Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Folkiekay on July 14, 2008, 03:18:09 PM
-
Good morning,
I was listening to Yann-Fanch Perroches's new CD on the way to work - and Scottish du Regret came on, and I immediately got a big smile on my face thinking back almost 10 years ago to when I was a beginner and just learning. To me it was easier to learn with tablature. It is still a very simple way to learn, and I can't say I don't do it occasionally, because I do. I can take a piece of tablature and play a tune immediately - say within 5 minutes - reasonably well. At least to a point. I play it how I think it should sound from what I see on the page of tablature music - without ever hearing the tune. I know sometimes that is what we have and that's all we have and it's a way to learn the tune.
I learned Scottish du Regret when I was a beginner with tablature. It's a great tune, and it's a lot of fun to play, and it is fabulous street music as it makes people dance - it grabs them inside and they have to move. There is a version of it on the Street Squeeze website - with Pete and me playing it the way we play it on the street. Well..... a year ago Yann-Fanch sent me his version of Scottish du Regret, and I know the look on my face when I first heard the tune had to be one of shock and awe. First off - his tune my way was totally different from his tune his way. They way he is plays it is nothing short of amazing. I could hardly sit still in my car to drive to work - I wanted to dance! I needed to move. There is no way that someone hearing both tunes back to back would even know they were the same tune.
Years ago I handed Yann-Fanch my minidisc recorder - to listen to his tune played in a blues style by Pete and me, and he listened and smiled. He said he'd never heard it played that slow before. That was probably kind. Just like when I was a beginner - say 6 months into it - and sent Yann-Fanch a tape of me playing lots of Breton tunes, and I excitedly waited to hear from him, and when I did, he said to me, "well, it's obvious you are learning without a teacher". I was so proud to think he thought I could do just fine on my own. When I met him in person, I figured out that wasn't what he meant at all - he didn't think I was playing just fine. He suggested even when I was a beginner that I play by ear.
It took awhile to learn to play by ear, but mostly that's what I do now - though sometimes if I do get a piece of tablature, I will use it to learn quickly. Lately I've mostly been playing my own tunes, and I always figure with those, there is no right or wrong way to play them since I composed them myself.
I listened to Scottish du Regret all the way to work - over and over with my repeat button, and I know I was smiling for 45 minutes......at least till I got to my desk. Still thinking about it so thought I'd write and see if anyone else has had the same thing happen - where you played a tune for so long it seemed right, but then you finally heard it played the way it is supposed to be played.
What is a shame is that I don't think I can ever get that tune right. It's in my head the wrong way, the tablature way - and I feel quite sure I will always play it wrong - my way. Once I get a tune down, I have found that I can't really change it up. It's just a failing that I have.
What thoughts do the rest of you have about learning to play from music notation or tablature versus learning to play by ear? The tunes I learn to play by ear, I never write them down into tab. I should, but so far I have not ever done that. I normally make recordings of the stuff I play, so if I lose a tune (forget it), then I have to go back and listen to myself play it in order to get it back the same way. I find that happening more and more as I age, and as I forget to play tunes for a long time.
I hope everyone is having an excellent Monday!
Bye,
Kay
-
For guitar, mandolin, mandola, bass or melodeon (melodeon is not my first instrument by any stretch of the imagination) I tend to learn tunes by ear - quite often in sessions - by fixing the tune in my mind and then mentally playing it over and over until I can figure out how to physically play it. I can sight read (though not for melodeon at the moment). Many of the Ceilidh musicians I play with read only - even at gigs - and I find their lack of flexibility with the feel of the music to be obstructive. When I have learnt from dots, the tune tends to come out differently to how it is normally played. I suspect the dots are a starting point for discussion with most musicians.
-
I'm only a beginner on the Melodeon although I've played guitar (and sung along) for a lot of years. My learning will almost always start from me hearing a tune or song and thinking 'I would like to play that'. I've never been able to work out by ear how to play a tune (except for a very simple three chord accompaniment to a song) so I always go looking for a written version. In my early guitar playing days this would usually be a published song book. Now, I look for the ABC and use ABC Edit to print the dots (after transposing if necessary). Then I work out how to play the notes on the box. Then I practice till it sounds as much like the original as I want.
An alternative - which I've used on both instruments - is to get someone else to show me how to play the tune. Even then, I have to "know" what it is I'm trying to play.
My wife has a different approach - she plays flute and learns almost exclusively from the dots. There was a post a while ago in the recordings and videos forum (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=374.0 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=374.0)) of the prelude from Bach's first Cello suite which inspired my to find the music (and to buy three different CDs of the piece, one on Cello, one on Double bass and one on French Horn but that's another story). I can now just about play the first four bars - this is a long term project. Whereas my wife - who approached it only from the dots - can play vurtually the whole piece but it doesn't (in my humble opinion) sound anything like.
So for me, the dots - or tablature if I can find it - can be the means whereby I learn how to play the tune, but I need to know - by ear - what I'm trying to play.
I hope that makes some kind of sense :)
Cheers
Pete
-
So for me, the dots - or tablature if I can find it - can be the means whereby I learn how to play the tune, but I need to know - by ear - what I'm trying to play.
That is exactly where I am except I use ABC not tab or dots. If the tune isn't firmly fixed in my head before I start to learn it I stand no chance. Mind you as years pass I get better at just ear playing but it never seems to fix it in my brain :(
-
It works for me, by hearing a tune in a session, and can often play it (a bit) by the end of the 3 times. However i won't remember it, so i then make sure I find out what its called, then IF I remember back at home (and that, I suspect, depends on the tune, and/or how many times I've intended to pursue it) I search the internet for it (and/or my collection of music books), then "remind" myself of it from the dots. If continue to remind myself of it regularly for a few days to a few weeks, it sometime becomes part of my repertoire. It helps if i link it in a sequence to a tune i already know, and get used to going from one to the next. I can play from the dots on a recorder much better than on a melodeon, sometimes i can even sing or whistle it from the notes! That also can help.
-
I find it harder to remember the names of the tunes than the tunes themself.
-
Everyone's comments are sure interesting, and I find it easier to remember tunes than tune names too. I especially have problems remembering tune names in other languages.
I suppose the best way to go about it is using all different formats - notation or tablature, listening to the tune, and grabbing bits of it by ear.
I have one tune that I've worked on for 3 years and cannot get. It is one that Jarle Fjeldheim played 3 years ago - and it was a great tune and obviously a lot of fun for him to play, and I wrote it down in tablature so that I wouldn't forget it. When I listen to him playing it though - I can't get my accordion to do what his does. I know it's not the accordion - it's my brain and my hands, but I am afraid I will never get it no matter how much I try. Maybe I'm not supposed to play some tunes..<smile> I can play it my way - but then when I listen to him playing it, I am always amazed and I know I'm just not getting it.
Oh I wish I didn't have to have a day job and could play all day long everyday.
Kay
-
hah !!! how dare you pinch my wish!!!! ;D
I too find that bits of all sorts works well, a bit of dots, a bit of listening others play that tune, a bit of having once "learnt" the tune then working with it till I play it "my way"
emmm.... what does tablature actually mean??? I understand dots, and ABC, but tablature??? I thought that was guitar chords marked underneath the dots????? so please could someone tell me how you learn a tune from tablature????
Lin ::) ::)
-
hah !!! how dare you pinch my wish!!!! ;D
I too find that bits of all sorts works well, a bit of dots, a bit of listening others play that tune, a bit of having once "learnt" the tune then working with it till I play it "my way"
emmm.... what does tablature actually mean??? I understand dots, and ABC, but tablature??? I thought that was guitar chords marked underneath the dots????? so please could someone tell me how you learn a tune from tablature????
Lin ::) ::)
? little signs ( arrows dots or whatever) that tell you which button to press & which way to move bellows. similarly some whistle books have little whiste over each note with holes whereon ones fingers should be & white ones where they shouldn't - or perhaps the other way round. Good for getting people up & running quickly but give no indication of note length or timing.
george
-
so please could someone tell me how you learn a tune from tablature????
You can't with most of the melodeon tab I've seen, because you get the dots as well. If you've got the dots-to-fingers-without-touching-the-sides algorhythm already in your head, you can only ignore the dots with great difficulty. The German Griffschrift system looks like dots, until you notice there's no treble clef, but the notes correspond to buttons on the box, and there's an underline to tell you whether to push or pull. You could learn a tune from that, but I wouldn't like to try.
-
hah !!! how dare you pinch my wish!!!! ;D
I too find that bits of all sorts works well, a bit of dots, a bit of listening others play that tune, a bit of having once "learnt" the tune then working with it till I play it "my way"
emmm.... what does tablature actually mean??? I understand dots, and ABC, but tablature??? I thought that was guitar chords marked underneath the dots????? so please could someone tell me how you learn a tune from tablature????
I don't think you can. The tablature, like dots or ABC will help you work out how to play a tune, but if you don't have some idea of what you are trying to play then nothing can help you :)
Regards
Pete
-
Ok thanks - so I misunderstood Folkiekay when she said she wrote a tune out in tablature so she wouldnt forget it - she didnt mean she would learn it from tablature. my mistake, but then I am still only learning this stuff. ;D
ta muchly
Lin
-
.... emmm.... what does tablature actually mean??? I understand dots, and ABC, but tablature??? I thought that was guitar chords marked underneath the dots????? so please could someone tell me how you learn a tune from tablature????
Lin ::) ::)
Lin,
Here's an example of tablature from Bernard Loffet's website. I've chosen a simple tune so you should be able to recognise the tune from the dots and see the tablature below. NB: this is written out for a G/C melodeon, so although you can play it on a D/G from tablature, the notes will sound a 5th higher (i.e. the first bar will be D E F-sharp D, not G A B G)
http://diato.org/tablat/tab212.gif
How to read the tablature:
The buttons are numbered from the chin end 1, 2, 3, 4, etc... on the outside row, and 1' 2' 3' 4' etc .... on the inside row. P (poussé) =push the bellows, T (tiré)=pull the bellows.
Or, see here:
http://diato.org/exptab2.htm
There are other tablature systems, but this is enough to be going on with :)
-
Y'all got it right - I write it out in tablature - which is just button number and push or pull - so I'll have it down for me...... and I've learned plenty a tune that a way. It is sort of like those old paint by number kits....only you play by number. Very simple - and I can play a tune immediately. I never noticed the notation above the tablature - so I never learned what the notes are on my boxes.
For tunes I learned with tab only - well, they are way off the beaten track for sure. I play them the way I think they should be - without ever knowing really how they should sound. I think it's great for a beginner to learn a few tunes that way and get a feeling of accomplishment quickly. I've learned though -that playing by ear is a much better way to go - and never see any tablature or notation - just figure it out from what is heard. All the tunes I've learned that way really do sound the best of the ones I play that belong to other people. If I hear it - and use tablature - it's easier to learn, but it doesn't stick in my head the way the ones do that I totally learn by ear.
Does anyone else find that to be true? That learning a tune by ear makes it stay in the brain better?
Kay
-
Unless you have staff notation written above, how do you determine the note durations?
-
Hi FolkieKay
It all depends on so many variables including where you hear a tune, under what circumstances, and how often.
When I first started to learn to play melodeon 6 years ago now at the age of 50, I had no previous personal experience of playing an instrument or of reading music :'(. I also had no outside contact with anyone playing the music I wanted to learn except through Mallys or other such books. So there was absolutely no way I could learn any tunes from others live performances. At that stage and for a long time afterwards I needed the dots and recordings to both see and hear the tune continuously in order to absorb a tune :o.
Fortunately I discovered sessions in my area, and so began the huge learning curve of learning to listen and pick up the tune, so that nowadays, I can pick up a tune in a session so that by the end of the tune I am just getting it, but there is no way I will remember that tune once I have left the session, unless I can find it on cd at home :(. With me its all down to repetition.
If one is lucky enough to grow up , say in a village, or small community, where tunes are played continuously, then I would assume that you would grow up simply absorbing them by listening at Grandma's knee, so to speak.
This is all coming out a bit garbled and I expect tomes have been written on the subject, but what Im trying to get at is, that in my opinion, it all depends on your circumstances. ???
happy playing ;D
Lin
-
Does anyone else find that to be true? That learning a tune by ear makes it stay in the brain better?
Kay
definately ! I think its something to do with automaatic psychological functioning of the brain. If you learn a tune from the dots the internal workings of the mind says to itself something on the lines of - 'I don't need to remember that lot cos I can get the piece of paper out again!' whereas tunes learned by ear are of necessity filed away in the long term memory for future retrieval.
If learning a tune from the dots or any other written aid I go through once anad then look away from the print and see how far I can get from memory, if necessary missing out bits I can't remember & sort of pressing on regardless. Then go back to the printed version & fill in a gap or two & have a go right through warts & all from memory repeating the opperation untill I can play it all from memory.
george
-
I basically had the same experience as Lin Erica (except that I played piano and violin)..... having to learn on my own without seeing live people play - and having tablature books, and then using tunes that I would hear on CDs. I used to record a tune over and over - on casettes - and listen in the car to and from work - sometimes one tune for weeks at a time. 50 hours of listening to one tune even. I was relentless. Then I would be able to sit down and play the tune without listening anymore. Now, thankfully, it doesn't take as long. Sometimes just an hour or two of the same tune - before I can play it.
As to getting the note length correct when only using tablature and not using music notation - well...I just winged it. I did the best I could - and made it sound how I thought it should sound - hence my screwed up tunes that I still play to this day, but they sound good to my ears, and they sound great to the people on the streets when I play. People dance and throw money in the box even to wrongly played tunes - as they get played with feeling and emotion, and that's the main thing, even if they are not right and never will be.
I have learned that no matter how badly I play a tune - if I smile and put some feeling into it, people here in Texas really don't care. Nobody has ever told me I played a tune wrong. Sometimes they will say, "that sort of sounds like.......", and I say, "yes - it's supposed to sort of sound like that"...<smile>
Fortunately I have never been a perfectionist in anything!!
Kay
-
:'( My trouble is not so much that I can't learn by ear (I can now, even though slowly) but that I can never associate tunes with their names. Consequently, I may know a tune, but I don't know that I know it (if you know what I mean!) :-[
Chris-the-confused
-
When I were a lad we had no tape recorders ( I did get one in 1962 but it got beer poured into it by accident!) I found that words and tunes came back after one hearing, it took about 3 days to recapture the words whereas tunes were more or less fixed but came back in bursts, often just before waking up, then it was a matter of whistling or diddling(lilting) as I walked to school or work to get the 'turns'
Of corse when I heard them again there were variations from what I rembered but that's the folk process and explains evolution in music locally and regionally
I also believe that there was a more restricted repertoire and now we have to learn a lot more tunes to play in sessions with new folks.
I was scared off dots by a sadistic music teacher so relied on my ear, now I do find ABc useful, I had evolved a similar method for the whistle and use it as an aide memoire , just the first few notes in a bar can bring back the whole tune and as you play more and practice muscle memory helps to consign it to long term memory
Do other people find that mood dependent learning takes place, eg if you learnt it in a pub it's easier to remember in the same context and with the same amount of whatever you were on in your system? That in itself is a fascinating subject
-
When I were a lad we had no tape recorders ( I did get one in 1962 but it got beer poured into it by accident!) I found that words and tunes came back after one hearing, it took about 3 days to recapture the words whereas tunes were more or less fixed but came back in bursts, often just before waking up, then it was a matter of whistling or diddling(lilting) as I walked to school or work to get the 'turns'
Of corse when I heard them again there were variations from what I rembered but that's the folk process and explains evolution in music locally and regionally
I also believe that there was a more restricted repertoire and now we have to learn a lot more tunes to play in sessions with new folks.
I was scared off dots by a sadistic music teacher so relied on my ear, now I do find ABc useful, I had evolved a similar method for the whistle and use it as an aide memoire , just the first few notes in a bar can bring back the whole tune and as you play more and practice muscle memory helps to consign it to long term memory
Do other people find that mood dependent learning takes place, eg if you learnt it in a pub it's easier to remember in the same context and with the same amount of whatever you were on in your system? That in itself is a fascinating subject
if you don't know the name of a tune (& many have more than one anyway) it can help to make one up just for your own convenience just as many morris bands/musicians refer to tunes using the name of the dance rather than the tunes proper name. I learned John of Paris as Gisburn Processional etc etc. a way of remembering tunes that don't also have a song version is to make up some words to fit the tune - they can be daft, rude or whatever.Years ago I had difficulty for some reason remembering the durham rangers so made up a bawdy set of words to fit it - now I still 'think' those words everytime I play it. :o
george
-
Dark Girl Dressed in Blue is still, to me ' the girl with no knickers on, or something like that' ... as thats what the guy who taught it to me called it at the time! Thats pretty memorable!
-
I have just thought about Morris tunes. Eg 'Lads a Bunchum' must have been ' Laudenum Bunches' taught by an inebriated fiddler to another from about 7 miles away, who never met again or if they did didn't recognise each other or didn't care.
I have so many tunes exchanged in noisy boozers eg Sligo Fancy = Lass on the Strand ( see Bronwyn Power from Ennis Co Clare) from Sally in Fagan's back room in Sheffield = Psycho Frenzy, I could go on for days, Guess these
Varnish me Foreskin
The Flying Toad
Garlic Revival
And that doesn't include
I'll Ask me Dad
Phone me Tommora
The One we played after the one we did Before That One ( in A minor or whatever)
Read last Night's Fun by Ciaran Carson for more on thisl
Where do these come from?
Upstairs in a Tent
The Floating Crowbar
Confused , Sheffield
-
Just an afterthought
What about the power of Osmosis?
Tunes that just dive into your soul and folk memory without any conscious process, they just go there?
They're the ones that stay for life and constantly refresh themselves and come back when you wake up
Give us a list and we can make them the 'Session from Heaven'What kicks it off
How many make a night to remember?
-
I believe the title of 'The Floating Crowbar' commemorates a large crane mounted on a barge.
One of my favourite tune title (though I can't play the tune) is a Scottish tune in memory of a place returned to after an absence is 'Return to Kasmagiro' - try saying it out loud to get the twist!
-
I believe the title of 'The Floating Crowbar' commemorates a large crane mounted on a barge.
The origin I have heard is that the crowbar was a bloodstained murder weapon that was disposed of in a river, but which refused to sink or rose to the surface, proving the perpetrator's guilt. From an Irish fairy story, or true story, who knows. The tune is a composition of the great northern fiddler Brendan McGlinchey. Great tune for a D box.
-
Being someone who has always sat uneasily between being a classical musician and a traditional one, I find the dots too easy. After 30 years of choral singing I can look at most tunes and hear them in my head straight off, but its hearing a tune played that makes mewant to learn it. Learning by ear from another player is also the only way to absorb the nuances of style in traditional music.
I've always written down tunes I've learned by ear, an insurance policy against memory loss. The other day I came across my old tune book of 25 years ago when I played whistle, mandolin and guitar in a remarkable sucessful dance band ( remarkably because we never practiced, never arranged anything and turned up to gigs, including teatotal methodist weddings, blind drunk). Leafing through my old book set me thinking how important manuscript collections of tunes have been in preserving a lot of dance music in Britain. There are so many old manuscripts full of really good tunes that would have been lost if they hadn't been written down.
Mind you if a future musicologist were to "find" my old tune book, s/he would get a laugh at my attempts to notate Jenny Lind. It was only years later when I got affluent enought to buy tune books I realised it changed from D to G for the second part.......... Now I play it in Harry Cox version which doesn't change key................
-
Guys like you are important parts of the tradition. In Ireland lot of tunes were taken from O'Neill's 'Book' by sight readers and passed on to local ear players . Before the 78s of Coleman etc from the States these helped to keep the music alive
I liken collections to buckets of water taken from a river. They need to be poured back to maintain the flow but can be put on ice for a bit!
I collect tune books but like it best when they have a CD or cassette too.
Niall Vallely's CDROM tutor for Anglo Concertina is a superb teaching aid
I've just bought the Great Northern Tune Book reissue, I got it from EFDSS.
I have great difficulty reading but can transfer to ABC and then work it out slowly, I do quite envy those who can read and hear tunes that way but wouldn't swop it for my ear.
I used to ask one of my my sons to play from my books on piano or recorder so I could get the tunes but it was in danger of turning him against traditional music! But when he came to festivals or Morris do's he picked them up by ear and loved them,although he then became a techno boy!
-
I cannot claim to read music, exactly although I understand the theory. When I get sheet music I can't get my head around, I put the dots into "Mozart" and play the midi it generates. So I end up with a tune to learn by ear with the dots to remind me. Not quite so successful is the use of scanning recognition software to reduce the acquired dots to digital format! Any suggestions?
-
I cannot claim to read music, exactly although I understand the theory. When I get sheet music I can't get my head around, I put the dots into "Mozart" and play the midi it generates. So I end up with a tune to learn by ear with the dots to remind me. Not quite so successful is the use of scanning recognition software to reduce the acquired dots to digital format! Any suggestions?
I can think of one. I mean, what would you say to an intelligent adult who said, "I can't read (i.e. words) very well. When I come across a book with a complicated passage, I scan the page and have speech-recognition software read it back to me. But it doesn't work perfectly. Any suggestions?"
-
O.K. Mea culpa! Lazy as charged!
Sometimes there are better things to do than struggle with the rythmic implications of the written tune and a quick midi can have you playing it in the pub that same night. I hope my young lady would agree there are better things to do in life (and she sight reads at grade 8!).
Rob ;D
-
Now I know this is odd.......
Not being playing long etc.. only been going to sessions for a few months, recently joined morris side.....
But, my problem is that in a session I recognise the tunes but then can't for the life of me play them until someone tells me the title! ???
So, they're all playing along and I'm shouting "What's it called?" and they're shouting back "Dunno", until someone kindly whispers the name.
Strange or what? It's almost as if I need to know the title for the brain to retrieve the appropriate file and then I can almost 'see' a form of tablature in my head.
As for picking up a tune in a session - absolutely no chance, but I use a little digital recorder and can then usually pick it up at home, but prefer to download the ABC or find the dots in a book.
-
But, my problem is that in a session I recognise the tunes but then can't for the life of me play them until someone tells me the title! ???
This I totally understand - I have exactly the same problem. Somehow the tune is linked to the title, even if most of the time I can't remember the title ::) But I don't then see the notes, but the fingering comes back properly. Very odd.
-
I've got the opposite problem. Many years ago I played several sessions with different groups of people - mainly guitar or mandolin. I quickly learnt that in Irish, at least, there were only a few underlying structures to all the tunes. When I started driving to sessions (having children meant I was no longer driven by long suffering wife) I realised there were more names than tunes. I've never been good with names, but can recognise a tune within a couple of bars at worst. I started doing pick up gigs with reading bands - and found the names at the top of the tunes about the most useless part. I'v done pick up gigs (on bass) where the leader has said - 5 minute before the start - do you know x, y, z - blank look - you know diddly, diddly... - yeah - what key? (blank look from leader) - and played the set with no issues.
The bottom line is - people remember different cues! There are, | think 4 tunes called the Butterfly, in 3 different keys and three different times.
I want to sit in the session (as audience) where someone calls "The Butterfly" - and all 4 start start at the same time!