Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: HarpDave on April 22, 2011, 06:30:08 PM
-
Hi,
I want to take my D/G GDR Galotta in for a tune up to resolve some sticky key issues. Is there anyone in or around Portland who is good with melodeons?
-
A shame Bill Pierce just passed away in Vancouver.
I'll check around
Just how "sticky" and do you feel comfortable opening it yourself ?
-
When it was sold to me, it played nicely. When I received it, a couple keys at the treble end of the right hand stuck a bit, but it played nicely otherwise. I made the poor decision to take it on a plane, and now much of the G keyboard doesn't pop up once depressed, or only moves slowly. I fiddled with the wires attaching the buttons to the palettes and was able to make the button height more even and help the stickiness on a few of the buttons, but for the most part the keys still stick, so I think the problem is swollen or warped levers inside the keyboard.
-
Galotta keyboards are not very nice to work on! It is very easy to make things worse while trying to make them better. :-(
-
... I think the problem is swollen or warped levers inside the keyboard.
Quite likely seeing that Galotta (G. A. Schlott & Söhne) were a Kilingenthal firm and the climate there in the Erzgebirge (Ore Mountains, on the Czech border) is extremely dry. It's always been a problem with instruments from the area that have wooden keyboards.
-
I still think Michael at Dancemaster does the most reasonably priced repairs and retunes. And the shipping isn't really that much, even with insurance.
-
If the Seattle area isn't too far for you, I would try this man. Excellent work. Both chromatic and diatonic accordions:
http://www.expertaccordionrepair.com/
-
Theo, making things worse while trying to make them better is already sort of a specialty of mine. I'm definitely leaving this one to a pro.
Triskel, I've heard that. It's seems odd to me that there's no way for Klingenthal makers to recognize that problem and adjust for it, but maybe a machine made for everywhere else wouldn't play right in that region.
GCFMan/Steve, I'm not familiar with that shop. Where are they located, and what are their rates like?
Andrel, it's about a 3 hour haul. Still, might be a good excuse to take a weekend trip to Seattle! ;D At any rate, that's the closest shop anyone can recommend.
Has anyone heard of this shop? http://portlandaccordioncenter.com/
-
Dave--they are in Sarasota FL (Irishdancemaster is website). Very reasonable prices.
-
expertaccordionrepair.com
Wonderful place... go for it. !
-
http://mulberryandgrand.blogspot.com/
http://portlandaccordioncenter.com/
http://www.chuck-berger.com/
I know nothing about them
-
Theo, making things worse while trying to make them better is already sort of a specialty of mine. I'm definitely leaving this one to a pro.
Triskel, I've heard that. It's seems odd to me that there's no way for Klingenthal makers to recognize that problem and adjust for it, but maybe a machine made for everywhere else wouldn't play right in that region.
GCFMan/Steve, I'm not familiar with that shop. Where are they located, and what are their rates like?
Andrel, it's about a 3 hour haul. Still, might be a good excuse to take a weekend trip to Seattle! ;D At any rate, that's the closest shop anyone can recommend.
Has anyone heard of this shop? http://portlandaccordioncenter.com/
Why not give your local guy a try? At least you can get a quote and have an encounter that will not cost a tank full of fuel.
-
Thanks for the words of warning on a bad shop, Melodeon and J.W.Forrest. I'll be sure to avoid expertaccordionrepair.com.
I have contacted my local shop and am bringing in the box this Friday. I'll come back and share my experience. Thanks for all the advice so far!
-
Best of luck.
-
Just a thought about fairness: I think we should try and refrain from using this platform when judging the quality (or maybe absence of it) of small businesses like the one Melodeon is warning us about. Even if the criticism may, in the mind of the submitter, be well founded, it is still a subjective opinion. While the claims are not documented or verified, they can be very damaging indeed, even when it turns out that they haven't been justified at all.
-
Equally though, if someone has had a bad experience, then they should be able to warn someone, or they could be trapped in the same boat, no? I get what you mean, but this forum, although it is a public sphere has to be a place where we can give advice and that includes advice against certain people/companies.
-
Equally though, if someone has had a bad experience, then they should be able to warn someone, or they could be trapped in the same boat, no? I get what you mean, but this forum, although it is a public sphere has to be a place where we can give advice and that includes advice against certain people/companies.
Absolutely, and everyone knows the advice is subjective. If diatonix wants to refrain from warning his melodeon.net acquaintances about bad experiences with certain businesses, then he should do so. As for the rest, I sure hope that they do use this forum to provide fair warning. When I began to get interested in diatonic accordions, I researched the few forums that existed at the time and found no negative advice about a certain shop in NY city. I went there and had a terrible experience with this business. It was upsetting to later find out that many people had had even worse experiences with this particular place and had not provided any warning. It is a different matter if someone puts false info into a "review," but then again, it works both ways -- there are also positive reviews that get posted on this forum and others.
-
I was once warned off sending any of my boxes to someone whose name I'd only previously only heard used with great reverence and told the story of them wrecking a Castagnari Mory, (IIRC necessitating completely replacing most, possibly all, of the reeds), that had been sent to them by a professional player who needed it tuned up before an important gig. I don't think it's fair for me to name them directly because this secondhand information that most likely does not reflect the standard of their work could deprive them of more in the future. I even recently had a bad professional experience with a personal friend I once shared a house with, had it been my only encounter with him I might have condemned him as a dangerous hack but I know otherwise.
It's very tricky but I think if you're going to report a bad experience with a shop or repairer and name them directly then it's important to be as even-handed, transparent and dispassionate as possible lest you do disproportionate damage to their reputation, (and ultimately, their way of making a living). I do think that it's important to only speak of firsthand experiences as well, stories starting with "I heard that..." or "someone told me" can do a lot of undeserved harm.
-
OK
I suggest that you send your accordeon to the aforementioned shop and take your chances.
Does that square it for you...?
Or would you prefer... oh my yes what a wonderful shop...
C'mon.. let's get real.... some tuners/techs are legendary... some for being good ,some for not so good.
Nothing subjective about butchered reeds.
Let's jump on the PC wagon and let our melodeon.net friends put their instrument and money on the line because we are gutless..
Tuners/techs/repairpersons/makers/importers/distributors and dealers make their own reputation.. I don't
Would you suggest I kiss MELODIE's rear quarters in spite of them screwing me out of countless hrs of my time and ultimately costing me about $310.13 USD NOT to own one of their instruments; keep my mouth shut and my fingers off the keyboard so they can potentially take advantage of some one else..
You walk the no comment, no opinion line... I'll take a stand anytime in the interest of facts and fairness and I'll go to the wall to stand up for my friends..
Time for another vacation.
-
I think Jeff makes some points that are fair. I use a technician who has already been mentioned above and I swear by his work. Has he always been perfect no but he's always done his level best to do right by me when I sent my boxes to him so I continue to use him and recommend him to those who ask! That said, I try to refrain from being a cheerleader online, others will unabashedly recommend him every chance they get and that is fine by me too. I also have two reliable friends and fellow box players who aren't so effusive in his praise. I think it's wrong to maliciously smear a craftsman but neither is it wrong to talk honestly about issues you have had about them. There are plenty of services online that people review professionals and it's up to the perspective customer to evaluate the merit's of these statements. I think it's fair to speak rationally and constructively about our experiences with box technicians. If I hired a Plumber or carpenter and they muffed the job I'd be honest and tell people about my experience.
-
If I hired a Plumber or carpenter and they muffed the job I'd be honest and tell people about my experience.
Flakes - California's got the most of them. At least your accordion didn't get eaten by snakes. ;D
I think all of the above points are fair. When I lived in Florida, there was a guy down by me who represented himself as a luthier. He routinely ruined guitars and all other makes of stringed instruments. Instruments came back smelling like cigarette smoke, glued together hastily, and not set up as discussed, if at all. This was no secret but it was taboo to speak against him because he had been in business for so long. I never understood that - the economics or the reluctance to criticize his work.
-
Due to the increasing number of complaints about our free service,
There will be no more free service.
I'll leave it to the apologists to continue protecting members of their mutual admiration society and leave you out there to take chances and fend for yourselves.
-
That's good news.
-
If I hired a Plumber or carpenter and they muffed the job I'd be honest and tell people about my experience.
Flakes - California's got the most of them. At least your accordion didn't get eaten by snakes. ;D
I think all of the above points are fair. When I lived in Florida, there was a guy down by me who represented himself as a luthier. He routinely ruined guitars and all other makes of stringed instruments. Instruments came back smelling like cigarette smoke, glued together hastily, and not set up as discussed, if at all. This was no secret but it was taboo to speak against him because he had been in business for so long. I never understood that - the economics or the reluctance to criticize his work.
Easy now! I'm northern Californian born and bred, that said I've lived in North Carolina for 7 years now and have no intention of going back to the Golden State. That said I know many flakes and assorted Nuts and fruits and love them from afar!
-
AJ- not to worry, the comment about flakes is a quote from a Frank Zappa song of the same name: http://youtu.be/RFvtoJrK1Zg (http://youtu.be/RFvtoJrK1Zg)
-
HarpDave, why are you saying you'll be sure to avoid http://www.expertaccordionrepair.com/ ? Besides my own, I can provide testimonies by two friends of mine who were extremely satisfied with Michael's work. And he's a true gentleman. Where did you hear the negative stuff ? Frankly, I'm puzzled.