Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on June 06, 2011, 08:30:56 AM

Title: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 06, 2011, 08:30:56 AM
I thought I'd start a new thread about this which kind of got tagged onto my blog thread.

I've been a guitar teacher all my working life.  I've been lucky to have been blessed with a good ear and also to have had a grandmother who taught me to read the dots.  The main part of my day job has always been teaching 7-11 year olds to play the guitar in school.  Several times over the past 35 years I've tried to introduce musical notation into my lessons and every time I've seen my pupils leaving in droves (it's not like maths, it's not compulsory!!).  If you can read and understand musical notation (the dots!) that can only be an advantage but I would rather have my kids playing by any means than not playing at all.  Having used my own system of letters and numbers alongside conventional guitar tablature (lines for the strings, numbers for the frets) I can tell you from experience that, in general, this is the only way with young children.  Very often my kids can only play a single string or an easy chord here and there in a tune but at least they are playing something and that guitar is not gathering dust up in the attic. That's a good thing, right?

As far as adults are concerned, try teaching someone to play Sultans of Swing or Hotel California on the guitar from musical notation - a complete and total nightmare!!

So.... use your ears, your charts, your codes and your dots if you can but by any means PLAY!!!!!!!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 06, 2011, 09:29:07 AM
We've had this debate more than once on this forum, and the intensity of feelings it generates is astounding, particularly among the 'I-can't-read-music, never-learnt, ain't-ever-going-to, it's-a-waste-of-time, I-can-play-perfectly-well-without' brigade. Methinks they do protest too much.

So.... use your ears, your charts, your codes and your dots if you can but by any means PLAY!!!!!!!
That's what is important. I think you've summed it up just about spot on there, Les!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Lyn on June 06, 2011, 09:37:18 AM
Nope, not aint ever gonna read dots, or they're a waste of time, and certainly not that I can play better anyway. I'd dearly love to understand more but it seeps in very slowly and rushes back out very fast!

The important thing is to respect others' capabilities, short-comings, and learning styles, and KEEP ON PLAYING as Les says.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: ladydetemps on June 06, 2011, 09:45:47 AM
Well I use both...can't play from dots without haring the tune...can't play from just hearing the tune without the dots. Although I'm slowly getting better at the reading music...learning the fiddle is helping that....still see the dots as a kinda tabulature to tell me what notes to play but not how to play (I can get general gist but I need to hear to kind of match the tune). When I try to play by ear it takes aaaggggeeeeees can't do it on the fly. Instead I memorize the tune instead so I don't have to look at the dots.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Theo on June 06, 2011, 09:55:00 AM
Several times over the past 35 years I've tried to introduce musical notation into my lessons and every time I've seen my pupils leaving in droves

<snip>

So.... use your ears, your charts, your codes and your dots if you can but by any means PLAY!!!!!!!

I wish my piano teacher had such an enlightened attitude.  When I was 8 or 9 my piano "teacher" got me to learn note lengths, treble clef and bass clef note names, then scales: one hand, two hands, one octave two octave, same direction, opposite direction, no sharps, one sharp, two sharps, one flat etc.  So once I could do that I have all the information needed to "play" from notation right?   Wrong.  I was so bored by that time that I could not take any more. It took me 30+ years to summon up enough motivation to start again.

The grounding in notation is still a useful skill, but I regret that I wasn't taught as a child how much fun you can have with music.  The irony is that if my ears had been opened to some of the things that makes music a great thing then I might well have wanted to learn the notation, scales etc as  means to playing better and having more fun!

So Les,  keep on doing what works!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 06, 2011, 10:07:25 AM
I  So.... use your ears, your charts, your codes and your dots if you can but by any means PLAY!!!!!!!

absolutely spot on Les! its reaching the destination rather than the   mode of traansport thats important!

george ;D
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 06, 2011, 11:00:13 AM
I agree totally, Les. If you are not enjoying it, you will stop playing, as Theo did and many others have done. So it's got to be fun. However, for many people, part of the fun is making progress and this can be done best by using all the methods of learning at one's disposal, but making greatest use of the one's that seem to work best.


I think the dichotomy between learning by dots or by ear is an artificial one. If you learn a tune from the dots, it will be easier to do so if you have heard someone else play it or a recording of it, in which case you are actually using a combination of learning from dots and learning by ear. Similarly, if you learn a tune by ear, referring to the dots can help you to embed it more firmly in your memory and to consider embellishments or other ways of playing the tune.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Owen Woods on June 06, 2011, 11:04:42 AM
I wish my piano teacher had such an enlightened attitude.  When I was 8 or 9 my piano "teacher" got me to learn note lengths, treble clef and bass clef note names, then scales: one hand, two hands, one octave two octave, same direction, opposite direction, no sharps, one sharp, two sharps, one flat etc.  So once I could do that I have all the information needed to "play" from notation right?   Wrong.  I was so bored by that time that I could not take any more. It took me 30+ years to summon up enough motivation to start again.

The grounding in notation is still a useful skill, but I regret that I wasn't taught as a child how much fun you can have with music.  The irony is that if my ears had been opened to some of the things that makes music a great thing then I might well have wanted to learn the notation, scales etc as  means to playing better and having more fun!

So Les,  keep on doing what works!

This is the advantage of the suzuki method. The theory is that music is like a language, which is best learned through immersion, rather than by learning tables of conjugations and declensions and that, like with you, children don't particularly want to do that (does anyone?). So I was taught entirely by ear, was encouraged to keep on doing so and musical notation was introduced gradually by using flashcards and games. I didn't much like it, but it was gradual enough that it was bearable by the end. Yes my sightreading on piano was a grade or two behind my performance, but I had a huge love of music and an ability that progressed rapidly. Oh, and the learning by ear, although dormant for years, has come in handy since :P
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Ray on June 06, 2011, 11:33:55 AM
At the end of the day, I guess it depends on the person. I find being able to sight read almost invaluable, but at the same time I wish I had've learnt more by ear as I struggle to do so now. But learning musical theory does drain the enjoyment out of playing, especially when young, so a mix of by ear and then learning by dots later is most definetely the best way to go methinks
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: rmenhinick on June 06, 2011, 12:00:52 PM
I started learning music theory rather late - in my 40's. I'd always been a "by ear" musician, playing self taught guitar quite happily. Then I joined the church choir with my children (the choir needed more "basses" and needed the basics of reading dots so I could follow the bass part of unfamiliar tunes. I started piano lessons and got to grade 2 before my exasperated teacher gave up on me - the problem was that the minute I had the tune in my head the dots became a blurr and instict took over! However I did learn to read the bass clef enough to improve my singing.

I love the melodeon because it is an instrument that seems designed for "by ear" musicians -  you feel your way along the keyboard and eventually work out the scales and arpeggios by sound, without having to sit down and learn them from the dots. Where I still find the dots useful is as a reminder of how tunes go, especially Morris tunes where you may get easily confused sets/pairs of tunes (e.g. Black Joke/Banks of the Dee/Queens delight which all sound a bit similar to me).  I only need the first few bars written out as a reminder.

I haven't a clue which note is on which button or whether it is on the push or the pull - and I don't care as long as the tune comes out right - I am gradually picking up little gems like the C# sits in the middle of the "D" row when playing tunes in "G" (e.g. 'Girl with a blue dress on') so in time I'm sure I'll be able to recite the notes for each row ... but for now it really doesn't matter.

My eldest daughter is a classically trained viola player who plays beatifully from the a score, but take away her music and she can't just pick up a tune by ear and play it - I know a couple of excellent pianists who are the same - totally useless without a folder full of paper.

Personally I'd rather play by ear ... I've usually got those with me!  :D :||:

Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 06, 2011, 12:45:38 PM
I was taught the dots at an early age, outside of school. However, I was completely put off music, aged 11, by a sarky music teacher and have only recently returned.

I can't learn by ear, other than simple tunes slowly by trial and error. I initially restarted using ABC, which makes you learn the note names but isn't easy to get the flow. Then I went back to dots (but now have to think to get the note names).

Like others I need to hear the tune to know how to play it - especially folk based tunes, where phrasing isn't always obvious from the dots.

And I too find that my fingers get ahead of my brain after a while - I discover that I'm playing a bar and a half ahead of where my eyes are looking (instant confusion).
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Hello on June 06, 2011, 01:05:23 PM
Dots as we know them today are the result of a long evolutionary process.  They're an official, globally standardised way of writing down what to play and how to play it.
This is especially useful in classical pieces where Mozart (or whoever) wrote an extremely complex work and wanted to convey a good idea of how he wanted a piece played without leaving it all to musicians' interpretation.
There were/are strict forms in classical music, with some things regarded as bad musical ettiquette.
Dots are also good because, as well as telling you what note to play next, it also shows you where that next note lies in relation to its neighbours by means of its position on the stave.

Of course folk music is much more relaxed with most tunes being inherited by ear and with a lot more scope for personal interpretation. As such, it isn't necessary to specify how something should be played and there aren't any rules which will be frowned upon.  This means that the dots for a tune in the folk world are really only the barest of bones with all of the meat left to the player.

I find reading dots is actually a lot easier to work with than many of the alternative systems. Not so much for sight reading, as tunes tend to take a bit of working out to get the right basses, but certainly with regard to transcribing or learning something complicated.


Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: GbH on June 06, 2011, 01:45:51 PM
For learning folk tunes, a basic understanding of scales, keys, chords and progressions seems to be really important.  For melodeon players, this seems particularly so, given the limitations and mechanics of our instrument.  Whether such theory is learnt via classical tuition or from more instinctive methods is possibly not so much of an issue, although it probably does help if you have a common language to use with others.

It's definately not the case that being able to read from notation automatically means that you understand the requisite theory of what's going on.  I've happily played inner brass band parts for years, largely oblivious to why the notes are what they are.  Yet, with the melodeon, I found that this approach doesn't work, so I've had to go back and learn some theory in order make any progress.

So, I'm now coming to the conclusion that if you're OK with the basic reasons behind why tunes are what they are, the actual method of acquiring a new tune isn't of great consequence.  Both notation and by-ear work well enough and seem to yield me similar results.  However, when the theory is missing (as I've noticed with one theory-shy acquaintance in particular...) that's when the problems with muscle-memory playing or sheet-music dependence really seem to cause problems and barriers.

Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Neil_M on June 06, 2011, 01:51:17 PM
I can only play by ear, but I think there may be a common misconception held by non-ear players following a dsicussion I had recently. Hopefully I'm not alone when I say that it takes a good deal of time to learn some tunes by ear, it's not instant gratification by any means! Ok, some tunes can be learned quickly but for me it's usually a case of sitting in front of youtube for a good while, getting the tune into my head and having a fiddle around  :o

I may be wrong but anyone vaguely musical should have the ability to be able to listen to a series of notes and know if the pitch goes up or down, experiment a bit (there are only so many options) and copy. This must be far easier than learning note names, dots etc!!

So, if you think you can't play by ear have a go, you may be surprised  ;)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 06, 2011, 02:54:16 PM
I learn some tunes by ear and others from the sheet music, but I have a particular frustration with learning tunes by ear. In a session, someone starts up a tune that I have never heard before. I like it and I want to learn it. The first time through, I am listening to the sound and structure  of the tune. The second time through I am searching for the notes and finding some phrases. The third time through I might, if I am lucky, manage to play most or all of the tune...and then it finishes and people move on to another tune. Perhaps another twenty tunes or more are played before the end of the session. I have no hope of remembering the tune I want to learn, so I ask its name and write it down. When I get home, I find the sheet music or ABC on the internet or in one of my collections of tunes and learn it from there.

For me, this is one of the ways in which learning by ear and learning from sheet music complement one another.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Lyn on June 06, 2011, 05:40:33 PM
Old Time fiddle sessions come in for a lot of flak, mainly because they can spend half an hour or more playing the same tune. ::) However this is a great opportunity for newcomers to pick up the notes, then phrases, and by the end of the session you've probably picked up half-a-dozen new tunes.It's a good method.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: oggiesnr on June 06, 2011, 10:05:43 PM
The point about "reading the dots" is that that is only half the battle, you then have to relate the dots to a fingering, a button or a hole!  So I can read music BUT I can play that music to different levels depending onthe instrument I'm playing at the time.  Perversely my best "reading" instrument is mandolin, followed by whistle with squeezeboxes a poor third.  The latter is probably because I play four different systems so the buttons are different on each.

In reality I tend to learn by a mixture of ear and dots and knowledge of what I expect to happen next in the fingering department.

Steve

PS Tablature (of any kind) is the spawn of the devil designed to show off the cleverness of the writer and condemn the rest of us to a purgatory of trying to decypher it  >:E
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 06, 2011, 11:36:12 PM
Dots as we know them today are the result of a long evolutionary process.  They're an official, globally standardised way of writing down what to play and how to play it.
This is especially useful in classical pieces where Mozart (or whoever) wrote an extremely complex work and wanted to convey a good idea of how he wanted a piece played without leaving it all to musicians' interpretation.
There were/are strict forms in classical music, with some things regarded as bad musical ettiquette.
Dots are also good because, as well as telling you what note to play next, it also shows you where that next note lies in relation to its neighbours by means of its position on the stave.

Of course folk music is much more relaxed with most tunes being inherited by ear and with a lot more scope for personal interpretation. As such, it isn't necessary to specify how something should be played and there aren't any rules which will be frowned upon.  This means that the dots for a tune in the folk world are really only the barest of bones with all of the meat left to the player.

I find reading dots is actually a lot easier to work with than many of the alternative systems. Not so much for sight reading, as tunes tend to take a bit of working out to get the right basses, but certainly with regard to transcribing or learning something complicated.

I think I know what you're trying to get at, but I think that you're overstating the case. It's true that folk tunes are open to interpretation, but it is not true to say that it's not "necessary to specify how something should be played and there aren't any rules which will be frowned upon".

Folk music is an essentially social activity and whilst the "rules" may not be written down and taught in a school of music (well, not commonly), they do exist and they are passed on from musician to musician (and often dancer to musician). This is why musicians can play together (even if they have never met before) and why dancers can dance to dance tunes.

Also, western classical music may use this "standardised way of writing", but there is a huge amount of music played around the world that does not use the same method.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: TomB on June 07, 2011, 12:02:56 AM
I usually try to shy away from this type of discussion but I've just read the post from GbH and I think that just about hit the nail on the head. 'Learning music' isn't 'learning to read the dots'. The dots are only a tiny part of a subject that takes a lifetime of learning, that's the beauty of music. I feel really sorry for all the people who have been put off by   ::) music teachers  ::) who just don't know HOW to teach. I guess I've been lucky, I've had two fantastic, enthusiastic and sensitive people to coach my musical endeavours over the years, who have really brought the subject alive for me. It doesn't really matter what route you take to your musical goal, but certainly, the more you learn, the better you get and the easier it becomes. The best part for me is that I know I'll never finish learning.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Peter_T on June 07, 2011, 11:01:55 AM
"Nothing at all is played as written." from the music section of Hook Eagle's Dance Notes at http://www.hookeagle.org.uk/
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 07, 2011, 11:10:10 AM
I  . The best part for me is that I know I'll never finish learning.


me to!

george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 07, 2011, 11:49:35 AM
Apparently a thirst for learning staves off senility, which makes me around six years of age and rapidly declining!  :|bl Doesn't improve my playing though!  :Ph
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Quebecois on June 07, 2011, 11:55:58 AM
You cannot learn music only by learning to read and write the dots. It's just a documentation system that permits to record musical pieces. It's a bit like a language, you can learn to speak without knowing how to write it, but it's much better if you can read, write and speak it. I play drums in community bands, and it's nice to get 15 or 20 musicians that never played together before, give them music sheets and almost instantly get them to play something. Of course, in a large ensemble, there is little room for creativity, and you need to follow what's written. But as a musician playing alone or in a small group you can always use a written score as a reference and add you own interpretation and style to a piece.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Anahata on June 07, 2011, 02:07:44 PM
...still see the dots as a kinda tabulature to tell me what notes to play but not how to play

The whole issue summarised perfectly in one short line....
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 07, 2011, 03:38:28 PM
One thing that fascinates me is that quite a few "traditional" players were musically literate and we rely on historical manuscripts or folk music collectors notebooks for almost our entire corpus of traditional music.

Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Kautilya on June 07, 2011, 04:15:18 PM
"Nothing at all is played as written." from the music section of Hook Eagle's Dance Notes at http://www.hookeagle.org.uk/
Do they also eat smoked male hams (with bells on) in Hook?
quote from site:" ... Floods mopped up, Virgins cured...."
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: nfldbox on June 07, 2011, 04:31:54 PM
When this thread expands it often seems necessary to repeat: Suzuki string method.
The best way to learn music is begin by ear and gradually add the dots.
But knowing the dots is always a great shorthand. It might just be me, but I have never become stuck in an error when I have the dots. On the other hand, when learning by ear, I have often found a nice groove only to discover that this groove is not in the original.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Marje on June 07, 2011, 04:55:58 PM
I think perhaps the title of this thread is misleading. It's rather like saying "learning a language by the written word versus learning by conversation".

For many (most?) of us, it's not a case of "versus" but of "plus". I play by ear, but use notation to remember and record tunes, to look them up, and to remind myself how they go. I can't really begin to play a tune with any fluency until I have it in my head, although I may use the dots at some stage to learn how it goes. I think I'd be enormously hampered if I couldn't play by ear, or if I couldn't read music.

To refer back to the parallel with language, it's possible to learn a new language from books and become a fluent reader/writer, but if we never learn to speak it aloud and have a conversation, we'll be very limited in our use of the language. Similarly, we can learn a language totally orally, but if we remain illiterate, our progress will be much slower and our grasp of the language more limited. It's much the same with music.

I can see why staff notation is not very suited to chord-based guitar playing, but for anyone who wants to play a tune, learning to read a single melody line in the treble clef is very useful, and really not that difficult. One you get the idea that the tune progresses from left to right  and the pitch goes up and down - the horizontal axis showing time, if you want a mathematical parallel, while pitch is shown by the vertical axis - you can begin to see the shape of the tunes, and learn the other stuff like time-signatures and keys and note values as you go along.

It's not as if you have to learn everything about reading music. You don't, for most of our purposes, need to read complicated scores, or the bass clef, or even chords, or dynamic markings, or how to count bars of rests before you come in, or how to find your note as singers have to. Just learning to read the dots for a 16-bar tune will do very well for most session players, and it's a skill well worth having.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Daddy Long Les on June 07, 2011, 05:02:55 PM
I really like the way you put this and you're dead right it should be "plus" not "versus".  I stand corrected!! ;)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Peter_T on June 07, 2011, 05:18:44 PM
"Nothing at all is played as written." from the music section of Hook Eagle's Dance Notes at http://www.hookeagle.org.uk/
Do they also eat smoked male hams (with bells on) in Hook?
quote from site:" ... Floods mopped up, Virgins cured...."

Well, my wife did say the pork from their [or the pub's]  hog-roast on St George's Day was very good and tender, so who knows? And I still have to explain to a lady from our side why Tony the Side Tart sat on her lap in particular. Not that I know, anyway....

I should have warned that the Hook website provides hours of entertainment and education. Music notes therein thought to be by Gareth Kiddier who used to  play keyboard to Nina[1] Hansell's fiddle and [back towards topic] Ed Rennie's melodeon in the Bismarcks. It's the reggae touch that does it for Hook.

Right back on topic, I started trying to play by ear with no dots whatsoever earlier today. Twinkle, twinkle, etc  from scratch. All fine until just noodling around turned into Bluebells of Scotland which I know anyway. Been trying to get Lilli Marlene in an alien key [not allen key] for ages , and as for doing The Dark Island by ear ...

It's beginning to seem worth me having a stab at something before getting the dots.


[1] Had to correct the Ninja typo.


Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on June 08, 2011, 11:40:53 AM
It's rather like saying "learning a language by the written word versus learning by conversation".
This is a really good comparison and certainly not a case of "versus"
I learnt my German by ear. The plus side is that my pronunciation is almost perfect (and very Bavarian, which probably makes it less perfect!) the down side is that my written German and my understanding of German grammar is awful! But you don't need to understand grammar to speak a language. Musically the parallels are obvious, I'd love to have the intuition and talent of people like DNT (who needs to read music!) but  I don't. However there are obvious advantages of reading music, understanding musical theory, chords etc that  might enable me to improve an get more out of my box.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: strad on June 08, 2011, 12:33:13 PM
I seem to remember that I had a smattering of dots knowledge from school but what prompted my interest in "folk music" was a thorough dislike of what i was hearing on the radio. Anyway, I taught myself to play the fiddle using the dots - learn the tune - close the book and find out if I had learned the tune. If not, repeat until successful. So as I got more proficient as a player I found tunes I wanted to learn but no  dots. This is in the days before the internet. So I started learning by ear. Then I went to live in a place where the nearest music shop was 2 ferry rides and an overnight journey away (one way!) so my learning by ear improved. And so now I do both.

Learning to play melodeon has repeated the trip, though I have more tunes in my head than when I started the fiddle, but I do find it easier and quicker to have the dots available when I'm learning a tune. I don't consider either ears or dots the better, just using what is available.  It's like thicknessing a piece of wood - it can be done with sandpaper but it's easier and quicker to use a plane or planer if you have one.

Without wanting to be personal, is it that one can't read the dots or won't learn? There's only 12 notes and about 6 different note lengths so five minutes a day should solve the problem and then you have the best of both worlds.

Nigel
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Anahata on June 08, 2011, 01:46:31 PM
is it that one can't read the dots or won't learn?

I think everyone has the same innate ability to learn to read music, but we aren't all born with the same ability to pick up and remember tunes by ear. My theory is that those of us who have exceptional learning-by-ear ability don't learn to read music because essentially they never have to.

I learned to read music at school. I also learned to play pieces from memory, which is not the same skill as being able to reproduce something you've only heard. When I got interested in folk music it took many years of playing in sessions and the like to acquire a reasonable facility for picking up tunes by ear. Now I can join in with a simple tune I've never heard before, but 5 minutes later I can't remember a note of it. It still takes me a long time to learn a tune so I can still play it from memory a day or a week later.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Tyker on June 08, 2011, 01:54:18 PM
Is learning by ear something that is natural to the young , and when you get to my age without doing it , is a severe struggle.All 3 of my children can play by ear , though I'm beginning to think that is hereditary as my father-in-law and brother-in-law do/did.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Marje on June 08, 2011, 03:15:26 PM
I'm pretty sure that most people can or could learn by ear if they needed or wanted to. The fact is that in our society it's not a skill that is particularly valued or needed in most situations, so we don't develop it from the start. When we decide later in life that it might be a useful skill, we don't know what part of our brains to engage or how to do without the props such as written notation.

But most people do learn by ear to a limited extent. Think of how you learned the tune to "Happy Birthday" or "You'll Never Walk Alone" or "Waterloo", or any of several hundred popular songs. You have probably never seen them written down, but you know how they go and can probably sing them. Picking out the tune on an instrument is the next stage, but the actual learning of the tune by ear is something almost everyone can do already.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Howard Jones on June 08, 2011, 04:38:11 PM
I think everyone has the same innate ability to learn to read music, but we aren't all born with the same ability to pick up and remember tunes by ear.

I' be surprised if that's the case - after all, imitation is how children learn to speak and later to sing.

I suspect the difference is that musicians who learn to play from music relate the button to the note, whereas ear players relate it to the sound.  The former struggle to play by ear because they haven't learned to link the sounds, and in particular the intervals between consecutive notes, to the buttons, just as ear players struggle to play from music because they haven't mapped the dots to the buttons.  Of course its quite possible to learn to do both, but they require different modes of thought.

Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 08, 2011, 05:09:36 PM
both can be learned. I have  taught several  exellent dot readers to play by ear (  on various instruments) which they have requeste because they can't play at alll without the notation.  I think one of the problems  encountered by good 'by ear' players when trying to learn to play from dots is that often they grasp the tune quickly & can then play it quicker than they can read the dots so the dots become meaningless.. Perhaps  learning the dots whilst learning to play a completely different instrument to the one you know would work so learning the instrument & the dot reading progress at a similar rate?

george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2011, 05:23:17 PM
Well I'm an OK sight-reader now, but for years that was what I would do. I'd listen to the piece a few times and that would get me enough to sight-read it fairly fluently. Which is why I did so badly on sight-reading tests having never heard the piece before. I remember once getting 7/21 in the sight-reading section of a graded exam.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 08, 2011, 05:50:26 PM
Sir Jimmy Shand  is quoted as saying " I can read the music for any tune I know" when asked if he was a good reader.

george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Owen Woods on June 08, 2011, 07:35:24 PM
Sir Jimmy Shand  is quoted as saying " I can read the music for any tune I know" when asked if he was a good reader.

george

Sounds about right! ;D
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Theo on June 08, 2011, 08:14:53 PM
Perhaps  learning the dots whilst learning to play a completely different instrument to the one you know would work so learning the instrument & the dot reading progress at a similar rate?

Something in that George.   I've recently started learning the fiddle and I find it much easier to play fiddle from dots that melodeon from dots.  I think the large number of repeated notes across rows makes playing from notation more challenging on melodeon than most other instruments. 
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2011, 08:58:40 PM
I think the large number of repeated notes across rows makes playing from notation more challenging on melodeon than most other instruments. 

I think you're right, Theo, but that is also one of the reasons why reading the dots (not sight-reading them) is such a useful skill for melodeon players. In many cases, we have to decide whether to play a note on the push or on the pull and this decision is often made on the basis of our choice of basses. Making these decisions on the hoof when learning a tune by ear is certainly possible, but I find it easier to deconstruct a tune using the dots. This helps me to determine which notes I want to play in which direction and with which basses. The ability to read music helps in making and recording those decisions.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Lester on June 08, 2011, 09:09:56 PM
I think you're right, Theo, but that is also one of the reasons why reading the dots (not sight-reading them) is such a useful skill for melodeon players. In many cases, we have to decide whether to play a note on the push or on the pull and this decision is often made on the basis of our choice of basses. Making these decisions on the hoof when learning a tune by ear is certainly possible, but I find it easier to deconstruct a tune using the dots. This helps me to determine which notes I want to play in which direction and with which basses. The ability to read music helps in making and recording those decisions.

Spot on Bob, that is exactly how I use the dots
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Alison Scott on June 08, 2011, 09:28:35 PM
One of the very interesting things I did at Chippenham was go to a pair of pipe and tabor workshops. Despite being very comfortable with dots in general, I *could not* play the three hole pipe from dots even a bit. Once I threw the dots away and just started playing tunes, all was fine*

*for varieties of 'fine' that include 'making a hellish noise that would raise the dead and makes the melodeon seem sociable by comparision'. Especially as so often, the solution to the noise being awful was to *blow harder*. Truly this is a dangerous instrument.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 08, 2011, 10:16:55 PM
[ .  I think the large number of repeated notes across rows makes playing from notation more challenging on melodeon than most other instruments. 

I also find  dot reading onto a DG box difficult  because of the number of repeated notes  so often use a BC (or BCC#) if learning a tune from the dots asI find the location & direction of notes is far easier to remember.
george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Lyn on June 08, 2011, 10:41:22 PM
Alison's comments really strike a chord ( ::)) with me. I must add to my earlier comments ie I learn by ear and find the dots difficult, that i CAN read the dots, so it's not a matter of refusing to learn them. I can 'follow' a simple tune in same way a child might read aloud Janet and John but not well enough to sight-read a piece when I don't know the tune. It is the rest of the theory I find so difficult, Lester, I can read something and think I understand it but trying to relate it to the instrument....well,any sense just flies out the window.

I also like the analogy with language learning..I was hopeless at French because we learned it very grammatically but once relegated to the bottom division(!) which was actually SPANISH I was a star pupil because we learned it CONVERSATIONALLY. Which made complete sense to me.I doubt my grammar was ever up to much, but I was certainly able to communicate well.

So, to recap, I'd love to be better at the theory, but try as I might and I do, I only manage to retain scraps. I am so chuffed I now know enough to hang on to a dotted note a bit longer than the others. This is a great advancement for me!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Howard Jones on June 09, 2011, 12:24:57 AM
In many cases, we have to decide whether to play a note on the push or on the pull and this decision is often made on the basis of our choice of basses. Making these decisions on the hoof when learning a tune by ear is certainly possible, but I find it easier to deconstruct a tune using the dots.

Whereas I am quite the opposite, and find it much easier to make these decisions on the hoof.  The melodeon has quite a limited number of choices and I prefer to explore which of these work (or can be forced to nearly work) rather than adopting your theoretical approach.  Which is not to say that one way is better than another, just that there are many ways of skinning the same cat.

I take it to extremes on guitar, which I play in an open tuning using chord shapes which I have worked out by ear.  I don't actually know what the chords are, or most of the time even which key I'm playing in.  Some people with a more academic background cannot understand how I could possibly play anything without knowing this.  However I do know which fingerings work, and which go together in a way which suits the music I play and my style of playing.  But if I play with someone else I have to figure out the key by trial and error. 
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: waltzman on June 09, 2011, 12:47:49 AM
Perhaps  learning the dots whilst learning to play a completely different instrument to the one you know would work so learning the instrument & the dot reading progress at a similar rate?

Something in that George.   I've recently started learning the fiddle and I find it much easier to play fiddle from dots that melodeon from dots.  I think the large number of repeated notes across rows makes playing from notation more challenging on melodeon than most other instruments. 

This is true for me too.  I can read much easier and quicker with the English concertina or guitar than with the melodeon and since I'm usually playing a three row ADG the duplicate notes are even more numerous.  As others have said, I use the chord structure to determine the 'preferred bellows direction' for each phrase but it's a slow process..... like working out a puzzle.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Steve C. on June 09, 2011, 04:03:51 AM
Tune "deconstruction": that's it exactly. 

It can't teach you how to play, but it sure it nice to know, "what is the tune" in it's essence.  Then you can do it your way to figure it out on your own 1-2-3 rows.

The other totally great thing about "dot reading": you can open up your midi keyboard and peck out any tune "to the dots" and at least get a sense of "what is the tune"?

Once you get it in your head, then go to whatever is your favorite mode of learning.

For us "old timers", the dots are what we used pre-YouTube.  ::)

(notice: geezer alert)

Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Howard Jones on June 09, 2011, 07:34:27 AM
I also find  dot reading onto a DG box difficult  because of the number of repeated notes 

There is a tendency to think that the melodeon and anglo concertina are unique in this respect.  However it applies to some degree to most instruments - on stringed instruments the notes appear on different strings, even wind instruments may use alternative fingerings.  Only a few have a strict one-key-to-one-note layout - the piano keyboard and English concertina come to mind.

Also, on any instrument the process of working out how to play a tune is long and slow.  Once you have worked out the basic tune, on any instrument you then have to work out the most interesting chord arrangements, best fingering patterns, perhaps where to breathe... every instrument has its own issues which have to be resolved.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: nfldbox on June 09, 2011, 09:19:20 AM
Just had an obvious experience: two quite easy tunes that I "knew" from hearing them in a session. The one for which I found the dots I learned in an evening, the other, for which I only have a Youtube, will take a couple more evenings.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 09, 2011, 09:30:12 AM
.  As others have said, I use the chord structure to determine the 'preferred bellows direction' for each phrase but it's a slow process..... like working out a puzzle.

 which is why I am ever grateful to the guy(s) who invented stadella bass!"

george ;D
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 09, 2011, 09:33:41 AM
Just had an obvious experience: two quite easy tunes that I "knew" from hearing them in a session. The one for which I found the dots I learned in an evening, the other, for which I only have a Youtube, will take a couple more evenings.

But then the latter tune  stands a much better chance of being stored in the head for  instant retrieval at future sessions!
george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Marje on June 09, 2011, 11:00:41 AM
Just had an obvious experience: two quite easy tunes that I "knew" from hearing them in a session. The one for which I found the dots I learned in an evening, the other, for which I only have a Youtube, will take a couple more evenings.

But then the latter tune  stands a much better chance of being stored in the head for  instant retrieval at future sessions!
george

Not necessarily. When I learn (or remind myself about) a tune from the dots, I do this only for as long as it takes me to get the tune into my head and start to play it. Once I can play it through, I put the dots away and don't look at them again unless I forget part of it. In fact, I'm more likely to remember and consolidate a tune I have printed out because I have it in my file of tunes and when I come across it I'll remember that this is one I'm working on, whereas with one learnt purely aurally, I may forget about it completely, or forget how it goes and find I can't be bothered to seek out the YouTube clip.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Ellie on June 09, 2011, 11:38:36 AM
Just had an obvious experience: two quite easy tunes that I "knew" from hearing them in a session. The one for which I found the dots I learned in an evening, the other, for which I only have a Youtube, will take a couple more evenings.

But then the latter tune  stands a much better chance of being stored in the head for  instant retrieval at future sessions!
george

Not necessarily. When I learn (or remind myself about) a tune from the dots, I do this only for as long as it takes me to get the tune into my head and start to play it. Once I can play it through, I put the dots away and don't look at them again unless I forget part of it. In fact, I'm more likely to remember and consolidate a tune I have printed out because I have it in my file of tunes and when I come across it I'll remember that this is one I'm working on, whereas with one learnt purely aurally, I may forget about it completely, or forget how it goes and find I can't be bothered to seek out the YouTube clip.

Yes, absolutely! Don't know whether it's because I seem to have a very short term memory, but things I've got the music for can be more easily resurrected at a future point. I never quite feel I know anything properly unless I've got the music for it hanging about. This may explain the large piles of music that litter my flat but never get looked at...
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 09, 2011, 11:46:43 AM
Different people's minds work in different ways, so, naturally, some people will retain tunes better if they learn them from the sheet music or from a combination of learning by ear and from the sheet music, while others feel that they retain better things that they have learnt entirely by ear. Personally, I agree 100% with Marje and Ellie: I am far more likely to retain a tune in my mind if I can refer back to the dots than if I can't, which is why I always write out the notation for the tunes I learn by ear.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Hello on June 09, 2011, 03:51:53 PM
There is a tendency to think that the melodeon and anglo concertina are unique in this respect.  However it applies to some degree to most instruments - on stringed instruments the notes appear on different strings, even wind instruments may use alternative fingerings.  Only a few have a strict one-key-to-one-note layout - the piano keyboard and English concertina come to mind.

I agree. Even the schoolboy's recorder can play the same note with different fingerings. 

The things that make sight reading difficult on the melodeon is that where you play a note on the treble end is dictated by what bass you want to play. I find this takes a bit of working out.
To a lesser extent (and not only for melodeons) is the fact that it isn't obvious by looking at the buttons what notes they play. I mean you can look at a piano keyboard and tell what note it just by looking.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Lyn on June 09, 2011, 05:14:38 PM
...and let's face it - it's a heck of a squint anyway, trying to see which button you are playing!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 10, 2011, 01:04:13 PM
Only a few have a strict one-key-to-one-note layout - the piano keyboard and English concertina come to mind.

Sorry Howard this is incorrect in the case of the English concertina. It is true to say that all of the 'white notes' have a single button but many accidentals are repeated leaving plenty of choices to be made.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: ladydetemps on June 10, 2011, 01:16:01 PM
I get quite depressed and frustrated that I can't play solely by ear. In the folk world I feel like a 2nd class citizen coz I can't 'join in' without the dots in front of me.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2011, 05:29:59 PM
Picking up tunes by ear is a skill that is acquired over many years. I'm still not very good and I've been doing it ages, so I wouldn't worry about that. And there are plenty of folkies who can't either.

Can you play from memory? That is arguably a more useful skill and that is rather easier to learn. Try playing nursery rhymes, stuff that you've known for years.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: ladydetemps on June 10, 2011, 05:34:20 PM
The thing is that's where I'm stuck. At nursary rhymes. And nobody does a nursary rhyme session.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: rmenhinick on June 10, 2011, 05:44:11 PM
The thing is that's where I'm stuck. At nursary rhymes. And nobody does a nursary rhyme session.

Try a session in a nursery  ;D (the kiddies would love it!)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: ladydetemps on June 10, 2011, 05:51:32 PM
*recalling the horror that was infants school recorders*
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: rmenhinick on June 10, 2011, 05:59:32 PM
*recalling the horror that was infants school recorders*

Exactly! The melodeon will provide a refreshing break from all those horrid squeaky recorders  :||:
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Owen Woods on June 10, 2011, 06:23:57 PM
The thing is that's where I'm stuck. At nursary rhymes. And nobody does a nursary rhyme session.

Well, start with Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. Nice simple melody, sing it to yourself and then try to play it. Start on a G on the G row, second note is the D above that. That should get you started ;D
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: george garside on June 10, 2011, 07:08:56 PM
Picking up tunes by ear is a skill that is acquired over many years. I'm still not very good and I've been doing it ages, so I wouldn't worry about that. And there are plenty of folkies who can't either.

Can you play from memory? That is arguably a more useful skill and that is rather easier to learn. Try playing nursery rhymes, stuff that you've known for years.

playing by ear is indeed somewhat difficult  as the buggers won't easily reach the keyboard!  Its more a question of learning a tune by ear & then playing it from memory, which eventually becomes sufficiently honed (all being well) so that some, but by no means all, tunes can be at least partially learned &  sent down the arm to the box  on the 2nd or 3rd 'hearing' e.g  as in a session. 

A very major difference  between the way a tune is learned from the dots Or by ear is that from the dots it is fairly normal to start at the beginning - where else? -   whereas the by ear learner will start with whatever bits are going round in the head  and subseqently, & often gradually, fill in the gaps where ever they may be. It is also useful to listen for repeated (or near repeated) bars eg Daavy Nicknack has only , I tnink, 5 different bars to learn.  Its then a question of playing them in the right order.

george
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: waltzman on June 10, 2011, 08:17:09 PM
Only a few have a strict one-key-to-one-note layout - the piano keyboard and English concertina come to mind.

Sorry Howard this is incorrect in the case of the English concertina. It is true to say that all of the 'white notes' have a single button but many accidentals are repeated leaving plenty of choices to be made.

Although it is technically true that the english concertina does have some duplicate accidentals I agree with Howard that it plays very much like a one note one button instrument. 
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Anahata on June 10, 2011, 10:27:47 PM
Exactly! The melodeon will provide a refreshing break from all those horrid squeaky recorders  :||:

 http://www.suffolkfolk.co.uk/sch-mini-melodeons.html
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 11, 2011, 10:35:34 PM
Although it is technically true that the english concertina does have some duplicate accidentals I agree with Howard that it plays very much like a one note one button instrument. 

Really? How sad! I won't comment further but for you waltzman the concertina years are over  :o
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: waltzman on June 11, 2011, 11:19:02 PM
Although it is technically true that the english concertina does have some duplicate accidentals I agree with Howard that it plays very much like a one note one button instrument. 

Really? How sad! I won't comment further but for you waltzman the concertina years are over  :o

Yes, the melodeon has seduced me away but not entirely.  I love the English concertina.  Perhaps a little clarification of my point is in order.  I'll use the duplicate G#/Ab buttons as an example.  If I were playing in the key of A I would essentially always use the G# buttons near the G buttons and never use the Ab buttons near the A's. (for melody).  I would consider it an 'obvious' choice that I don't have to think about.  So, in my brain when I'm reading music, there is only one spot for that G# to deal with.  With the melodeon (my ADG) the same note may be in three different places and two different bellows directions and there is often no 'obvious' choice leading to multiple fingering and button possibilities.  Feel free to comment further.   ;D
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 12, 2011, 07:27:32 PM
Feel free to comment further.   ;D

I'll venture one reply as this is severe thread drift! I too would generally stick to the obvious notes that match the key I'm playing in, but tend to grab the most convenient if I'm playing a piece with a lot of accidentals. Knowing where the duplicates are and being able to use them on the fly without thinking about it too much is a great help at times. Yes I can see that having a three row would offer a confusion of choices!

So that my post isn't entirely off topic I'll poke my toe into the dangerous waters of learning an instrument from music or not. I would always recommend that people at least try to learn to read music, learning that alongside learning an instrument adds to the load of course but the two are self regulating and you will learn them both at a reasonable pace. If in the end you can't get on with written notation then fair enough, find another way to learn the instrument. One of my pleasures is ferreting through tune books and trying out tunes that are new to me even though they may be very old, now you can't do that if you can't read music.  8)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Howard Jones on June 12, 2011, 07:36:49 PM
One of my pleasures is ferreting through tune books and trying out tunes that are new to me even though they may be very old, now you can't do that if you can't read music.  8)

Although with the advent of computer software it is fairly quick and straightforward to copy the tune into ABC, or even scan it, and have the computer play it back.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 12, 2011, 07:47:04 PM
Hmm - I don't know of any software that scans dots to ABC, but to do it manually you still need to be able to read the music.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 12, 2011, 07:47:57 PM
Although with the advent of computer software it is fairly quick and straightforward to copy the tune into ABC, or even scan it, and have the computer play it back.

I would agree that a scanner and the right software may help but if you can't read music how are you going to transcribe a tune to abc?  ::)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 12, 2011, 07:49:22 PM
Sorry for the cross post Malcolm!
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 12, 2011, 08:03:47 PM
Sorry for the cross post Malcolm!
LOL - wonders of electronic communications.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 12, 2011, 11:33:48 PM
I loved that comment, I think it was in this thread, that a tune will often "let you know when it's ready for you".

Playing a tune "by ear" isn't a magical process any more than any worthwile learnt skill, and as with any worthwile skill it also takes time and dedication to usefully aquire.

The real keys are listening and familiarity with your instrument and the style that you're going to play in. By "listening" I don't mean that you just heard the tune and therefore want to play it, I mean literally hundreds of hours of absorbing and internalising the music.

I spent years in sessions before I was at all comfortable with playing in one. You have to be a little driven, especially at the start when you will sit week after week, month after month just hearing loads of tunes that you can't play and can't remember, then sitting at home going through tunes trying to put them togeter ... then it starts happening, tunes pop into your mind, you can start to recall them, you start humming them absent mindedly as you're waiting for the bus or going round the supermarket and appearing spontaneously whilst you're practising. These are the tunes letting you know that they are ready.

Our band often practises in an Irish club in Leamington Spa and on one evening we came downstairs to find that there was was a bit of a session going on at the bar. It was some of the local Comhaltas people and a couple of us joined in for a few minutes. One of our band members turned round to me and asked "do you know every tune?" (we don't play much Irish stuff in the band) ... obviously I laughed and said of course not, but then had to explain having gone to a local Comhaltas session every week for about six years in the 90's.

Does that sound a bit elitist or prescriptive? Sorry, I don't mean it to sound like that, all that I'm trying to put over is that it takes time and effort, but, is extremely rewarding, just about anyone can do it and it starts with simple experimentation.

Edit: spelling
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Kautilya on June 13, 2011, 02:11:49 AM
I loved that comment, I think it was in this thread, that a tune will often "let you know when it's ready for you".


I am driven on by George's "playing by ear is indeed somewhat difficult  as the buggers won't easily reach the keyboard!  " and Ukebert's encouragement to move forward per ardua ad parva astra.

For me this was a little known tune (my ayah was tone deaf and knew no Raj English..so I had a musically deprived childhood...) but I sense I heard George whistling it as he went home, under a clear night sky,  down the hill in the dark and past the little harbour at Bull Bay, Amlwch. 

So this by ear and without dots before my eyes. BTW, those are grace notes, not mistakes, to give that Lark Ascending to Candlewick and so-to-Bedspread atmosphere.

 It is amazing how in a few minutes with a little prestdigitation one can double the speed of playing...
(The crackling is something to do with the sound engineer, S. Rattle & Co., who was in a rush to get off to a session with a crowd of fiddlers playing Mahler toons..)


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QDdLPgCt_Y
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Anahata on June 13, 2011, 08:15:15 AM
One of my pleasures is ferreting through tune books and trying out tunes that are new to me even though they may be very old, now you can't do that if you can't read music.  8)

Although with the advent of computer software it is fairly quick and straightforward to copy the tune into ABC, or even scan it, and have the computer play it back.

That is absolutely no substitute when you are leafing though half a dozen or more books trying to find a tune whose title you don't know. As with English text, an eye trained in reading music can scan a page at a glance and tell in two seconds whether a tune is "that one" or not.

Mind you, an iPhone app that played music instantly on sight would be a close approach, a bit like the one that can read 2D barcodes off business cards and store the data in its address book, or the one that can hear a tune and tell you what it is.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Guy on June 13, 2011, 08:48:50 AM

Mind you, an iPhone app that played music instantly on sight would be a close approach,


Now that really would be brilliant....
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Howard Jones on June 13, 2011, 08:50:36 AM
[I would agree that a scanner and the right software may help but if you can't read music how are you going to transcribe a tune to abc?  ::)

Fair enough, you have to understand the basics sufficiently to know which note is where on the stave and the different note lengths, but youdon't need to be able to play from written music.

And Anahata is right, you can't just flick through a music book and pick out tunes, which I agree is a handicap.  I've tried this, but reading music without access to an instrument is completely beyond me.  However  if you don't know the title there are search engines which will look for tune patterns in internet collections.

The difficulty I have with reading dots is that, having had no formal musical training, I don't think about music in that structured way.  I hear a tune and I can play it without thinking about the notes, or even thirds and fifths.  I can add chords by instinct rather than I, IV, V.  If I have to, I can deconstruct it (slowly and painfully) but that doesn't really add to my understanding.

Computer software has been a godsend to me because it helps me to read and write notation and the aural feedback it provides enables me correct my (many) mistakes. 
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Kautilya on June 13, 2011, 12:11:44 PM
Find toon just with dots and no name? - phew -- That's a P2C2U for me.
Name and midi yes.

 go there do this but they dont always find toons such as that old E Anglian favourite: "The Thraw Black Craws -- sittin' on  a branch"

http://www.shazam.com/

http://www.soundhound.com/


Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 13, 2011, 12:27:33 PM
[I would agree that a scanner and the right software may help but if you can't read music how are you going to transcribe a tune to abc?  ::)

Fair enough, you have to understand the basics sufficiently to know which note is where on the stave and the different note lengths, but youdon't need to be able to play from written music.

Quite so and if you know enough theory to transcribe the tune that's good enough.

Quote
And Anahata is right, you can't just flick through a music book and pick out tunes, which I agree is a handicap.  I've tried this, but reading music without access to an instrument is completely beyond me.  However  if you don't know the title there are search engines which will look for tune patterns in internet collections.

On a good day I may be able to look at a simple tune and hum it to myself but it's certainly not a well developed skill! I would want to play the music on something to hear it properly.

Quote
The difficulty I have with reading dots is that, having had no formal musical training, I don't think about music in that structured way.  I hear a tune and I can play it without thinking about the notes, or even thirds and fifths.  I can add chords by instinct rather than I, IV, V.  If I have to, I can deconstruct it (slowly and painfully) but that doesn't really add to my understanding.

Computer software has been a godsend to me because it helps me to read and write notation and the aural feedback it provides enables me correct my (many) mistakes.  

I would love to be able to hear a tune and just play it, I'm hopeless in sessions! That has nothing to do with the ability to read music either (having read many accounts of dot readers who can't play anything without music), my other half is a far better reader (and musician) than me and picks up tunes, even ones she's not heard before, very quickly indeed. I can play lots of tunes without music but they are memorised. I can't play anything, even a tune I know well, without learning and memorising it first.

Edit: typo.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: malcolmbebb on June 13, 2011, 12:30:26 PM
Getting horribly technical - but given the technology available in modern kit - I would have thought a application that scans a sound file say four times a second and carries out a Fourier analysis wouldn't be too hard, for a musically minded developer.

The basis - e.g software tuners and Audacity - already exists and can identify selected peaks, both as frequency and note, so it's mainly an automation exercise. If you say it quickly, of course ::)....

Output could be a simplified form of ABC. One could then use a combination of ears, eyes and fingers to simultaneously finish the transcription and learn the tune!  :D
Multimeeja, innit? ::)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 13, 2011, 12:43:41 PM
Multimeeja, innit? ::)

Bill Farmer of this parish tinkers with projects like that, having already created his own tuner as I recall ...
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: East Clare Box Player on June 17, 2011, 05:08:27 PM
I am fortunate enough to learn from other players in the irish tradition.  We go phrase by phrase at first.  Later, as I became more proficient, I could repeat nearly half of a tune after one or two go-rounds. We don't use music much, and the reason for that in irish, is that the notated music, unless if was composed by someone known (O' Carolan, for example) and notated,  is taken from one person's performance at one particular point in time and transcribed.  What if that person had it all wrong?  Hmmm?  So there you go.  That's how it was explained to me.  I can tell by listening if you've learned an irish tune from reading dots or listening to another player, and I'm not alone.  The reason for not reading music as you're playing is obvious.  What happens if the lights go out? 
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: zippydw on June 17, 2011, 10:23:10 PM
The way I look at it you have to know both skills in traditional music. So much is transfered by ear. But in order to work with our less Trad brethren and sistren (?) they only operate on the dots, but view their limitation as a mark of superiority over the 'heathen' by -ear players.

I love when they struggle, I've heard a bit and can show them...'This is how it goes' before they can get their paper settled on the music stand. I not always that good, but the Muse sometimes shows up in those circumstances.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: xgx on June 17, 2011, 11:16:44 PM
... they only operate on the dots, but view their limitation as a mark of superiority over the 'heathen' by -ear players.

Benny Hill had the answer to that sweeping generalisation: A Road of Cobras

Quote
I love when they struggle, ...

a little bit of schadenfreude goes a long way....................

(best to identify foot before opening fire ;D ... especially if consumed by inverse snobbery, init)

back to the topic... learning method is a matter of choice limited by having (or not) the ability to read/hear  the 'music', not to mention an ability to interpret what one sees/hears

subject to the caveat, 'you can't please all of the people all of the time' 
(so it's best to please yourself :-*)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 17, 2011, 11:59:59 PM
subject to the caveat, 'you can't please all of the people all of the time' 
(so it's best to please yourself :-*)

Well yes, precisely. I will always advocate learning to read music if at all possible (or desirable), but not at the expense of excluding/putting people off playing music. Music plugs straight into your soul, it is therapy in good times and bad, a joy and a solace all in one. This brings us back to the message in the original post, get kids playing music and curiosity about the theory may or may not follow on, it's the involvement and interest that matters.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 18, 2011, 12:00:42 AM
.... The reason for not reading music as you're playing is obvious.  What happens if the lights go out? 
This happened to me once, many years ago.
I was playing (clarinet) with the Sheffield Symphony Orchestra and we were giving an evening concert in Chesterfield. As I recall, the last item on the programme was Tchaikovsky 5.

Everything was going well and we were about a minute from the end of the final movement when there was a power-cut and suddenly all the lights went out. We were left with just the faint green glow-worm illumination of the emergency exit lights by the doors which must have been battery-powered. It wasn't enough to read our music by but somehow we just kept going with the music for the final few bars, receiving tremendous applause at the end! The fact that we managed to do this just showed how much we had 'memorised' the music previously at rehearsals without realising it.
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: xgx on June 18, 2011, 02:07:05 AM
... it's the involvement and interest that matters.

It had to happen sooner or later Pete.... we're agreed on that point!

It's all about enjoying the music... the native American Indians  had their own flute ..usually a five hole  bored to the dimensions relative their own  hand...

we've still so much to learn ;-)
Title: Re: Learning by dots versus learning by other methods
Post by: Kautilya on June 19, 2011, 09:38:10 PM
Learning by 'ear' listening when sleeping or watching **TV with subtitles on and toon in headphones or while driving, walking, reading melnet?
i.e. brainwashing

Going even more deaf here with Durham Reel and Gwent Reel midis repeating themselves on headphones for last 20 minutes....

http://www.abroadlanguages.com/blog/amazing-scientific-discovery-learning-languages-while-sleeping_2322/
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal