Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: nemethmik on June 06, 2011, 02:39:09 PM

Title: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: nemethmik on June 06, 2011, 02:39:09 PM
I've read somewhere on the forum that the tune Jump in the Sun was written in G minor originally to demonstrate the capabilities of DG. The right hand side is clear; but, what bass chord can be used without a stop-to-remo-thirds (eg on a Pokerwork D/G with low-end accidentals)?
Is the only way to tape the third reeds in the G chords?
Thank You!
Title: Re: G minor on an an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 06, 2011, 03:17:43 PM
I have  posted the sheet music for Jump at the Sun recently in another thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7019.msg87549.html#msg87549

It doesn't use any basses other than those that can be found on a standard D/G melodeon. However, I no longer have a two-row box, so I have not checked that all the basses can be played on one in the way that I have written them because I have reversals on my three-row box. Even if they can't, it should give you something from which to start.
Title: Re: G minor on an an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: nemethmik on June 06, 2011, 05:41:19 PM
I have  posted the sheet music for Jump at the Sun recently in another thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7019.msg87549.html#msg87549
It doesn't use any basses other than those that can be found on a standard D/G melodeon.
Thank You, Bob. I guess that the lower case g letters are for the fundamentals and the capital G is for chord. I found that the G chord is never played against a Bb note; that is, never a clash of B in the G major chord and Bb in the tune. The trick is then, I have to elaborate a chord pattern where the G major chord is never played along with a Bb, haven't I?
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2011, 01:14:01 PM
Yes, Miklos, you are correct on both counts. The lower case does represent the fundamentals and the upper case the chords and the way I play the tune, the G chord is never played against a B flat note.
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: jonm on June 08, 2011, 01:21:10 PM
There appears to be a Bb in both octaves for this tune, the lower in the A music and the upper in the B music - I only have the lower accidental! How do you get around this?
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Ollie on June 08, 2011, 02:24:19 PM
There appears to be a Bb in both octaves for this tune, the lower in the A music and the upper in the B music - I only have the lower accidental! How do you get around this?

Play it in E minor.  ;)

Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2011, 04:33:16 PM
I think Ollie is right that, if you don't have a B flat in both octaves, you would struggle to play Jump at the Sun in G minor, so E minor may be your only option. It might be possible to fudge it in G minor, but I doubt it. Never having tried to fudge it (because I do have B flats in both octaves), I can't say for sure whether or not it is possible.
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Howard Jones on June 08, 2011, 04:48:19 PM
I've read somewhere on the forum that the tune Jump in the Sun was written in G minor originally to demonstrate the capabilities of DG.

Is that true?  When JK recorded it on his first album "Jump at the Sun" he played it on his B/C/C# accordion.

It may be possible (just) to play it on a D/G if you have the right accidentals but the chord options are severely limited.  The natural key is Em which opens out far more possibilities.

He has written other tunes (eg the Broken Rifle) which demonstrate the capabilities of D/G
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 08, 2011, 04:55:58 PM
Some years (I forget how many) before he released his first album, I remember clearly the first time I heard John K play Jump at the Sun in the pub after a Hammersmith Morris practice, when he was still a student. I am sure he played it in G minor, but I can't remember whether he played it on a D/G or a chromatic box.

What I do remember was the uncertainty he expressed about whether it was a good tune and the incredulous reaction to his uncertainty from everyone else in the room!
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: jonm on June 08, 2011, 06:46:33 PM
I think Ollie is right that, if you don't have a B flat in both octaves, you would struggle to play Jump at the Sun in G minor, so E minor may be your only option. It might be possible to fudge it in G minor, but I doubt it. Never having tried to fudge it (because I do have B flats in both octaves), I can't say for sure whether or not it is possible.

I can play it in Em no problem and also in Gm if you play the B part an octave down but go up at the end. I had just thought that the dots as posted were intended to be possible on a standard DG.

Thanks.
Title: Re: G minor on an 8-button bass DG or GC
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 11, 2011, 10:26:49 AM
So many tales are apocryphal. I can't substantiate this one, just can't remember where it came from, whether spoken word or written...  JK said he couldn't understand why people play the tune on a quint box as it derives from a very simple fingering on the B/C/C# and is far more difficult on a quint.  Whether he had in mind playing it in Gmin or Emin, I don't know.

Rob.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal