Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Simon on April 16, 2011, 03:18:09 PM

Title: Talking and playing
Post by: Simon on April 16, 2011, 03:18:09 PM
Sometimes when I'm playing in public people start talking to me or even ask questions. I know some people can play and talk at the same time, but I'm not one of them. I already get confused if somebody asks me what I'd like to drink. How do you handle this? Stop playing? Ignoring the guy talking to you? Put a "don't talk while I'm playing" sign on your box? Any help is welcome.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: blafleur on April 16, 2011, 03:24:06 PM
I can't either, how about getting a louder accordion. ;D
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Sandy Flett on April 16, 2011, 03:38:51 PM
The odd time it has happened to me I have tried to give them a big smile, like you might do if you do not speak the language, then, if I care enough, speak to them once I have stopped playing and explain.

Sure you can't manage a nod if somebody offers to buy you a drink? Perhaps the sign you need to wear is of the ale you prefer.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Alan Morley on April 16, 2011, 03:54:31 PM
Sometimes when I'm playing in public people start talking to me or even ask questions. I know some people can play and talk at the same time, but I'm not one of them. I already get confused if somebody asks me what I'd like to drink. How do you handle this? Stop playing? Ignoring the guy talking to you? Put a "don't talk while I'm playing" sign on your box? Any help is welcome.

I'm glad it's not just me then.....I can sing and play, but not talk and play. The 'What do you want to drink' question is always difficult to answer without stopping.. :|glug

Almo
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Simon on April 16, 2011, 03:56:04 PM
I might try singing. They never bother the singer  ;)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: xgx on April 16, 2011, 04:06:54 PM
Have a go at saying words (any will do for a start) in time with the music ...keep it simple!
Practise it whenever you get the chance... e.g.  :||: :|bl :Ph  or Mine's a a large Brandy Ta!  :|glug

Al(mo) it should be a doddle for you as you can already sing along  ;)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: george garside on April 16, 2011, 04:14:23 PM
the slightest utterence ( or attempt  at ) results in a balls up. I put it sown to overload of my feeble brain which has enough to cope with deciding which button on which row to press, which bellows direction and what to do with both ends of the box at  the same time plus of course watching the dancers, listening to singers etc etc.  How I envy those with split brains who can play & call dances at the same time!

george
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Stiamh on April 16, 2011, 04:26:35 PM
I reckon that in many people, myself included, playing music and talking uses the same neurocircuits. Attempt to do both and one will stop. Other people seem to have completely separate circuitry and I am very jealous of them.

I once watched the American fiddle player Eileen Ivers in performance, playing reels at 150 mph, walk to the edge of the stage and engage in a very animated back-and-forth conversation with the fellow at the sound desk for a good couple of minutes, without dropping a note.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Alan Morley on April 16, 2011, 04:49:27 PM
Have a go at saying words (any will do for a start) in time with the music ...keep it simple!
Practise it whenever you get the chance... e.g.  :||: :|bl :Ph  or Mine's a a large Brandy Ta!  :|glug

Al(mo) it should be a doddle for you as you can already sing along  ;)

I can only sing whilst playing 'rhythm' melodeon chords (or guitar for that matter) it's a great skill to be able to sing while playing a melody line.

Just slightly off topic - When I used to play a lot of Working Men's Clubs, I was always fascinated when watching the clubs organist.
Both feet playing base lines and controlling the volumn while their hands fly all over the place playing melody / chords / changing the slides and stops for different voices on the old Hammond organs - no midi in those days....Pure genius...

Alan
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Marje on April 16, 2011, 05:16:35 PM
I can sing and play but not talk and play. Even calling "Out!" or "Change!" is tricky and I have to time it at the end of a phrase if it's not going to throw me. I can listen to what others are saying, and greet people with a friendly nod while playing, but that's about it. I think other musicians are generally sympathetic, but non-players don't always understand that although I may seem to be playing without thinking much about it, certain parts of my brain are locked into the music and are temporariy unavailable for other activities such as talking.

I suppose there is a good side to this. I find that other activities incompatible with playing include fretting or worrying, which is one reason that playing music is such a refreshing and relaxing activity. Maybe this is because when I'm stressed, I tend to worry in a very verbal way, so anything that gets in the way of talking will also get in the way of worrying.

Works for me, anyway.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Anahata on April 16, 2011, 10:12:23 PM
I heard Bob Cann spent a long of time in bed recuperating from an illness, during which he taught himself to call dances while playing the melodeon.
Dave Jolly sometimes plays melodeon and calls as a complete one-man ceilidh band.

I think it is something you can learn with practice, but it certainly comes easier to some than others.
You have to go through a learning process with singing too; the difference between singing and talking is you've practised what you're going to sing.

The next step after you've mastered "change" and "out" is to call the name of the next tune, while playing in a session.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: juker on April 16, 2011, 11:37:34 PM
I suspect that for some reason it is easier (relatively speaking) to say something while playing a fiddle. I have seen quite a few people do this, but never someone with a melodeon (though I am sure it is possible).
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Gary P Chapin on April 17, 2011, 12:52:40 AM
I can barely keep from drooling when I play, let alone talking. I get such joy out of playing, but my vids are so slack jawed. No I'm not having conversations.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Alan Morley on April 17, 2011, 08:59:41 AM
It's really hard talking and playing harmonica.... ::)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: brianread on April 17, 2011, 09:38:20 AM
when I first started Morris dancing I was asked quite early on to dance "no 1" which mean't calling the next move as the dance progressed. It took quite a bit of work to be able to do it (including dancing in my front room and calling - amused the family).  Over 10 years I did get quite easy with it, even to the extent of calling funny names for the moves (Bed and Breakfast for Back to Back?).

When I started playing the melodeon for dances, I could "just about" call "change" or "out", although sometimes it degenerated to "hup".  Now I can manage to call that the next tune is coming or the end, but I still have to "think" about it.

As others have said, sometimes people will ask you questions, I can manage a one or two word answer, often timed to correspond to an "easy bit" in the tune.  I can even tell someone (our whistle player normally) what the tune is called, although it has to be spat out at a juidicious moment.

The point I am making is that these things can be overcome (to a certain extent) by practice. 

I have also see players calling at the same time (melodeon, fiddle, not whistle though).  Those guys are one level higher than us mortals I think.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: xgx on April 17, 2011, 10:16:02 AM
It's really hard talking and playing harmonica.... ::)

It's a Gender thing Alan, males can't multi-task :D
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Anahata on April 17, 2011, 10:20:19 AM
I suspect that for some reason it is easier (relatively speaking) to say something while playing a fiddle.
Maybe, but a fiddle player in my regular sessison is notoriously unable to do this! A rabbit-in-headlights stare is usually  the best she can manage  (:)

I can manage a one or two word answer, often timed to correspond to an "easy bit" in the tune.  I can even tell someone (our whistle player normally) what the tune is called

That's about my level too.
Though I remember playing a ceilidh where the caller started losing her voice, and we decided the members of the band should each call a dance. I managed that, but it was years ago, before anyone told me it was almost impossible to do  ;D
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: george garside on April 17, 2011, 12:34:42 PM
It's really hard talking and playing harmonica.... ::)

It's a Gender thing Alan, males can't multi-task :D


? bionic gobs - work without any connection to the brain whatsoever!

george (ducking fast!) ;)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: strad on April 17, 2011, 02:21:00 PM
"I suspect that for some reason it is easier (relatively speaking) to say something while playing a fiddle."

I disagree with that. If the fiddle is under your chin it's hard to speak at all. I can just about manage to
mumble the next key. But I find it much easier when playing melodeon - strange, that!

Nigel
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: brianread on April 17, 2011, 02:27:10 PM
"I suspect that for some reason it is easier (relatively speaking) to say something while playing a fiddle."

I disagree with that. If the fiddle is under your chin it's hard to speak at all. I can just about manage to
mumble the next key. But I find it much easier when playing melodeon - strange, that!

Nigel

Our fiddle player just points with the neck of the fiddle if he is using music, sand wants to move onto the next tune (or back or whatever).  Moving on is usually a nod of the head when he sees me looking at him.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 17, 2011, 08:36:55 PM
Yes, it takes practice - that's why I can manage to say "pint".  It's just the awkward ones who want to know which beer...

Rob.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on April 17, 2011, 10:11:19 PM
The answer to calling while fiddling is of course not to stick the thing under your chin! This also makes it easier to dance while playing,  :M but this technique is not one I would recomend to people who are not me, because it has several disadvantages. Isn't this supposed to be a Melodeon Site?  :o
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Owen Woods on April 17, 2011, 10:23:01 PM
It is a practice thing. The last time this subject was taken up I said that I couldn't at all, I now can a bit. It requires a fair bit of concentration, but I can do it. Interestingly I have no problem playing piano and talking over it, but box is harder. Of course, I can't sing and play something different underneath, that would be a long way off :P
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Simon on April 18, 2011, 07:30:59 AM
I'll try practicing then. I would love to be able to utter a few words without messing up the notes. I don't have this problem with other instruments (except for xaphoon), so it must be a box thing.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: summerstars on April 18, 2011, 07:47:50 AM
In my very early days of playing (about 4 years ago)  I found myself as being the only regular musician with our dance side at a weekend event at Upton upon Severn.  I struggled through the Saturday and recruited some help from friends and other musicians.  On the sunday, we had a procession to do - the musicians being myself and an an another chap who occasionally played PA with us.  we agreed in advance what tunes we would play, and in what order, and set off.  I then realised that I had never tried walking and playing at the same time, never mind talking as well - it took so much concentration to be able to put one foot in front of the other and to continue to play the tune in time.   after a while of playing our first tune "Donkey Riding" I decided it was time to change - no matter how hard I tried, I couldn't even utter a grunt to indicate change to the next pre-arranged tune - so we carried on playing Donkey Riding, and carried on .......  eventually I just stopped playing, communicated with my fellow musician, and then started the next tune.   

The same weekend, at one dance-spot, in the middle of a dance, someone approached me and asked "Can you talk and play at the same time" - in order to say "NO" I ended up stopping playing in the middle of the dance - luckily our dancers were aware of my limitations at the time and had learnt to carry on with the dance by singing the tune themselves until such time as I could pick it up again.   
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Anahata on April 18, 2011, 08:02:37 AM
Of course, I can't sing and play something different underneath, that would be a long way off :P

That's just practice too.
When Mary and I do "Sweet Chiming Bells" (every Christmas) I sing a bass line to the chorus while playing tune + chords on Anglo concertina. Similarly with Truro Wassail on melodeon.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Owen Woods on April 18, 2011, 09:43:13 AM
Of course, I can't sing and play something different underneath, that would be a long way off :P

That's just practice too.
When Mary and I do "Sweet Chiming Bells" (every Christmas) I sing a bass line to the chorus while playing tune + chords on Anglo concertina. Similarly with Truro Wassail on melodeon.


I expect it is just practising yes. Unfortunately I'm not much of a singer, so it won't be something that will be practised very much! :P
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: waltzman on April 18, 2011, 01:06:27 PM
Unfortunately I'm not much of a singer,

also largely a matter of practice.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Quebecois on April 18, 2011, 05:31:17 PM
I can sing and play but not talk and play.
Then, sing the answer!
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Marje on April 18, 2011, 06:23:11 PM
I have wondered about singing the answer. Maybe I need to give this a try in the privacy of my own home first, in case I find it messes up both my tune and my reply. I will need to consider the likely questions and answers, but it's an interesting challenge.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: siamsa on April 18, 2011, 07:38:12 PM
The bane of my life is trying to talk or sing along whilst playing. I even find it hard to shout out a key change whilst playing fast tunes.
How about this cheeky sod.  He even goes off stage to speak with the sound man and never drops a note. :o
http://youtu.be/mIdUTNfSUno
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: TomB on April 18, 2011, 07:49:51 PM
..and he can even chew gum out of time with the music..awsome  :o ;D
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: brianread on April 19, 2011, 10:02:04 AM
I've learned to sing with box, but can't do speech at all. however - try out this "commented improvisation" from Pignol - shot by my lad Fred about 6 years ago

  http://www.youtube.com/user/doc3row?blend=7&ob=5#p/u/0/p2iDyTwy1xQ

Chris - your link seems to not be a link - possibly the leading space?
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: nemethmik on April 19, 2011, 03:49:18 PM
I think it is something you can learn with practice, but it certainly comes easier to some than others.
You have to go through a learning process with singing too; the difference between singing and talking is you've practised what you're going to sing.
The next step after you've mastered "change" and "out" is to call the name of the next tune, while playing in a session.
Exactly, with practice it will come step-by-step in about a year or two.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Noodle on April 20, 2011, 07:52:38 AM
Think yourselves fortunate. I struggle to play the basses while playing, let alone be able to talk
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: diatosoldo on April 20, 2011, 10:59:30 AM
The bane of my life is trying to talk or sing along whilst playing. I even find it hard to shout out a key change whilst playing fast tunes.
How about this cheeky sod.  He even goes off stage to speak with the sound man and never drops a note. :o
http://youtu.be/mIdUTNfSUno
maybe chewing gum is a help  ;)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: diatosoldo on April 20, 2011, 11:16:04 AM
The same weekend, at one dance-spot, in the middle of a dance, someone approached me and asked "Can you talk and play at the same time" - in order to say "NO" I ended up stopping playing in the middle of the dance - luckily our dancers were aware of my limitations at the time and had learnt to carry on with the dance by singing the tune themselves until such time as I could pick it up again.   

And what about dancing and playing (though  I know it's not the present topic !) ?
a link hereabove which amazed me summer 2009 ..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gGKPqLm0luw
(I was there ... only among the dancers .. )
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Stiamh on April 20, 2011, 01:14:58 PM
A while ago I was watching a clip of Jimi Hendrix and my daughter, five at the time, observed, "Daddy, that man can play guitar, dance, sing and chew gum at the same time!"
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Sandy on April 20, 2011, 01:41:22 PM
It's important for parents to learn to play and say No! , Yes! , Not now! and In a minute!  ::) It started with a nod for me  (:)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: TomB on April 20, 2011, 07:22:43 PM
Years ago I remember Jack Brown's morris workshops. He always would accompany himself on melodeon whilst dancing a solo jig.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 21, 2011, 07:05:22 AM
Try again in a full [ url ] wrappper - this looks to be a bug in the 'modify' button - invisible on 'preview'

"I've learned to sing with box, but can't do speech at all. however - try out this "commented improvisation" from Pignol - shot by my lad Fred about 6 years ago"

  http://www.youtube.com/user/doc3row?blend=7&ob=5#p/u/0/p2iDyTwy1xQ (http://www.youtube.com/user/doc3row?blend=7&ob=5#p/u/0/p2iDyTwy1xQ)

.. (it would always cut and paste)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Lyn on May 05, 2011, 04:00:16 PM
DAMN!! I knew I was going to have to watch the dribbling, but didn't realise that melodeon players in full flow are rendered speechless too - believe me, I know no fiddler player who can do more than grunt whilst playing (or any other time, really....) I can just about mange CHNNG! between gritted teeth. I suspect singing may be easier, but keep forgetting to try it.

"Yes! I'll have another pint, tra-la-la, no make it a double vodkammmmmmmmmm!"

Oh well, no instrument as yet, so probably weeks to practise. ;D
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Folkiekay on May 05, 2011, 08:24:45 PM
I can barely keep from drooling when I play, let alone talking. I get such joy out of playing, but my vids are so slack jawed. No I'm not having conversations.

I'm with Gary on this one.  I drool.  I have to stop playing when someone asks me a question - or just smile and nod and wait to finish the tune to talk.  I'm thinking that diatonic accordions are really more difficult to play than a lot of instruments - or at least they take more brain power.  Not only are we trying to remember all the notes on both hands - but then we also have to deal with the bellows in and out.  There's a lot going on there.  People should just bring us booze without asking...:-)
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Martin J on May 07, 2011, 05:49:51 PM
Talking and playing is an art form.  Simon, you should practice the words "mine's a pint of !!??" in every tune you play.  It will fit very well somewhere in time to the music.  You need to practice regional variations ie. Green King, Ruddles, Ringwood Forty Niner etc.

Treat it as personal development on your journey toward calling and playing.

Oh yes, one last thing.  Never listen to the question, just place your order for a drink.   ;D :|glug :|glug :|glug
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 09, 2011, 11:40:53 AM
I suspect that most of our playing is subconcious - whenever I actively think about anything for more than a few seconds I screw up!  It seems to tie in with the defensive "denial" phase of dealing with problems.  I think I switch off the main part of my brain so as not to impinge on its subconcious activities (playing).  Speaking is just too much, unless I've practiced patting my head and rubbing my tummy!

Rob.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Marje on May 09, 2011, 02:29:35 PM
I surprised myself at a session the other night. I was leading a tune, a hornpipe, and when I got to the 4th line I couldn't remember how it went, expect that it was a "rumpy-pumpy bump bump bump" like so many hornpipes. And I found myself shrieking "Arrrgh, I've forgotten how this bit goes!" while keeping the bass chords going in a feasible manner. I never knew I could do that. Luckily someone else knew the tune well and patched it up for me, so we never missed a beat.
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: IanD on May 09, 2011, 11:36:18 PM
You just have to get the tune into the groove so it's playing almost automatically, then you can talk at the same time :-)

Comes in very handy for commenting on dance cock-ups or reminding Smiffs how they could improve their sticking during a dance...

Ian

("By doing it in time with the bloody music!")
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 10, 2011, 12:30:29 AM
Hear! Hear! (ie "in time with the bloody music!"  :M
Title: Re: Talking and playing
Post by: Accordion Dave on May 16, 2011, 02:44:42 AM
I can not talk and play at the same time. I try to smile or nod, but most people have no clue and think I am rude. I try to explain when I finish the tune.

There are some folks who have no concept of how a bellows works and sit on my left side. At that point the music stops and the conversation begins.
Some know full well how the bellows works and use it to stop the music.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal