Meant to post the chart too....For me, that is pretty much my ideal layout for a 2-row D/G. The only change I would make would be to flip the reed plate on the G-row accidental so you have the Eb (or D# as I prefer to call it) on the push, with the F-natural on the pull. This is because quite often a tune which needs the D# will also need the left-hand B bass/chord which is only available on the push.
(ii) There is an increased finger stretch involved to get to the accidental buttons at the chin-end. This is something that most people get used to very quickly, and, on a small-size keyboard like on a Lilly, the stretch is lessened anyway.
Is an "open E" chord the same as "E major"? I want to be sure I am communicating with the tuner to get the most neutral E so it can sound major or minor depending upon the right hand.
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.
A question has haunted me for years. Think I have the opportunity of asking it in this thread:
Why do people play DG at all? In my opinion that's nearly the least suited combination for a 2R, placed high in the scale and therefore lacking the more mellow/heavy sound of GC (and AD). In Denmark, where I live, DG has invaded during the last 20-30 yours and is by now the main standard in folkmusic instead of the former GC. Near to 100% of players in Sweden and Norway luckily still prefers GC. Me too.
Anybody who can tell me a bit about the background and arguments for these different key-choices?
PS. Of course I have a DG. Being a dane I have to. But in the lonely, dark nights I sneak to playing my GC ;-)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6748.0.html
Q for stevefreereeder: could you suggest a tune that would utilize the flipped F/D# that I can try out?
I also find the B part of Jump at the Sun wants this reversal.
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.
Actually, one of the tunes up for vote for ToTM - Mr. Beveridge's Maggott. The D# in the second bar wants to be played against a B bass and/or B major chord which are press only.
X:1
T:Jump at the Sun
C:John Kirkpatrick
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Em
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB eBB |BAG F3 |
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB cBA |GAF E3 ::
eBB gfe |fBB agf |gfe gfe |f^dB c2 B |
eBB gfe |fBB agf |eBB cBA |GAF E3 :|
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?See the ABC that mglamb has posted. (We need to be careful that we do not infringe copyright here.... :o )
If you play Jump at the Sun in G minor ( the key in which JK wrote it), there is a D sharp (or E flat, as I think of it) in bar 4 and another in bar 7 of the B music.Hmm.... No, sorry Bob. In G minor the accidental in bar 4 of the B-music is F#, not D#. As explained above, it doesn't occur in bar 7. Look at mglamb's ABC.
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?If you play Jump at the Sun in G minor ( the key in which JK wrote it), there is a D sharp (or E flat, as I think of it) in bar 4 and another in bar 7 of the B music.Hmm.... No, sorry Bob. In G minor the accidental in bar 4 of the B-music is F#, not D#. As explained above, it doesn't occur in bar 7. Look at the mglamb's ABC
X:1
T:Jump at the Sun
C:John Kirkpatrick
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Gm
GBd ^c2 d |GBd ^c2 d |gdd gdd |dcB A3 |
GBd ^c2 d |GBd ^c2 d |gdd edc |BcA G3 ::
gdd bag |add c'ba |bag bag |a^fd e2 d |
gdd bag |add c'ba |gdd edc |BcA G3 :|
Hi Marc,I think I'm the source of some the confusion here. Yes, Bob you are quite right of course. In the key of G minor there are Bb and Eb in the key signature. I'd forgotten that you would be playing this in Gm on your D/G box! Me, being a lazy git, would of course play it in Gm using a C/F box. ;)
I have just checked through your version and it is the same as mine.
No worries - If I weren't 3000 miles away, I'd say a round or three would be in order! :|glug
Hasse: You seem to have the same accidentals (F/G#) at the bottom of both the D row and the G row. Is this a mistake on the diagram? If not, what was the reason for this?Looking at the numerals next to the notes, I would hazard a guess that the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row.
I would suggest an alternative pattern of low notes for those playing mostly English traditional tunes, where the most common key is G major. Two reed changes, and one brain change, will give a full scale of G down an octave below the G on button 4 of the G row:
1) change the low B/D on the G row to B/C
2) change the low F#/A button on the D row to G/A
3) in your head think of the low G/A button as part of the G row.
Back to the thread: Another Melnetter I met yesterday ( Guy ) is also thinking about converting his little Saltarelle to a 4th button start to include the low notes. He was saying he's now encountering another morris side's tunes and many of them need some low notes. It seems that once you come into contact with a tune requiring some low notes, and actually get thinking about it, then it's a natural thing to have done. Well, that's what I did!
Q
Blimey!
Is this a Saltarelle Owners Club mass decision here..... :D
Q
ps.... are you sure Guy's not your middle name? ;)
mglamb:
Was just out of curiosity wanting to check your version of Jump at the Sun.
Just tried to convert your abc's into dots using several converters, none seem to recognise it.
Is it in the correct format?
I'm not used to abc's, always convert to dots so don't know what's wrong with the version simply by glancing at it......
Q
Yes, it's exactly as Steve points out the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row. Should maybe have used the Italian numbering system to clarify: G-row F(32)/G#(35) D-row F(20)/G#(23). These accidentals are of course good to have when for instans playing tunes in G with parts in C and A natural minor, and for tunes change around in G, C, D, A and so on. Not that the bass side always works perfectly, when treble side does...Hasse: You seem to have the same accidentals (F/G#) at the bottom of both the D row and the G row. Is this a mistake on the diagram? If not, what was the reason for this?Looking at the numerals next to the notes, I would hazard a guess that the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row.
exactly as Steve points out the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row. Should maybe have used the Italian numbering system to clarify: G-row F(32)/G#(35) D-row F(20)/G#(23). These accidentals are of course good to have when for instans playing tunes in G with parts in C and A natural minor, and for tunes change around in G, C, D, A and so on. Not that the bass side always works perfectly, when treble side does...Interesting concept for the accidentals and I can see there are many occasions where having them in both octaves is good.
I have a Binci with 4th button start, conventional low notes and accidentals. I find that I am still mainly doing the D up to G run starting on the low D on the outside row as you would with a 3rd button start box, so this revised low note layout is starting to make a lot of sense as it opens up a complete lower G octave as Theo suggests. Having seen Anahata's version of Stoney Steps Hornpipe on YT, that also sounds much nicer using these low notes rather than very squeaky ones when I try it on my C/F Pokerwork.I would suggest an alternative pattern of low notes for those playing mostly English traditional tunes, where the most common key is G major. Two reed changes, and one brain change, will give a full scale of G down an octave below the G on button 4 of the G row:
1) change the low B/D on the G row to B/C
2) change the low F#/A button on the D row to G/A
3) in your head think of the low G/A button as part of the G row.
That is exactly the layout of my Oakwood, and was so successful that I changed my Saltarelle to be the same. If I ever get another D/G box it will be like that too, even if it's only a 19 key box like the Dino Baffetti Binci II.
I'm also considering reversing the G row accidental from F/D# to D#/F
My Pokerwork also has the same low note layout without the accidentals.
Tru-
Any problem with the reversed D#/F, at least reversed from what one usually sees?
Revised 21 Button Low and Accidental, with revisions suggested by members
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.
Revised 21 Button Low and Accidental, with revisions suggested by membersI use this tuning with one difference - my low G on the push (D row) has a low B on the pull. I'm convinced that this better suits the rhythm of the irish fiddle tunes I play. And this low B on the treble side fits in with the Em bass.
It sees that open chords are under-rated. They are maybe a little bit thin, but opens up lots of fun combinations. Opinions?