Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ollie on April 24, 2011, 04:47:47 PM
-
Having pretty much settled on the idea of getting a 2.6 row Loffet, I've set about designing my own system (PDF attached). It's based partly on the Club system, and partly on the Saltarelle layout, with Castagnari basses. Some feedback from those who know more about these things than I do would be really helpful. (:)
Many thanks to Lester for the wonderful Google docs templates! :D
-
Any particular reason why there is a low push G# and pull Bb? Given the rest of the layout it seems a little strange. Other than that looks very well thought out!
-
They're a reversal of the Bb/G# on the accidental row, allowing me to play things like Jump at the Sun and Jiggery Pokerwork. :P
-
Any particular reason why there is a low push G# and pull Bb? Given the rest of the layout it seems a little strange. Other than that looks very well thought out!
My Salterelle came with those low accidentals as standard. I'm not sure what changes would help there, given that those notes aren't likely to get used much anyway.
I agree the rest of the layout looks good.
-
Any particular reason why there is a low push G# and pull Bb? Given the rest of the layout it seems a little strange. Other than that looks very well thought out!
My Salterelle came with those low accidentals as standard. I'm not sure what changes would help there, given that those notes aren't likely to get used much anyway.
I agree the rest of the layout looks good.
So did mine... what I meant was, why not flip the reedplate, given that every other Bb is on the push and every other G# is on the pull, plus the Bb bass is on the push and the E bass is on the pull... :P
-
Surely a 'Dutch reversal' would be more use than a unisonic D in the middle, I know I use my E push a lot. You will most likely have to re-learn fingerings anyway, so you might as well have an extra note!
With a C chord and bass in both directions, is the C reversal as necessary in the low octave? You could have a low E push or another note here too. Just musing really. I'm assuming that you'll have bass stops, otherwise I would go for a Bm push chord.
The bass layout obviously gives lots of chords - I would rather opt for the standard Saltarelle basses (A push/G pull and F#m push/F pull on the extra buttons) which give more bass versatility in the main box keys at the expense of chromaticism. However, the push G bass + Bb chord and the pull D bass + F chord will give you Gm and Dm for playing in those keys happily. Too many choices really!
-
I wanted to have unisonoric accidentals, but couldn't find a good way of working it. The accidentals at the bottom are as standard, but the F/Eb are flipped and an octave lower than usual.
Surely a 'Dutch reversal' would be more use than a unisonic D in the middle, I know I use my E push a lot. You will most likely have to re-learn fingerings anyway, so you might as well have an extra note!
With a C chord and bass in both directions, is the C reversal as necessary in the low octave? You could have a low E push or another note here too. Just musing really. I'm assuming that you'll have bass stops, otherwise I would go for a Bm push chord.
I'm really happy with the Club layout, and the Dutch reversal makes my brain hurt. :P
Hmm. I dunno, I don't use my push E that much at all on my Erika. I guess it makes it vaguely symmetrical. :P Yup, there will be a bass stop.
-
My preference would be to reverse the highest reed on the D row to give f# on the pull as I am more likely to need that note in the key of G than in D. YMMV
-
The problem with spending a lot of time carefully designing what is (to me) the perfect layout is that every time someone decises a different one you automatically think that they are wrong :P
-
Having pretty much settled on the idea of getting a 2.6 row Loffet, I've set about designing my own system (PDF attached). It's based partly on the Club system, and partly on the Saltarelle layout, with Castagnari basses. Some feedback from those who know more about these things than I do would be really helpful. (:)
Many thanks to Lester for the wonderful Google docs templates! :D
i would still ... busk! , do whatever! find the difference and get the 3 row myself!.... >:E
-
Buy a cheap club of ebay.de and a file. Try it, change it, change it back, get it all out your system before you buy an expensive custom box with much reduced resale value.
-
Unfortunately, I don't have the time. :-\
-
I think there is a lot to be said for having the core two rows of your instrument 'standard' (that is no gleitchton or dutch reversal) for the simple reason that the work you put into your repertoire will be locked in to that particular instrument to a large extent. Changing the accidentals and/or low notes around is a lot more forgiving.
-
Buy a cheap club of ebay.de and a file. Try it, change it, change it back, get it all out your system before you buy an expensive custom box with much reduced resale value.
That is the kind of experiment for which one of those Roland MIDI boxes would be perfect.
Once you've decided on the perfect layout (and tested it by playing on it) you get it made as a real box.
And if you don't want to keep the Roland, sell it...
-
Buy a cheap club of ebay.de and a file. Try it, change it, change it back, get it all out your system before you buy an expensive custom box with much reduced resale value.
As far as I'm aware, Loffets don't have diamond coated reeds araldited onto irremovable reedblocks and you can have reeds retuned or replaced if they don't quite work for you. ;D
Ollie, you're the only one who really knows what you need for the tunes you want to play and the way you play them. Highly personalised layouts will always look strange and raise questions from other people but if you've put some thought into it and want to try it and feel that it would suit you then go ahead. It might not work quite so well in the flesh as on paper but if you find alterations necessary, big deal....
-
Having pretty much settled on the idea of getting a 2.6 row Loffet, I've set about designing my own system (PDF attached). It's based partly on the Club system, and partly on the Saltarelle layout, with Castagnari basses. Some feedback from those who know more about these things than I do would be really helpful. (:)
Many thanks to Lester for the wonderful Google docs templates! :D
i would still ... busk! , do whatever! find the difference and get the 3 row myself!.... >:E
I was tempted, but if I did I fear my playing would become too cross-row orientated. I've watched players of 3 row boxes who cross-row all the time and I feel they may as well play CBA or PA! Don't really want my playing to turn into that.
-
But with a 3 row you have a choice. You can play it as a one row in three keys, a two row. or use the three row technique. The more I mess around with a standard three row the more I like it. Someone said it's the 'swiss army knife of diatonics'. Great description.
-
I was tempted, but if I did I fear my playing would become too cross-row orientated.
Two words. Saul Rose. ;D
-
I was tempted, but if I did I fear my playing would become too cross-row orientated.
Two words. Saul Rose. ;D
Yeah, but I'm not "made of iron". :P (his own words, I'm told!)
-
I can't see the point of the D/D. It will lock you into this layout, seems neat but how many systems do you want to learn?
What music are planning to play on this box (given it's weight etc)? How many of your choices are "it would be cool to.." and how many will you actually use?
On my Loffet the most used inner row buttons (on a C/G) are the reversals of D and G, most of the rest are window dressing.
Steve
-
My most used box is my Bb/Eb Erika which is fully clubbed. Over the last 9 months, I've found the gleichton very very useful indeed. I wanted a D reversal somewhere, and it seemed silly to use up an accidental button when I'm already used to playing with a gleichton.
My repertoire is mainly English and French. One thing I really want to venture into is playing in Gm, Dm and Cm, and their relative majors (hence having Bb, F and Eb in both directions), and generally more complex tunes than is possible on my Pokerwork. I also hope to bash out some bouncy English stuff on it too (some of the best dance music I've heard has been coming from a 2.6 row - or more - Loffet!), another reason I've not gone for the Dutch reversal.
-
Everyone's design is personal to themselves. What some love, others will find strange, so I am sure that you will go with your gut feeling.
However, having spent a lot of time designing layouts for new boxes over the past few years (including the 2.6 row that I will be making on Emmanuel Pariselle's course in July), the only thing that would worry me about your layout is the lack of choice for middle E. Since you like the gleichton D on the midlde row, I would be tempted to put an E natural on the push on the inner row in place of the E flat or the F natural, probably the F. I have an E natural on the push in that position on a couple of my boxes and I use it a lot. On the other hand, despite playing quite a lot of French tunes in C and A minor, I have never found the need for an F natural on the push. Just a thought!
-
Don't want to 'thread drift' but can someone briefly tell me what a 'Dutch Reversal' and a 'gleitchton' is?
ta
Q
-
I know what you mean Bob, that is one thing I tried to work in, but then thought I wouldn't need. I may be veering towards a 3 row now (depending on whether Bernard can make a 2.6 row in the style of his 3 row), so the whole thing may need a re-design.
Don't want to 'thread drift' but can someone briefly tell me what a 'Dutch Reversal' and a 'gleitchton' is?
ta
Q
Gleichton - On a DG box, instead of having D/E on the G row, you have D/D.
Dutch reversal - On a DG box, instead of having D/E on the G row, you have E/D.
(:)
-
Don't want to 'thread drift' but can someone briefly tell me what a 'Dutch Reversal' and a 'gleitchton' is?
ta
Q
So on a D/G the 5th or 6th button is D/E, where D is on the pull and E is on the push. The dutch reversal literally reverses this reedplate, so it instead plays E/D. The Gleichton tunes the E down to a D, making it D/D. They all seek to give a reversal for the D, which is the only note in either scale which you do not have on the pull.
-
I still think the easiest solution to the problem of needing/wanting a D on the pull is to put one on the third row. It preserves the basic integrity of the G row and it makes runs and triplets containing a D much easier. I've been using this system for years and I wouldn't be without it, but each to his or her own.
-
Thanks Ollie and Ukebert.
Right, carry on with the thread!
Q
-
Having taken into account what you've all said, along with the fact that I much prefer having couplers behind the keyboard, and the fact that it is only an extra 3 buttons, I've designed a 30 button 3 row layout (again, PDF attached). Again, comments/critique welcomed. (:) :||:
-
But with a 3 row you have a choice. You can play it as a one row in three keys, a two row. or use the three row technique.
Agreed. I use a plain D/G as a D/G and when I need more notes I use my good old A/D/G. No need for an exotic layout that would require a particular technique to play.
It seems to me that this layout has too many buttons for too few notes!
Just my opinion. ;)
-
I think there's a fundamental disagreement here. Either you like the D/D or (like me) you put the reversal on the inside row. From my perspective I can't see the point of messing up the ease of the standard tuning but I accept that there are other views (:)
The thought crosses my mind, why not go the whole hog and get a B/C/C# with stradella bass and then you can play in any key?
You mention the dance music being played on Loffetts, how much is D/Gs and how much on G/C? In terms of widening your scope I think you're limiting yourself by going down a D/G route.
In terms of portability I'm finding that a combination of my D/G box (morris and most of my D repertoire) and a 2.6 G/C is giving me a wide range of options without the problems of transferring fingerings from box to box.
Steve
-
To my mind, D/D is much easier than having a D on the accidental row, but then I'm used to playing with it.
B/C/C# is a completely different system, which I have neither the time nor the inclination to learn. The system I have designed is fundamentally what I'm used to, with a few added extras. I should've mentioned that I'm on a time limit here, as I need to be proficient on this box before next Feb/March for exams and University auditions and such like.
My only real experience of dance music on Loffets is English dance music on D/Gs, Matt Crum being the prime example - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZ5l-CrmbNo
I know what you mean about G/C, but it's not really suited to the punchy English style that I liked to play, whereas D/G is suited to both that and the more fluid Anglo-French style that I like to play.
-
That is some box playing!
-
I think the three-row in D and G with a row of accidentals is a wise choice. I know that I have never regretted it.
I can't see any obvious issues with your layout of the D and G rows. I prefer the low G/A button at the bottom of the G row rather than on the D row, but it should also work where you have put it.
My main suggestion would be to consider a C# reversal rather than an E flat push in the middle of the accidental row. I have never had a problem with only having the middle E flat on the pull but I do find a C# reversal very useful.
At the bass end, I prefer a B minor chord to a B major because the D natural third fits in more comfortably when playing in D or G than the D# third. I know you are intending having a stop to remove the thirds, but I would still consider the B minor chord.
This is just food for thought: in the end, it all comes down to what suits your style of playing and only you can decide that.
-
ukebert/Ollie - having seem them last year ( year before?) at Chippenham, I still haven't worked out why his Loffet didn't issue forth flames due to friction! ....and he never missed a beat.
Q
-
Tribute to both the player and the box. It's not everyone that can play that fast with that punch and that rhythm... and not many boxes that could handle it!
-
Ollie:
Have you made a final decision on layout, or are you still in the throes of making a decision?
Simply curious as to what ( if ) you finally decided!
cheers
Q
-
I think I'm probably going to go for the 3-row layout after all, with one change: the G# push will be an octave lower. This will allow (I think) at least two octaves of every scale (chromatically) from G to G. Hopefully the order will be in with Bernard by the end of the month. ;D
-
Much has been said about the right hand and I agree you should stick to what you have found suits you. On the bass hand though, I moved my 8 standard base to the 'chin end' and put the extras at the 'knee end'. This gives you an order of descending flats similar to the Straddella concept and makes for much easier runs plus the three chord tricks are better grouped.
I know it's unusual but it works for me. ;D
-
One of the Gogs musicians has this, and I tried his box last week... it felt very odd to me, not something I think I'd get used to either. I did consider it, and it makes sense logically, but my fingers didn't like it.
-
OK, Fair 'nuff.
It must be both exhillarating and brain aching in equal order to design your own layout, then tense excitement waiting!
best of luck
Q
-
Much has been said about the right hand and I agree you should stick to what you have found suits you. On the bass hand though, I moved my 8 standard base to the 'chin end' and put the extras at the 'knee end'. This gives you an order of descending flats similar to the Straddella concept and makes for much easier runs plus the three chord tricks are better grouped.
I know it's unusual but it works for me. ;D
Depending on your hand size it also makes less of a stretch to the air button.
Steve
-
I think that this weekend I'm going to post a thread about my new box. It will be interesting to see the reaction to my (bizarre) layout... watch this space ;)