Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Sandy Flett on April 28, 2011, 03:12:47 PM

Title: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Sandy Flett on April 28, 2011, 03:12:47 PM
I love the richness of sound of LMM from a melodeon on its own, but can't help but feel it becomes indistinct, even a bit muddy, when played along with other instruments, especially when compared with the typical clarity of MM. Anybody else feel the same?

Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Theo on April 28, 2011, 03:48:59 PM
Yes, though it depends on what, and how many, other instruments you are playing with.   A duo or trio is ok, but its not good in a session.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Rob2Hook on April 28, 2011, 03:50:14 PM
I guess it will depend on the individual instrument's tuning.  I use my Trilly for both Morris and ceilidh playing.  The Hohner players complain that it is too loud, whilst in the ceilidh band they reckon that its dry tuning allows it to cut through whilst still adding the richness of the lower octave.  I have heard tremolo tuned LMM and I think you have a point, they seem to lack the cutting edge and tend to meld into the overall sound of a band.

Rob.

P.S. good to see you in Odiham on St George's day.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Anahata on April 28, 2011, 03:58:14 PM
Works OK with high pitched instruments.
Do you remember Umps and Dumps? Tufty Swift played 1 row melodeon (OK, that was LMMH so a bit more top) John Kirkpatrick played Anglo concertina which would have been incredibly squeaky by itself, but nicely complemented the lower tones of the one-row, and Sue Harris played Hammered Dulcimer which is also a bright and tinkly instrument that did the same.

Mix an LMM box with a clarinet and tenor sax, for example, and you'd get a very muddy sound.

Also if the Pig Dyke Molly musicians turn out in force, we have a Loffet LM box with my Oakwood (MM, bright) which complement each other nicely.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: IanD on April 28, 2011, 04:41:57 PM
I love the richness of sound of LMM from a melodeon on its own, but can't help but feel it becomes indistinct, even a bit muddy, when played along with other instruments, especially when compared with the typical clarity of MM. Anybody else feel the same?



I would agree 100%, even for otherwise identical boxes from the same manufacturer. None of the 3-reed Oakwoods I've played (including ones like John's that's currently for sale) has quite the same the crispness and "bite" of their 2-reed boxes, even with the low reed shut off.

It's not to do with size either, the 3-reed (Model 7) and 2-reed (Model 4) are exactly the same size. One reason may be that the pallet holes have to be quite a lot smaller on a 3-reed box to allow for the sliding valve to shut off the low reed, and this restricts the flow of sound from the reeds to the air.

When the low reed is sounding it fills in the gaps caused by the beating between the MM reeds, and the ear is better at picking out sounds which vary more with time so interprets the 2-reed sound as "louder" even though it's not when you measure it with a sound level meter. This certainly happens even more when playing with other instruments.

But I do agree with the richness of sound when played solo; my dry-tuned G/C Tommy sounds fabulous on its own, but is much less useful in a band setting because you can't pick it out. Used for Morris it couldn't cut its way out of a wet brown paper bag...

Ian
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 28, 2011, 07:29:18 PM
My experience with Castagnaris is similar to Ian's with Oakwoods. The three-voice Dony I used to own did not have the carrying power when played for Morris that my two-voice Bennys have. When playing in loud sessions, I found it difficult to hear myself play when I used the Dony, but I have hade no such difficulty with the Bennys.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Andy in Vermont on April 28, 2011, 09:34:38 PM
Yes, though it depends on what, and how many, other instruments you are playing with.   

That is my experience as well.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Sandy Flett on April 28, 2011, 09:46:34 PM
My experience with Castagnaris is similar to Ian's with Oakwoods. The three-voice Dony I used to own did not have the carrying power when played for Morris that my two-voice Bennys have. When playing in loud sessions, I found it difficult to hear myself play when I used the Dony, but I have hade no such difficulty with the Bennys.

Really interested in Ian's theory about the MM sound from an LMM setup not being as powerful as MM from a 2-voice box. Any more observations/evidence on the Tommy MM not being as powerful as the Benny MM?
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 28, 2011, 11:21:56 PM
My experience of the Tommy is somewhat limited, but I have always thought that the Tommy has a more powerful sound than the Benny.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Anahata on April 28, 2011, 11:30:12 PM
Really interested in Ian's theory about the MM sound from an LMM setup not being as powerful as MM from a 2-voice box. Any more observations/evidence on the Tommy MM not being as powerful as the Benny MM?

Not on the Castagnaris, but when I was trying out Oakwoods the MM sound from the LMM box was much thinner and weaker than the MM box, which is why I went for the latter.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Steve_freereeder on April 29, 2011, 09:52:17 AM
My experience of the Tommy is somewhat limited, but I have always thought that the Tommy has a more powerful sound than the Benny.
Really interested in Ian's theory about the MM sound from an LMM setup not being as powerful as MM from a 2-voice box. Any more observations/evidence on the Tommy MM not being as powerful as the Benny MM?
Not on the Castagnaris, but when I was trying out Oakwoods the MM sound from the LMM box was much thinner and weaker than the MM box, which is why I went for the latter.
For Lizzie Dripping, our usual line-up is two melodeons and a soprano saxophone. I play on my TAM-reeded Sander, usually on its LMM setting, and my fellow melodeonist plays on a Tommy. Her Tommy cuts through everything, whether she has it on MM or LMM. It's a great outdoor box (I sometimes wonder why I ever sold mine).

I agree with Anahata that the Castagnari LMM sound in general is extraordinarily rich and powerful, and definitely audible over other instruments in an outdoor setting.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: IanD on April 29, 2011, 12:07:13 PM
My experience with Castagnaris is similar to Ian's with Oakwoods. The three-voice Dony I used to own did not have the carrying power when played for Morris that my two-voice Bennys have. When playing in loud sessions, I found it difficult to hear myself play when I used the Dony, but I have hade no such difficulty with the Bennys.

Three-voice Dony -- are you sure, mine (and the others I've seen) is 2-voice?

Remember also that the Dony is a lot bigger than the Benny, the larger bellows area means you get a lot less air pressure for the same muscle power. It's one reason people think the Lilly is a loud little box when they pick one up for the first time, you're working the reeds much harder than you think compared to a bigger box -- also one reason they're a bit prone to blowing reeds, it's easy to get so much air pressure that the reeds first bend out of tune (usually flat) and then snap if you keep doing it...

This is why the difference between the Oakwood 2-reed and 3-reed boxes makes the differences so clear, as Anahata said -- same size, same bellows, same reeds, same maker, but the MM definitely sounds better than the (L)MM.

Ian
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Theo on April 29, 2011, 12:34:19 PM
The three-voice Dony I used to own .

Perhaps you mean a Mory?  The Dony is the two voice brother of the Mory according to the old official castagnari website (http://castagnari.trad.org/fr/rik.html), the new site seems to be unavailable just now.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Anahata on April 29, 2011, 01:52:01 PM
I agree with Anahata that the Castagnari LMM sound in general is extraordinarily rich and powerful

For the record, "Not on the Castagnari" was intended to mean I didn't have the experience to comment on the Castagnari, whereas I could make a comparison with the Oakwood...

Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: IanD on April 29, 2011, 01:57:23 PM
My experience of the Tommy is somewhat limited, but I have always thought that the Tommy has a more powerful sound than the Benny.

Is that a Tommy with only the MM reeds, or LLM?

A 3-reed Tommy will sound fuller than a Benny, but then we're back to the LLM vs MM sound which is where this started...
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Andy in Vermont on April 29, 2011, 04:26:00 PM
[...] about the MM sound from an LMM setup not being as powerful as MM from a 2-voice box [...] Any more observations/evidence on the Tommy MM not being as powerful as the Benny MM?

Years ago, I read some articles published in a Breton diatonic accordion newsletter (can't find the link now), where several authors were supporting the idea that, given a box of identical dimensions, the 2-voice version had superior sound in MM (in several ways, including volume) to the 3-voice version in MM mode. The authors attributed the difference to to the amount of real estate on the fondo (soundboard if you insist) taken up by the reedblocks. (Of course, it could also relate to the amount of space inside the box, not just the area on the fondo.)
If this is correct, then size could make a difference, i.e. an "inefficiently" designed box, with lots of excess space on the fondo beyond that space that is required by the reedblocks, could excel in 2-voice mode even on an LMM box.
There are other factors that can contribute as well, such as placement of reedblocks in the space directly "blocked" by the keyboard; the keyboard design (hollow vs. solid; openings) can affect the sound as well.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 30, 2011, 02:17:03 PM
The three-voice Dony I used to own .

Perhaps you mean a Mory?  The Dony is the two voice brother of the Mory according to the old official castagnari website (http://castagnari.trad.org/fr/rik.html), the new site seems to be unavailable just now.

You are quite right, Theo. I have owned both a Mory and a Dony in the past. I meant to write Mory and somehow it came out as Dony. Stupid boy!  :|bl
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Bob Ellis on April 30, 2011, 02:29:45 PM
My experience of the Tommy is somewhat limited, but I have always thought that the Tommy has a more powerful sound than the Benny.

Is that a Tommy with only the MM reeds, or LLM?

A 3-reed Tommy will sound fuller than a Benny, but then we're back to the LLM vs MM sound which is where this started...


Well, I'm not sure about that, Ian. I am the one playing the Benny. Those playing Tommys alongside me in sessions/workshops etc. always seem to have the louder instrument, but whether they were MM or LMM I couldn't say. However, I am not convinced that a three-voice melodeon will always have a fuller sound that a two-voice instrument. For several years I played a three-voice Castagnari Mory for our Morris side alongside a friend playing a two-voice Dino Baffetti Black Pearl II. The Black Pearl sounded louder to me than the Mory, but maybe that was down to differences in our respective playing styles.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: george garside on April 30, 2011, 02:58:27 PM
to me its not so much the difference between mm & lmm in the broad sense of the argument but more down to the way the box is tuned,with particular reference to the mm reeds. Also very much down to the individual handling of the box and also there is the question of one mans meat etc.

 My personal prefcerence is for the mm reeds to be tuned quite far apart (wet) which the concert pitch L reeds  complement nicely,    I  am not over keen on dry tuned mm with concert pitch L  as this combination just provides a louder indistinct buzz! - but as I have said one mans meat is another mans poison!

george
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: IanD on May 20, 2011, 12:06:44 AM
My experience of the Tommy is somewhat limited, but I have always thought that the Tommy has a more powerful sound than the Benny.

Is that a Tommy with only the MM reeds, or LLM?

A 3-reed Tommy will sound fuller than a Benny, but then we're back to the LLM vs MM sound which is where this started...


Well, I'm not sure about that, Ian. I am the one playing the Benny. Those playing Tommys alongside me in sessions/workshops etc. always seem to have the louder instrument, but whether they were MM or LMM I couldn't say. However, I am not convinced that a three-voice melodeon will always have a fuller sound that a two-voice instrument. For several years I played a three-voice Castagnari Mory for our Morris side alongside a friend playing a two-voice Dino Baffetti Black Pearl II. The Black Pearl sounded louder to me than the Mory, but maybe that was down to differences in our respective playing styles.

I deliberately said "fuller" (meaning a richer sound) not "sounding louder" (which is where this thread started off) -- I agree 100% that a 2-reed MM box usually *sounds* louder (all other things being equal)  than a 3-reed LMM one even though it may measure quieter.

Again, all other things being equal (which of course they're not) a Black Pearl will sound louder than a Mory anyway unless you apply about double the left arm force on the Mory to get the same air pressure, since the Mory bellows area is about double.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Steve C. on May 20, 2011, 02:22:59 AM
My Benny is extraordinarily "unloud", which around the house is a virtue.  Plus with the lower GC pitch I think that makes it even more so.

When no one's home, out comes the Pokerwork!  >:E
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Noodle on May 20, 2011, 05:03:07 AM
My recent experience is that my Double Ray and my Baffetti Binci both sound different when playing among the other musicians in Black Pig (we have a big band) and during sessions, the 2 voice Double Ray requires less effort to be heard by myself among the noise. Mind you, I've read somewhere (probably here) that certain tremolo settings allow a melodeon to cut through easier. While it's tuned to what you'd expect of a Hohner, my Baffetti Binci is a bit different. In 2 voice form, it's easier to blend in while I learn tunes, and actually sounds far better with its drier tuning, but it's far easier to hear with the stop out to bring the low reeds in. In a session I have no problems hearing myself.

I can't comment on what it sounds like to onlookers or other session musicians, but I've never heard any negative feedback on either of my boxes... Only positive feedback on my Binci. And the Tommy's that the Witchmen musicians play (one of which regularly attends the same session I attend) seem to cut through with ease wherever they're played.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: nemethmik on May 20, 2011, 01:19:34 PM
My Benny is extraordinarily "unloud", which around the house is a virtue.  Plus with the lower GC pitch I think that makes it even more so.
This is a very helpful comment. I am just thinking of buying a Benny, but definitely I do not want a too quiet melodeon.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: EeeJay on May 20, 2011, 05:40:42 PM
Years ago, I read some articles published in a Breton diatonic accordion newsletter (can't find the link now), where several authors were supporting the idea that, given a box of identical dimensions, the 2-voice version had superior sound in MM (in several ways, including volume) to the 3-voice version in MM mode. The authors attributed the difference to to the amount of real estate on the fondo (soundboard if you insist) taken up by the reedblocks. (Of course, it could also relate to the amount of space inside the box, not just the area on the fondo.)

You must be talking about these, I think... thankfully saved by the Internet Archive...

Regarding the Norman Armoires (http://web.archive.org/web/20050217221308/http://www.cadb.org/Parole-2/10e.html), written by Yann-Fañch Perroches... and the sequel (http://web.archive.org/web/20050217221428/http://www.cadb.org/Parole-2/12e.html), written by Bernard Loffet...

Ed J
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 20, 2011, 08:17:55 PM
My Benny is extraordinarily "unloud", which around the house is a virtue.  Plus with the lower GC pitch I think that makes it even more so.
This is a very helpful comment. I am just thinking of buying a Benny, but definitely I do not want a too quiet melodeon.

I can't comment about the G/C Benny because I have never heard one, but my D/G Benny is loud enough to play for my Morris side and also to be heard clearly in the sessions in which I play, some of which can have as many as 30 musicians playing at once. We all have our own opinions about what constitutes loudness, but I find my Benny loud enough for just about any occasion without being too loud.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Steve C. on May 21, 2011, 02:01:09 PM
Bob, you are probably right. 

Maybe what I meant to say was it's easy to play the benny quietly, while it's easy to play the pokerwork loud.

Also, the DG vs. GC pitch difference, also the dryness I have on the GC, all contribute.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: sticky fingers on May 23, 2011, 07:53:59 PM
tommy,hascy,dony,handry,sandy denny, lets call the whole thing off. sf
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Ollie on May 23, 2011, 08:14:18 PM
I think it very much depends on what octave you play in as to whether it sounds muddy. LMM boxes generally sound a bit muddy if you play them in the normal octave as the lower reeds are fighting against the bass reeds. If you play in the upper octave, this isn't a problem, in fact the higher notes make it more pronounced. You just have to listen to Andy Cutting with Blowzabella to hear this in action.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: mglamb on May 23, 2011, 08:45:55 PM
Fully agree with Ollie on this!  I was just practicing "Parson's Farewell" in the upper octave on my newly-acquired D/G Saltarelle Elfique and added in the low reeds to tame some of the shrillness.  What a difference - a nice, full sound with a lovely metallic ring to it!  To me it sounded much clearer and more piercing than MM alone.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: ganderbox on May 23, 2011, 10:19:53 PM
I agree too. My main reason for having a 3 voice box is so that I can play tunes that I've learned on a G/C (in the upper octave) on a D/G without having to learn them in both octaves. (Now there's laziness!  :|bl)

I used to have a Tommy, and now have a Loffet Pro, and I would say about both of them that they sound superb on their own or with a small group, but somehow don't seem to work so well for me in sessions, regardless of which combination of voices I'm using. I don't know if that's how it sounds to other people, or whether it's just my own perspective from the other side of the box. For playing in the ceilidh band or generally out and about, I prefer a 2 voice.

Some time ago I was at one of the "local" French dance clubs, and the melodeon player in the band had a Dony and a Mory. For dancing, the Dony won hands down - it had a brightness that the Mory just doesn't have.  
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 24, 2011, 07:18:37 AM
Hmmm....

I'm beginning to feel that I'm in the minority here. I really like the sound of the LMM setting on my D/G boxes, and tend to use it a lot in many situations including playing for street dancing, gigs and ceilidhs, sessions, etc. I don't think it sounds muddy, perhaps because my MM reeds have only a very light tremolo, but it does have a richness which I like, and avoids the shrillness of a 2-voice D/G when playing in the upper octaves. Because of this I can also jump about from lower to upper octaves, without having to think about using the stops.

Maybe I like the LMM sound so much because I also love the sound of 1-row 4-stop instruments tuned LMMH. Perhaps my ideal 2-row box would be a four voice LMMH. But I'm happy with what I've got.

On the other hand, I also have a 3-voice G/C box, tuned LMM, but I rarely use the L voice on that, as it is generally very mellow just with MM, even in the upper octave.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Just4Fun on May 24, 2011, 09:11:14 AM
This is a fascinating discussion for me as I've just sold my two voice Salterelle and have bought a Hascy with switches and stops which are all rather new to me. Besides the fact that I just love the sound it produces, it is so much fun exploring the different combinations of settings and how they do or don't suit various 'types' of tune. I've only played it in one session thus far, which was medium in size, and didn't notice any problems with volume but certainly regretted my choice of setting on a tune that I started with the low reeds included. Next time (if I'm allowed back) I'll know which setting to use with that particular tune. So I suppose it's just another part of the learning process that I'm still relatively new to. All good fun. :D
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: ladydetemps on May 24, 2011, 09:36:46 AM


I used to have a Tommy, and now have a Loffet Pro, and I would say about both of them that they sound superb on their own or with a small group, but somehow don't seem to work so well for me in sessions, regardless of which combination of voices I'm using. I don't know if that's how it sounds to other people, or whether it's just my own perspective from the other side of the box. For playing in the ceilidh band or generally out and about, I prefer a 2 voice.
I have your tommy...and I find can't hear myself with stop in...put if I pull the stop out got no problems hearing myself play.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Guy on May 24, 2011, 09:46:26 AM
Hmmm....

I'm beginning to feel that I'm in the minority here. I really like the sound of the LMM setting on my D/G boxes, and tend to use it a lot in many situations including playing for street dancing, gigs and ceilidhs, sessions, etc.

Well Steve, you're in a minority of at least two, as I entirely agree with everything you say. I'm lucky enough to have several D/G boxes. and usually use all 3 voices for most things-ceilidhs, Morris, sessions etc. because it's the sound I prefer. The exception would be the Mory, which I'll use all the settings on for different effects, usually for concert sets or to amuse myself at home....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Gary P Chapin on May 24, 2011, 02:54:59 PM
Hmmm....
I'm beginning to feel that I'm in the minority here. I really like the sound of the LMM setting ...
Well Steve, you're in a minority of at least two ...
Guy

Make it three.  I love the L reed on my Pastourelle, and recently wrote a tribute to it (http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2011/05/playing-low-lonesome-reed.html).

Actually, in a conversation, I realized that I'm of two minds.  I love the LMM, but also love the MM.  I've never found the LMM to be weak or indistinct, but it is different.  I like having both.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Andy in Vermont on May 24, 2011, 07:46:49 PM
Make it three.  I love the L reed on my Pastourelle, and recently wrote a tribute to it (http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2011/05/playing-low-lonesome-reed.html).

I like LMM, too, especially on C/F and D/G boxes.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Howard Jones on May 24, 2011, 08:10:33 PM
On my Saltarelle Nuage, which has stops for everything, I can select different reed combinations and I often use just LM on tunes which would be a bit high and squeaky with MM.  I also think it suits French tunes.  On the other hand when I'm going for the full English I'll sometimes use LMM and try (probably unsuccessfully) to pretend it's a one-row.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Andy in Vermont on August 15, 2011, 03:49:09 PM
Make it three.  I love the L reed on my Pastourelle, and recently wrote a tribute to it (http://accordeonaire.blogspot.com/2011/05/playing-low-lonesome-reed.html).

I finally got around to "responding" with another low-voice recording -- a brace of hornpipes:
http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/low-and-lonesome-hornpipes.html (http://melodeonminutes.blogspot.com/2011/08/low-and-lonesome-hornpipes.html)
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: george garside on August 15, 2011, 04:26:24 PM
On my Saltarelle Nuage, which has stops for everything, I can select different reed combinations and I often use just LM on tunes which would be a bit high and squeaky with MM.  I also think it suits French tunes.  On the other hand when I'm going for the full English I'll sometimes use LMM and try (probably unsuccessfully) to pretend it's a one-row.

using LMM with big handfuls of right hand buttons can result the effect of a 6 voice LLMMMM box a lot of the time and even touches of 9 voice now and then but the bellows don't half move fast!

george ;D
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Christopher K. on August 16, 2011, 01:28:47 AM
This is an interesting discussion. I think with typically high pitched melody instruments like pipes or fiddles, the sound of LMM does not work very well. It gets lost or sounds muddy. But I was just listening to Los Texmaniacs and it sounds like David Farias is playing a box with reeds in a LMM configuration, maybe a Corona III N Xtreme? I guess he could be playing just about anything and I've seen him with a few different accordions. The LMM sound really works well with the low pitched stringed instruments in a conjunto - maybe not the best for English or Irish trad but it has its place in other musics.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Martin J on August 16, 2011, 11:12:22 AM
I bought my Dony nearly twenty years ago based on two reeds being easier to play than three.  I love the box and have never once had a regret either playing alone, in sessions or in bands.  In band work, if I wanted a low reed then a BOSS octaviser was foot switchable and worked a treat.  Switched in and out on command minimised over usage.  Careful adjustment got musette and a second little box, a chorus unit, gave a very full sound.  Nowadays I've gone back to being more of a purist and the least said about my using a phaser the better.

I now have several boxes with LMM and even LMMM available which are a delight but no so good in bands unless it is a duo (piano) and acoustic.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 16, 2011, 09:24:14 PM
There are a lot of variables seemingly getting confused at times in this thread!  The human ear also perceives things differently from what we expect.  A sound which is discernable above other sounds may not be the loudest.  Take for example a harpsichord continuo in a chamber orchestra.  It's not a particularly loud instrument, but its bright sound and percussive attack makes a tremendous addition to the overall sound.

OK, the Lilly is quite a loud box with a piercing tone which I believe can be attributed to the small cross section bellows giving high pressure and the flat mounted reeds which seems to give very different harmonics to those mounted on a conventional reedblock - just like a concertina.  The halfway version of this effect is the BPII which can be played very loud (and overblown), I sometimes switch to mine when there are too many other Pokerworks around and I can't hear mine.  It can be made to sing out over the Hohner sound.  My only LMM box is a Castagnari Trilly and I am delighted with the LMM sound, so I rarely play MM - but I'm still told it's quite loud.  I don't think it has quite the punch I would have expected in MM though.

I have a few old Hohner Clubs and the big 2 voice models were tuned to their original sound by Ivor Hyde - less tremolo than a Pokerwork, but a nice round sound.  Being C/F they're also a little more mellow than a D/G.  DTN played one of them at a morris practice and I was surprised how loud it sounded.

The Eb/Bb wooden "Club Modell I" has a wonderfully rounded tone and is still fairly loud.  But the Preciosa - effectively the same configuration as the Lilly, but 2 voice, retuned to D/G by Theo, is piercing and loud for the few seconds before the bellows run out of air!

I have played my mate's Tommy and found it slightly less impressive than the Nik 2 voice when in MM mode.

Rob.
Title: Re: Is LMM a bit indistinct when playing with other instruments
Post by: nemethmik on August 17, 2011, 02:43:29 PM
I love the richness of sound of LMM from a melodeon on its own, but can't help but feel it becomes indistinct, even a bit muddy, when played along with other instruments, especially when compared with the typical clarity of MM. Anybody else feel the same?
Not really, I play mostly with hurdy-gurdies (pitched in G, A or mostly Bb) and I prefer playing LMM (Hohner Club III), since I can hear myself clearly/distinctively.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal