Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Noodle on May 05, 2011, 08:48:20 PM

Title: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Noodle on May 05, 2011, 08:48:20 PM
There I was, casually minding my own business at Rochester Sweeps, perusing the music stalls and trying the odd box. I already own a older B/C Hohner Double Ray so I wasn't really on the lookout to buy anything. I came across this wooden box and enquired about it. I knew the model and I knew it had been modified, but I wasn't expecting it to be a 3 voice. As soon as I took the first squeeze, I got that knotty feeling in my stomach and it was instant love. Today I took delivery of a Oakwood-modified Dino Baffetti Binci III as MADness continues to wreak havoc with the finances.

Who'd have thought I'd fall for a wood-finished box in D/G? The sound it makes is just fantastic. Loud and quite savage in its tone. Now I just have to learn how to play it.

I thought I'd share this tale with you as I couldn't contain my excitement any more
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Chris Ryall on May 06, 2011, 07:32:15 AM
As soon as I took the first squeeze, I got that knotty feeling in my stomach and it was instant love.

I'm transported back to Whitby 1984 - touched my first Castagnari - "I want one"- (wifey and babe in arms begin to weep softly)...
Quote
Today I took delivery of a Oakwood-modified Dino Baffetti Binci III as MADness continues to wreak havoc with the finances.
For some reason these things always seem to cost you about a months salary. It was true when I was 20 looking avariciously at concertinas. Remains true in decently remunerated grey middle age  ???
Quote
Who'd have thought I'd fall for a wood-finished box in D/G? The sound it makes is just fantastic. Loud and quite savage in its tone.

Hmmm .. one is reminded of a couple of characters here  >:E
Quote
Now I just have to learn how to play it.

Ah, there's the rub. If that's where you are going I wouldn't start with "I own a B/C Hohner"  ;)  But we all remember that sense of joy. Savour it all year if you can! Congrats.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Rob2Hook on May 06, 2011, 04:48:14 PM
Congratulations.  I was very good and took my belt and jacket off before I played it...  Nice action and bright tone.  You should have a really good time getting to know it.

They say there are certain trials in life which can lead to divorce - Moving house and redundancy among them.  Could impulse buying a melodeon belong to that list?

Rob.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Quebecois on May 06, 2011, 05:30:06 PM
Yes. D/G is unavoidable... resistance is futile... you will be assimilated...
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Guy on May 06, 2011, 11:55:21 PM

They say there are certain trials in life which can lead to divorce - Moving house and redundancy among them.  Could impulse buying a melodeon belong to that list?

Rob.

Rob, there's no such thing as impulse buying a melodeon. There's only buying a melodeon you really really need....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Alan Morley on May 07, 2011, 07:44:28 AM
Noodle - nice one. That would have been my choice of a next box, if I didn't already have two D/G already.

Enjoy

Almo
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: pipives on May 07, 2011, 10:31:02 AM
I was there too, and although working for a different retailer of said musical instrument of choice, it was my first play on the 3 voice baffetti-binci as well. What a box, and a good choice too.

I thought it was a really good weekend all round to.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Gary on May 07, 2011, 12:22:34 PM
Reminds me of a narrow escape at Whitby while trying out boxes on Theos display spot. That dry tuned box was so sweet sounding . Just as well that I resisted, 5 months later the tax man hit me with a huge bill and the box would have been sold on .
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Noodle on May 07, 2011, 10:34:49 PM
I'm starting to get used to the difference in the push-pull department. I've noticed a number of times I've been automatically playing in patterns I've been playing on my B/C and it all sounding horribly, horribly wrong. I don't think it'll take me too long to get used to it, and I'm relatively comfortable with a couple of tunes. Atholl Highlanders, for example is so, so much easier to play now. I'm still extremely happy with what I've got and I don't intend to let this one go any time in the near or distant future.

I was there too, and although working for a different retailer of said musical instrument of choice, it was my first play on the 3 voice baffetti-binci as well. What a box, and a good choice too.

I thought it was a really good weekend all round to.
I do remember talking to you about the Saltarelle and the ceilidh the previous night. I was in my border morris kit. It's just as well that I made the decision to go for the Baffetti as when I returned to your stall, the Saltarelle had been sold.

Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Theo on May 07, 2011, 11:09:05 PM
Atholl Highlanders, for example is so, so much easier to play now.


Playing it in the 'proper' key of A major I hope!
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Noodle on May 08, 2011, 12:55:43 AM
I have tried a few times, but with disastrous results. G is all I've been able to manage so far
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Lester on May 08, 2011, 09:36:43 AM
Atholl Highlanders, for example is so, so much easier to play now.


Playing it in the 'proper' key of A major I hope!

So decided to take on this in A. Question, is it normally played as a 2 part or a 4 part tune as it exists as both out in t'internet?
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2011, 09:59:57 AM
Round here it is always played as a 4 part tune, in A.

If you play it in G on a standard D/G then you are missing the F natural and F chord in the fourth part, but put it into A (played mainly on the D row) and the F transposes to G.  There are no G#s in the tune, so it is an ideal candidate for learning the A major fingering on a D/G box.

Noodle: just use the same fingering that you would have used for G major on the B/C box, and you will be 95% there.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Owen Woods on May 08, 2011, 10:09:26 AM
Here it's a four part in A. The third part is a little tricky, requires more bellows control than the rest, since you are playing edc# at speed. Plus if you want the chords to work properly you'll have to cross row a fair bit, which means that you end up a lot on the pull, so you'll need to grab air reasonably regularly.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Anahata on May 08, 2011, 10:26:46 AM
Plus if you want the chords to work properly you'll have to cross row a fair bit, which means that you end up a lot on the pull, so you'll need to grab air reasonably regularly.

Ah, the joys of playing melodeon....  :||: :||:
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Owen Woods on May 08, 2011, 10:37:08 AM
Aye, so much of the skill involves saying "I need to collapse the bellows. I shall do it on this D here. Which of the chords would sound least bad for that note? Bmin7th. Good, that'll let some more air out", all in a fraction of a second.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2011, 11:10:02 AM
Aye, so much of the skill involves saying "I need to collapse the bellows. I shall do it on this D here. Which of the chords would sound least bad for that note? Bmin7th. Good, that'll let some more air out", all in a fraction of a second.


No wonder most of us find it hard to talk and play at the same time!
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Bill Young on May 08, 2011, 01:47:19 PM
Atholl Highlanders, for example is so, so much easier to play now.


Playing it in the 'proper' key of A major I hope!

So decided to take on this in A. Question, is it normally played as a 2 part or a 4 part tune as it exists as both out in t'internet?
It's pretty well always played with four parts. Here's a typical example (http://sheetmusic.lyco.org.au/Atholl%20Highlanders/Atholl%20Highlanders%20-%20Violin.pdf). Listed here as a jig, play it a bit slower as a 6/8 march.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Theo on May 08, 2011, 02:33:08 PM

It's pretty well always played with four parts. Here's a typical example (http://sheetmusic.lyco.org.au/Atholl%20Highlanders/Atholl%20Highlanders%20-%20Violin.pdf). Listed here as a jig, play it a bit slower as a 6/8 march.

Or a played a bit faster it is brilliant for Cumberland Square Eight.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Owen Woods on May 08, 2011, 02:51:59 PM

It's pretty well always played with four parts. Here's a typical example (http://sheetmusic.lyco.org.au/Atholl%20Highlanders/Atholl%20Highlanders%20-%20Violin.pdf). Listed here as a jig, play it a bit slower as a 6/8 march.

Or a played a bit faster it is brilliant for Cumberland Square Eight.

Agreed. Although I like playing it for Strip the Willow as well, mostly because our other strip the willow sets are rather less than melodeon friendly.
Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Keithypete. on May 08, 2011, 03:19:12 PM
But  Noodle, dear Noodle the 'people's key' - A maj. is great fun on the B/C. Perseverance is the key.

 I think you may become so besotted with your new acquisition that you desssert B/C. They are very different animals as you are aware which can be confusing, although you may be one of those people, of whom I am very jealous, who can comfortably learn & play both. 


 Have fun Noodle.


Title: Re: Well I finally took the leap into the world of D/G
Post by: Noodle on June 09, 2011, 08:36:46 PM
Well it's been just over a month and for those interested, I must confess that I love it. I can play basses far easier as they're more intuitive, the right hand is easier to work with and when I get the muscles working with the low reeds in, it sounds better than anything I've heard. I feel like my playing has improved immensely technique-wise too. Just need to work on my air button use.

I'm also pleased to say that after visiting the Music Room in Cleckheaton (coincidence as I was actually visiting friends there) and fiddling around with a few boxes (including a Paolo, Lilliput, new Sandpiper, 2 voice Bincis) I still think I've got probably the best box for me.

Fear not though, Pete. The B/C still has its place and after a few seconds of muddling, I still use it.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal