Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Steve C. on May 28, 2011, 11:28:07 PM

Title: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on May 28, 2011, 11:28:07 PM
Hello all--

Need a reality check, please.

Any reason why one would not want a 21 button DG (like a Lilly) with both low notes and accidentals?

I am still pretty much a beginner on DG but have never even seen a tune that needed the high B/F# or F#/C#.

Also, pretty sure also wanting "open E" instead of the Em.  Is this a pretty common set up?

Thanks, regards, Steve
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 12:36:28 AM
When I got my Castagnari Rik ADG, I had it set up with both low notes and accidentals, 4th button start.  Being a 33-button layout, the D and G rows were effectively a 21-button system.  I never had a problem with the missing high notes.  As far as the E minor, I would never give that up.  I can't recall ever needing an E major chord and I love the sound of the full minor chord.  I will say that I've only owned boxes with stops or switches to remove the thirds in the last decade or so.  That being said, I prefer to use the full chords whenever possible.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on May 29, 2011, 01:00:16 AM
Meant to post the chart too....
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Lester on May 29, 2011, 07:58:20 AM
My Castagnari Tommy is set up like your chart. I have taped all the thirds out.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 29, 2011, 08:10:13 AM
Meant to post the chart too....
For me, that is pretty much my ideal layout for a 2-row D/G. The only change I would make would be to flip the reed plate on the G-row accidental so you have the Eb (or D# as I prefer to call it) on the push, with the F-natural on the pull. This is because quite often a tune which needs the D# will also need the left-hand B bass/chord which is only available on the push.

Having the low notes is also good. There are many tunes I play which need the low B (button 2 on the RH).

The possible disadvantages of a fourth button start to give you these low notes and accidentals are:
(i) You lose the very highest notes from the knee-end of the keyboard. But nevertheless, you still go up to an E which is three ledger lines above the treble stave, which is plenty high enough for most people: most traditional tunes never go higher than the B or C# below that.

(ii) There is an increased finger stretch involved to get to the accidental buttons at the chin-end. This is something that most people get used to very quickly, and, on a small-size keyboard like on a Lilly, the stretch is lessened anyway.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Lester on May 29, 2011, 09:21:58 AM
The only difference between my set up and your chart is that I have reversed the F#/C# highest reed on the D row to give me F# on the pull for use on the key of G which is the only time I go up that high, then only with the extra L reed in play on my Tommy.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Theo on May 29, 2011, 09:55:16 AM
I think the fourth button start should be the standard layout for D/G because it is the highest pitch of all the common fourth apart systems,  so you really do need the low notes.

I would suggest an alternative pattern of low notes for those playing mostly English traditional tunes, where the most common key is G major.  Two reed changes, and one brain change, will give a full scale of G down an octave below the G on button 4 of the G row:

1) change the low B/D on the G row to B/C
2) change the low F#/A button on the D row to G/A
3) in your head think of the low G/A button as part of the G row.

so on the first few buttons you have (ommitting the accidentals):

-/-  B/C  D/F#  G/A etc
-/-  G/A  A/C#  D/E  etc

So you can now cope with any tune that goes down to low G.  And since that is the lowest note on a fiddle, which has been an enduring influence of folk music, it opens up a whole range of tunes that would otherwise have to be played an octave higher than written.



Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Andy in Vermont on May 29, 2011, 11:21:51 AM
(ii) There is an increased finger stretch involved to get to the accidental buttons at the chin-end. This is something that most people get used to very quickly, and, on a small-size keyboard like on a Lilly, the stretch is lessened anyway.

This is true!  My Castagnari Jacky GCF has both low notes and accidentals, so the first note of the scale is button 4.  The stretch is fine -- but it really is a stretch, unless you have very large hands.  Would definitely be no problem on an instrument with closer buttons like a Lilly.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on May 29, 2011, 04:46:22 PM
Thanks all for the additional ideas.

(Ignorance warning)

Is an "open E" chord the same as "E major"?  I want to be sure I am communicating with the tuner to get the most neutral E so it can sound major or minor depending upon the right hand.

Thanks, as usual, regards, Steve
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 04:50:20 PM
E major = E-G#-B, E minor = E-G-B, open E = E-B (this is what you get if you tape off the thirds or use a stop or switch to remove thirds.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Theo on May 29, 2011, 04:51:18 PM
Is an "open E" chord the same as "E major"?  I want to be sure I am communicating with the tuner to get the most neutral E so it can sound major or minor depending upon the right hand.

No!

E major is E G# B
E minor E G B

"open" E is just E and B, so it has only the notes common to both major and minor.  Adding the G# or G on the right hand will the make it major or minor as long as you have those notes on the right in the correct bellows direction.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on May 29, 2011, 07:12:25 PM
Thanks, gentlemen.

Q for stevefreereeder: could you suggest a tune that would utilize the flipped F/D# that I can try out?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 07:56:45 PM
Actually, one of the tunes up for vote for ToTM - Mr. Beveridge's Maggott.  The D# in the second bar wants to be played against a B bass and/or B major chord which are press only.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Lester on May 29, 2011, 08:00:14 PM
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.

Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 08:08:08 PM
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.



Good catch, had to check my ABC file since I haven't learned that one yet - you do want a B chord there.  I also find the B part of Jump at the Sun wants this reversal.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: tostean on May 29, 2011, 09:47:01 PM
A question has haunted me for years. Think I have the opportunity of asking it in this thread:

Why do people play DG at all? In my opinion that's nearly the least suited combination for a 2R, placed high in the scale and therefore lacking the more mellow/heavy sound of GC (and AD). In Denmark, where I live, DG has invaded during the last 20-30 yours and is by now the main standard in folkmusic instead of the former GC. Near to 100% of players in Sweden and Norway luckily still prefers GC. Me too.

Anybody who can tell me a bit about the background and arguments for these different key-choices?

PS. Of course I have a DG. Being a dane I have to. But in the lonely, dark nights I sneak to playing my GC ;-)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 10:24:53 PM
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6748.0.html
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Hasse on May 29, 2011, 10:37:58 PM
A question has haunted me for years. Think I have the opportunity of asking it in this thread:

Why do people play DG at all? In my opinion that's nearly the least suited combination for a 2R, placed high in the scale and therefore lacking the more mellow/heavy sound of GC (and AD). In Denmark, where I live, DG has invaded during the last 20-30 yours and is by now the main standard in folkmusic instead of the former GC. Near to 100% of players in Sweden and Norway luckily still prefers GC. Me too.

Anybody who can tell me a bit about the background and arguments for these different key-choices?

PS. Of course I have a DG. Being a dane I have to. But in the lonely, dark nights I sneak to playing my GC ;-)

Well, for one thing: I guess you play the D/G because most tunes in Denmark are in G or D, and the fiddlers and others prefer to play these tunes in D and G. In some people's opinion (I often hear from fiddlers) they prefer the more sharp crisp sound of the D/G compared to the more dark and dominant G/C. To illustrate you could compare melodeons to saxophones: The D/G being a soprano sax, C/F the alto, A/D the tenor and the G/C a baritone sax.

So I guess you answered the question very well yourself - The G/C is best for lone and dark night, but the D/G on the other hand...  ;)

And yes:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6748.0.html
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 29, 2011, 11:11:12 PM
Q for stevefreereeder: could you suggest a tune that would utilize the flipped F/D# that I can try out?

I also find the B part of Jump at the Sun wants this reversal.

In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.

Actually, one of the tunes up for vote for ToTM - Mr. Beveridge's Maggott.  The D# in the second bar wants to be played against a B bass and/or B major chord which are press only.

That's three good suggestions from the others so far.  ;)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Ollie on May 29, 2011, 11:19:10 PM
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 11:28:50 PM

X:1
T:Jump at the Sun
C:John Kirkpatrick
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Em
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB eBB |BAG F3 |
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB cBA |GAF E3 ::
eBB gfe |fBB agf |gfe gfe |f^dB c2 B |
eBB gfe |fBB agf |eBB cBA |GAF E3 :|

Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 29, 2011, 11:34:08 PM
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?

If you play Jump at the Sun in G minor ( the key in which JK wrote it), there is a D sharp (or E flat, as I think of it) in bar 4 and another in bar 7 of the B music.

My E flats on both the melody end and the bass end are on the push and my F sharps are on the pull. I find them more useful that way round.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 29, 2011, 11:43:54 PM
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?
See the ABC that mglamb has posted. (We need to be careful that we do not infringe copyright here....  :o )
The ABC as shown is a faithful transposition into E minor of JK's original tune in G minor as it appears in his tune book Opus Pocus (Dragonfly Music, 1988).

In the E minor version there is a single D# in bar 4 of the B-music. Nowhere else.

If you play Jump at the Sun in G minor ( the key in which JK wrote it), there is a D sharp (or E flat, as I think of it) in bar 4 and another in bar 7 of the B music.
Hmm.... No, sorry Bob. In G minor the accidental in bar 4 of the B-music is F#, not D#. As explained above, it doesn't occur in bar 7. Look at mglamb's ABC.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 29, 2011, 11:48:57 PM
I would also add to what Steve said by pointing out that E flat is not an accidental in the key of G minor.   ;)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 29, 2011, 11:49:22 PM
How does the B part to Jump at the Sun need a D#?
If you play Jump at the Sun in G minor ( the key in which JK wrote it), there is a D sharp (or E flat, as I think of it) in bar 4 and another in bar 7 of the B music.

Hmm.... No, sorry Bob. In G minor the accidental in bar 4 of the B-music is F#, not D#. As explained above, it doesn't occur in bar 7. Look at the mglamb's ABC

In the version I have, which I got from JK himself many years ago, there is, as you say, an accidental F sharp in both bars 4 and 7, but the second half of each of those bars begins with an E and, since the tune was written with two flats, those E notes are flattened. If you like, I can post the dots.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 30, 2011, 12:02:04 AM
Bob, I'd be interested to see your version if you don't mind posting.  This is what I have directly from "Opus Pocus" in G minor:

X:1
T:Jump at the Sun
C:John Kirkpatrick
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Gm
GBd ^c2 d |GBd ^c2 d |gdd gdd |dcB A3 |
GBd ^c2 d |GBd ^c2 d |gdd edc |BcA G3 ::
gdd bag |add c'ba |bag bag |a^fd e2 d |
gdd bag |add c'ba |gdd edc |BcA G3 :|


Thanks,
Marc
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 30, 2011, 12:20:45 AM
Hi Marc,

I have just checked through your version and it is the same as mine.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 30, 2011, 12:28:27 AM
Bob, I thought that might be the case.  I made my ABC file years ago by copying directly from Opus Pocus into Melody Assistant, transposing to E minor, and exporting the resulting ABC.  I had to go back tonight and revert my master file to G minor because I don't trust myself to transpose in my head anymore.  What I saw seemed to match up to what you were describing, so I made a G minor ABC so we could compare.  Aside from having too much fun playing with software, it's undeniably a fantastic tune!

Cheers,   :|glug
Marc
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 30, 2011, 12:30:32 AM
Hi Marc,

I have just checked through your version and it is the same as mine.
I think I'm the source of some the confusion here. Yes, Bob you are quite right of course. In the key of G minor there are Bb and Eb in the key signature. I'd forgotten that you would be playing this in Gm on your D/G box! Me, being a lazy git, would of course play it in Gm using a C/F box.  ;)
Apologies for the confusion!
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 30, 2011, 12:35:04 AM
No worries - If I weren't 3000 miles away, I'd say a round or three would be in order!   :|glug
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 30, 2011, 12:48:47 AM
No worries - If I weren't 3000 miles away, I'd say a round or three would be in order!   :|glug

We'll have one  :|glug or two  :|glug :|glug for you.  ;)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 30, 2011, 01:06:19 AM
That's a plan, I'll have to double up here to maintain the balance across the pond.   :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on May 30, 2011, 01:20:25 AM
Business proposition for the digerati of the forum:

We need a "paypal" of brewskis.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 30, 2011, 02:44:28 AM
Something along the lines of a "PublicanExpress" card...   :|glug
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 30, 2011, 08:03:28 PM
Just rewinding a touch:
Have just had the lower notes put into my keyboard as Theo suggests earlier, deliverd back to me on friday.
With our Whit Tour ( morris ) then starting have only had a cursory squeeze before having to rush off and meet guests and then dance all weekend so haven't tried it much. I have noticed that I can still get to the Bb accidental, even though it's now a further button away. Bit of a stretch but do-able
My plan being this week is half term for me so I can get some good practise in and start to learn the new keyboard system.

One mior hiccup: First dance today got a stick across the first finger of right hand which is now blue, somewhat stiff and throbbing. Don't think it's broken but a hell of a bash.
I'm currently using the mouse click with my other hand.....I might have to postpone my practising until I can manage to put finger to keyboard :(
Frustrating ot what?
Still someone's got to  :M
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: MartinW on May 30, 2011, 10:06:05 PM
Q,
Your finger really didn't look very happy. When I said to you that it would be an opportunity to build up your little finger I really wasn't anticipating this thread
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7021.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7021.0.html)

I do hope it recovers quickly.

Martin
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Hasse on May 31, 2011, 08:59:26 AM
(Sorry about your finger Q!)
I’ve also recently got a keyboard layout with accidentals and low notes on my new Luukinen accordion (Lilja III). Of course as always it’s a compromise, but I’ve been playing with this layout and a variation of this layout on two others boxes, and have finally settled for this layout (see the attached chart).
The only major difference from the one I rejected is the low note on D row was G/G and bass C/C. On my current layout I preferred low notes F#/G and bass E/C (see the chart).

Edit: typo!!
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 31, 2011, 09:14:35 AM
Hasse: You seem to have the same accidentals (F/G#) at the bottom of both the D row and the G row. Is this a mistake on the diagram? If not, what was the reason for this?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 31, 2011, 09:50:44 AM
Hasse: You seem to have the same accidentals (F/G#) at the bottom of both the D row and the G row. Is this a mistake on the diagram? If not, what was the reason for this?
Looking at the numerals next to the notes, I would hazard a guess that the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 10:34:45 AM
Hi Martin,
Sorry to have been a bit glum yesterday, but it hurt! Haven't had a finger hit in years, and never this bad. Hey ho.
Am somewhat happier today now the purple tinge is subsiding a bit, to a more natural tone. Might be hopeful for a quick  :|||: later on.
Did look at the 'Ouch' thread but I'm only bruised!

Hasse: thank you for the thought!

Back to the thread: Another Melnetter I met yesterday ( Guy ) is also thinking about converting his little Saltarelle to a 4th button start to include the low notes. He was saying he's now encountering another morris side's tunes and many of them need some low notes.  It seems that once you come into contact with a tune requiring some low notes, and actually get thinking about it, then it's a natural thing to have done. Well, that's what I did!
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Anahata on May 31, 2011, 11:25:49 AM
I would suggest an alternative pattern of low notes for those playing mostly English traditional tunes, where the most common key is G major.  Two reed changes, and one brain change, will give a full scale of G down an octave below the G on button 4 of the G row:

1) change the low B/D on the G row to B/C
2) change the low F#/A button on the D row to G/A
3) in your head think of the low G/A button as part of the G row.

That is exactly the layout of my Oakwood, and was so successful that I changed my Saltarelle to be the same. If I ever get another D/G box it will be like that too, even if it's only a 19 key box like the Dino Baffetti Binci II.

I'm also considering reversing the G row accidental from  F/D# to D#/F
My Pokerwork also has the same low note layout without the accidentals.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: JohnA on May 31, 2011, 11:35:47 AM
I made the same changes to my Handry - makes such a difference and have not once missed the notes I lost.

John
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Guy on May 31, 2011, 11:43:46 AM

Back to the thread: Another Melnetter I met yesterday ( Guy ) is also thinking about converting his little Saltarelle to a 4th button start to include the low notes. He was saying he's now encountering another morris side's tunes and many of them need some low notes.  It seems that once you come into contact with a tune requiring some low notes, and actually get thinking about it, then it's a natural thing to have done. Well, that's what I did!
Q


This is scary. I'm also planning converting my new little Saltarelle to a 4th button start to include the low notes, as I'm encountering tunes that I've got used to playing on my 4th button start Loffet...just waiting for it to be played in...
I'm sure I'd remember if I met you yesterday, but unless you were the other person scraping rust out of the frame of the swimming pool prior to re-lining it, I think it's unlikely as I'm sure I'm married to her.

So are there two of us?
Guy

Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 12:20:29 PM
Anahata: took your advice from a similar thread months back, just got it done. Thanks!

Guy: Sorry to confuse, yes it's the other Guy!
We had Sheffield City down for the weekend, hence meeting Martin ^^ and over many chats, he mentioned another musician playing with them called Guy. Yesterday we chatted and he mentioned he was thinking of the same conversion.
I immediately remembered your avatar, but was told it wasn't you.
....and yes the coincidence is a bit scary!
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 31, 2011, 02:50:16 PM
I'm not Guy or Guy, but I'm also considering this modification to my Saltarelle!
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 03:24:15 PM
Blimey!
Is this a Saltarelle Owners Club mass decision here..... :D
Q
ps.... are you sure Guy's not your middle name?  ;)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 03:35:44 PM
mglamb:
Was just out of curiosity wanting to check your version of Jump at the Sun.
Just tried to convert your abc's into dots using several converters, none seem to recognise it.
Is it in the correct format?
I'm not used to abc's, always convert to dots so don't know what's wrong with the version simply by glancing at it......
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Guy on May 31, 2011, 03:38:08 PM
Blimey!
Is this a Saltarelle Owners Club mass decision here..... :D
Q
ps.... are you sure Guy's not your middle name?  ;)

It's a condition of buying a Saltarelle that one changes one's name by deed poll to Guy (and adopts a rather posh manner of referring to oneself, looking back at what one has just scribed).

Hence Guy Speirs, Guy Parkinson, Guy Edey, Guy Daniels, Guy O'Connor etc etc....

Guy Guy (I have 2 Saltarelles)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: OwenG on May 31, 2011, 03:40:48 PM
mglamb:
Was just out of curiosity wanting to check your version of Jump at the Sun.
Just tried to convert your abc's into dots using several converters, none seem to recognise it.
Is it in the correct format?
I'm not used to abc's, always convert to dots so don't know what's wrong with the version simply by glancing at it......
Q

I've just tried it in the Concertina.Net tune-o-tron thingy and it looked as if it was missing carriage returns. I've tried to tidy it up as follows:

X:1
T:Jump at the Sun
C:John Kirkpatrick
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Em
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB eBB |BAG F3 |
EGB ^A2 B |EGB ^A2 B |eBB cBA |GAF E3 :|
eBB gfe |fBB agf |gfe gfe |f^dB c2 B |
eBB gfe |fBB agf |eBB cBA |GAF E3 :|
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 31, 2011, 04:18:06 PM
Here's the original G minor version of Jump at the Sun in music notation. The fingering only works for my personalised button configuration.

I can post a transposition into E minor if anyone would find that useful.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 05:03:28 PM
Thanks both, now I can go and compare versions.
many thanks
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 05:04:42 PM
ps.....Owen, your version now works in Montreal Tunefinder, my usual converter.
Thanks for cleaning it up
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: mglamb on May 31, 2011, 05:06:26 PM
Not sure, I just pasted it into the reply editor and used the "Preformatted Text" tag on it - perhaps that's the problem.

I'll try to attach an image here:
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Hasse on May 31, 2011, 06:43:53 PM
Hasse: You seem to have the same accidentals (F/G#) at the bottom of both the D row and the G row. Is this a mistake on the diagram? If not, what was the reason for this?
Looking at the numerals next to the notes, I would hazard a guess that the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row.
Yes, it's exactly as Steve points out the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row. Should maybe have used the Italian numbering system to clarify: G-row F(32)/G#(35) D-row F(20)/G#(23). These accidentals are of course good to have when for instans playing tunes in G with parts in C and A natural minor, and for tunes change around in G, C, D, A and so on. Not that the bass side always works perfectly, when treble side does...
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve_freereeder on May 31, 2011, 07:35:28 PM
exactly as Steve points out the accidentals on the D-row are an octave lower than on the G-row. Should maybe have used the Italian numbering system to clarify: G-row F(32)/G#(35) D-row F(20)/G#(23). These accidentals are of course good to have when for instans playing tunes in G with parts in C and A natural minor, and for tunes change around in G, C, D, A and so on. Not that the bass side always works perfectly, when treble side does...
Interesting concept for the accidentals and I can see there are many occasions where having them in both octaves is good.
However, on balance I think I would still prefer to have 4 accidentals in one octave rather than 2 accidentals in 2 octaves.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on May 31, 2011, 08:17:17 PM
mglamb: thanks!
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: MartinW on May 31, 2011, 11:04:05 PM
Q,
The Guy in Sheffield City is Melnet member GuyWyatt.

Glad to hear your finger is just bruised and is recovering.

Martin
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 01, 2011, 09:35:52 AM
Hi Martin,
Yes, thank you, I twigged that. I've also pm'd him with my change to the keyboard design, as we chatted about it on the Quay on Monday and him taking up New Esperance tunes ( I think....) prompted him to say he could do with some low notes. I then mentioned I'd just had it done!
Finger is ok. Yipeeee!!!!!!!!
Somewhat stiff and considerably bigger, but recovering. Now red as opposed to blue/purple. That's progress!
Not sure if will take a concertina tonight or have to make a debut with the melodeon at a local session if finger can't fit on the 'tina. As it's tunes from all over, ( more a 'tunearound' rather than session thrash ) and on all instruments including bagpipes, I tend to only take the 'tina as never sure what's coming or in what key. Will 'test drive' finger again later.

Yesterday was my first sensible attempt at using the box with my new low notes installed. Made progress somewhat gently, trying to get my head and fingers round having the low notes. Starting to find the low notes in 'Stony Steps' h.p. and enjoying the run from low G up through. Got quite excited! Needs a lot of work, but definitely a 'wow' factor!
To the original poster, am glad I've taken the step and had it done.
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: David J on June 02, 2011, 01:55:47 PM
I would suggest an alternative pattern of low notes for those playing mostly English traditional tunes, where the most common key is G major.  Two reed changes, and one brain change, will give a full scale of G down an octave below the G on button 4 of the G row:

1) change the low B/D on the G row to B/C
2) change the low F#/A button on the D row to G/A
3) in your head think of the low G/A button as part of the G row.

That is exactly the layout of my Oakwood, and was so successful that I changed my Saltarelle to be the same. If I ever get another D/G box it will be like that too, even if it's only a 19 key box like the Dino Baffetti Binci II.

I'm also considering reversing the G row accidental from  F/D# to D#/F
My Pokerwork also has the same low note layout without the accidentals.
I have a Binci with 4th button start, conventional low notes and accidentals. I find that I am still mainly doing the D up to G run starting on the low D on the outside row as you would with a 3rd button start box, so this revised low note layout is starting to make a lot of sense as it opens up a complete lower G octave as Theo suggests. Having seen Anahata's version of Stoney Steps Hornpipe on YT, that also sounds much nicer using these low notes rather than very squeaky ones when I try it on my C/F Pokerwork.

B section of Lillibulero also uses an F natural accidental on the pull as well I think
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 02, 2011, 03:45:22 PM
David: Have just come in from a sunny garden trying to get my fingers round that run up in Stony Steps.
I did have it sort-of-sorted by using the bass notes on the left hand, but to me it didn't ever sound nice and I never felt comfortable when practising the tune. It did serve it's purpose though as i started to learn the tune simply as a bass button exercise to get to know them.
With my keyboard now down to low G I can start learning the tune properly as opposed to using it as a learning exercise.
.....and very nice tune it is too!
Just need to give the tune time to sink in properly ( it'll take a lot of time! )
yours somewhat hot and bothered  :Ph
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on June 18, 2011, 05:10:45 PM
Revised 21 Button Low and Accidental, with revisions suggested by members
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 18, 2011, 05:59:12 PM
That's what I've got..... and still getting my head around the extra 2 buttons, but it is a lot easier than playing G,A,B and C on the basses!
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on June 18, 2011, 06:45:03 PM
Tru-
Any problem with the reversed D#/F, at least reversed from what one usually sees?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 18, 2011, 06:56:57 PM
Ahhh... only looked at the main notes, sorry.
I've got a Tommy and the Bb is on the push, Castagnari standard set up, appearently, or at least that's what sages here say.
Being a bit new, that's the only accidental I've currently discovered so cannot make a sensible comment.
After ~ 2-3 weeks of having low notes they seem to be starting to be used, and 'found' easily by my fingers.
cheers
Q
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 18, 2011, 08:30:50 PM
Tru-
Any problem with the reversed D#/F, at least reversed from what one usually sees?

I have them that way round and I like them that way. Admittedly, I have D# basses on the push and F basses on the pull, but you can also use C basses with the F natural and G basses with the D#.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Theo on June 18, 2011, 11:35:51 PM
I think it depends on what you play.  F on pull gives you the possibility of playing an F chord on the right.  If that would be useful in your playing then go for it.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on July 03, 2011, 01:50:33 PM
Revised 21 Button Low and Accidental, with revisions suggested by members

The treble ends looks ideal, a low B and accidentals exactly what I need!
A question to the bass end - what are the pros and cons for a B- chord instead of a B+ (I have a B- on my present box and use it a lot)
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 03, 2011, 04:39:35 PM
In Continental Mood by Andy Cutting needs this reversal to get the b chord I believe.

Not quite. The B triad is  B+D#+F#. Your B+F# are there in both directions on a standard D/G.  So both ways up of an Eb/F plate 'work' ..

.. of course if you feel (quite sensibly) that you want to play the dominant arpeggio over your B bass note ... there may now be only one choice.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on July 07, 2011, 02:37:24 AM
In making the E minor chord into an open E, I understand the notes should be E and B.  Are there not 3 reeds on the chords?  Should there be 1 B and 2 E's or 1 E and 2 B's or ??  If you take out the third, won't it sound thin?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: smiley on July 09, 2011, 11:35:03 AM
Revised 21 Button Low and Accidental, with revisions suggested by members
I use this tuning with one difference - my low G on the push (D row) has a low B on the pull. I'm convinced that this better suits the rhythm of the irish fiddle tunes I play. And this low B on the treble side fits in with the Em bass.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Microbot on July 14, 2011, 03:31:06 PM
Hi GCF Man, Theo and all,

I was asked to make up an instrument with the layout suggested above by Steve - a Pressed Wood Hohner in D/G.

Regrettably, I now have to send the completed instrument on to its new owner. Having been for years a confirmed '3rd button-start' player, after playing this box for the last week, I have to confess that I absolutely love the layout. It works rythmically and chordally and really adds a dimension to playing, I find.

http://www.onmvoice.com/play.php?a=60367

Forgive clumsy rendition ... I blame that blasted red recording light ...

cheers

Mike R

Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Anahata on July 14, 2011, 07:40:21 PM
Since I got Martyn White to reverse the D#/F button on my Oakwood recently, that's *exactly* my layout.
I can't imagine anyone trying it and not liking it.
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Steve C. on July 15, 2011, 02:30:02 AM
Just had my yearly re-tune-up and am trying out open B in addition to the open E.  It sees that open chords are under-rated.  They are maybe a little bit thin, but opens up lots of fun combinations. Opinions?
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Microbot on July 15, 2011, 10:26:24 AM
Hi Steve,

... thanks again for this discussion ...

Yes, E and B chords, without thirds, opens up possibilities ... and yes again, they can sound a bit 'thin'. There are various reasons and options ...

First off, removing the 3rd and having only 2 notes in the chord naturally makes the chord thinner, although this could also be described as a 'clean' sound and part of the character one is after...

Also, the 'DIY Hohner' method of taping over the reed-slot to remove the third leaves you with just a two-reed chord rather than a three-reed chord... this obviously gives less volume/substance/body to the sound simply through fewer reed-tongues 'on the go'.

Another solution is to replace the third with an additional fifth - ie 'doubled-up fifths', which would be

E/B/B and B/F#/F#

But these are 2 fifths in unison ... another, and even better solution, is to have 'octave-fifths', where the two fifths are an octave apart, which would be

B/E/B  and  F#/B/F#
.
I believe Pete Coe has a D/G club set up with doubled-up fifths throughout, and I have set up a number of boxes with some/all chords with such octave-fifths'. The 'body' of the sound is in no way less than the traditional 3-note chord with thirds, and the tone can be majestic.

The drawback comes with the fact one is driven to octaves/reeds that can be un-comfortably high or low ... for example, lowF#/B/highF# gives a gorgeous sound for the B-chord - the notes are within the range of those commonly used within the chord blocks... BUT for the E chord,... the B/E/B chord tends to 'sound' either rather high (using mid and high Bs) or rather low and sluggish (using mid and low Bs).

Of the two, I prefer the midB/E/highB, but the best compromise I have found is to break with the pattern and use a chord of E/B/E ... this is still fifths only, but with the tonic (ie scale) note of E doubled up. Again, this gives a full-sounding, rich 'open' chord, in keeping with the overall chord/note range of the remainder of the 8-basses... not too high or too low.

Anyways, that's my learning/experience - it's mostly confined to working on Hohners - other makes may well have different chord/reed patterns, and allow different possibilities.

Incidentally, some players also go for no thirds/doubled-fifths/octave fifths on the A (draw) chord of a D/G, which again gives some additional options.

cheers

Mike R
Title: Re: 21 Button DG with low notes and accidentals
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 16, 2011, 04:22:06 AM
It sees that open chords are under-rated.  They are maybe a little bit thin, but opens up lots of fun combinations. Opinions?

I don't think that they are under-rated -- many of us play boxes with switches or stops to remove the thirds from all the chords!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal