morgane resulting in a faster air release.
-
Did you find anything inside that could be the cause of a subtle change in my playing technique?
I'm finding that I'm giving my Morgane a bit more Oooom and a little less Pahh over on the bass side.
Can't think why.
Phil
-
I didn't really investigate the left hand gubbins. I will poke about some more and play it alongside a Pokerwork to see if I can spot the difference.
-
.... Secondly...I found the left hand side a bit heavy after playing nothing but a pokerwork for years....maybe down to lack of playing and just having had a flu jab though.
Phil (?), don't blame yourself on that. My accordion had a job done on the treble side (see another thread) but the guy who did it, fixed the springs on the bass side also without saying anything to me and though we had not agreed of any jobs regarding the bass side. After I received the box I found I was actually able to do someting on the bass side. Afterwards I asked if he did something or was I only dreaming and he says yes, he fixed the springs as they made the bass side unplayable. And that is the opinion of a 5-row player and guy who has studied accordion building in school for some years.
You know, I'm really puzzled why folks have so many different opinions regarding the Morgane and it's playability. Have Hohner done modifications on the way so that there are different "setups" around and this is causing so many the different opinions, I just wonder.
PS. As far as I know piano keyboards have commonly accepted standards regarding the key travel and key force required. These values have been found suitable for human finger muscles. When values deviate from the optimal the players will experience difficulties of different kind. Not too difficult to agree that this is how it must be.
-
I didn't actually mean that the bass buttons were heavy.
I meant that the whole left side was heavy i.e. it weighs a lot more than a pokerwork left end.
Having said that, I think I''m getting used to it although my left arm now looks and feels a lot more powerful.
I can also play some really nifty triplets on the right hand side....faster than I used to be able to play on a pokerwork.
AND.........it doesn't clatter so much.
On the whole, I think its a gorgeous instrument and excellent value for money. It might be a bit of a dog in a manger attitude but I really can't see much sense in paying out a load of cash for an instrument that will be used for accompanying Morris....I mean, they are hardly likely to recognise a quality tone if it hit them in the face. Also, it would break my heart leaning a Castagnari against a lamp-post then watch a beagle pee all over it.
-
Hohner instruments vary so much.
I've just taken delivery of two brand new Corona II three row melodeons.
The one had a sweet sounding and very playable treble side but I had to fix the bass action as it was so hard that I could hardly push the buttons in.
The other had a perfect bass action but the treble side had several sticking buttons and a few notes way out of tune.
One Morgane that I recently had in stock had the bass strap screwed in the wrong place and the air button mechanism badly assembled resulting in the action being too short.
I'm awaiting delivery of a Corona Xtreme (I think, made in Germany). I'll report on the quality when it arrives.
-
I didn't actually mean that the bass buttons were heavy.
I meant that the whole left side was heavy i.e. it weighs a lot more than a pokerwork left end.
OK, my apolgies misreading and misunderstanding. Anyway, what I said still is totally valid concerning the button force required.
Some may think I am too pendantic or splitting hairs but what you want and/or can accept in you instrument varies a lot depending what you play etc.. When you are looking an instrument which does not limit you in any way these little details actually do make a difference. The Morgane has the potential but it is not quite yet there IMO.
-
Hohner instruments vary so much. <snip>
I guess this is true for most mass-market musical instruments, not just Hohner melodeons!
Take 3 guitars/violins/trumpets/etc of the same brand and model and they will all feel and sound different. This is true even for upscale models.
-
I've been following this thread with great interest as I would like to try a Merlin in G/C (Morgane with two extra treble buttons) I can't see that the extras would alter the tone and I agree with Dazbo that the lower toned boxes have an entirely different character.
On a practical matter, my Dony had sharp finger board edges when I received it and despite having paid a mortgage for it I took a wood plane to it the very first day. That was eighteen years ago and I'm still thrilled with the box.
Martin
-
I've just received a Merlin in D/G (quite rare). I haven't had time to put it on the website yet but will try to do so in the next few days.