Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: ladydetemps on May 28, 2011, 10:36:54 AM
-
ok. I decided to try playing what shall we do with the drunken sailor today. I have the dotsin G (could be Em). Now on the 2 row if I played it on the D row it sounded ok. But when I tried it on my 'C' one row the chords clashed.
Help, advice, explination?
-
As you surmised it is in E min when played on the two row and thus you have the correct chords. On a 1 row in C it will come out in D min for which you have no chords and will sound odd ;)
So on a 1 row with no chords - good, with chords - BAD
-
Heh, not so bad.
There's A minor as well ya know :||:
-
With low notes rather than accidentals.
-
Just try basing the tune around the G/A button (two buttons down the keyboard) as your "home" button (rather than then the C/D). In that way you can work out tunes in A minor (not the modal thing but the circle of fifths minor thing) and the tunes that will fit in G with the missing F#.
A dead easy tune to try in A minor on a C one row is The Bear Dance. The second note is the A on the pull instead of a D, just position your hand and work it out.
-
Working still on one row version here is my 2 row version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvVdunhxlp4
-
Working still on one row version here is my 2 row version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvVdunhxlp4
Video is marked as 'private' :(
-
Working still on one row version here is my 2 row version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GvVdunhxlp4
Video is marked as 'private' :(
Try again it says 'public' to me.
-
Try again it says 'public' to me.
Yes - it's OK now, thanks.
-
I like the tune but i'd play it more often if there was some kind of B part to play,i like your version on Youtube btw
-
I like the tune but i'd play it more often if there was some kind of B part to play,i like your version on Youtube btw
thanks.
I have done an audio only version as well
http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=54746
-
yeah i've found some really good stuff on that audio thing,your username keeps cropping up