Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: marker on April 17, 2011, 11:45:30 AM
-
Hello folks, I am new to the forum and the melodeon.
I have just purchased a new Hohner Double Ray B/C box. I am an owner of a Lachenal 48 key English concertina, when I bought this four years ago, I had no idea what type of tunes I wanted to play. I learnt some traditional folk tunes, but I found myself drawn more to the traditional Irish tunes, especially after buying Dave Mallinsons book and CD.
I learnt to play some of the tunes from Daves book "Vital Irish Session tunes" on my tina, but came to a stop when a lot of them did not sound correct and became difficult to play.
I just want to find out if I am thinking correctly! I have read the thread about B/C boxes being ideal for Irish tunes, so I have bought one, but I noticed that Dave Mallinson plays the tunes from his book on a D/G box, as most of the tunes are in D and G, am I right in thinking that I would still play these tunes on my B/C box in the same keys as they are written in the book, by cross fingering the rows of majors and sharps?
-
I still have me 'L' plates on with BC & BCC# boxes but this may help....
Match your buttons on the BC with the correct chart (you'll need to scroll down to BC) here:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard_2_row.html
You'll see that the C row has all the naturals and the B row has the F# and C# you'll need... there are possibilities for different fingerings...
If you're free 18-22 July there's always the button box course here:
http://www.smo.uhi.ac.uk/Foghlam/Tagh-Cursa/Cursaichean-Goirid/cursaichean_samhraidh_en.html ...
-
Hi-
I'm pretty new to the B/C box myself, though I've played Irish music for many years. B/C does seem to be the box of choice right now for Irish players. Tunes in D and G work fine on the B/C box. You do cross into the B row for the F# and C#. I found the DVD tutor by John Williams very helpful. He suggests thinking about the e F#G buttons and the b c# d buttons as "triangles" to familiarize yourself with.
http://www.amazon.com/DVD-Learn-Play-Irish-Button-Accordion/dp/B000929USW (http://www.amazon.com/DVD-Learn-Play-Irish-Button-Accordion/dp/B000929USW)
I'm also planning on taking the button box class at the Willie Clancy School in County Clare in July, and I'm hoping that it will give my technique a big boost!
-
That looks to be a great place to be for that week
http://www.setdancingnews.net/wcss/ and good value at €140
Thanks for mentioning it Zana ... shame they don't do smallpipe classes and cheaper ferry crossings ;)
-
Thanks for the replies, they answer my question.
I have looked at the keyboard layout thread, vey helpful, thanks. I am presuming that the Hohner B/C layout, is the same as the diagram for the modern bass?
-
I have looked at the keyboard layout thread, vey helpful, thanks. I am presuming that the Hohner B/C layout, is the same as the diagram for the modern bass?
I don't know, never having tried a recent Double-Ray. But if you want help identifying the chords, we can walk you through which r/h buttons to press along with the basses to find out.
-
New Double Rays sold in England do seem to have 'traditional' (paolo soprani) (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BC21tradbass.gif)bass layout as standard with the seemingly pointless repeated push C. I had a recent double ray in the workshop last week with that bass setup.
-
Thanks, I shall go with the traditional.
I have not received my melodeon yet, it should be with me by Thursday!
-
The best way to understand the BC at the beginning is to learn the most common scales, D, G and A.
-
A very very helpful book is The Box by David Hanrahan. See if you can scare up a copy. I gave mine away to a budding player (who is miles better than me already, durn talented kid!!). Worked for him!
-
It helps some beginners to think in terms of the C row being similar to the white notes on a piano ;& the B row akin to the black notes. i.e. learn scale in C first for full length of box. Then G which is the same scale as C but starting part way through & diverting to the B row for F#. Then do same for D & A. When playing in A make as much use as possible possible of push E & B otherwise bellows are going to go ever outwards.
george
-
Thanks for all the tips, can't wait to try them.
-
I have a copy of "The Box" as recommended above. To be honest I don't find it much use, but you are welcome to it with my blessing. If you're interested, pm me your address and I'll post it out.
-
I have a copy of "The Box" as recommended above. To be honest I don't find it much use, but you are welcome to it with my blessing. If you're interested, pm me your address and I'll post it out.
Thanks for your offer Gandy, I shall see how I get on and let you know, as I only received my box today.
-
As far as I know, the only button accordion classes in London.
http://www.irishculturalcentre.co.uk/?q=content/irish-traditional-music-beginners-improvers-and-advanced-musicians
(Also, the ICC is campaigning for survival, after a shocking decision by Hammersmith and Fulham to sell the building.)
-
I found it strange when I started out on the road of getting to grips with the BC that there so few, indeed no, tutor books for the instrument apart from 'The Box'. Apart from the sources mentioned above, there is also Damien Connolly's 'The Accordion Tutor Vol.1', available from his website http://www.irishmusicinconnecticut.com/. When I bought it, the cost was c£30, which is expensive compared to some tutors, but what's the cost of an hour's tuition?? It covers the use of both right and left hands, includes a CD to play along with, and is designed as a programme of tutorials.
You do need to learn his symbol set to interpret the diagrams, and I am not a fan of 'slipping' the fingers from key/button to adjacent key (I have moved from that to trying to use the opportunity of repeat notes on the same key to change fingers and so get into position for the next notes/phrase, as recommended by Jim Mackay), but if you work your way through the book you will certainly master the basics in a very thorough way.
Any-one coming from playing Celtic music on the anglo concertina will be familiar with cross-row playing, and so the technique of the BC is relatively familiar BUT the options are a lot fewer, so bellows technique is much more important. Working on scales and arpeggios for a few minutes at every practice certainly sharpens that up.
As far as I can see, at least!! Good luck.
-
John Williams DVD is useful (he use to be with Solas)
Learn to Play the Irish Button Accordion with John Williams
http://www.johnwilliamsmusic.com/store.htm or on Ebay
-
Yes to Connolly.
-
Well, my box arrived Thursday, as I was told it would by the Music Room who gave me a very good deal on it.
I think I have been getting to grips with it, I have learnt the D and G scales, and I am starting to learn the first tune in Dave Mallinsons "Vital Irish Session Tunes"
Having played the English concertina, and reading advise on this forum, has helped me understand finger positioning, in the sense of having my finger in the correct position for the next note, and I soon learnt not to use all my fingers up straight away, lest I run out!