Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Other Free Reed Instruments => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on April 19, 2011, 11:27:41 AM
-
Just noticed that Pigini have now got a 30-treble Preludio PA, so I thought I would share my quick summary of the 3 models (edit - now 4) I am aware of at the higher quality end of 30-treble, 72-bass PAs. Would be pleased to hear views on these, and of any other options.
Fantini/Allodi SP/30T
http://www.accordions.co.uk/Newinstviewdocs.htm/Fan0GBSp.htm
3-voice, 5+2 couplers.
Keyboard incl ends - 380mm
Key width - 19.5mm
Weight - 5.8kg (NB - this is lighter than the Pigini and Brandoni 2-voice 30s)
£2790 (Allodi)
Pigini Preludio P30
http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/cPath/244_245_247_477/products_id/3710
2 voice, 3+0 couplers
36x18cm
6kg
£1899 (Music Room)
Brandoni Piccolo
http://www.brandoni-accordions.com/en/piccolo-series-super.html
2 voice, no couplers
Sizes (cm.): 37,5 x 17,0 x 36,0 (H x W x D)
Weight (kg.): 6,2
£1760 (Allodi)
Edit - have just spotted that Borsini now also do a 30/72
http://www.accordions.co.uk/Newinstviewdocs.htm/BorsVag.htm
http://www.subzerorecordingstudio.co.uk/accordion/Borsini/BorsiniPiano.htm
-
I've tried both the pigini and the fantini/Allodi - and I much prefer the Fantini. Extra voice, better weight distribution (which just means that I noticed I was wearing it a lot less than the Pigini) and the Fantini model gave me an indescribable sense of confidence that whatever I played was going to be ok (at my level, that boost of confidence is worth it's weight in gold!). Can't afford either at the moment (and may never be able) - but am definitely hoping that one day I'll be able to get my hands on a Fantini. I also thought the Pigini was a little bit 'clacky', and not worth shelling out that kind of money for a small two voice box. The Beltrami study series is worth looking at also - this one is in the P2 and not the P1 as it says:http://www.beltrami-fisarmoniche.it/fisarmoniche.php?id4=1 (http://www.beltrami-fisarmoniche.it/fisarmoniche.php?id4=1) not sure of latest price - but comparable I'd have thought with the Fantini?
AL
-
Speaking to Emilio Allodi on the phone today I learned some interesting facts which I thought I would pass on:
Apparently Phil Cunningham plays a Borsini Vagabond 30/72.
The Fantini/Allodi SP30T is housed in a standard 26-treble accordion body; they have shaved a sliver off the width of each treble key and added a fraction to the length of the treble keyboard to fit in the extra 4 keys.
Emilio will soon also be offering a Vignoni 30/72 model.
Needless to say I have asked him to let me know when he has all 3 in the shop (Fantini, Borsini and Vignoni)and I will be over for a comparison test. This small bodied 30/72 variant of PA does seem to me to be the ultimate folk PA.
-
I know someone who has one (I think, it's a small Fantini and it's the one that Allodi is recommending) and yes, I think I'd agree with you for it being the ultimate folk PA. It is compact, light and sounds fantastic.
-
I know someone who has one (I think, it's a small Fantini and it's the one that Allodi is recommending) and yes, I think I'd agree with you for it being the ultimate folk PA. It is compact, light and sounds fantastic.
I have one of these Fantinis - latest and smallest in a long line of PAs for me. I play it regularly, including for gigs, and in my opinion it is excellent.
The only negative I have, if it's any consideration for you, is that I don't get a great sound from the internal mic system. I have the Sennheiser system which you can also see on the Allodi site. I had the same system fitted in my previous larger accordion, and it was great. So I guess there may be something critical about the internal acoustics of the smaller box, or the mic positioning, or something.
But the box itself is terrific.
-
I have one of these Fantinis - latest and smallest in a long line of PAs for me. I play it regularly, including for gigs, and in my opinion it is excellent.
That is good to hear.
How did you find the slightly narrower keys at first, and do you notice when you go from this box back to your standard key size box (eg on the longer "leaps", etc)?
-
My better half has the Fantini, but in four-voice form (LMMM). Very loud!
I've had no difficulty playing it on the rare occasions I've managed to wrestle it from her. I have a couple of tunes I tend to run through on any PA the first time I play it to get my fingers in tune with the key and button spacings, and by the end of those I'm fine. I found her previous Sonola ladies' 120 more difficult in this regard.
-
How did you find the slightly narrower keys at first, and do you notice when you go from this box back to your standard key size box (eg on the longer "leaps", etc)?
I don't play the standard one regularly now. But I have played it occasionally, and not found this a problem.
Mind you, for me the leaps are always subject to random error, on either box. So I guess I'd have to say that I don't find it a statistically significant problem.
-
How did you find the slightly narrower keys at first
So I guess I'd have to say that I don't find it a statistically significant problem.
Two of the best people in one quote!
Sandy, can you find out if Mr Allodi has a small C-system 3-voice CBA. How Fantini can squeeze 3-voices into a 6-kg box ???
JB used to be my favorite TotM presenter, until he stopped delivering :(.
-
My better half has the Fantini, but in four-voice form (LMMM). Very loud!
I was not aware of Fantini doing a 4-voice version smaller than 34/72 (and in normal "34 size" body). Sure its a 30/72, small body?
-
Sandy, can you find out if Mr Allodi has a small C-system 3-voice CBA. How Fantini can squeeze 3-voices into a 6-kg box ???
Hi Miklos. Just had a quick word with Emilio and he said the Fantini SCR31 is the CBA equivalent of the 30/72 PA - same body, same weight, 3-voices.
http://www.accordions.co.uk/Buttonviewdocs.htm/FanSCR31.htm
To get it even lighter you can order it as a 3-row. He has a 5-row C-system in stock, is more than happy to ship to Hungary, but he also said he is to be away for about 10 days.
Fantini do not have any of these compact models on their own website, so looks like they are specials for Emilio.
Let me know if I can help further.
-
My better half has the Fantini, but in four-voice form (LMMM). Very loud!
I was not aware of Fantini doing a 4-voice version smaller than 34/72 (and in normal "34 size" body). Sure its a 30/72, small body?
Without counting keys, all I can say is it's very compact and light and takes up about the same amount of space in the music room as my old 48 did.
-
A past thread has gone into the vagaries of quoted weights for accordions, and here we go again. I thought it worth noting that:
(a) the Allodi webpage http://www.accordions.co.uk/Newinstviewdocs.htm/Fan0GBSp.htm quotes the SP30T as being 5.8kg
(b) Emilio said he thought the Borsini Vagabond might be just a little bit lighter than the Fantini (eg they spray the finish rather than mould bakelite)
(c) This website http://www.subzerorecordingstudio.co.uk/accordion/Borsini/BorsiniPiano.htm quotes the Vagabond as 7.5kg!
The 5.8kg does seem consistent with the 26-treble body size, and I trust Emilio. So if anybody was looking at a Vagabond, you might just want to double check its true weight.
-
Interesting to see so much traffic on this thread. As a player of folk tunes who is...um...less tall, and has the back of a 65-year-old, I think these are the ideal PA instruments. I have a quite nice 34/72 3-reed Serenellini, but do at times think about wanting to maybe trade it off for something like the 30/72 SP/30T.
So, just to add to the confusion, here's another such PA that I haven't seen mentioned: the G. Verde Ultralite III. 30/72, 3-reeds, painted finish. Anyone have any experience with one of these?
http://www.musicmagicusa.com/gverde.htm
Bob
-
So, just to add to the confusion, here's another such PA that I haven't seen mentioned: the G. Verde Ultralite III. 30/72, 3-reeds, painted finish. Anyone have any experience with one of these?
http://www.musicmagicusa.com/gverde.htm
Bob
Have not come across these before. Interestingly, on the website it says the Ultralite weighs 16lb which Google tells me is 7.3kg.
-
I have one of these Fantinis - latest and smallest in a long line of PAs for me.
A big advantage of the forum is that we can share weight information about our accordions.
I'd like to ask, John, to measure your accordion's weight with or without straps.
My Cooperfisa Perla 300/A 2-voice, 5-row CBA, 60-bass is a tiny bit less than 6 kg with two 80-mm wide straps.
I completely agree that a ligh box is much more fun to play. I have a 4-voice, 11-kg Borsini, and I always pick the 6-kg Cooperfisa.
-
I'd like to ask, John, to measure your accordion's weight with or without straps.
According to one of these (http://www.balanzza.co.uk/products.php?product=Balanzza-Original-%252d-BACK-IN-STOCK-FOR-A-LIMITED-TIME), my Fantini SP30/T weighs 6.95kg without shoulder straps.
The 5.8kg spec is from Fantini's own site (http://www.fantiniaccordions.com/fantini-prodotti-dett.asp?idcat=6906&idpro=6911).
Mine has Fantini's Extra Lusso finish, which involves pearloid keys and lots more spangly stuff. And it has an internal mic system, which from the look of it must be 80g max.
I bought it (new) in late 2006. I suppose the build/materials might have changed since then. Hard to imagine a kilo's worth though. And anyway I seem to remember the spec saying 5.8 then too. Never bothered to weigh it before now.
Still an excellent box, though, in my opinion. And feels very light and well-balanced, as Al says above.
-
jb - that is really helpful, thank you.
So it looks like the real weight is nearer 7kg after all. But probably the most important things (wrt weight) are how heavy it feels to pick up and to wear/play for a sustained period, and how balanced it feels. I also recall a recent thread mentioning that a heavier box with really responsive reeds is easier to play than a lighter box with poor quality reeds (edit - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5115.msg64574.html#msg64574). I am much encouraged by Al and jb both remarking on how the Fantini feels light and well balanced. Indeed, I would guess that any of the quality 30/72s being discussed here would be pretty good on all these counts.
Just as an aside, my Pigini P36 34/72 3-voice weighs 8.2kg on my bathroom scales, but is advertised by the Music Room as 7kg. I also have an old Hohner Concerto II 34/72 2-voice which weighs 5.8kg and that really is noticeably lighter to lift and wear - but is harder work to play than my Pigini.
-
my Pigini P36 34/72 3-voice weighs 8.2kg on my bathroom scales, but is advertised by the Music Room as 7kg.
Perhaps the Official Accordion Weigher lives on Venus.
Especially in Italy. Can safely say that no 3-voice chromatic accordion can be made below (about) 7 kg?
Or, always add +1.1 - 1.5 kg to any offcial weight numbers of an Italian made accordion.
-
C
an safely say that no 3-voice chromatic accordion can be made below (about) 7 kg?
Or, always add +1.1 - 1.5 kg to any offcial weight numbers of an Italian made accordion.
Do you think that they weigh them without the reeds :D
-
Or how about a 1930s Hohner Regina (felt sorry for it on ebay!)
3 voice treble LMM with switch to take out the L reed
4 voice bass
34 treble keys
111 bass
6kg
And all in a case not much bigger than a three row diatonic!
-
Or how about a 1930s Hohner Regina (felt sorry for it on ebay!)
3 voice treble LMM with switch to take out the L reed
4 voice bass
34 treble keys
111 bass
6kg
And all in a case not much bigger than a three row diatonic!
Ah so it was you that bagged it! I was watching that. What's it like?
-
yes, my max bid was below the reserve, but the in the end seller let me have it for what I'd bid.
It's one of Hohner's top quality boxes, their best reeds with the Hohner name stamped on every plate, bass machine shoe-horned into a very tight space. One small piece of celluloid lifting, but all there. The bass buttons all had a real MOP top many of which are missing. It plays well enough that I can hear it will sound great once refurbished.
-
yes, my max bid was below the reserve, but the in the end seller let me have it for what I'd bid.
It's one of Hohner's top quality boxes, their best reeds with the Hohner name stamped on every plate, bass machine shoe-horned into a very tight space. One small piece of celluloid lifting, but all there. The bass buttons all had a real MOP top many of which are missing. It plays well enough that I can hear it will sound great once refurbished.
Glad to hear that it's gone to a good home (:) It did look like a lovely box, far too nice to do anything with other than lovingly restore.
-
How did you find the slightly narrower keys at first, and do you notice when you go from this box back to your standard key size box (eg on the longer "leaps", etc)?
Bit of concern has crept in about the impact of the slightly narrower treble keys. Last night I had a play of a friend's Beltuna PA which has narrower treble keys, but on tunes that "go up and down a bit" I found I had to look to see where my fingers should be going all the time, which is something that I have been trying not to do ever since attending a Karen Tweed workshop at Sidmouth 2 or 3 years ago. Karen said that she found it best if you followed a mental model of where you were going rather than actually looking down. It can take a lot of getting used to but I really do feel I play better that way, more fluent generally and also because my mind can deal with more challenging (for me anyway) bass manoeuvres as well as treble; and lets face it, it does look a lot better than the old "broken kneck" stance, and you can even watch the dancers.
So a bit concerned about allowing a non-standard key-width such as the small-bodied 30/72 into my collection.
Having said that, I seem to be able to go between my Tommy and Pokerwork fairly easily, but the "leaps" are much smaller on a melodeon, and the anchored thumb helps.
-
and the anchored thumb helps.
That is one of the only two reasons I picked the CBA to be my chromatic system and not PA: I cannot play without an anchor.
-
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/72-BASS-PIANO-ACCORDION-FANTINI-ALLODI-SP03-GB-/320704974695?pt=UK_MusicalInstr_Keyboard_RL&hash=item4aab818f67
Am completely and utterly pig-sick that I'm in no position to go for the above little beauty! Looks a bargain!
AL
-
Hi,
This was on before,I contacted seller,Its about 9 years old.With some checking it,at that time, cost less than the start bid,also the reeds were standard export,Allodi now has tipo a mano fitted as standard.
Pete
-
Ah - didn't know that - thought it would the TAM as per standard?
-
Ah - didn't know that - thought it would the TAM as per standard?
I think the basic reeds are still the default standard as some of the Allodi ads, like for the 30/72, mention "Available with hand made reeds at extra cost of £230".
Wonder if it would be cost-effective to buy the eBay 26/72 and replace the reeds with TAM reeds?
-
i tried this 12.5 pound, 30-treble, 60-bass Weltmeister Rubin PA yesterday and loved it. if i were still playing PA, this would be the one for me. yes, the treble keys were a bit undersized, but i was fine with them. the compactness and light weight are unbelievable. it makes the 15-pound 72 bassers feel like anvils. ha, it was actually this exact color.....
everybody's different, but i personally have never found handmade/TAM reeds essential in a unisonoric. solid, well-made, well-fitted, well-installed factory reeds are to me more than fine for world folk genres in a unisonoric accordion. it is the bisonorics where i have found hand/TAM to be essential....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utrr1FrgtWU
-
Hi,
The info re the reeds came from Allodi himself,he now has TAM fitted as standard in this model.When it was first advertised we thought of swapping Jills Guerrini 30/48 which she loves as a small box to throw in the caravan or just to pick up when grand kids about but decided against it.The extra 4 treble keys mean it will be a good starter box for children and only 2 voice helps with weight.
Pete
-
Re: the Weltmesiter Rubin.
When I first picked up the PA after a forty year lapse, I got a Rubin. Very nice little box, I thought. Thirty keys fit into the space of the standard 26 made them a tad narrower, but I never found it troublesome. (Then again, I have smallish hands.)
A few years ago, I traded that for a Weltmeister Juwell......essentially the same as a Rubin, but with an extra set of treble reeds (LMM), so a tiny bit heavier. AND, it's a 72 bass. I found the quality of the Juwell to be a bit nicer than that of the Rubin: quality leather bellows straps, wood reed blocks on the treble side, felt-bushed bass buttons. It comes with three rows of reeds on the bass side, and I recently added a fourth (the space was already there), so that bumped up the weight a few more ounces. But it really is an amazing compact little box. Kind of like the Allodi SP/30T, without some of that Italian quality, but also without the price.
Bob
-
juwell: yes, the store had one of those as well, and i saw it was the same dimensions but more switches and stuff. cool, though lighter is better for me....i'm also very intrigued by the single-reed ones that weltmeitster does, 24 free-basses on the left,
[That is one of the only two reasons I picked the CBA to be my chromatic system and not PA: I cannot play without an anchor.] really? i use my thumb, so no anchor....
-
I had the pleasure of a visit to the Allodi shop today, first time for many years.
I actually took my bathroom scales with me and Emilio was happy for me to weigh various accordions (all with straps).
Fantini/Allodi 26/72 3 voice PA - 6.3kg
Fantini/Allodi 30/72 3 voice PA - 7.2kg
Fantini/Allodi 5-row 3 voice CBA - 7.2kg
Vignoni 30/72 3 voice PA - 7.2kg.
The other thing I was able to confirm was that I did not notice at all going between a standard key-width PA and the very slightly narrower keys of the 30/72 boxes.
-
Sandy, can you find out if Mr Allodi has a small C-system 3-voice CBA. How Fantini can squeeze 3-voices into a 6-kg box ???
Hi Miklos. Just had a quick word with Emilio and he said the Fantini SCR31 is the CBA equivalent of the 30/72 PA - same body, same weight, 3-voices.
http://www.accordions.co.uk/Buttonviewdocs.htm/FanSCR31.htm
To get it even lighter you can order it as a 3-row. He has a 5-row C-system in stock, is more than happy to ship to Hungary, but he also said he is to be away for about 10 days.
Fantini do not have any of these compact models on their own website, so looks like they are specials for Emilio.
From another thread:
..... I am still on the market for a light 3-voice CBA that sounds exactly your Allodi.
I was never sure whether you saw my reply on another thread back in May - http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6704.msg85735.html#msg85735. Later in that topic I posted actual weights of various accordions, with my 26/72 PA being 6.3kg and the 5-row CBA Allodi 7.2kg, but it does have 8 extra treble notes.
I definitely want a 3-voice 5-row LMM CBA that is not heavier than the 6.3kg of your 26/72PA, even less. A Hohner Xtreme LMM is 6kg. This is the maximum I am willing to handle; I'd choose less buttons rather than more weight: 7kg is too heavy, 6.5kg is too heavy, 6.4kg is too heave, 6.3kg OK. If there is no such an animal (3-voice 5-row LMM CBA no more than 6.3kg) I live with my 2-voice 5-row Cooperfisa.
Thank You Sandy for the Help!
-
I had the pleasure of a visit to the Allodi shop today, first time for many years.
I actually took my bathroom scales with me and Emilio was happy for me to weigh various accordions (all with straps).
Fantini/Allodi 26/72 3 voice PA - 6.3kg
Fantini/Allodi 30/72 3 voice PA - 7.2kg
Fantini/Allodi 5-row 3 voice CBA - 7.2kg
Vignoni 30/72 3 voice PA - 7.2kg.
The other thing I was able to confirm was that I did not notice at all going between a standard key-width PA and the very slightly narrower keys of the 30/72 boxes.
So, Sandy - what did you think/buy and did you get to try the Borsini too? I'm looking at replacing my 3-voice Serenellini box with something like the SP30T or a Brandoni 65 Wood....
Also, any idea how much swing these two have as standard? I want something quite dry....
-
I ended up going back and buying the second hand Fantini 26/72 LMM accordion as I wanted smallest/lightest for sessions and working at computer (transcribing tunes). But my top box is still my Pigini 34/72 which does everything I want, and sounds and feels really great.
There wasn't a Borsini 30/72 there to try that day, but I would guess it would compare well with the others. I did try a 34/72 wood finish Brandoni just because it was there and it is an absolutely lovely looking, playing, sounding accordion. Assuming the Brandoni 65 30/72 will be the same standard, then I would go for that if you can afford the extra cost and you know you really want/like the wood finish.
I felt the Vignoni had a slight quality edge over the Fantini. And I know my Pigini P36 has the edge on my Fantini for quality, but I also tried a Pigini 30/72 2-voice at a festival last year and did not feel it was as good quality as my P36. You really need to try and compare if at all possible.
I recall Emilio saying all these accordions come in a mild swing tuning of around 4 cents offset at A=440, but of course he could change that to whatever you ask.
Hope this helps.
You might find www.accordionforum.co.uk useful for information.
-
Thanks for that Sandy - really helpful. (You my remember that we've discussed being both melodeonists and PA players in the past, and wanting to play the PA a little more like a diatonic box...?)
I really love the look of the Brandoni in wood, but then I may as well pop to Ireland and try the Pietro Mario too for a few more hundred pounds. Oh dear....!
Serenellini has a new 34/72 3 voice box in a cherry case and a mano reeds that I'd really like to try first!
I've tried lots of Pigini P36/3s at festivals, some with TAM reeds and I have noticed that they tend to be variable. I'm a thin bass end chap and I tend find the bass reeds a little strident, although one I played a few years back was perfect for me!
Thanks for the info on the swing tuning too. 4 cents sounds just about right!
Barry
-
One great 30-key PA that got left out ot this thread is Beltrami's P6/s http://www.beltrami-fisarmoniche.it/fisarmoniche.php?id3=9 . Mine tips the scale at 6.9 kg, a little heavier than I might like for a 2-reed 30/60 PA, but the handmade reeds realy sing, and it's a delight to play. Having said that, I'm making the jump to CBA, partly because of the relative savings in size and weight for a given musical capability and partly because of the many advantages of the fingering system in terms of flexibility, economy of space, and ease of transposing--even on a lowly 3-row, a tune would be fingered the same in B, D, F, and Ab. I've never played a tune in Ab on the PA!
-
My wife has a Weltmeister Rubin, 60 bass piano accordion. She loves the light weight and has no problem with the width of the keys. She does not care for the sound of the accordion. She likes the sound my BC Lilly and BC Cairdin mini. I have been telling her that she could probably get more of the sound she likes by having it re-tuned or partially re tuned dry. I do not know much about piano accordions so I was wondering if one of you could tell me what retuning (by a professional) would entail. I know it has a couple of switches on it (voices?). How could she have this instrument re tuned to make it sound more like my BC boxes. Excuse my ignorance in describing this situation. Thanks in advance. Charlie
-
I have a Borsini 724 34/72 and I love it. It's a 4/4 and packs quite a punch. It weighs in at about 17 lbs. I hardly
ever play my Petosa Antiquo Mussette (Zero Sette) anymore. This one is deffinitely easier on my back.
-
My wife has a Weltmeister Rubin, 60 bass piano accordion. She loves the light weight and has no problem with the width of the keys. She does not care for the sound of the accordion. She likes the sound my BC Lilly and BC Cairdin mini. I have been telling her that she could probably get more of the sound she likes by having it re-tuned or partially re tuned dry.
A weltmeister dealer can order reeds for any weltmeister tuned however you like. A new set of keyboard blocks will cost around $275 for stock reeds, and hand finished reeds are available for somewhat more.
I have done this for several customers here in the US.