Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Telemorris on April 15, 2011, 01:05:43 AM

Title: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Telemorris on April 15, 2011, 01:05:43 AM
I'm playing with a mini-melodeon design. One thing I've been searching the archives for is an understanding of how much space there should be between the inside edges of the bellows and the both the treble and bass reed blocks. Tolerances in a small melodeon are quite tight so I'd like to make the clearance as small as possible.

If you have a small instrument, would you please measure the distance between the inside of the bellows and one or the other reed block? Has anyone had problems with the clearance being too small with the result that the valves closest to the bellows are bent or damaged?

Thanks
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Theo on April 15, 2011, 07:26:24 AM
Has anyone had problems with the clearance being too small with the result that the valves closest to the bellows are bent or damaged?


This is a regular problem with small format boxes.   I have had to replace valves on the left hand end of  several Oakwoods.  Castagnari get round this in the Lily (and Tommy?)  by designing a single bass/chord reedblock.

It is not usually such a problem on the treble side because, (a) the reeds and blocks are smaller, and (b) the reedblocks are mostly enclosed within the treble case.   
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 15, 2011, 09:12:59 AM
Castagnari get round this in the Lily (and Tommy?)  by designing a single bass/chord reedblock. 
Yes - the Tommy also has a single bass/chord reedblock.
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: diatosoldo on April 15, 2011, 10:27:46 AM
what about Castagnari Benny ?
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Theo on April 15, 2011, 10:50:42 AM
Benny has two blocks.   It's not particularly small compared with the Lily and Tommy,  though it is small for a three row.
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Christopher K. on April 15, 2011, 04:07:08 PM
I'm playing with a mini-melodeon design. One thing I've been searching the archives for is an understanding of how much space there should be between the inside edges of the bellows and the both the treble and bass reed blocks. Tolerances in a small melodeon are quite tight so I'd like to make the clearance as small as possible.

If you have a small instrument, would you please measure the distance between the inside of the bellows and one or the other reed block? Has anyone had problems with the clearance being too small with the result that the valves closest to the bellows are bent or damaged?

Thanks

Can you lay the blocks flat against the soundboard? As in Lily, 1040, etc.
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Telemorris on April 15, 2011, 05:36:24 PM

This is a regular problem with small format boxes.   I have had to replace valves on the left hand end of  several Oakwoods.  Castagnari get round this in the Lily (and Tommy?)  by designing a single bass/chord reedblock.

It is not usually such a problem on the treble side because, (a) the reeds and blocks are smaller, and (b) the reedblocks are mostly enclosed within the treble case.   

I did take another look at my Hohner Pokerwork last night. The treble reed blocks are about 9mm away from the bellows at the end of the reedblock. And there's very little of the reedblock exposed above the edge of the case. If any rubbing did occur it would only hit the wood end of the treble reedblock.

The bass end is the real issue. I'm looking at designing a single reedblock, yes, but there are designs I'm coming up with that would allow me to fit quite a bit (12 button) into a very small space.

How much distance is there between the edge of the bass reedblock in a Lily or a Tommy and the inside folds of the bellows. Would someone with one of these instruments please measure?  Also, the same measurement on an Oakwood would be helpful given Theo's comments.

Thanks
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Theo on April 15, 2011, 05:39:07 PM
Remember that bass reeds need the have a large volume of reed chamber in order to speak promptly.  So don't make the reedblocks too shallow.
Title: Re: How much space necessary between reedblocks and bellows?
Post by: Telemorris on April 15, 2011, 06:03:36 PM
Remember that bass reeds need the have a large volume of reed chamber in order to speak promptly.  So don't make the reedblocks too shallow.

I'm planning on a good size of reed chamber for the bass end.

My main issue is not the width of the reedblock but the length of the block, if that makes sense. I have plenty of room for the reeds and the valves to open, in the current design. It's the distance from the wooden end to the bellows fold that I'm concerned about. Maybe a picture would help. I'll try to get one up today.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal