thanks! any other major keys?
In theory you can play in any key on a 3-row with accidentals like the A/D/G, as all the notes are there!
even something like d minor? so why in theory and not in practace?
even something like d minor? so why in theory and not in practice?A typical 3-row is chromatic, but bellows movements and fingering are tricky when getting away from the tonals and relative minors, for example on a A/D/G the A, D and G are easy, relative minors require a bit of thinking (Bm and Em have basses, not F#m) and anything else is painful...
even something like d minor? so why in theory and not in practace?
;)
You should also know that your are chromatic on about just an octave. So say, if you learn something in D minor in the lower octave, you will miss the e flat in the higher registry.
i have such a limited knowledge of music theory that i find the whole thing baffling??? i
thats nothing to be ashamed of whatsoever - many top class 'traditional' musicians both living & dead have been completely devoid of such theoretical knowledge - a state t hat some would argue has been of considerable benefit to them !
george :D
As Chris has said the ADG is fine for playing in AD & G & their relative minors. For those wishing to go beyond this the only genuinely chromatic push pull box is the BCC#Completely agree. The good thing of ADG is that you can buy a GCF and BbEbAb as well, and your problem is (mostly) solved: 3 boxes one fingering and you can play in three keys. Of course, an FBbEb and an EAD can be added to the set to increase the number of keys you can play a tune. With my son we have bought 2 ADG boxes, 3 GCF boxes (one with gleichton buttons), and a BbEbAb, all of them Hohner.
the same size hohner trichord is chromatic in a practical & logical way & A,D & G are dead easy, the scales needed to play all 12 major keys are CADGF. As Chris has said the ADG is fine for playing in AD & G & their relative minors. For those wishing to go beyond this the only genuinely chromatic push pull box is the BCC#
which is why I play DG ,mostly on the row, for some session & most band work as its lightweight & highly portable & has bass rhythm & drive available as powerful but not as harmonising as stradella on a big box ..
For anything else that may require other keys I use the bcc# as it saves carting 12 one rows about in different keys & offers the big bonus of stradella bass!.
Every single harmonic minor scale lacks either its minor 3rd, its 'Neapolitan' 6th or the 'sensitive-note' leading 7th note. That's a handicap for Baltic, Klesma, Russian, Balkan, a lot of Spanish stuff, a lot of French - be it folk or swing. OK, you might get there via the so called accidentals. But that's sort of saying you don't ever intend to play in the second octave :-\
...
All in all, its good for its base keys playing up and down the rows ('though with that extra weight to shift) and their relative minors. In these you also a lot of cross row runs for free. Outside those keys .. intrinsically restricted IMHO
.... Carrying around a whole row of accidentals on a three row diatonic instrument so you can 'play in all twelve keys' misses the whole point of a diatonic instrument in my view. If you want to play solid rhythmic music and utilize the chords available on a diatonic you are going to have to stick with the keys it was designed to play in. ....
I have customised accidentals and make frequent use of them. With this setup I manage a fair amount of klezmer and other eastern european stuff.This is a very important point. Contemporary or the folk music of some regions are "modal-intesive", and you definitely need a number of accidentals. For example, to play Hungarian music on an ADG in A you definitely need F, D#/Eb in the second octave, too; since a hell lot of tunes in A requires them, and because of the nature of the music there is no workaround.
So I still feel the strength of these double quint systems is may be that they are lighter than three x one row?
This is a very important point. Contemporary or the folk music of some regions are "modal-intensive", and you definitely need a number of accidentals. For example, to play Hungarian music on an ADG in A you definitely need F, D#/Eb in the second octave, too.
So I still feel the strength of these double quint systems is may be that they are lighter than three x one row?
JB, what accidentals do you have? I love the concept of three-row quint-boxes, but I badly need the extra notes to play my music.
Most (but not all) of is designed for klezmer. By far the most important for me is the G#, which I have both ways. The pull (which I think is a standard accidental on CF and GCF boxes) gives me the raised 4th of D mi-sheberach, a klezmer minor mode. The push gives me the third of E freygish (major with flattened 2nd). In effect, D mi-sheberach is the relative minor of E freygish. And in klezmer these are common keys for these modes.
Attached is the low end layout of my GCF. My ADG is equivalent. It looks a bit weird at first sight. And probably at second and third too.
Firstly - I really enjoyed that botoÅŸani hora - thanks for it.Thanks Chris. Yes it's a cracking tune, all the more fun for being a blatant cut-and-shut. Even the modalities are completely different in the two halves, the first in C freygish and the second in C lordknowswhat (major with flattened 6th).
freygish? That's a totally new word on me, but its notes are the same as the Spanish/flamenco/phrygian major scaleThe accepted view is that it's a yiddish corruption of phrygian. Although, as you note, this is phrygian major rather than minor.
JB, you've certainly resolved the missing F Bb Eb (Eb G# Db for you) issue, which was the 'nub of the problem' in my post. Begs the question whether an effectively 3 row + 3.5 button layout remains a true double quint? Its aficionados should best decide that.
I But overall I much prefer playing the 3-row quint (or whatever you want to call it) than the PA. Mainly, for me, this is because the smaller box (and I think the bisonority has something to do with this, too) is more dynamic and gives you a real sense of physical/tactile connection with the notes you are producing. A kind of ability to sculpt each note and phrase dynamically in a way which just isn't there on even the lightest PA. I And it really is extremely satisfying to bludgeon reluctant musical square pegs into the round holes of this system.
and with this I think we all agree heartily, irrespective of our personal favouirite 'bisonoric' set up!
george ;D
And it really is extremely satisfying to bludgeon reluctant musical square pegs into the round holes of this system.John, this was a revelationally brilliant comment. I'd like to apply a couple of modifications to my standard 3-row Hohner Coronas to be able to play a wider range of (modal) music (in the home keys, of course). Based on this layout http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/ADG31corona.gif what modifications would you recommend? The A row has only 10 buttons on a Corona. I am thinking that the high end button(s) (B/F# or maybe G/E) can be altered for some higher pitch accidentals.
I'd like to apply a couple of modifications to my standard 3-row Hohner Coronas to be able to play a wider range of (modal) music (in the home keys, of course). Based on this layout http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/ADG31corona.gif what modifications would you recommend? The A row has only 10 buttons on a Corona. I am thinking that the high end button(s) (B/F# or maybe G/E) can be altered for some higher pitch accidentals.I don't have a view on using the top end for accidentals. I think this would be very strange to play, at first. Other people may have views on this.
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/ADG31corona.gifThis was terribly helpful from an experienced and brilliant world-music musician, Thank You! One more question about bass. When playing Hungarian music on my ADG, I play 99% in different modes (major, mixolydian, dorian and minor, and very often a combination of them within the same tune) of A, I guess I should play a (mostly) "minorish" (dorian and minor) tune on the G row against a pulled A bass + C chord cross-chord, shouldn't I?
At the low end I'd certainly suggest binning the D on the G row and likewise the A on the D row, each of these having nearby duplicates.
then I think I'd replicate what I currently have on my D and G rows. On the A row I'd definitely keep the Eb push. That would leave me one slot (pull) for one of my current C G and A. Offhand I guess I'd try it with the C, and see how it goes.
But this almost certainly won't be your optimum. I expect you could make better use of my A# push in the D row, for example.
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/ADG31corona.gifThis was terribly helpful from an experienced and brilliant world-music musician, Thank You! One more question about bass. When playing Hungarian music on my ADG, I play 99% in different modes (major, mixolydian, dorian and minor, and very often a combination of them within the same tune) of A, I guess I should play a (mostly) "minorish" (dorian and minor) tune on the G row against a pulled A bass + C chord cross-chord, shouldn't I?
At the low end I'd certainly suggest binning the D on the G row and likewise the A on the D row, each of these having nearby duplicates.
then I think I'd replicate what I currently have on my D and G rows. On the A row I'd definitely keep the Eb push. That would leave me one slot (pull) for one of my current C G and A. Offhand I guess I'd try it with the C, and see how it goes.
But this almost certainly won't be your optimum. I expect you could make better use of my A# push in the D row, for example.
Thanks Chris. Yes it's a cracking tune, all the more fun for being a blatant cut-and-shut. Even the modalities are completely different in the two halves, the first in C freygish and the second in C lordknowswhat (major with flattened 6th).
The accepted view is that it's a yiddish corruption of phrygian. Although, as you note, this is phrygian major rather than minor.
Agree and disagree (so no change there!) and would like to strike another blow against this silly and probably meaningless term 'accidental'. If you stick a Bb into a G or Em arrangement it is anthing but 'accidental! It's a flat 5th - technically as far 'out' of the home key as one can get. You are choosing to stick in a very 'blue' note .. hold it .. play melody through that ... detente 8) Miraculously this works and is the basis of much of the stuff I listed above.
but what would you call the C natural in the second part of Ashokan Farewell? Somehow it doesn't have the feel as the Scottish flattened 7ths. More like a sharpened B?:D
| I don't hear it as a passing note at all (what does it pass to)? The preceding tune notes spell out the D7 arpegio in detail D - F# - A - C even returning to the clashing F# a second time (in the usual way we voice it). No that is a bog standard D7 with its Cnatl bold as brass and thus a Dominant - we have modulated into G ... .. and sure enough the next chord is G :D but the tune returns to using C#! So its G lydian with its #4 lovely tinkling over the G bass. We've spent just a ½ bar in the new key centre returning immediately to the D scale. Clever! I have to say it feels closer to a western jazzer's modulation to me. Despite the guy's name, a Csárdás player would probably slip in an Eb passing note between the chord's D and F# to maintain major/minor ambiguity. Interestingly both that and Enat work - but they have quite different feel. |