I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
They watch TV.
Different? Hmm, don't really see it myself...
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
They watch TV.
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!Well, I know people who are not musicians but have a keen interest in listening to music, and that's their passion! Some have an impressive music library and are extremely knowledgeable on classical music, jazz, etc.
I think we are. Maybe similar to folks who speak multiple languages? I think anyone who's taken the time master a discrete skill to the point of competence is something of a rarity these days.Tried to just 'quote' the bit about sessions but it did the lot. What I wanted to respond to was the sessions bit - this is where I feel that empathic bonding. I was recently at an ad hoc pub session sitting round a table with friends and also some other musicians who became friends - if only for a few hours - very quickly.Most of the others were band members/gig-players, and I felt incredibly privileged to be sat there playing with them, and for that space of time I think we certainly felt different to the other listening punters. Not sure this extends to 'real life', though. If I was sitting on a bus, I wouldn't be smugly thinking hah! I'm different to all these other plebs cos I'm a musician. Though perhaps if I was an investment banker I WOULD be thinking just that. But then I wouldn't be on the bus.........
So, as for feeling "at ease" with musicians ... sometimes. Not in sessions, I don't. Not in a working band (all bands I'm in have ended in disaster ... and I do own my contribution to that). Musician friends over to play ... yeah.
My most "at ease" musical situation was doing incidental music for a performance of "The Winter's Tale." That was amazing. Theater vs. a band ... no contest.
Tried to just 'quote' the bit about sessions but it did the lot.Use the 'Quote' button which will give you the lot, as you say. But then you can edit/delete any part of the quoted contents lying between the "quote" "/quote" tags (in square brackets) just to display the relevant section.
I think we're very fortunate - friendships do tend to be made when people are doing something together, and playing music for a shared goal is a great example. .....Most of my closest friends are my fellow musicians, especially those who play alongside me in the wind section of the Sheffield Chamber Orchestra. Some of us have been playing together for many years and we have developed a very special and intimate relationship in that time. I hesitated a short while before writing 'intimate relationship', as sadly it so often is taken to mean something with sexual connotations. But not in this case, although we are very much at ease with each other and we know the physical cues which each of us make (mostly subconsciously), and which help us perform well together.
.... my long-standing 'music friends' have become my closest, and hers too. Playing music is a good reason for meeting up, and so it reinforces the friendship (though it is also important to have time out from music). I do think this works with bands, too, provided egos don't get in the way of building sound.
... middle aged women who scratch out of time on a bodhran!
Mind you. in a session, I find that if I start a waltz or mazurka, everyone races away til the tune loses its purpose.
I share your frustration. I like to play Ashokan Farewell as a slow air with droned basses, but I have given up trying to do so in sessions because others race away with it and destroy what I am trying to do. On one occasion, I tried to point this out to a repeat offender and he looked at me indignantly and told me that it was my fault for starting the tune too slowly! What can you do?
Some of us have been playing together for many years and we have developed a very special and intimate relationship in that time. I hesitated a short while before writing 'intimate relationship', as sadly it so often is taken to mean something with sexual connotations. But not in this case, although we are very much at ease with each other and we know the physical cues which each of us make (mostly subconsciously), and which help us perform well together.
Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Different to banjo players, that's for sure. :D
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.
I'll get my coat...and I think I might also need my tin hat.
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.
I once read some interesting research on Alzheimer's. Apparently it is virtually unknown for musicians to present with the symptoms. Something to do with instrumental music being a cross-brain activity which causes the area attacked by the disease to strengthen. That's not to say we don't get it…it just doesn't show up as symptoms. So maybe musicians are different in that respect?
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.
.....and while we're at it, will people PLEASE use 'fewer' and 'less' appropriately!!!! GOSH it makes me cross! >:( You even hear the incorrect usage on the BBC these days. (The end of civilisation as we know it, it nigh, surely.) ::)and somethink (sumfink) instead of something...
.....and while we're at it, will people PLEASE use 'fewer' and 'less' appropriately!!!! GOSH it makes me cross! >:( You even hear the incorrect usage on the BBC these days. (The end of civilisation as we know it, it nigh, surely.) ::)and somethink (sumfink) instead of something...
(The record is six)
Bollocks ;)
[thread drift]This is a situation up with which I will not put.
For those concerned about the declining state of English grammar, I was taught a preposition was something you should never finish a sentence with. (:)
[/thread drift]
[thread drift]This is a situation up with which I will not put.
For those concerned about the declining state of English grammar, I was taught a preposition was something you should never finish a sentence with. (:)
[/thread drift]
As for the original question: Musicians are like the rich, only the opposite.
Some people who use this forum haven't had the luxury of an extensive education and might feel too intimidated to comment because of their inferior grammar.I would like to think this forum is an inclusive and welcoming place for all musicians,whatever their background.
Some people who use this forum haven't had the luxury of an extensive education and might feel too intimidated to comment because of their inferior grammar.I would like to think this forum is an inclusive and welcoming place for all musicians,whatever their background.
I've felt fairly well accepted so far :Ph
I'm not sure about the definition of musician though......
http://xkcd.com/326/
So... how about them musicians there being all different, eh..?
Many band players are technically correct but produce a lifeless rendition.
In another two box players made it clear that they met every festival in the same pub on the same seats to play the same style of tunes and had zero interest in mixing with others.
If it's the chaps I'm thinking about its ..
Same tunes
by same people
in the4 same order
in keys others cannot join in with
I agree wholeheartedly with Chris. Quite a few years ago I went into a session in Sidmouth where "No Irish music!" was written in block capitals on the blackboard by the dartboard.
A mixed bunch, musicians. As Rollo Woods observed with a grin, that there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians.
there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians
Quotethere are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians
Guilty
Now there's another question - what is the difference between someone who plays and instrument and a musician..