Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: brianleach on July 23, 2008, 04:15:50 PM
-
I have been playing for a few months and watching the posts on here with interest. Not bad on the right hand now but very poor on the left. Much more practice needed!!
However on Sunday I took part in the folk orchestra at the Proms which was good fun although the D/G wasn't altogether an asset as a couple of the tunes were in a different key. However on looking at the photos of the event I see that whilst the other experienced player Andy is resting the box on his left knee I rest mine on my right knee.
Is this just personal preference or is there a right and a wrong knee??
Best wishes,
Brian Leach
-
Is this just personal preference or is there a right and a wrong knee??
No just a right and left knee. They are your knees you can pick whichever you want ;D
Sorry, being serious, if you have the instrument too far to the right of your body your right arm has to be bent back from the shoulder, and your wrist will be bent too, both of which can be uncomfortable, or even painful after a while. Aim to have the treble buttons roughly on the centre line of your body, or further to the right for a relaxed right arm and wrist.
Using two straps is worth trying too then you don't have to use any knees, can stand up or sit down and generally be much freer. In the end you have to find out what works for you.
-
Using two straps is worth trying too then you don't have to use any knees, can stand up or sit down and generally be much freer. In the end you have to find out what works for you.
Or use a single strap then you don't have to use any knees, can stand up or sit down and generally be much freer. In the end you have to find out what works for you.
You will find one of the things we fight about discuss in this forum is two straps good, one strap bad or vice versa.
-
Using two straps is worth trying too then you don't have to use any knees, can stand up or sit down and generally be much freer. In the end you have to find out what works for you.
Or use a single strap then you don't have to use any knees, can stand up or sit down and generally be much freer. In the end you have to find out what works for you.
You will find one of the things we fight about discuss in this forum is two straps good, one strap bad or vice versa.
Lester, I take my hat off to you and anyone else who can play standing with one strap. I could never get enough control over the box to play with one strap while standing. I think it looks funny too ;D ;D tee hee
-
I'm too new to be getting into this one strap/two strap thing but the right knee seemed more natural to me. I think that this is because I seem to have more control of the bellows when my arm is closer to my body rather than stretching if you see what I mean. Perhaps even that might change as I hopefully get better.
Thanks for your views.
Brian
-
I'm too new to be getting into this one strap/two strap thing but the right knee seemed more natural to me. I think that this is because I seem to have more control of the bellows when my arm is closer to my body rather than stretching if you see what I mean. Perhaps even that might change as I hopefully get better.
Thanks for your views.
Brian
Same here, Brian, the right knee seems better for me too. I tried the left but it just wasn't comfortable. But I will persevere if that is what seasoned professionals recommend!
I haven't tried two straps yet, still trying to remember whether I have to push or pull to get the right note! Still its only a 50/50 choice :-\ I'm sure I'll get there
-
Same here, Brian, the right knee seems better for me too. I tried the left but it just wasn't comfortable. But I will persevere if that is what seasoned professionals recommend!
I don't see anyone here saying there is a right way to hold the box, or even one recommended way. But what is important I think is to try out the main alternatives in order to find what suits you best
-
Same here, Brian, the right knee seems better for me too. I tried the left but it just wasn't comfortable.
I normally play standing, with 2 straps, but on the odd occasion I play sitting, I play with it semi-balanced on my left knee, but you have to sit slightly twisted in order to do so. But then I generally sit slightly twisted anyway :D
-
probably one reason for resting the box on the left knee is to avoid damage to the bellows from friction with leg/trousers. The bellows tape wears very easily & is not intended to be in contact with anything other than fresh air. A lot of new(ish) players extend the bellows far more than is necessary which of course means arm right out if resting on left knee. It is also important to keep the left knee facing straight ahead rather than 22% to port. It should then be possible to play comfartably with both elbows at the side of your body .
My personal prefered position is to use two straps sitting or standing. No adjustment is needed between the two positions if you set the straps so that the top of the box is about a spread hands width bellow chin when looking straight ahead i.e. thumb under chin, stretched little finger just touching top of box.
As Theo said there is no one correct positionso experiment. But don't forget the box is a machine and needs to be in a position where you can operate all the knobs & handles with minimum effort & with the certainty that they are always in the same place!. The same goes for the human body - it is more comfortable vertical with elbows at side than lookin as if its having flying lessons!. You can of course not bother about any of that anad go for a bellows waving flamoyanat effect! at which point I'll duck to avaoid the bullets :o
George ( a tight squeezer!!) ;)
-
Thanks for the input. I think the position results from my style of playing. As I am
not very good useless at the rhythms I tend to play long chords in the left hand alongside the melody in the right. This usually involves cross rowing and a lot of air ie bellows at full stretch. I suspect this is not a good plan because as has been said the bellows do occasionally catch on the left knee. More suggestions from the experts please other than do more practice!!
Brian
-
This usually involves cross rowing and a lot of air ie bellows at full stretch. I suspect this is not a good plan because as has been said the bellows do occasionally catch on the left knee. More suggestions from the experts please other than do more practice!!
Brian
It could be that your air button technique needs some work to get your bellows right in before a long out passage.
-
Not an expert Brian, as you well know, but might it be worth just forgetting the bass end for a while and concentrating on getting the rhythm right in the right hand first? Perhaps practising tunes just on one row rather than cross-rowing?
I find that as soon as I add in basses I find it very hard to keep them staccato, and subsequently end up with the bellows too open - but I'm working on it, staccato on the basses does sound good if you can manage it!
-
Not an expert Brian, as you well know, but might it be worth just forgetting the bass end for a while and concentrating on getting the rhythm right in the right hand first? Perhaps practising tunes just on one row rather than cross-rowing?
spot on Ellie. The bass is there to provide accompanyiment to the rhythm thats already there in the melody. If rhythm isn't inherent in the way the melody is played the bass has bugger all to accompany!
george
-
I am afraid that is what I am doing!
I am very happy playing tunes in the right hand in either row or both but the temptation when practising is to concentrate on improving what you can do rather than banging about in the basses making a hash of it. Somehow that just seems to be learning half the instrument, hence my inclusion of the long basses which at least gives the impression of using both sides!!. Or is that too simplistic a view?
Brian
-
If you want some real fun try playing some simple tunes on the bass only(ignore the chords for this exercise). On a standard D/G bass you have all but one of the notes of the G scale, and they are all available on the same bellows direction as on the G row. It may help to start with a scale on the bass, then a really simple tune. It will give you new insight into the left side.
-
Brian,
I've found from the very beginning it's best to learn the basses at the same time as the right hand, it might seem to complicate matters but it's worth the effort. (It also means you come up to alternative ways to play - bellows direction for example - as you go along as opposed to learn the tune one way then have to re-learn it to do something easier, more interesting or musical.
-
If you want some real fun try playing some simple tunes on the bass only(ignore the chords for this exercise). On a standard D/G bass you have all but one of the notes of the G scale, and they are all available on the same bellows direction as on the G row. It may help to start with a scale on the bass, then a really simple tune. It will give you new insight into the left side.
Donkey Riding fits really well
-
Thanks for that Theo. I can play Shepherds Hey rather ponderously so perhaps I should widen my range!! I'll give Donkey riding a go if you see what I mean!
I'm sure your right Dazbo but my coordination is pretty poor and my sight reading isn't up to much either so unless I can hear what it's supposed to sound like it all becomes a bit of a stop start mess. I suppose that's what practise is for but unless you know what you're aiming for it's not easy.
Brian
-
If you want some real fun try playing some simple tunes on the bass only(ignore the chords for this exercise). On a standard D/G bass you have all but one of the notes of the G scale, and they are all available on the same bellows direction as on the G row. It may help to start with a scale on the bass, then a really simple tune. It will give you new insight into the left side.
Donkey Riding fits really well
Something new and exciting to try tonight then ;D At least I know what it's supposed to sound like! :D
-
I found that it was easiest to start integrating the basses with tunes that were built around arpeggios rather than scales, as it meant that I only had to worry about co-ordinating my left and right hands and not the bellows as well.
Once you can do this, another trick is to try and sneak up on tunes and take them by surprise! I've found that if I play a tune which I find the basses more difficult to play directly after playing a tune I'm OK with, the basses often work themselves out!
Hope with helps,
Owen
-
I guess in the end it all comes down to the right sort of practise and watching more experienced players.
Hopefully I shall get plenty of time for the latter at Melodeons at Witney in November.
Brian
-
I found that it was easiest to start integrating the basses with tunes that were built around arpeggios rather than scales, as it meant that I only had to worry about co-ordinating my left and right hands and not the bellows as well.
Owen
This type of practice helped me through the waltz bass, this advice came form a workshop at a festival which for me learing in isolation (long before the melodeon.net) proved informative and good for motivation.
For the Waltz I started with I R/H note per bass note, with the bellows going in one direction, for several bars and then reversed the bellows. Next I gradually expanded for different combinations of bellows and note patterns and then on to putting them together into musical sounding sequences. The key is to keep the bass end going in time and practice until the R/H end fits.
It's simple just practice, practice and then practice.
As the old saying gos "You are lucky to be able to play so well, yes and the more I practice the luckier I get"