Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Chris Cartwright on April 30, 2011, 06:16:20 PM
-
Hi all
I'm embarking on the adventure of building my first box, and would appreciate some words of wisdom from those who've gone before.
I'm starting with the treble end, and have been building a couple of prototypes.
I want to build a 2.5 row so the various 1-row designs illustrated herein (esp from Rees) with springs in front of the faceplate don't really work, I don't think.
I've been trying a simple construction for the pallet/key mechanism based around an L made of 2 pieces of steel 4mm rod joined at the bend by a brass block, which is also drilled to take an axle rod. The big problem I'm finding with this is that with the small width of block possible at the pivot (around 6mm) there is way to much lateral play which will result in leaking pallets.
This has led me to appreciate the design of traditional Casta-style open keyboards where the key rides in a long, deep slot which minimises both lateral and twist play. I'm currently trying to emulate this by riding the steel rod in a wooden slot. Jury still out on this one. I'm hoping once the spring is fitted this will reduce the play I'm seeing.
Meanwhile I've been trying to understand the trad Casta mechanism properly. I've read everything here and looked at the various close ups available (Lilly). I gather that there is a line of torsion springs sitting under the wooden key levers, held in place by an axle rod. I assume (but don't know) that there must also be another axle rod which passes through each key lever to form the pivot. Is this correct? If so, is it in front of or behind the point where the pallet rod emerges from the key lever? Do all 3 rows sit on a single axle rod in an 11/10/2 type trad design?
Any insights on this stuff would be most most helpful at this stage in the thought process.
Cheers, Chris.
-
A couple of observations . . . I think you'll find 4mm steel rod is overkill and will make for a very heavy action. Phosphor bronze is the more usual material for bushes running on a shaft as in this scenario, but brass will be cheaper / easier for experimenting with and isn't going to wear out very rapidly in this situation. 6mm width is more than ample for making your pivot with little or no lateral play, it sounds as though you've made the hole too big - the bush (pivot) only needs a minimum of running clearance on the shaft. It's more about 'feel' than measurement but say around 1/2 a thou or so at a guess. Ditto endfloat. Just drilling a hole is unlikely to be accurate enough - drilling slightly undersize and then machine reaming to clearance in a lathe or mill if you have access (Or even a good pillar drill) is the way to go to ensure that they all come out identical in size, concentricity, squareness to the axis etc. It's more model engineering than instrument making.
Casta type springs aren't torsion - they're a simple hairspring 'squashed' between the underside of the lever and the bottom of it's slot. The only axle is the one the levers pivot on.
If you hunt through the websites of every box maker you can find there are some very informative and interesting pictures to be found.
Good luck,
Graham
-
It is not just Castagnari who use the type of action you are describing, its used my most Italian makers, and they all(even Castagnari) use the same generic components. You would find it very informative to get hold of an Italian box so that you can examine how it is put together. Unless of course you want to be like Doug Briggs (http://www.briggsaccordions.com/images%20inside%201.html) and make everything in house.
-
Thanks both.
Graham:
I selected steel rod as stiffness seemed to be the most important thing. Ali is obviously much lighter but you need much more thickness to get the stiffness. I calculated that the treble action would only weigh 0.1kg more using 4mm steel over ali. When you say the action will be heavier do you mean the feel (so momentum related) rather than mass? Also any thinner than 4mm has a lot of bend in it. The only way to address this that I can see would be to move to flat bar (but see below).
My Loffet (the only box I have access to close up) uses flat ali bar - similar config to a Hohner - ie bent at a right angle the difficult way at the pivot. Looks like Doug Briggs uses something similar. I can't find a source of this other than buying large extruded angle and cutting slices off it which sounds painful. Hence trying fabricating the right angle out of rod and a bush.
I wondered if I might have made the hole too big as you say (I drilled it 0.1mm oversize), but looking at pics of hohner actions it hardly looks like 1/2 thou precision -a thin bar going through a couple of bent steel pressings - so I assumed there must be something to design out the slop (e.g. having the spring registering the bush against one side of the hole) rather than relying on engineering tolerances.
Thanks for the clearing up the confusion on springs - this came from a melnet article that I must have misinterprested.
Theo:
Many thanks for the Doug Briggs link. I'd not come across him. Very interesting. Certainly looks more like where mine was headed. Am not trying to be different - just want to understand what the key design criteria are and pick from those that have worked.
Both: Any further thoughts on any of this most welcome.
Further question: Do the closed Italian boxes use the same wooden slot design as the open ones, or is it more like a hohner, or somthing completely different?
Thanks, Chris.
-
For the same weight aluminium alloy is stiffer than steel, so if you want a certain stiffness for minimum weight use aluminium, even though steel is stiffer for a given thickness. That is why aircraft are built from alloys of aluminium.
Round or flat - again flat will give you more stiffness for the same cross section area, which is why flat material is used for most levers.
My Loffet (the only box I have access to close up) uses flat ali bar - similar config to a Hohner - ie bent at a right angle the difficult way at the pivot. ...
...Further question: Do the closed Italian boxes use the same wooden slot design as the open ones, or is it more like a hohner, or somthing completely different?
I'm almost certain that Bernard uses the same generic action components as Italian makers. These have a folded brass piece riveted on that forms the pivot. I think these levers are cut out of flat stock, not bent at the pivot.
-
Thanks Theo
I was aware of the stiffness/weight thing. My problem is/was being constrained to round bar rather than flat then the diameter becomes the limiting factor - hence stiffness/dia rather than stiffness/weight.
I hadn't considered the option of cutting the L shapes out of flat stock. That makes sense. It would be very painful to do 'at home' in steel plate but perhaps not so bad in ali on a bandsaw. I'll do some tests.
Brass riveted collets I can do - I'm a clockmaker.
Cheers, Chris.
-
Hello again
On Your suggestion, I have scoured all the makers sites I can find for pictures including
- Loffet
- Gaillard
- Serafini
- Van DerAA
- Bergflodt
- Luukinen
- Gaubert
- Pariselle (2.5 row making course photos)
Whilst there's lots of good stuff, on none of these can I find a picture of the pivot part of the treble mechanism (where the aluminium rods hinge on the axle) on an Italian style covered fingerboard box (ie aluminium levers rather than wood). This is typically because it is hidden under the front part of the fingerboard. There are pics of the hohner style mechanism (most notably on Bernard Loffet's site), but no Italian ones.
Does anyone have a pic of this part they could send me? Or even a detailed description of how it's set up.
Does someone like Carini sell these parts (they don't list them on their site)? From the similarlities it looks like several makers are using a bought-in mechanism and adapting it.
Thanks, Chris.
-
Does someone like Carini sell these parts (they don't list them on their site)?
Yes, they have far more than is shown on their website
From the similarlities it looks like several makers are using a bought-in mechanism and adapting it.
Yes, as I've already said.
There are several pictures that should help in this facebook album (https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.50177028166.61330.709188166&l=c221326df9) of mine. This is a public link so you should be able to browse all the photos. The last four images in the album are all of the treble mechanism and you can see the axle rod, and the levers.
-
Thanks Theo - sorry for being dense.
I'll email Carini and see what I can get from them.
Thank you for the photos - they are certainly helpful, though frustratingly just short of having enough resolution for me to really see what is going on at the pivot.
Don't suppose you happen to have a higher res version of this one kicking around that I could trouble you for?
Thanks, Chris.
-
This is one that I took a while ago.
(http://i376.photobucket.com/albums/oo201/ukebert/IMG_2415.jpg)
http://i376.photobucket.com/albums/oo201/ukebert/IMG_2415.jpg
-
Thank you very much ukebert - that's a lot clearer!
This raises another question. Quite a few of these boxes use the mechanism here with the inner row of pallets hinged at the top.
But my Loffet along with many others hinges them all at the bottom, which seems more straightforward.
Is there any particular merit in doing it one way or the other that you're aware of?
Cheers, Chris.
-
It enables you to have a row of pallets (and therefore reedblocks) much closer to the keyboard where the geometry would not allow a simple lever to work. As a result you can either design a more compact box, or you can get more reedblocks in for a given size of box. The downside is that the pallets nearest the keyboard can actually end up partly 'under' the keyboard and the sound from this row can be masked.
-
Perfect. I see. Many thanks Theo.
-
Hi all
Having studied the picture ukebert kindly posted in higher resolution, I have to say I'm still puzzled why this construction works well. It is in fact very similar to the Hohner construction with each lever pivoted via a pair if thin pieces of (probably) brass, riveted to the lever, which the axle passes through. In fact in this version these two pieces are even closer together than the hohner, at around 4mm rather than 6mm according to my measurements.
As I observed before, these hardly look as if they're made to the kind of 0.01mm engineering tolerances that Graham was discussing earlier, So I would expect quite a bit of lateral play given the short bearing surface (4mm). My hypothesis is that the spring action removes this play by holding the lever holes against the axle. However thinking about the geometry I can see how this would work to take out side to side play (ie the pallet moving left and right across the sound hole) but not the more critical rotational play (pallet lifting its left or right hand edge off the 'fondo'). Is this a known problem with this design? It looks like the fit of the spacers between the levers may be critical in addressing this.
Thoughts / observations welcomed.
Thanks, Chris.
-
As I observed before, these hardly look as if they're made to the kind of 0.01mm engineering tolerances that Graham was discussing earlier,
Precisely, they're made slightly undersized.
-
Sorry - I don't understand Andy. If they're undersized they wouldn't move on the axle. That's called an interference fit.
Chris.
-
Which is why you need to fit them properly to the axle yourself...
-
Oh I think I unerstand what you're saying now.
They are supplied from Carini (or whoever) with undersized holes which you ream to fit the axle. Did I get it?
Thanks, Chris.
-
Yes, more or less exactly as Graham said in the first reply.
-
Here is a dimensioned pic of the Carini lever, showing 6.1 mm across the outer width of the bearing .
http://www.flickr.com/photos/graham-w/5689314737/
As an aside, does anyone know what action Gaillard uses, because that is truly sublimely smooth, light and fast?
-
That's brilliant. Thank you both very much!
I think the secret is that reaming holes just right by feel in two thin strips like this is a very different operation to reaming a 6mm bush to within 0.01mm. The first is something I'd do by hand with a tapered 5 sided hand broach (clockmaking technology) - the latter with a lathe and machine reamer (engineering technology).
Now I feel equipped to do battle with the metal again - off to the workshop.
Thanks again.
Chris.
-
The way Emmanuel Pariselle reams the holes is using a short length of axle rod in the chuck of a hand held electric grinder! It works, but might be a method that would offend a clockmaker!
-
Ah - the secrets of the melodeon makers course - if only I could have got a place. <sigh>
I'm trying to go it alone as a consequence of having missed out for July. Hence all the stupid questions!
In fact the technique you describe probably works well as it will serve to work harden the inside of the hole into the bargain. Normally for clock bushes you use the aforementioned broach, then finish off with a smooth broach with a slightly roughened surface to harden the brass. Not so different really.
Cheers, Chris.
-
Which reminds me I think (not quite sure) that he roughened the surface of the rod before using it to ream the holes.
And the same method is effective for reaming the axle holes in wooden levers if you go for that type of construction.
-
Cool - I was wondering about that. Thanks again!
-
Wood levers is the only ones I have experience with, and I use 3/32" (2.3813mm) stainless steel axle, then a #41 drill bit (2.4384mm) for the axle hole in the lever. This may not work well for metal to metal, but for wood, it seems to allow good movement without slop, and so far I haven't had problems with humidity.
Theo thanks for the FB photo story. I liked the enlarged stop rod fix, superglue is a versatile substance besides for sticking my fingers together.
-
Thank blafleur
That's quite a bit more clearance than I was expecting. I am finding 0.03mm excessive on a 6mm brass collet. As you say I expect the wood expands after the hole is drilled. Also on a 1 row box your lever is probably nearer 20mm wide?
Cheers, Chris.
-
Hi Chris,
Any progress on the keyboard and mechanism? I'm about to start work on my own keyboard and am hoping you can tell us how you did. Photos of the finished keyboard would be wonderful.
Thanks,
Ed
-
Hello again
On Your suggestion, I have scoured all the makers sites I can find for pictures including
- Loffet
- Gaillard
- Serafini
- Van DerAA
- Bergflodt
- Luukinen
- Gaubert
- Pariselle (2.5 row making course photos)
Whilst there's lots of good stuff, on none of these can I find a picture of the pivot part of the treble mechanism (where the aluminium rods hinge on the axle) on an Italian style covered fingerboard box (ie aluminium levers rather than wood). This is typically because it is hidden under the front part of the fingerboard. There are pics of the hohner style mechanism (most notably on Bernard Loffet's site), but no Italian ones.
Does anyone have a pic of this part they could send me? Or even a detailed description of how it's set up.
Does someone like Carini sell these parts (they don't list them on their site)? From the similarlities it looks like several makers are using a bought-in mechanism and adapting it.
Thanks, Chris.
Carini does sell these parts, and the leavers come in 3 different sizes, and they come with the brass plate bush already riveted to them you can then buy the mounting plates rods and spacers needed. But when I ordered them to get my order right I had to send photos with exact details to what i wanted. I was even able to get the leavers without bushes so they could be mounted the way that i wanted them. Someone told me that you should ask Carini for Galman rods as they have the finest tolerances.
Peter
-
Carini will also provide the necessary broaches, they are as necessary as they are expensive. When using the very common 3mm rod (which in fact can be anything from 2.96 to 3.00, most often 2.98) you'd need the 2.97 and 2.98 broach. But bear in mind, that even when using broaches you will still have to use a specially adapted rod for the final touch. The task is quite delicate, actually. The brass, or whatever alloy the bushes are made from, sticks easily to the steel rod and must be removed continuously with very fine sandpaper or steel wool. As to using grease or oil while doing this, opinions differ. I only start using grease during the final assembly.
-
What is a broach? ???
-
What is a broach? ???
I have to be very careful describing this to an engineering under-grad :o As I understand it broaching is the process of drilling to slightly undersize, applying heat and forcing a hardened piece of steel machined to very close tolerances to create a very tight fit. There again there are devices called 'broaching drills' that are best described as magnetically attached milling machines that bore precise holes in steel plate.
-
What is a broach? ???
I have to be very careful describing this to an engineering under-grad :o As I understand it broaching is the process of drilling to slightly undersize, applying heat and forcing a hardened piece of steel machined to very close tolerances to create a very tight fit. There again there are devices called 'broaching drills' that are best described as magnetically attached milling machines that bore precise holes in steel plate.
I think this link might help with the tools.
http://www.hoj.com.au/images/catalogue/983dfbf27e2a9569bf3d1a578503168c.jpg
-
What is a broach? ???
I have to be very careful describing this to an engineering under-grad :o As I understand it broaching is the process of drilling to slightly undersize, applying heat and forcing a hardened piece of steel machined to very close tolerances to create a very tight fit. There again there are devices called 'broaching drills' that are best described as magnetically attached milling machines that bore precise holes in steel plate.
Ah, thank you (:) And no need to be careful, a normal Engineering student might know that, but I go to Cambridge, where we aren't taught things of that ilk :P
-
a normal Engineering student might know that, but I go to Cambridge, where we aren't taught things of that ilk :P
An acquaintance of mine who was a natural sciences (including physics) graduate from Trinity Hall used to delight in calling himself a "quantum mechanic".
-
Ah, those were the days - visiting my brother at Trinity! The bar staff would clear the tables immediately before calling time so that there was plenty of room to set up a few rounds. "Last one out drop the latch, guys!"
Rob.