Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: henrikfan on July 08, 2008, 02:49:55 PM

Title: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 08, 2008, 02:49:55 PM
Hello

     First post on your site, so I hope there's someone out there who can maybe help me.  After waking up one day and deciding I should learn to play an instrument before I die, I've been sucked into a melodeon vortex.  I found a shop online selling a two row Hohner which was listed as having G/C tuning.  I contacted them and exchanged emails.  I know nothing about the finer points of tuning etc., I don't read music (yet) and my taste in accordion music runs to Cajun and French tunes. The most recent email from the vendor states it's in good playable condition and is tuned C/C#, but couldn't be more specific as to some of the other enquiries I'd made as he played piano accordion.

     I am now confused about the tuning issue (their website said G/C, email says C/C#).  Are they different ways of saying the same thing, or should I write off the web details as a misprint?  Is there such a thing as a suitable tuning for a complete beginner, and if so, is C/C# one of those?  My head is now birlin' as I had to go online and try and find out about C/C#, and some of the stuff I came across says that it's almost obsolete!  I am attempting this in a complete vacuum as I don't know anyone who plays an instrument so would be grateful of any help anyone can offer which'll get me closer to owning and learning to play.

thanks in advance
henrikfan 

   
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Clive Williams on July 08, 2008, 03:11:09 PM
Hi there and welcome! Where about do you live? I think you're going to be much better off going to a specialist music shop if at all possible, rather than buying sight unseen from a website, and maybe we can put you in touch with like minded souls to get you started?

Re: your tuning - C/C# isn't what you'd recommend for people to learn on - it's one of the less commonly played tunings out there, but heaven knows there are lots of old instruments out there in these keys. For the music you're interested in, a G/C would probably be most appropriate, but if you're in the UK, consider a D/G, since you may find even local French sessions and playabouts are best suited for those keys.

Cheers,

Clive

Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 08, 2008, 03:52:11 PM
Hello Clive

     Thanks for the quick response.  Your input kind of bears out  the impression I was beginning to form about C/C# tuning (though I read that it's good for Irish tunes?). I live in rural SW Scotland and would prefer to buy from a friendly local shop, but there are none that deal with melodeons.  I went through the phone book for Glasgow, and could only come up with one which sold new Stephanelli's and one other store specialising in piano accordions, but they'd only one secondhand buttonbox which was close to the asking price of a new Stephanelli. Am trying to resist the temptation to jump and buy anything, as I'm keen to get started but worry about buying 'wrong'.  Am not aware as yet of any local melodeon groups, and think it may be down to trying to learn on my own (the man from shop selling the Hohner kindly sent me details of a tutor, but budget won't stretch to that at present).  I initially thought the one he was selling had my name on it (as it was listed as G/C)since I've been reading posts on this site for a few weeks and felt that's what I should look for. Will try and be patient  and hope that I will find something soon.

cheers
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Theo on July 08, 2008, 04:03:22 PM
Hi Henrik

Have you tried John Douglas Music in Dumfries?  They mostly deal with piano accordions, but they have the occasional button box. Looking at their site I see a Hohner G/C listed, maybe that is the one you are discussing.

I'd agree that C/C#  is not a good system to start with.  It is virtually an obsolete system.  The advantage of sticking with a commonly used system is that you will find it possible to find tuition, either in books and videos, or in person.        Do you know Jim Bainbridge from Glentrool?  Very good D/G player and singer.  Email me if you would like his contact details.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 08, 2008, 05:49:41 PM
Hello Theo

     Thanks for your input.  Have sent you email.

cheers
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: rees on July 08, 2008, 05:56:15 PM
Stay away from Stephanelli. They are made from re-cycled Chinese toilet paper! :o
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 08, 2008, 06:57:01 PM
Hello Rees

     Thanks for your insightful critique.  I bow to your superior knowledge, but I don't want to be looking much longer and might cave in and buy one if nothing else within my budget turns up.  I don't anticipate playing for ears other than my own, so who will ever know that either me or my instrument are rubbish?

cheers
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Bill Young on July 08, 2008, 08:58:49 PM
Stay away from Stephanelli. They are made from re-cycled Chinese toilet paper! :o
I don't agree with that at all. I recently played a Stephanelli 2-row B/C in Victor Morris, Glasgow, and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was - action at least as good as a Hohner Double Ray, good bright tone, excellent tuning. The bass action was better than my recently-acquired Delicia Popular. They're excellent value for money at half the price of Hohners. I have no hesitation in recommending a Stephanelli as a good beginner's instrument.
I also had a Stephanelli piano accordion for a while, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with it.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: an bosca ceoil on July 08, 2008, 09:16:15 PM
Without first hand experience I am not qualified to comment BUT I did send a converted Erica to Cork for a child who had been lent a Stephanelli by the school. According to the parents she had been unable to get on with that because " it did not sound right and made her arm hurt". Admittedly the bellows on mine were already played in so who knows? Could it be that early ones were not so good but now they are getting it right, like "Chinese" Hohners
Regards, Bruce
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Larry Anthony on July 09, 2008, 01:58:50 AM
Stay away from Stephanelli. They are made from re-cycled Chinese toilet paper! :o
I don't agree with that at all. I recently played a Stephanelli 2-row B/C in Victor Morris, Glasgow, and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was - action at least as good as a Hohner Double Ray, good bright tone, excellent tuning. The bass action was better than my recently-acquired Delicia Popular. They're excellent value for money at half the price of Hohners. I have no hesitation in recommending a Stephanelli as a good beginner's instrument.
I also had a Stephanelli piano accordion for a while, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with it.

I have a Stephanelli 2 row B/C, have had for about a year now, and I am well pleased with it. 

Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: rees on July 09, 2008, 12:27:32 PM
My mistake. I've just heard that the toilet paper is no longer re-cycled
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: george garside on July 09, 2008, 12:54:19 PM
Stay away from Stephanelli. They are made from re-cycled Chinese toilet paper! :o
I don't agree with that at all. I recently played a Stephanelli 2-row B/C in Victor Morris, Glasgow, and was pleasantly surprised at how good it was - action at least as good as a Hohner Double Ray, good bright tone, excellent tuning. The bass action was better than my recently-acquired Delicia Popular. They're excellent value for money at half the price of Hohners. I have no hesitation in recommending a Stephanelli as a good beginner's instrument.
I also had a Stephanelli piano accordion for a while, and there was absolutely nothing wrong with it.

I have a Stephanelli 2 row B/C, have had for about a year now, and I am well pleased with it. 



I have tried several stephanelli's in both BC & DG tuning  & agree with the various ' in favour' comments posted.  Several of my students on piano accordion have bought new stephanellis & they have all been quite good.  i.e. the 2 row boxes for around £200 are good value for a beginner & probably better than the other chinese stuff as the quality? seems consistant.  Having said that I still consider a second hand hohner pokerwork/erica to be a better bet if available as it will last for as long as you want it to & there is no reason why you need to upgrade (Tony Hall, John Kirpatrick and  others play pokerworks for a living).  Theo's restored vintage pokerworks are also worth considering.

As you go up the price ladder  the  'improvement' becomes  less per step whereas the jump from a chinese box to a pokerwork/erica is quite significant.
george
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 09, 2008, 01:13:14 PM
Hello

     Thanks for the posts reC/C# tuning.  I'm not ruling anything out in my search for a suitable instrument and would be happy to buy a Stephanelli in the light of the posts from those who sprung to it's defence.
regards
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Theo on July 09, 2008, 01:42:38 PM
I live in rural SW Scotland and would prefer to buy from a friendly local shop, but there are none that deal with melodeons.

It would be worth a try advertising locally, eg the Admag, card in post office window etc.  There are lots of old squeezeboxes sitting unused at the back of wardrobes, if you can just find them.

ps avoid any old German one-row boxes (except for Hohner) or anything that says made in Saxony.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 09, 2008, 01:57:16 PM
Hello Theo

     How well you recognise the mind set of the would-be melodeon player who's looking for an instrument.  I'm guessing you already know that I went on ebay on the wee hours and bought a one row Hohner with a bit of wood stuck on the back, so you'll probably see another post from me soonish, looking for bits to fix it up!  I intend to keep looking for a 2row though, as I've read conflicting information about the ease/difficulty of learning on 1row.
regards
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 09, 2008, 06:23:24 PM
Hello Theo

     How well you recognise the mind set of the would-be melodeon player who's looking for an instrument.  I'm guessing you already know that I went on ebay on the wee hours and bought a one row Hohner with a bit of wood stuck on the back, so you'll probably see another post from me soonish, looking for bits to fix it up!  I intend to keep looking for a 2row though, as I've read conflicting information about the ease/difficulty of learning on 1row.
regards
Henrikfan
The one-row will get you started well enough and you can do a lot with it as a beginner, but I do strongly advise you to get a two-row a.s.a.p. so that you can learn the relationship between the rows at an early stage. Two-row instruments are more than just a pair of one-rows stuck together.

I'm not sure how many would agree with me here but in my opinion, because of it's inherent limitations, it's harder to play a one-row really well than it is to play a two-row really well. The top one-row players make superb music from such an innocent looking little box.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: rees on July 09, 2008, 07:49:44 PM
As a beginner, much of the difficulty in playing a one-row four stop is due to the amount of air required to sound all four reeds.
When learning on a one-row push two of the stops in thus reducing it to a two voice instrument. Once you have reached a reasonable playing standard (give it a month or two) pull them out again and let 'er rip.

Depending on the make of instrument the stops will be arranged in a different order. It will be some combination of L M M H. You need to close Low and High leaving the two middle voices open.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 09, 2008, 08:16:47 PM
Hello

     Thanks to both the members who posted (see above).  Not sure that my instrument has any stops on it.  Does that make it a '2 voice'?  For anyone who's curious, I've added a link to it.
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=270253735102&ssPageName=STRK:MEWN:IT&ih=017
regards Lib
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 10, 2008, 10:02:04 AM
Yes, your "new" box is a two voice, with three chords available in the bass.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: george garside on July 10, 2008, 10:02:15 AM
Hello

     Thanks to both the members who posted (see above).  Not sure that my instrument has any stops on it.  Does that make it a '2 voice'?  For anyone who's curious, I've added a link to it.
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&rd=1&item=270253735102&ssPageName=STRK:MEWN:IT&ih=017
regards Lib
[/quote

Its a hohner 1140 , 2 voice, they were available in C & G

george
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 11, 2008, 12:12:01 AM
Hello

     Thanks George & Rob2Hook for snippets of info.  Feel like I'm holding my breath 'til the postie arrives.

regards
Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Lester on July 11, 2008, 09:02:33 AM
Whilst I own a Tommy and a L'Elfique, and love them to death, I am currently having most fun playing my Hohnner Liliput and an Ebay £100 Hohner Club. The Hohner sound is so happy and all the button clacking and other spurious percission adds to the whole effect.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 11, 2008, 05:42:20 PM
Hello Lester

     Box arrived today, so can finally breathe out.  I love it.  The vendor had packaged it really well, so it arrived intact, and yes, it does clack a bit (buttons on the bass side) and sometimes I can hear a sound which I can only describe as a bit like a jew's harp, but it's all sweet music to my cloth ears.  Think it deserves a bit of a buff up and I'll maybe try and change the cloth behind the grill as it looks like a heavy smoker's lungs.  If there's anything you'd recommend I do to diminish the clacking buttons, I'd appreciate it ( I can see what look like old, very flat, felt backed washers under a couple of the base buttons: I'm guessing that I should replace these?).

regards
Henrkfan 
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Theo on July 11, 2008, 05:45:05 PM
That is the big secret - the built in Hohner percussion section, and no MIDI required.  Just enjoy playing it.
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: henrikfan on July 11, 2008, 06:14:57 PM
Hello Theo

     Just looking at it is making me happy, and I will enjoy trying to play it.  I'm still at the 'picking out a tune with one finger' stage, so clacky bass buttons are not really a hindrance to progress. Thanks to all who post on this site for allowing beginners to share the knowledge pool.  Am off now to bond with my melodeon.

Henrikfan
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Theo on July 11, 2008, 07:50:08 PM
   Just looking at it is making me happy,

That's the way they work!  Looks like a good buy, in fact I've I'd seem it first I would have bought it!!
Title: Re: Tuning confusion
Post by: Old Leaky on July 11, 2008, 10:22:20 PM
Have you tried John Douglas Music in Dumfries?  They mostly deal with piano accordions, but they have the occasional button box.

Er, not a good source of button boxes in my experience (and closed on Thursdays!)

I'm from the Clyde Coast, and have found that the only specialist folk/traditional music shop in all of Scotland on a par with the Hobgoblin(s) and Music Room(s) that my English (and Welsh?) neighbours have more ready access to, and perhaps take for granted, is "Celtic Chords" in Stonehaven, near Aberdeen. OK it's in the NE of Scotland but having bought two (C#/D) Saltarelles* as well as a vintage Lachenal Anglo concertina there over the years, I'd give the friendly and knowledgeable owner (and player) Pete Murray serious consideration. His web-site (www.celtic-chords.co.uk) is still in need of development (Theo?) but his shop is well stocked with a good variety of button boxes (Cajun one-row, B/C, C#/D, D/G tunings), piano accordions, fiddles, guitars, whistles, books/tutors and CDs.

I've not been shy about promoting Pete's shop to all and sundry, including Theo, as he really is unique north of the border.

*I think he specializes in Castagnari rather than Saltarelle these days, but carries other makes like Hohner as well as trade-ins. A bit late for Henrik, but I'd recommend Celtic-Chords to others - well worth a try wherever you are.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal