Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Alan Morley on May 31, 2011, 08:14:13 AM

Title: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on May 31, 2011, 08:14:13 AM
I have been playing instruments since I was around seven years old and got a mouth organ, then started on guitar at 13 in 1963 - so I have been playing for a while....

I suspect that over the years of playing in bands and being with other musicians my attitude to life has been shaped differently.

When I'm in the company of musicians, I feel more at ease and more my 'real' self - is it just me, or is this common amongst musicians?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ray on May 31, 2011, 08:28:10 AM
I think we do a differ a little bit, not too much though
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on May 31, 2011, 08:44:21 AM
Theres bound to be an empathy with other musicians,for starters you share the same passion for music and i think most artistic people are probably sensitive souls
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Bob Ellis on May 31, 2011, 09:08:23 AM
I have never noticed anything about their personalities that sets my music friends apart from my non-music friends. Perhaps the only obvious difference between musicians and non-musicians is the greater passion for music of the former.

For the first 48 years of my life, I was a non-musician; for the last fifteen years I have been trying to become a musician. I don't notice any particular change in myself since taking up the melodeon other than that I am (and feel) older. Conclusion: playing the melodeon makes you feel older.  >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: strad on May 31, 2011, 09:13:28 AM
It's playing music that keeps me young (in my own mind)

Nigel
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Theo on May 31, 2011, 09:34:19 AM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on May 31, 2011, 09:55:01 AM
With me - I think it was gigging in the 60's- four nights a week and practicing on a fifth, that gave me a load of brothers that I never had. The 'beat group' was an extended family. All the fun and the problems and the late nights and booze, and difference between the band and the audience - another world away from my day job...
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: GuyWyatt on May 31, 2011, 09:58:45 AM
Yes, musicians are different to other people, but so is everyone else.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on May 31, 2011, 09:59:52 AM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!

They watch TV.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: squeezenplease on May 31, 2011, 10:05:07 AM
YES.....superior in every way and usually better looking! (modest too)....TomC
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on May 31, 2011, 10:12:34 AM
What's a TV please?  ???
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 31, 2011, 10:13:46 AM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!

They watch TV.
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: GbH on May 31, 2011, 10:19:44 AM
Different?  Hmm, don't really see it myself...
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Guy on May 31, 2011, 10:22:50 AM
Different?  Hmm, don't really see it myself...

No, I don't have a mirror in my house either...
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: zubz on May 31, 2011, 10:23:44 AM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!

They watch TV.
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)

Typical female "I can multi-task" showing off.
I can chew and walk at the same time, but usually end up bumping into something.

I did try playing melodeon and watching TV at the same time once.
It wasn't fully appreciated.
Apparently it "rather kills the atmosphere" of Wallander.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: ladydetemps on May 31, 2011, 10:28:13 AM
I tend to play during programs like 'masterchef' where its all about the pictures and sound isn't that important. ;)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Guy on May 31, 2011, 10:58:27 AM
You can do both you know...I sometimes watch TV and play. ;)

I tried that....apparently it destroys the storyline of "Corrie" (whatever that is).

I had to build a log cabin in the garden as a practice room when we got married....

But back on topic, I tend to agree with Almo's original statement....
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on May 31, 2011, 11:23:58 AM
it works fine if your watching cricket,not when your girlfriend is trying to watch a tense thriller
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: TomB on May 31, 2011, 12:27:26 PM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!

Listen to.. musicians
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Earbrass on May 31, 2011, 12:54:24 PM
Are musicians 'different' to other people ?

Different to banjo players, that's for sure.  :D

Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on May 31, 2011, 02:27:28 PM
I think we are.  Maybe similar to folks who speak multiple languages?  I think anyone who's taken the time master a discrete skill to the point of competence is something of a rarity these days.

So, as for feeling "at ease" with musicians ... sometimes.  Not in sessions, I don't.  Not in a working band (all bands I'm in have ended in disaster ... and I do own my contribution to that).  Musician friends over to play ... yeah.

My most "at ease" musical situation was doing incidental music for a performance of "The Winter's Tale."  That was amazing.  Theater vs. a band ... no contest.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Quebecois on May 31, 2011, 07:03:49 PM
I'm just puzzled about what non-musicians do with all the time when they are not playing!
Well, I know people who are not musicians but have a keen interest in listening to music, and that's their passion! Some have an impressive music library and are extremely knowledgeable on classical music, jazz, etc. 
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Lyn on June 01, 2011, 08:08:27 AM
I think we are.  Maybe similar to folks who speak multiple languages?  I think anyone who's taken the time master a discrete skill to the point of competence is something of a rarity these days.

So, as for feeling "at ease" with musicians ... sometimes.  Not in sessions, I don't. Not in a working band (all bands I'm in have ended in disaster ... and I do own my contribution to that).  Musician friends over to play ... yeah.

My most "at ease" musical situation was doing incidental music for a performance of "The Winter's Tale."  That was amazing.  Theater vs. a band ... no contest.
Tried to just 'quote' the bit about sessions but it did the lot. What I wanted to respond to was the sessions bit - this is where I feel that empathic bonding. I was recently at an ad hoc pub session sitting round a table with friends and also some other musicians who became friends - if only for a few hours - very quickly.Most of the others were band members/gig-players, and I felt incredibly privileged to be sat there playing with them, and for that space of time I think we certainly felt different to the other listening punters. Not sure this extends to 'real life', though. If I was sitting on a bus, I wouldn't be smugly thinking hah! I'm different to all these other plebs cos I'm a musician. Though perhaps if I was an investment banker I WOULD be thinking just that. But then I wouldn't be on the bus.........
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 01, 2011, 08:20:25 AM
Tried to just 'quote' the bit about sessions but it did the lot.
Use the 'Quote' button which will give you the lot, as you say. But then you can edit/delete any part of the quoted contents lying between the "quote" "/quote" tags (in square brackets) just to display the relevant section.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 01, 2011, 09:26:04 AM
I think we're very fortunate - friendships do tend to be made when people are doing something together, and playing music for a shared goal is a great example.  My wife has in the past said to me on occasion that my many music friends aren't 'real' friends - for goodness sake, I know nothing about most of them!  But yes, I do, I appreciate things like when they bend a note, what kind of tunes they like to play, or how they go about writing a song.  And that has been quite enough to draw us all together in good spirit, and I think my wife now appreciates that actually, my long-standing 'music friends' have become my closest, and hers too.  Playing music is a good reason for meeting up, and so it reinforces the friendship (though it is also important to have time out from music).   I do think this works with bands, too, provided egos don't get in the way of building sound.

And all this may even be true of the accordion!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 01, 2011, 09:57:35 AM
I think we're very fortunate - friendships do tend to be made when people are doing something together, and playing music for a shared goal is a great example.  .....

.... my long-standing 'music friends' have become my closest, and hers too.  Playing music is a good reason for meeting up, and so it reinforces the friendship (though it is also important to have time out from music).   I do think this works with bands, too, provided egos don't get in the way of building sound.
Most of my closest friends are my fellow musicians, especially those who play alongside me in the wind section of the Sheffield Chamber Orchestra. Some of us have been playing together for many years and we have developed a very special and intimate relationship in that time. I hesitated a short while before writing 'intimate relationship', as sadly it so often is taken to mean something with sexual connotations. But not in this case, although we are very much at ease with each other and we know the physical cues which each of us make (mostly subconsciously), and which help us perform well together.

For example, I normally sit behind a short distance behind and to the right of the 1st oboeist. As well as listening to her, I know from many years of experience and friendship exactly how she breathes, how her shoulders and head move, when she is nervous, or not feeling 100%. The same goes with the 1st flautist who sits directly in front of me. To my left is the 1st bassoonist. Although I don't see her quite so directly, I am very much aware of her breathing and movements in my peripheral vision, and I know just which notes on her bassoon are going to be slightly out of tune and which I therefore have to match with my own clarinet playing (because it's easier for me to adjust my intonation on those particular notes than it is for her to match to me). And so on. I could give several other examples.

I feel very privileged to belong to such an intimate group - there, it's that word again - and my life is deeply enriched because of my fellow musicians. 
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 01, 2011, 10:41:13 AM
Steve,
What a good reply, and it illustrates how I feel musicians can experience something wonderful through music and contact with other musicians.
An ability to listen to others and a spacial awareness and sympathetic feelings....all great qualities.

And then there are drummers.... >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 01, 2011, 12:32:59 PM
I have known some very good drummers - but that doesn't include any of the middle aged women who scratch out of time on a bodhran!  It's not their fault that a drum is inherently loud, particularly when they are executing more complex rythms - just like trying to play fast on a box!

I find that there are some musicians with whom I feel an instant affinity and some whose style is so different that I can't get on with them musically at all. I was listening to a slow session at Chppenham at the weekend and although I appreciate that it serves a purpose for neginners, the playing of even the leaders was so lifeless I left my box in its bag.  My pet hate is dance music played so slow you can't dance to it!  Mind you. in a session, I find that if I start a waltz or mazurka, everyone races away til the tune loses its purpose.  Haven't they ever enjoyed dancing with a woman???

Rob.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Stiamh on June 01, 2011, 02:01:17 PM
... middle aged women who scratch out of time on a bodhran! 

Nice try Rob. But shouldn't you add blind, crippled, mentally retarded, black, Jewish and homosexual to the description if you really want to offend everybody with a blanket generalization?  ;D

BTW I have come across young women & men and middle-aged men who are totally incompetent public nuisances on the bodhran.

Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 01, 2011, 02:43:35 PM
Mind you. in a session, I find that if I start a waltz or mazurka, everyone races away til the tune loses its purpose. 

I share your frustration. I like to play Ashokan Farewell as a slow air with droned basses, but I have given up trying to do so in sessions because others race away with it and destroy what I am trying to do. On one occasion, I tried to point this out to a repeat offender and he looked at me indignantly and told me that it was my fault for starting the tune too slowly! What can you do?   ::)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 01, 2011, 05:55:15 PM
Do you want the polite reply?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 02, 2011, 06:29:42 AM
I share your frustration. I like to play Ashokan Farewell as a slow air with droned basses, but I have given up trying to do so in sessions because others race away with it and destroy what I am trying to do. On one occasion, I tried to point this out to a repeat offender and he looked at me indignantly and told me that it was my fault for starting the tune too slowly! What can you do?

I had a weird experience in Upton upon Severn last month. The session in the back of the Swan is it seems the hereditary bailiwick of a fellow with a loud piano accordeon and hair somehow blessed with endogenous Brylcream (if that helps place him). In a lull I had the temerity to launch into Teddy Bear's Picnic - a tune I'd been asked to play at an NCT garden party in 1985 - actually looked up dots for in Newcastle library!  I can assert that I've had no trouble whatsoever with it in sessions through the 25 intervening years. Commonly people who cannot play it sing along merrily, and  medley* into Nellie the Elephant keeps up the spirit of the thing nicely.

Anyway - come "picnic time for teddy bears" our Worthy plays the music in  a completely different key! A bit of googling since reveals this was 'original score' - unplayable on a 2 row though my kit could make it should I ever feel the need. Well, this happens. It's usually "NP".  I 'd thought there was something in the mythical session etiquette book about a 'tune leader' ???

But not this time. He -- keeps -- going. I'm transported mentally back to face-to-face singing competitions in my teens as in a macabre duet we played that B music all the through .. about 2½ tones apart.  

Was he having a bad hair day?  Is this a Buddhist reincarnation of Adolf?  Or is the poor fellow just - deaf?  It comes round again. Same behaviour!   Thinking back -  I now regret walking out afterwards rather than in the middle of my tune!  A sound of one hand clapping still resonates in my soul

* they do say that there's no diet like one's own words!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 02, 2011, 07:01:55 AM
Some of us have been playing together for many years and we have developed a very special and intimate relationship in that time. I hesitated a short while before writing 'intimate relationship', as sadly it so often is taken to mean something with sexual connotations. But not in this case, although we are very much at ease with each other and we know the physical cues which each of us make (mostly subconsciously), and which help us perform well together.

I try to avoid consecutive posts, but Steve's concept is so near "The Truth" for me that I have to support him. I have the same hesitation as he in a public forum but have several times discussed with friends what I've perceived as a close parallel between musical and sexual expression.  It's about those unspoken signals, a sensitivity to another's expression and to feelings, 'every time the same, every time different'  I'll leave it there, but you hopefully know what I mean.

Ancient Greeks also had an 'agapic' intimacy which is perhaps closer to Steve's concept - though not such 'common experience' in our modern sense.  As I've (purposefully) tried to move from a wham bam, thank you M'aam "straight through twice - then medley" style of playing toward 'playing with a melody' .. my best moments have been in quite small groups where we have kept something going for an extended time. Some amazing new music has emerged, often astonishing even those who have just played it. 

I guess that we all just don't listen enough?  They say life is a journey not a destination. But how high can you fly with broken wings?

Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 02, 2011, 08:41:31 AM
Are musicians 'different' to other people ?

Different to banjo players, that's for sure.  :D



A very banjoist comment!  I play banjo and melodeon.  ;)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Flanna on June 02, 2011, 08:57:41 AM
I always think that it's the other people that are different, not the musicians. It's weired to think that there really are people who don't play music (or sing). It's a bit sad but they do exist.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 02, 2011, 10:19:15 AM
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.

I'll get my coat...and I think I might also need my tin hat.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 02, 2011, 10:20:27 AM
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.

I'll get my coat...and I think I might also need my tin hat.

You are quite right - I stand corrected   (:) (well sit corrected as I'm typing this...)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: trevork on June 02, 2011, 10:24:23 AM
I find the "at ease" feeling extends to being with dancers. Are dancers musicians, with the body being the instrument?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Guy on June 02, 2011, 10:26:05 AM
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.


Not in Wales...they'd be "different to those over by there"....
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Noodle on June 02, 2011, 10:42:58 AM
Answering the question in the title directly:

No. On the whole I don't necessarily believe we are. Of course there are several individuals who have a big enough ego to believe they are, or they're just naturally 'different', but I think a talent for music is more of a coincidence rather than it being the defining factor.

Then again, a) I'm 22. I haven't had years of consistent experience to be able to answer more confidently and may have missed something a lot of other people have noticed. b) I have a form of autism, so the subtleties or even obvious signs from people tend to pass me by, which doesn't help with c) I'm rarely at ease with anyone, even other musos. I'm sure that's just down to me still being quite green in the folk music world. It was the same when I was younger though, playing in rock and metal bands, and especially so when I was younger still and playing in orchestras.

I still have plenty of time to have my opinion change with personal experience
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Paul Davenport on June 02, 2011, 12:16:30 PM
I once read some interesting research on Alzheimer's. Apparently it is virtually unknown for musicians to present with the symptoms. Something to do with instrumental music being a cross-brain activity which causes the area attacked by the disease to strengthen. That's not to say we don't get it…it just doesn't show up as symptoms. So maybe musicians are different in that respect?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 02, 2011, 12:33:45 PM
I once read some interesting research on Alzheimer's. Apparently it is virtually unknown for musicians to present with the symptoms. Something to do with instrumental music being a cross-brain activity which causes the area attacked by the disease to strengthen. That's not to say we don't get it…it just doesn't show up as symptoms. So maybe musicians are different in that respect?

Phew....now where did I leave that squeezy thing that make a noise..!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Stiamh on June 02, 2011, 02:09:14 PM
Our mother died from complications of dementia, or Alzheimer's (we never knew whether it really was Alzheimer's or had another name, and never cared either). She was a very good musician, a conservatory-trained organist. Long after she had stopped playing the piano, at a time when she was confused about the time of day and we were worried about her ability to operate the stove, my brother asked her to play something. She got out a book of sonatas, Mozart I think, and bro was astonished and moved at how well she rendered them. Not long after that even her long-term memory was gone and she was dead within a year.

Research is one thing. Experience is another. There was my fiddler friend who smoked 2 packs a day and died of lung cancer, and the doctors said that the type of cancer he had wasn't associated with smoking. And my guitarist friend who had been a heavy user of the first generation cell phones (which produced far more radiation than those of today) and in recent years developed a series of unusual (baffling) cancerous growths in the skull, just above the right ear: not a cancer associated with cell phones, said the doctors. Then there is the scandal of all the people dying of rare cancers in Shannon, Québec, where the groundwater was massively polluted by TCE used by a nearby army base to clean equipment: government scientists kept repeating that these types of cancers were not documented in the research about cancers caused by TCE, so there couldn't be a link, and therefore no compensation was justified. 

So take your research with a grain of salt. And keep doing the crosswords and learning new diatonic systems, lads and lasses.


 
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Earbrass on June 03, 2011, 09:41:59 AM
As a card-carrying member of the 'grammar police', may I point out respectfully that we should be writing that musicians are different from, not different to, other people.

Not according to Fowler's Modern English Usage: That different can only be followed by from and not by to is a superstition.
He points out that writers of all ages have used "different to".
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Lyn on June 03, 2011, 10:30:08 PM
.....and while we're at it, will people PLEASE use 'fewer' and 'less' appropriately!!!! GOSH it makes me cross! >:( You even hear the incorrect usage on the BBC these days. (The end of civilisation as we know it, it nigh, surely.) ::)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 03, 2011, 10:52:40 PM
.....and while we're at it, will people PLEASE use 'fewer' and 'less' appropriately!!!! GOSH it makes me cross! >:( You even hear the incorrect usage on the BBC these days. (The end of civilisation as we know it, it nigh, surely.) ::)
and somethink (sumfink) instead of something...
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: ladydetemps on June 03, 2011, 11:04:22 PM
A historical or an historical event?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 03, 2011, 11:20:39 PM
.....and while we're at it, will people PLEASE use 'fewer' and 'less' appropriately!!!! GOSH it makes me cross! >:( You even hear the incorrect usage on the BBC these days. (The end of civilisation as we know it, it nigh, surely.) ::)
and somethink (sumfink) instead of something...

Oh on The Weakest Link - where people get the question wrong - when the should say people got the answer wrong
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 04, 2011, 12:15:03 AM
That is not a completed sentence.  >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on June 04, 2011, 12:20:30 AM
close enough for jazz
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 04, 2011, 12:23:03 AM
Of course musicians are different, they can dislocate their jaws to swallow an object up to the size of a bowling ball and have three testicles....or is that just me?. ???
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 04, 2011, 09:23:50 AM
(The record is six)

An octopus has eight - they can play four melodeons at once
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on June 04, 2011, 10:05:43 AM
I think he was refering to testicles not tentacles
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Theo on June 04, 2011, 01:23:02 PM
Bollocks  ;)

[thread drift]
On my first visit to Newcastle University, many moons ago, I asked the official on the gate for directions.    He pointed along the road to a set of bollards and said "Go along this road till you reach those bollocks, and then turn left"
[/thread drift]
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 04, 2011, 01:36:29 PM
Fascinating!  I was told to turn right at the Agriculture Building.

We might even have passed without knowing it
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 05, 2011, 02:06:39 PM
[thread drift]
For those concerned about the declining state of English grammar, I was taught a preposition was something you should never finish a sentence with.  (:)
[/thread drift]
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on June 05, 2011, 02:09:26 PM
[thread drift]
For those concerned about the declining state of English grammar, I was taught a preposition was something you should never finish a sentence with.  (:)
[/thread drift]
This is a situation up with which I will not put.

As for the original question:  Musicians are like the rich, only the opposite.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 05, 2011, 02:25:04 PM
[thread drift]
For those concerned about the declining state of English grammar, I was taught a preposition was something you should never finish a sentence with.  (:)
[/thread drift]
This is a situation up with which I will not put.

As for the original question:  Musicians are like the rich, only the opposite.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zA4sLyHp4Fw
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Lyn on June 05, 2011, 09:06:24 PM
I wondered when someone would dredge up old Winnie ;)

And last time I looked I had none of either......does that mean I'll never be a musician?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on June 06, 2011, 08:38:15 AM
Some people who use this forum haven't had the luxury of an extensive education and might feel too intimidated to comment because of their inferior grammar.I would like to think this forum is an inclusive and welcoming place for all musicians,whatever their background.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Lyn on June 06, 2011, 09:43:10 AM
WHOA! Actually, what I object to is not genuine ignorance but the general sloppiness of speech which has been creeping in. Not to get into a debate about the transitory nature /development of languages, but a comment on the largely media-led degeneration of accepted usage.

I would certainly not be denigrating anyone else's offerings on this forum!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 06, 2011, 10:18:33 AM
As the person who first suggested (diplomatically, I hope) a grammatical inaccuracy in this thread, I would hope that none of us would ever denigrate someone else's contribution on the grounds of the standard of their English. Having seen this happen on a different forum, I was one of a number of people who left that forum in protest at the rude and inconsiderate treatment of the the person in question. While I doubt whether such behaviour would ever happen here, I hope and expect that, if it did, our gallant moderators would couch lances and ride to the defence of anyone who was unfortunate enough to be on the receiving end of such treatment.

In an attempt to bring us back on topic, I wonder whether one of the ways in which musicians (or melodeon players, at least) are different from other people is that we aere more considerate. Certainly this is the most civilised, considerate and gracious of the fora to which I have subscribed.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Sandy on June 06, 2011, 10:42:03 AM
Some people who use this forum haven't had the luxury of an extensive education and might feel too intimidated to comment because of their inferior grammar.I would like to think this forum is an inclusive and welcoming place for all musicians,whatever their background.

I've felt fairly well accepted so far  :Ph

I'm not sure about the definition of musician though......



Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: mansfieldmick on June 06, 2011, 10:47:31 AM
Love Peace Gimme!!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 06, 2011, 10:48:09 AM
Some people who use this forum haven't had the luxury of an extensive education and might feel too intimidated to comment because of their inferior grammar.I would like to think this forum is an inclusive and welcoming place for all musicians,whatever their background.

I've felt fairly well accepted so far  :Ph

I'm not sure about the definition of musician though......

I agreae wiv wot mik sed goin to sekendry moden skool dint privent me gettin on in da wurld.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 06, 2011, 11:23:45 AM
http://xkcd.com/326/
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Sandy on June 06, 2011, 11:26:01 AM
http://xkcd.com/326/

Brilliant

 (:)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 06, 2011, 11:46:17 AM
EUROPEAN ENGLISH

The European Commission has just announced an agreement whereby English will be the official language of the EU rather than German which was the other possibility.

As part of the negotiations, Her Majesty's Government conceded that English spelling had some room for improvement and has accepted a five year phase-in plan that would be known as "Euro-English".

In the first year, "s" will replace the soft "c". Sertainly, this will make the sivil servants jump with joy. The hard "c" will be dropped in favour of the "k". This should klear up konfusion and keyboards kan have 1 less letter.

There will be growing publik enthusiasm in the sekond year, when the troublesome "ph" will be replaced with "f". This will make words like "fotograf" 20% shorter.

In the 3rd year, publik akseptanse of the new spelling kan be ekspekted to reach the stage where more komplikated changes are possible. Governments will enkorage the removal of double letters, which have always ben a deterent to akurate speling. Also, al wil agre that the horible mes of the silent "e"s in the language is disgraseful, and they should go away.

By the fourth year, peopl wil be reseptiv to steps such as replasing "th" with "z" and "w" with "v". During ze fifz year, ze unesesary "o" kan be dropd from vords kontaining "ou" and similar changes vud of kors be aplid to ozer kombinations of leters.

After zis fifz yer, ve vil hav a reli sensibl riten styl. Zer vil be no mor trubl or difikultis and evrivun vil find it ezi to understand ech ozer. Ze drem vil finali kum tru! And zen world!
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Noodle on June 06, 2011, 03:12:47 PM
So... how about them musicians there being all different, eh..?
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 06, 2011, 03:21:52 PM
So... how about them musicians there being all different, eh..?

Seems like a 'Thread Drift' happened....typical musicians.  ;D
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ollie on June 08, 2011, 01:15:22 AM
I think musicians are different from other people, but then I think musicians are not necessarily the same as those who play an instrument...

Anyone can learn to put their fingers in the right place, in a certain order, at the right time, and play a coherant tune. It's the same as writing or typing. The difference, to my mind, between those who play an instrument and musicians is musicality. This is getting feeling, emotion and expression into the piece of music, and is something that cannot necessarily be taught. It's something that is a natural skill to some and that is what sets apart musicians from other people.


I may well've upset quite a few people there; no offence was intended!

Now, where's that can of worms emote gone?  >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 08, 2011, 12:58:15 PM
I agree that musicianship is a different thing from pushing the right buttons.  It's especially noticeable in the Morris world.  Many band players are technically correct but produce a lifeless rendition.  On the other hand, whilst Jim and DTN are both (sometimes) polite about my playing, I often wonder what goes on in their heads?!

Rob.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Earbrass on June 08, 2011, 03:45:41 PM
Many band players are technically correct but produce a lifeless rendition.

I'm the opposite; I play all the wrong notes, but with great feeling. ::)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 08, 2011, 05:45:42 PM
So did Miles Davis  ;)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Lyn on June 08, 2011, 10:52:20 PM


I'm the opposite; I play all the wrong notes, but with great feeling. ::)
[/quote]

Oh I do that too! ;D

Lyn. AKA Amateur Grammar Nazi (apparently!) >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Gary on June 09, 2011, 09:32:14 AM
It is tempting to think that musicians are different however they are still part of the mixed up world of humans . My visit to Whitby folk week showed up the truth rather than my ideal world where the desire to play tunes in sessions was shared by all.
In one pub everyone joined in  and fun was had by all. In another two box players made it clear that they met every festival in the same pub on the same seats to play the same style of tunes and had zero interest in mixing with others. In another crowded  session I was asked to move because I was blocking a players view of other players.
So my conclusion is that you cannot assume anything until you chat and get to  know a person.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Theo on June 09, 2011, 09:43:29 AM
In another two box players made it clear that they met every festival in the same pub on the same seats to play the same style of tunes and had zero interest in mixing with others.

Haha!  I think I know who you mean ;)
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 09, 2011, 12:07:39 PM
If it's the chaps I'm thinking about its ..

  Same tunes
  by same people
  in the4 same order
  in keys others cannot join in with
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Ollie on June 09, 2011, 04:36:38 PM
If it's the chaps I'm thinking about its ..

  Same tunes
  by same people
  in the4 same order
  in keys others cannot join in with

Mmmm, I know of a similar bunch, only younger and more of 'em.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Gary on June 09, 2011, 05:47:43 PM
Chris, I am astounded, thats exactly how they played !  Luckily Whitby has such a variety of places to play that I found venues where I could join in and feel welcome. I did stay away from the Irish session in the pub by the harbour because at the time I knew my ability to join in was limited. But since then I practice using Mallys cds I will return !
Whitby withdrawal symptoms getting bad , I miss the beer, music, sea food, location, friends I made .

Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Chris Brimley on June 09, 2011, 05:57:49 PM
I wonder if I may make a generalised and gentle plea to sessioners to avoid tribalism, in any of its forms?  Musicians are good at being welcoming, it seems to me.  That's what they can do best.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 09, 2011, 09:39:04 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with Chris. Quite a few years ago I went into a session in Sidmouth where "No Irish music!" was written in block capitals on the blackboard by the dartboard. While I don't play many Irish tunes myself, this annoyed me so much that when we began our sessions in the Sailing Club I said that I hoped that all forms of music and all standards of musician would be welcome in our sessions. Fortunately, my fellow band members concurred and we have stuck to this ever since.

While most sessions tend to have this 'all are welcome' ethos, it is a shame that there are still a few elitist ones that do not. If a newcomer has the ill fortune to attend such a session, it could put them off attending a session ever again.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Peter_T on June 10, 2011, 08:18:27 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with Chris. Quite a few years ago I went into a session in Sidmouth where "No Irish music!" was written in block capitals on the blackboard by the dartboard.

And in the Middle Bar you will find a list of penalties, headed by either five or ten quid for the singing The Wild Rover.

Funnily enough, the sessions at the Ram Ciderhouse years back started as a singers' session, one evening a week. Instrumentalists showed up and began to dominate the session. The singers moved to another evening. Guess what happened? Yes, instrumentalists muscled in on that as well. The ultimate was the guy - now dead - who could bring everything else to a halt by setting up a hammer dulcimer in the middle of the bar and then going on and on and on. Most of us nipped round to the other bar just to chat.

A mixed bunch, musicians. As Rollo Woods observed with a grin, that there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians. As for the guy who listened to me start a tune on guitar and then comes in louder in a different key and tempo on xylophone...that really was a very good reason to go for melodeon instead.



Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2011, 08:32:24 PM
A mixed bunch, musicians. As Rollo Woods observed with a grin, that there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians.

It seems that we have a shared acquaintance.
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: GuyWyatt on June 10, 2011, 08:46:04 PM
Quote
there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians

Guilty
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: Alan Morley on June 11, 2011, 07:52:19 AM
Quote
there are many people who play instruments who are not necessarily musicians

Guilty


Now there's another question - what is the difference between someone who plays and instrument and a musician... >:E
Title: Re: Are musicians 'different' to other people ?
Post by: GuyWyatt on June 11, 2011, 09:30:33 AM
Quote
Now there's another question - what is the difference between someone who plays and instrument and a musician..

A musician is like an elephant - hard to describe, but you know one when you see it.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal