Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: HallelujahAl on April 29, 2011, 05:50:36 PM
-
Hi - been doing a little bit of thinking today :o about the bass layout on the vintage Hohner Double Ray. I've got one with the obsolete bass layout (that is unless you like playing in Bmajor or F#) and so before sending the reedblocks off to our Theo to be retuned into something more useful I've been mucking around looking at the options. What I've come up with is attached - and theoretically would give tune cover in the keys of F, C, G, D, & A (and if the thirds get taken out then other possibilities also present themselves in terms of minor keys). What do you guys think? Having said all that I'm still just minded to go for a straightforward conversion to a modern B/C system layout! Although I can see me getting frustrated with no cover in F.
Anyways - I'd love to get your opinions. I'm not 'set' in any particular way of playing the B/C bass buttons yet so changes made would not affect my learning pattern as it's all pretty new to me. I'd still rather have a stradella unisonoric bass-end ;D
AL
-
Like this one that I recently nabbed on ebay.
-
Hmmm...interesting???
-
Actually I'm not sure what tuning it is till it gets here, but since its coming from Angus, BC is the favourite.
-
Ok - made my choice - and gone for my own preferred option! So blocks sent off to Theo today for adjustment etc...will advise on how it works for me as soon as I get them back. I've decided to stick with my plan to have the keys of F, C, G, D & A available - just can't do without F I'm afraid!
;D
-
Hi Al,
The only suggestion I have to make now you've made up your mind is to swap just one E and a D
so there's a D and an E in both directions. Hope that adds to the confusion!
Nigel
-
Hi Nigel and thanks for your thoughts - bit late now as Theo already has the reedblocks, I see what you're saying but actually think I'll stick with my preferred option. What I've kind of inherently designed is not too much swapping about on the bass rows I hope - keeping an albeit limited G, D, & A on the inside bass row, and C & F on the outer row with the occasional jump over to the inside row for G when playing in C major - hope that makes sense ...anyway...I'm looking forward to getting the reeds back soon from Theo and I'll know then whether I've made a decent decision or not ::)
Looking forward to meeting up with you soon.. doing Inverness in September? Or will it be the Buttonbox & Moothies at Aberdeen? Either way you'll be able to try it for yourself too ;D
AL
-
I'll be at one or both - not sure what,yet. I'm recovering from the Shetland Folk Festival and playing for the second night of a Skerries
wedding at the moment so a bit fragile. Both on the same weekend!!!
Nigel
-
I'll be at one or both - not sure what,yet. I'm recovering from the Shetland Folk Festival and playing for the second night of a Skerries
wedding at the moment so a bit fragile. Both on the same weekend!!!
Nigel
Heh, my memory of the Shetland Folk Festival (went in my Gap Year) is that recovering is the right word :P
-
Heh, my memory of the Shetland Folk Festival (went in my Gap Year) is that recovering is the right word
Fancy coming up to Aberdeen in November?
;D
-
Wish I could but university rules you know ::)
-
university rules you know
Ah yes, I remember them things... ;D