Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ollie on May 27, 2011, 04:58:57 PM
-
Is it possible to change a box from having stops to having switches behind the keyboard? If so, how much would it cost to get it done?
-
Depends how the stops work. If they're operating a mechanism,(eg, Saltarelle Nuage), then it might be possible but if it's just a knob attached directly to a shutter, like most boxes with stops, then it's probably technically possible with a lot of work but realistically it's likely a non-starter.
-
I've just found this - http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/4616 - which is pretty much perfect for what I want, apart from the stops.
PLEASE - no one buy this. *puppy dog eyes*
-
PLEASE - no one buy this. *puppy dog eyes*
It's been on their 2nd hand list for a good few months, Ollie!
-
I've just found this - http://www.themusicroom-online.co.uk/product_info.php/products_id/4616 - which is pretty much perfect for what I want, apart from the stops.
PLEASE - no one buy this. *puppy dog eyes*
That can almost certainly be converted to switches from the stops.
-
That can almost certainly be converted to switches from the stops.
Really Lester? Have you experience of such a conversion?
-
I may be missing something simple here, but could someone explain to me what D/G/#b means? (I know I'm going to regret asking,LOL)
-
I may be missing something simple here, but could someone explain to me what D/G/#b means? (I know I'm going to regret asking,LOL)
It's just one way of indicating that it is a D/G box with a third (inside) rows full of "accidentals" ("sharps and flats").
For instance, there is an F# on both the D and the G row, so on the inside row there is probably an F natural. The D and G rows also have only B natural, so the inside row probably has a B flat. And so on.
Cheers,
Andy
-
That can almost certainly be converted to switches from the stops.
Really Lester? Have you experience of such a conversion?
Nielson told me he could convert my Connemarra 3 by using the switch mech off a piano accordion to drive the coupler mech in the melodeon. But I did not hav it done as I decided to sell the box. Admittedly this is not what Ollie asked for with switches on h back of the keyboard.
-
Is it possible to change a box from having stops to having switches behind the keyboard? If so, how much would it cost to get it done?
Just wondering, is it that you find swtiches handier or just don't like look of stops? If the box's perfect otherwise maybe you'd just get it and get used to the stops. I know that behind the keyboard is handy for quick changes but I'm of the opinion that whipping your hand off the keyboard and changing stops really quickly looks slicker if you pull it off ;)
-
Thanx for that, Andy. I understand now. Seems I've still a lot to learn about melodeon terminology. Sorry for the thread drift :||:
-
Is it possible to change a box from having stops to having switches behind the keyboard? If so, how much would it cost to get it done?
Just wondering, is it that you find swtiches handier or just don't like look of stops? If the box's perfect otherwise maybe you'd just get it and get used to the stops. I know that behind the keyboard is handy for quick changes but I'm of the opinion that whipping your hand off the keyboard and changing stops really quickly looks slicker if you pull it off ;)
I find switches or couplers easier, but I agree with you, it is perhaps more impressive to learn to deal with stops. :P
Hopefully going up to the Music Room to try it on Thursday (if it's still there).
Also, if it's possible to drift your own thread, it claims to have "With three sets of hand made reeds at 8' pitch and a warm musette tuning". What does "8' pitch" mean?
-
Also, if it's possible to drift your own thread, it claims to have "With three sets of hand made reeds at 8' pitch and a warm musette tuning". What does "8' pitch" mean?
It's an indication of the octave. The term derives from organ pipes. An 8' reed (pipe) is what we'd call a middle reed (M).
16' = L = bassoon
8' = M = clarinet
4' = H = piccolo
-
I'm pretty sure that box was on their stall at Sidmouth last year and I played it....I wasn't exactly impressed if it is that one...
-
Hmmm, just come across this old thread - http://forum1.aimoo.com/melodeon/categroy/Saltarelle-Horizon-3-row-for-sale-1-729560.html
Not massively impressed with either bass or treble layout. Still worth a jaunt up to Clecky to have a look at it, but if I like it so much that I think it's worth it, how much would it cost to get the layout changed?
Actually, no, the bass seems Ok, but I'm struggling to make sense of the accidental row from the way it's written there.
Edit 2: bugger, hang on! It's MMM. Arse. >:( Not really worth getting it, then getting the layout changed and getting a lower set of reeds put in, is it? Daaaaammmmnnn...
-
Back to the original question the front switches of say a modern Paolo or Cairdin are linked to the same mechanism as the stops operate on a Salterelle, the linkage is a simple set up, the real problem comes with the amount of space above the treble mech, hence the raised front on the Cairdin, plenty of space on the Paolo. the actual switch or couplers if 2 is a swivel on a central pivot connected to rods, and before the inevitable question, yes I have, in various ways, including moving to the back, and one actually thumb operated on the edge of the finger board, I've also fitted a 96 bass from a Hohner Verdi into a BCC# CoronaIII but that's another story, good luck with your hunting, sometimes I think half the fun's coming up with Idea's and then researching the practicality's, mory.
-
, I've also fitted a 96 bass from a Hohner Verdi into a BCC# CoronaIII but that's another story, ,
Tell us more!
george
-
]
I'm of the opinion that whipping your hand off the keyboard and changing stops really quickly looks slicker if you pull it off ;)
I can do the push bit but not the pull quick enough. ?how about lengthening the stops to come within reach of the gob! ;D
george
-
The master at work (:) (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLxfc7l63Pg)
-
George sent you PM mory
-
I have stops but would prefer switches behind the keyboard for mid-tune changes, but have quite happily got around this limitation by just playing up or down the octave. It's obviously harder to do than just flicking a switch, but certainly makes you a better player!
On another note, listen to Spiers and Boden playing the Rochdale coconut dance and see if you can hear the really noisy Oakwood coupler mechanism in the stop before the octaves change down!
-
Just catching up on threads I've missed:
I've been trying to improve my basic knowledge of boxes, and am aware of the 'things' behind the keyboards on some larger models, so do they just bring in/take out sets of reeds to alter the sound?
Having listened continually to Saul Rose on his Handry, playing Banks of the Dee/Willaim and Nancy on 'Banquet of Boxes' there's several changes of 'sound' going on and I'm a bit puzzled.
I'm also a bit miffed as over our Whit weekend i had the chance to have a go on a Mory, but was a bit over-refreshed ( :|glug ) to really have a go.
:|bl
Hey ho
Q
-
Just catching up on threads I've missed:
I've been trying to improve my basic knowledge of boxes, and am aware of the 'things' behind the keyboards on some larger models, so do they just bring in/take out sets of reeds to alter the sound?
Having listened continually to Saul Rose on his Handry, playing Banks of the Dee/Willaim and Nancy on 'Banquet of Boxes' there's several changes of 'sound' going on and I'm a bit puzzled.
:|bl
Hey ho
Q
The Mory and Handry are both 3-voice instruments tuned L M M+. On the RH treble end there are three switches behind the keyboard which control which banks of reeds are in use. Each switch has two positions: up = towards the chin, down = towards the knees.
Switch 1: up selects MM+, down selects M only
Switch 2: selects LMM+ in both up and down positions and overrides any previous setting.
Switch 3: up selects L only, down selects LM
On the LH bass end, there are 4 small-size stops, 1 is nearest the knees, 4 is nearest the chin. Selecting a stop by pushing down overrides any previous setting. Each stop controls whether the lowest bass reed (out of three) is selected AND whether the thirds are included/removed from the chords (dashed clever arrangement, what?)
Stop 1: All bass reeds in, thirds in.
Stop 2: All bass reeds in, thirds out.
Stop 3: Lowest bass reed out, thirds in.
Stop 4: Lowest bass reed out, thirds out.
Hope this helps....
-
Thanks for the definitive answer Steve..... looks like a complex set up, but a lot of variables there.
Q
-
Just a thought Ollie
Unless you particularly like or need the MMM musette tuning, you would find a three voice LMM with stops would give you a greater variety of sounds.
My box for example can do:
M clear and pure like a concertina, nice for quiet reflective tunes with no bass
MM sort of standard workerday melodeon sound
LM rich and sonorous - my favourite setting
LMM all out rousing dance tunes
MM and LM blend well with other instruments.
-
In reply to the original question. The mechanism inside the Oakwood I recently parted with was as simple as it could possibly be - it's like a simple single stop to engage and remove the low reed on a three voice LMM.
Link to a picture of the mechanism inside RHS without reedblocks (http://www.flickr.com/photos/squeezyjohn/5793355444/in/set-72157626874797764)
The little box at the bottom is designed to stop the air getting through too much and contains that long piece of wire with a right angled piece soldered/welded on that the lever slots in to.
The lever itself with the slot that goes inside the box - pivoted on a bellows pin! (http://www.flickr.com/photos/squeezyjohn/5792797209/in/set-72157626874797764)
The slot on the main box with the underside of the keyboard showing at the front of the picture (http://www.flickr.com/photos/squeezyjohn/5792797487/in/set-72157626874797764)
What makes me think it might be hard to incorporate this kind of thing in an existing box even though it is simple - is that the Oakwood needed to have reedblocks which had pieces cut away to allow the mechanism to operate underneath. This is what it looks like with the reedblocks in (upside down I'm afraid) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/squeezyjohn/5792795399/in/set-72157626874797764/)
Cheers
Squeezy
EDIT: Just saw LDT's post about the same box - yes it did make a bit of a noise!
-
Great pictures Squeezy (:) Although I was kind of hoping that I would look at them and think "Ah, so that is why a Oakwood sounds great" :P
-
The mechanism inside the Oakwood I recently parted with was as simple as it could possibly be -
Heck and a half, I am constantly amazed by how forkin' clever these devices are!
-
Many thanks for the pictures Squeezy! The photos really capture the details of the construction. Very helpful.
I'm puzzled by the arrangement of reeds for the bass end though. Looks like you've got three reeds for the octave - low, middle, high. The chords look like they use a lower note for the tonic with the third and fifth an octave higher. Is that correct?
Thanks,
Telemorris.
-
Don't be puzzled! That's how they are arranged. My Saltarelle Connemara 2 models have a 3 voice bass as well giving a nice full tone. With a stop to remove the low bass reeds it's kind of essential to have two reeds left for the lighter tone without sounding like a concertina. On that particular box (no longer in my posession) some of the basses are MMH rather than LMH which made for an odd sounding light configuration.
The chords are again as you describe.
Cheers
Squeezy