Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Pat. on April 16, 2011, 07:47:24 AM

Title: Boxeen
Post by: Pat. on April 16, 2011, 07:47:24 AM
I have just got hold of a Boxeen B/C ,21 button box .It has 3 registers and 3 voices tunned to the dry side of swing very pleased with it but the base cords are very thin sounding ,but very pleased over all  ,Has anyone else ever had one of these boxes?
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: jackson10 on April 18, 2011, 12:54:16 PM
I bought one pretty much like the one you describe from Jim Coogan (RIP) at "The Box Office" in New York about 5 years ago. It's a 3-reed MMM. The basses have no thirds so that could be a limitation sometimes but I bought it to play Irish so I was not too concerned. I like the sound and playability but sometimes think about having something lighter than 9 1/2 pounds. When that happens I play my Black Dot B/C for a while. I am pleased overall with the Boxeen and will probably stick with it unless my playing technique develops to the point where I really think I need something else. Hope you enjoy yours as well as I have enjoyed mine.
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: Pat. on April 18, 2011, 03:03:27 PM
Thankyou for your response Jackson 10.you have identified my base problem ,does this mean I am lacking a set of reeds  compared to a paolo soprani for example ,bare with me as I do not understand musical terms.
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: jackson10 on April 18, 2011, 08:07:08 PM
I'm not an expert either but yes I believe leaving out the 3rds saves weight so some reeds are not there. Jim explained that to me when I bought it.  I think for the Irish music it is not considered that important.
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: Stiamh on April 18, 2011, 08:24:19 PM
Not having thirds in the basses makes the chords "neutral" so that they can do duty as major or minor.

This is because the third degree of the scale is what makes the scale and the chord major or minor: e.g. D + F# + A is a D major chord. D + Fnat + A is a D minor chord.

Having the thirds is not so much unimportant for Irish music as a distinct disadvantage. If you have thirds, then your D chord will always be major, and you can never use it in a D minor tune, for example. If you have thirds, your A chord will be major and you can forget about accompanying A minor tunes, and so on. Whereas if your chords are thirdless - neutral - you can use them for both major and minor tunes.

You will find that most players using classic Irish boxes such as the old Paolo Sopranis will have removed the thirds by taping over them. So you are in good company.

Some boxes have a stop or register to remove the thirds temporarily. I have them switched off permanently. In my opinion, if the box has no thirds at all, you don't have a "bass problem" but the solution to the usual bass problem. (:)
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: DaveCottrell on April 18, 2011, 11:37:24 PM
I have a 4-voice model that I like very much. It is not session-loud, but it is my box of choice for playing for dances when there is amplification. In neither of these situations do I use the bass, but they are a little quieter than my Saltarelles. 

This is an excellent sounding accordion. It has all the character of a Paolo Soprani but is sweet and not brash. It also cost about 30% of the going rate for a Paolo. Enjoy this accordion as they are scarce and special.

Dave
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: Pat. on April 19, 2011, 06:38:46 AM
Thanks for all your helpful reply s ,the thing is with me is that I am from that old school of b/c players that like the deep grunt on the bases,so iwill it mean having to have a reed added or having one converted?
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: jackson10 on April 19, 2011, 03:57:34 PM
Seems to me it will need that, but better to let someone more knowledgeable answer.
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: Stiamh on April 19, 2011, 04:20:10 PM
Pat, do you mean you want to add thirds to the chords, or an extra bass reed? Either way, this is likely to involve alterations to the bass reed blocks, which may not be a simple matter.

I suggest you get in touch with John Nolan via his website (http://accordionwizard.com/). If I recall correctly, he helped Jim Coogan to design the Boxeen, and he repairs boxes, so he could probably advise you on what could be done.
Title: Re: Boxeen
Post by: Theo on April 19, 2011, 04:20:34 PM
Thanks for all your helpful reply s ,the thing is with me is that I am from that old school of b/c players that like the deep grunt on the bases,so iwill it mean having to have a reed added or having one converted?

Adding in the extra reeds to put thirds into the chords is not going to give you a "deep grunt", though it will fill out the chord sound.

I wonder if your box has perhaps had the low bass reeds taken out of play as well?  Many players of Irish music prefer a light sound and I've seen this mod on BC boxes of various makes.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal