Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Malcolm on April 25, 2011, 11:13:48 AM

Title: Why G/D?
Post by: Malcolm on April 25, 2011, 11:13:48 AM
This may have been aired before and, if so, then apologies but I am wondering why G/D melodeons are the predominant format(?) for playing English music?   I know that C is a popular key in East Anglia and there may well be other regional preferences but a G/D box will get you into most sessions, etc.  Is there a reason for this or is it just a happy accident?
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on April 25, 2011, 12:03:27 PM
You can blame Peter Kennedy and EFDSS who specified/introduced/imported the first ones in to the UK in the late forties.
And the rest of history...
I'm sure someone else can give a more expansive explanation.

Andy
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 25, 2011, 12:13:27 PM
I wish Peter Kennedy had taken a more careful look at the keyboard -
bottom knee end = dog whistle, also useful for clearing wax from ears.
top chin end = 'Oh I've got these notes left over....'

I've asked before why the odd selection of notes at the chin end, and it seems it reflected the previous common keys from which it was converted giving such an incomplete range of notes.
Perhaps Theo et al can give the definitive version.
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Andy Simpson on April 25, 2011, 12:36:44 PM
Before Mr Kennedy's brainfart, there was no standard system and English melodeon players probably played whatever system happened to be available to them and could be found playing boxes in C/F, G/C, C/C#, B/C or C one rows, the only thing in common being a C row.  English fiddlers, on the other hand, were playing mostly in G, D and A, (which can be done with the same fingering, just shifted along a string), and it was reasoned that a D/G melodeon would make it easier for box players and fiddlers to play together.

The lack of adequate low notes and superfluous high notes is a result of simply transposing the standard C/F layout up a tone, missing out the lower end of the scale of G and adding some dog whistles at the top. In retrospect, a lazy and poorly thought out way to go about making a box that can be played in common fiddle keys....then again, what would you expect from a non-melodeon player and a company that provided useless basses to Scottish and Irish players for decades?. ;D
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on April 25, 2011, 01:02:29 PM
ive asked for my next box to have low notes and accidentals , losing the very highest notes on each row, i have always wandered why not many others have done it as i would think that this would be more beneficial??? but im only a beginer, i hope ive done the right thing!
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 25, 2011, 01:35:33 PM
gypsylad: I've asked the question before about low notes
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,5294.0.html

I'm seriously thinking about changing to a 4th button start, loosing the top two ear cleaning devices....sorry, notes ... and having a low G start. Several times I have to play the notes below C# often down to low G on the basses and it doesn't sound good. Good learning exercise though!
What seems amazing to a new person like me, is that if for the last 40 years people have been muttering about the original poor design, no one has stamped their foot and tried to sort out a new 'industry standard' with a drop to low G and loosing the top notes.
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 25, 2011, 01:38:20 PM
Gypsylad: To answer your question - the advice I've had from here is that to change the keyboard to allow a G,A,B and C run up the the 'normal' 3rd button start of both scales is considered a good thing.
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Owen Woods on April 25, 2011, 02:38:58 PM
ive asked for my next box to have low notes and accidentals , losing the very highest notes on each row, i have always wandered why not many others have done it as i would think that this would be more beneficial??? but im only a beginer, i hope ive done the right thing!

Definitely. I have a 23 button D/G and could probably count on one hand the number of times I've gone up to the top. The second from top key on the D row I do use, because of the C# on the pull.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 25, 2011, 03:13:41 PM
I changed to fourth button start and low notes about five years ago and have never missed those piercing top notes. Recently, while working out the layout for the 2.6 row I shall be building in July, I went through about 250 tunes that I play and made a table showing the frequency with which I use each note. I discovered that I use all the notes on the G row down to low G, but that I rarely go below A on the D row. Even with a fourth button start, I rarely use the top two buttons on either row. Apart from my one-row Cajun box, both my other boxes are 3 row, but if I were to buy a two row G/D, I would definitely have a fourth button start with low notes on the G row, although I would consider seriously having accidentals on the lowest two buttons of the D row and perhaps on the highest buttons on both rows.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Theo on April 25, 2011, 04:56:41 PM
Just to avoid confusion,  the conventional way to describe the keys of a multi-row box is to start with the outside row,  so it should be D/G.  I believe it is important because there a occasional boxes where the rows are in a different order.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Tattyjacket on April 25, 2011, 05:53:28 PM
I've had mine re-tuned so that I have low notes on the G row and accidentals on the D row. This is simply so that I can play my party piece tune, "The Drinking Song," from The Student Prince.
In years to come, after I pass away, somebody will find my box and create a tradition that never existed.

There is one note that I don't have though.....boy do I wish I had an F natural.

Phil

p.s. Can we have "The Drinking Song," from The Student Prince nominated for Tune of the Month please.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on April 25, 2011, 06:08:56 PM
just looking at my new keyboard layout ive got

A row - Eb/f accidentals / E/G# low notes

D row - Bb/Bb acidentals / G/B low notes

G row - F/Eb accidentals / G/C low notes
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: rees on April 25, 2011, 06:40:59 PM
I've had mine re-tuned so that I have low notes on the G row and accidentals on the D row.

I also use this system. I'd rather have a low B and a D on the pull than an F natural or an E flat.  :|glug
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Mike Averill on April 25, 2011, 09:48:31 PM
The top notes are definately useful especially if you have a low octave voice. If you only have MM reeds make sure they've been well tuned and they become much more useable.

The G row accidentals are essentials but the hohner standard needs the plate turning over to put the D# on the push for Bmajor chords.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Theo on April 25, 2011, 10:52:51 PM

The G row accidentals are essentials but the hohner standard needs the plate turning over to put the D# on the push for Bmajor chords.

And the F on the pull for F chords!
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Howard Mitchell on April 26, 2011, 09:29:07 AM
I knew the Kennedy family, particularly Douglas and Peter and was on the EFDSS board with Peter.
I asked Peter in 2000 about the D/G melodeon as several stories had been circulating about his involvement.  By the way he was a melodeon player and played my melodeon on several ocassions.

He said - he was collecting songs and music in Northumberland in the 1950s and found that much of the material was in G and D, often played by fiddlers and pipers (notated in G even though the actual key was nearer F). Also many of the tunes were of Irish origin. He realised that, due to a freak of radio reception that local musicians often listened to Radio Éireann and heard melodeon players possibly playing B/C melodeons but that the few local melodeon players were more used to fifth-tuned instruments.  He arranged with Hohner to have a batch of melodeons made in D/G and these were sold by the EFDSS folk shop and by Bell's of Surbiton. I don't think he had any say in the detailed button layout.  As we know, they became popular throughout the country.

Howard Mitchell
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on April 26, 2011, 12:38:23 PM
thanks Howard, that osunds like it's got to the bottom of it.
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: seinegydd on April 26, 2011, 01:23:16 PM
Peter Kennedy certainly was a melodeon player! I taught myself by listening to the 78 rpm records he made of English folk dance music.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Steve C. on April 26, 2011, 01:27:14 PM
Lester sent me his DG with low notes and accidentals, and that's what I'm going to retune to.  Also, eliminate the minor third in the chord.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: smiley on April 27, 2011, 12:10:07 AM
..local musicians often listened to Radio Éireann and heard melodeon players possibly playing B/C melodeons but that the few local melodeon players were more used to fifth-tuned instruments.  He arranged with Hohner to have a batch of melodeons made in D/G and these were sold ...

Can anyone confirm what tuning was mostly played by irish 2-row button box players in the 1950's? Is it safe to assume mostly chromatic tuned boxes were being played in Ireland & UK before the diatonics became established? Maybe this is a good topic for an faq, to consolidate the various historical snippets previously discussed on the forum.

This stuff is fascinating - it must be time for a book on the emergence of the most popular melodeon tunings (and the early box players) of irish and english folk music. Reg Hall and his contemporaries must have a wealth of info to share.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on April 28, 2011, 06:17:38 PM
I suppose that I must count as one of Reg Hall's contemporaries.  In January 1955 whilst I was still at school, I joined a Morrismens club that was just starting up in Gravesend.  The Musician was Reg Hall.
He turned up one week with a new Melodeon and the Squire remarked that it sounded different from his previous one.   He had just got it from Bell Accordions of Surbiton; I believe that this was the first of the second batch of D/G Melodeons that Bell's had had made by Hohners, at the request of the EFDSS. This was a "Pokerwork" instrument, I think they were unimaginitively called 2915 at the time.
I was very impressed with Reg Hall's playing and the instrument that he played; so I saved up all my pocket money, cashed in my War savings certificates, sold my stamp collection to a school friend; and about a year later I had just enough (twelve pounds ten shillings) to buy my first Melodeon at Bell's.
More about that later, is this the sort of information that you want ?
Inventor. 
 
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Anahata on April 28, 2011, 06:32:47 PM
Can anyone confirm what tuning was mostly played by irish 2-row button box players in the 1950's? Is it safe to assume mostly chromatic tuned boxes were being played in Ireland & UK before the diatonics became established?

They used to play one row melodeons in what was referred to as "the old style", so that was before the chromatics, but I don't know when that change happened.

Whether they also played two row quint (e.g. D/G) boxes in those days I wouldn't know.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Stiamh on April 28, 2011, 07:01:11 PM
Paddy O'Brien began playing B/C as a kid in the late 1930s, and 1953 made several famous 78rpm recordings which launched the B/C tidal wave that practically swept all other tunings aside.

However other semitone tunings were played prior to that, and to some extent after. Michael Grogan's recordings (1930s I believe) were apparently made on a G/G# box, and John Clifford played a D/D# box "inside-out" (by all accounts he was a very good player, but then he went to London and became a PA player with truly catastrophic results  ;) ). Joe Cooley also played C#/D and D/D# inside-out. In the 1940s and 1950s, according to Jackie Daly, a number of Sliabh Luachra players used C/C# boxes, again inside-out, because C#/D models were very hard to come by at the time. A few years ago I was at a gathering with Mike McHale, a well-known whistle and flute player in NY state. He asked me what tuning my box was and on hearing it was C#/D, said "that's my kind of box," picked it up and amazed everyone present by pumping out a set of great reels - nobody had any idea that he played the box. He said that was the system he had played in Ireland when he was young, which would be in the 1940s and 1950s.

There were also B/C/C# players in Ireland, and a small handful of them remain. I haven't heard of players using quint boxes but there must have been a few odd ones here and there. But the short answer to your question is that in the 1950s, B/C became the standard.

I have referred to this discussion on concertina.net several times - well worth reading: http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=2347
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: smiley on April 29, 2011, 02:24:31 AM
It's all good grist to the mill ... thanks
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Malcolm on April 29, 2011, 01:04:27 PM
Thanks Inventor - that is absolutely the sort of information I was after.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on April 29, 2011, 05:07:38 PM
The saga of my first Melodeon continued.
It was the Saturday a week before Christmas 1955 that I went along with my father to Bell Accordions at Surbiton to buy my 2915 (pokerwork) D/G melodeon. There I met the manager a Mr Larkin, who was conversant with the requirements of English Folk Dance players.  He was pleased to say that there was just one left out of the second batch of D/G melodeons that they had stocked at the request of the EFDSS. When it came out to my horror it was not a pokerwork but an Erica; which with it's plastic overcoat did not look in the least folky, and to top it all at fourteen pounds was going to cost thirty shillings more than I had managed to scrape together. I enquired when they might be getting the next batch of D/G melodeons, but Mr Larkin told me that they would not be getting any more; the first batch had sold quite quickly but the second batch much more slowly, and he felt that they had virtually fulfilled the total demand that there would ever be for D/G Melodeons ! 
In those days there were strict Board of Trade restrictions on imports of all foreign goods: Bell's had more or less the exclusive  monopoly of the limited number of new Hohner Accordions that could be imported into England.  Mr Larkin did say however that in another year or so's time they might, just might be ordering a batch of A/D/G Melodeons as there had been a small number of requests for those.  He showed me the equivalent in G/C/F which to me looked gigantic compared with the Melodeon that I wanted, and would cost quite a bit more than even the Erica; the only thing it had going for it was that in was in a nice bright Red rather than the dull grey of the Erica.
So it was the Erica or nothing.  My father reluctantly lent me the extra thirty shillings, and I left clutching the last ever D/G Melodeon ;D and no pocket money for a whole 3 months; but what does money matter when you have a lovely musical instrument to play ?
Inventor.
 
   
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: waltzman on April 29, 2011, 08:17:59 PM
Great story.  Thanks for sharing it.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on May 08, 2011, 03:46:42 PM
To return to the original question of why D/G.
Before I took up the Melodeon I had had 2 years violin lessons at school. The first key we learned to play in was not C as you might expect but G because it is a somewhat easier key to start the fiddle on.  This was then followed quite quickly by the key of D, and after a good interval by the key of A. Right at the end of my time on violin lessons the key C was finally introduced. I never liked this key as to my mind it sat awkwardly on the fiddle.  Traditional English Scottish and Irish fiddle players had discovered all this generations earlier.  There were Melodeon players around in the Fifties, with Melodeons in a variety of keys, but almost without exception they played solo, so it really didn't matter what key(s) their boxes were in.
From Cecil Sharp's time up to WW2 The piano had been the predominant instrument used by EFDSS groups, sometimes with a violin (I use this word deliberately rather than fiddle) alongside. After WW2 in the early fifties Douglas Kennedy the director of the EFDSS was keen to get away from the School Piano image of English folk dance and was encouraging other more portable instruments like accordions, concertinas, flutes, and drums to come into small bands. His aims were accidentally given a boost by two movements that came from quite outside the EFDSS: American Square Dancing (caused by images of Princes Elizabeth and Prince Philip doing Square Dancing whilst on a visit to Canada) and the Skiffle craze. This brought in the guitar banjo and even the odd tea-chest bass, to the mixture.  The leading instrument in these new bands was usually the fiddle and so this is why the fiddle favoured keys of G & D (and sometimes A) predominated.  Although there was still a living tradition of Melodeon playing in England (Loftus, High Spen, and Abbots Bromley to name but 3 that spring to mind), the instruments and those that could be bought in the local music shop weren't in keys that suited the newly forming bands.  Peter Kennedy's work in getting instruments in at least the right keys, if not the best compass has been adequately covered by earlier writers above. I met Peter early on, and he was very encouraging of my early efforts on the D/G Melodeon.
So to sum it up D/G (and A/D/G) Melodeons, it's all the fault of the Fiddle Players!
Maybe more to follow on my adventures as the only, yes only melodeon player at the 2nd Sidmouth Festival.
Inventor.           
 
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 08, 2011, 03:59:10 PM
Inventor:
Thank you so much for all of this, it's certainly filled a big hole in my knowledge, I'm sure there's a lot of very appreciative others out there too.
best wishes
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Owen Woods on May 08, 2011, 09:24:12 PM
Maybe more to follow on my adventures as the only, yes only melodeon player at the 2nd Sidmouth Festival.

Wow.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Gary on May 09, 2011, 03:05:04 PM
Great history notes thanks, so my 2915 has a background based aorund English folk dance and also the DG keys are good for fiddle players,lucky for me then.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 09, 2011, 03:14:06 PM
To return to the original question of why D/G.
Before I took up the Melodeon I had had 2 years violin lessons at school. The first key we learned to play in was not C as you might expect but G because it is a somewhat easier key to start the fiddle on.  This was then followed quite quickly by the key of D, and after a good interval by the key of A. Right at the end of my time on violin lessons the key C was finally introduced. I never liked this key as to my mind it sat awkwardly on the fiddle. 
I started learning fiddle a year ago (had to look that up can't believe its a year already!) and quite soon after I started I played tunes in C...I can see why some find it awkward (I'm still persevering with it). Would having an 5 string violin help with the extra C string?
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 09, 2011, 03:35:07 PM
I always found playing in C on the mandoline a bit awkward to pitch and the chords for the three chord trick are not nice to fret, so it's no surprise that the fiddler in our band picks up a four-stop (HA114C) when we go there!

Rob.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: mglamb on May 09, 2011, 04:20:16 PM
Would having an 5 string violin help with the extra C string?

Possibly, but it would have to be pitched an octave below middle C in order to maintain the established string interval of fifths.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 10, 2011, 12:23:20 AM
I can't see the problem with playing fiddle in C - it's exactly the same fingering as G and D, just another string further down. Or have I missed something? It's easier even than A, and it has no horrible flats!  ???
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Malcolm on May 10, 2011, 06:09:39 AM
Dear Inventor - Your input has been extremely helpful in understanding why we favour G/D in English music.  However, are we alone in this key fixation I wonder....?
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: old geezer on May 10, 2011, 07:43:21 AM
Dear Inventor - Your input has been extremely helpful in understanding why we favour G/D in English music.  However, are we alone in this key fixation I wonder....?

here, on the western side of Victoria in Oz,  our preference for Australiana and folk songs are in the key of G, whilst there are quite a few that do receive an airing in D.  :||:

Charlie seems most popular on the apple isle if you where to visit.   ::)
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Anahata on May 10, 2011, 07:57:04 AM
I can't see the problem with playing fiddle in C - it's exactly the same fingering as G and D, just another string further down. Or have I missed something? It's easier even than A, and it has no horrible flats!  ???

One string further down is fine until your original tune goes below D, then there isn't a lower string.
Five string fiddle (as mentioned above) isn't always a satisfactory solution because when you play that low a fiddle doesn't produce much sound. The larger body of a viola helps a bit, but it's still not a sound that carries well.
Play an octave higher and it's not the same fingering, plus on the E string to get an F natural you have to move your 1st finger back closer to the nut, and you don't have to do that in any of the 'folk' keys so I suppose it's a shock if you're not used to it.

(playing devil's advocate here, as a cellist used to playing in five flats when required...)
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Banjo Ray on May 10, 2011, 10:08:53 AM
When learning the violin pretty much the first fingered note anybody ever plays is F# (first finger on the E) - and the last in first position is F (flattened first finger).

I've always found it strange that G is so popular for British fiddle tunes as the root tends to be third-finger of the D string.  For old-time US tunes, A and D are popular because one can use the open strings to "drone" particularly if your bowing isnt that accurate.

Ray

Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 10, 2011, 10:11:26 AM

One string further down is fine until your original tune goes below D, then there isn't a lower string.
Five string fiddle (as mentioned above) isn't always a satisfactory solution because when you play that low a fiddle doesn't produce much sound.
Unless its an electro-acoustic one like I tried a few months ago. ;)
Then that definitely is LOUD....when turned up to '11' of course.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 10, 2011, 11:16:39 AM
I can't see the problem with playing fiddle in C - it's exactly the same fingering as G and D, just another string further down. Or have I missed something? It's easier even than A, and it has no horrible flats!  ???
At least I'm not the only one who finds 'A' tricky...well screechy. ;)
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Anahata on May 10, 2011, 11:52:26 AM
A fiddle tuned down a tone would have F C G D for open strings, which would be fun, especially for plying French music in the usual keys.
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on May 14, 2011, 03:55:02 PM
Early Sidmouth:  Before I got my first Melodeon I had never tryed one, I only knew that a D/G one was the right one for Morris Dancing (and English Country Dancing); so when I got home I took it out of it's box (they came in a cardboard box and no shoulder straps in those days) and tryed a few buttons. To my delight the first two bars of Shepherds Hey flopped out, and within a very short time I found the buttons that played the whole tune.
By the time that the Morris Dancing Season arrived in the summer of 1956 I had learned, and could play up to speed all the Morris Dances that my Side did (mostly Headington Bampton and Adderbury), which was my reason for taking up the Melodeon in the first place.  I didn't need to play for Country Dancing because all those dances came on gramophone records, so my ability to play those especially up to full dancing speed was very limited. I could play the Winster Gallop (that's a Morris tune anyway allbeit not a Cotswold Morris), Brighton Camp (for that peculiar Eynsham dance) and The Cock of the North, and that was about it, although I had worked out how to give a good Um Pah accompanyment to any dance tune, provided it was in either G or D Major.
So off I went in August 1956 to the second Sidmouth Festival, with my sister and little Melodeon. In those days Sidmouth was a very small affair with a company of about 40 dancers and just 7 public performances the whole week: afternoon and evening on the Monday (which was August Bankholiday Monday in those days), evening on Tuesday, afternoon Wednesday, evening Thursday, and afternoon and evening on the last Friday.  This wasn't nearly enough dancing for a lot of the younger crowd that had come to Sidmouth, so we formed an informal busking group. 
A small group had arrived from Hitchen in Hertfordshire, in a Volkswagen Minibus, being half a Morris side and a fiddler, together with some from Sheffield and the Stafford fool, and a Lancia car.  We all squeezed into the Volkswagen and Lancia, and went off into the surrounding countryside as far as Widdicombe in the Moor on one day.  Fortunately I could play practically all the morris dances that were common to the group; but the country dances were more problematical.  The fiddler from Hitchin knew plenty of tunes but was not confident enough to play on his own. So it was Winster Gallop - a dance to my only reel - a dance to my only jig - and the Winster Gallop. 
The Hitchin group and some of the others were into Playford Dances, however most of these tunes like Nonesuch and Parsons Farewell were in minor keys which were an absolute mystery to me at that time; so it came down to Newcastle in G major, Jacks Maggot in D major, with me providing a hearty Um-Pah Um-Pah. to be followed by - you guessed it Winster Gallop.
I said previously I was the only Melodeon player at Sidmouth, unlike nowadays when you just can't move for Stampedes of Melodeon players, all playing the Winster Gallop (did I start a tradition I wonder); but this was not quite strictly true. On the very last farewell dance the Official Band (4 fiddles 3 piano-accordions & double-bass) decided that they wanted a rest; so the music was provided by John Burgess an experienced Melodeon player from Swindon on a D/G Club (his wife a Melodeon Widdow had only agreed to come to Sidmouth provided he didn't play the whole week), and Nibs Matthews (the SW EFDSS organiser), who borrowed my Melodeon as his own could only be played in other keys.
Inventor.                 
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 14, 2011, 05:57:09 PM
Inventor - this is a priceless insight.
Apart from being a local person involved in moris and folk, I have great affection for the festival. My mum was one of a local village folk dance club in East Devon who used to go and dance in Bill Rutter's back garden in Clyst Hydon. I don't know how or why, but he then took this folk dance idea to be an embryonic festival, as I understand the first Sidmouth was in 1954. She never went to the festival as a folk club dancer, as by then she'd given up.
Presumably '56 was the third festival?
I'm not sure how much is known or written, but this might be the start of a fascinating history of the festival from a folk person's view point. I think there was a book published around 2002-ish, but have never read it so not sure what detail of the early days are in it.
Absolutely fascinating. Thank you!
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on May 14, 2011, 08:24:50 PM
The book was writen for the 50th Aniversary of the Sidmouth Festival I have a copy somewhere, I'll look it up for the dates. The book does give some of the information about the earlier Festivals, there's even a photograph of me at an early Festival playing my Erica for a "scratch" Morris Side, and another of me several years later playing a borrowed Erica for the Sheffield Cutlers 
The first few festivals were run by Nibs Mattews assisted by Tony Foxworthy, with Marjorie Grant and another lady on the administrative side. Bill Rutter took over both the running of the South West EFDSS and the Sidmouth Festival several years later.
Inventor. 
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 14, 2011, 09:49:54 PM
Thanks for putting me straight there. I knew Bill was involved early on, I think mum hinted he'd started it, but obviousl got it slightly mixed up. Bill was a good friend to our morris side too, so again links there in my memory. Also little things like meeting my morris side there, then my wife, and having to be hauled off the Arena because our first daughter was definitely on the way!
I couldn't remember when the book came out, it all blurs into one. Still I was lucky enough to have danced at the 25th and the 50th Sidmouth, and really miss the international aspect of it.
hey ho. Happy days!
Q
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Inventor on May 15, 2011, 12:00:26 PM
Correction to my last post. I haven't found the book yet, but I think that the earlier photograph of me shows me dancing in a scratch team not playing.  In those early days there was an official photographer with a Rolycord who took loads of photos of the official displays, and displayed them at the next mornings Rehearsal.  I bought one with me playing for a scratch Morris side of the same vintage.
Inventor. 
Title: Re: Why G/D?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 15, 2011, 01:56:19 PM
For Sidmouth's 50th year, our local regional BBC news programme featured a reflective look back at the festiival, starting with the arena.
I think it was 1970/72 about when I first drove into Sidmouth on my day tripping hols and wondered what planet I'd gone to!
Anyway..... the presenter was sat in the arena, in a deckchair with the camera panning around behind. I was stunned at how empty it was; a few deckchairs close to the stage; the other 50 odd sat on the grass; the stage was a few flat boards and a little tent behind for changing.....
and that was recent compaired to your stories! Things sound far more spontaneous and unorganised, which in my opinion has greater ability for meeting, sharing and learning, I think.
I must take a look at that book.
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal