Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Nick Hudis on June 08, 2011, 10:49:56 PM

Title: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 08, 2011, 10:49:56 PM
Well I went to see Theo today and came back as the owner of a pretty basic but perfectly playable 1 row. Nice sound, bright but mellow and not too wet.

Given that my entire playing career so far as been spent on big Hohner Clubs and for  the last year and a bit a lovely Loffet 3 row 18 bass, the one row is a strange beast indeed. 

First issue is how do you hold it?  With the big boxes I  strap them on with 2 straps and a cross strap and they feel nice and secure.  But the little one row with its single strap jiggles around with each push or pull.

How useful is the thumb strap?  To me it seems to just restrict easy movement up and down the keyboard.

Is there an accepted way of getting the left hand comfortable?  I seem to have to grip the bass end between the heel of my hand and the middle and ring fingers leaving the pinky and index to play the buttons. This doesn't seem very relaxed.  How to you cope with an air button that is under the heel of the hand rather than the thumb? 

Despite all this  I've a a fun afternoon with my copy of Before The Night Was Out.  Learn from the masters! Managed to scramble my way through "Oh Joe the boat is going over" and the Yarmouth Hornpipe.

So any arcane one row specific advice would be most welcome

Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: ladydetemps on June 08, 2011, 11:00:01 PM
I hold it different every time I pick one up...and it always tries to leap out my hands.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 09, 2011, 06:44:51 AM
[quoteI hold it different every time I pick one up...and it always tries to leap out my hands.][/quote]

Lively little devils aren't they?
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Anahata on June 09, 2011, 08:13:18 AM
I use the thumb strap and a single shoulder strap.
Many players manage with thumb strap only.
Left hand I do much as you, holding it with middle fingers and using outer fingers on the levers. You can do that in a way that lets you use your thumb on the air button.

I very rarely play it standing up, which avoids some of the problems.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Lester on June 09, 2011, 08:19:22 AM
First issue is how do you hold it?  With the big boxes I  strap them on with 2 straps and a cross strap and they feel nice and secure.  But the little one row with its single strap jiggles around with each push or pull.

All answers assume a Hohner 1 Row.

I use a single strap and have my palm on the edge of the keyboard thumb on the back, this seems to anchor it OK, plus if it's good enough for John Kirkpatrick it's good enough for me.

Quote
How useful is the thumb strap?  To me it seems to just restrict easy movement up and down the keyboard.

When playing sat down I sometimes use just the thumb strap but if using a shoulder strap I never use it

Quote
Is there an accepted way of getting the left hand comfortable?  I seem to have to grip the bass end between the heel of my hand and the middle and ring fingers leaving the pinky and index to play the buttons. This doesn't seem very relaxed.  How to you cope with an air button that is under the heel of the hand rather than the thumb?  

I don't grip the bass end at all, I lpace  my thumb on the back of the keyboard above the air spoon and all the others stick out the front when not pressing a spoon. I use my ring and first fingers to play the spoons.

A largish stomach seems to help (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlbsnRVn1dA)

Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Anahata on June 09, 2011, 08:37:15 AM
A largish stomach seems to help (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlbsnRVn1dA)

That might explain why my playing's improved over the years  ;)
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: ladydetemps on June 09, 2011, 09:14:01 AM
A largish stomach seems to help (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlbsnRVn1dA)

That might explain why my playing's improved over the years  ;)

And why I struggle. :P  :|||:
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Hello on June 09, 2011, 11:39:46 AM
I play it with a single strap. I find it helps to have the strap longer so that it hangs nearer to the waistline that if you were using two straps. Sometimes angling the instrument forward so that it leans away from you helps to stead it.
I use index an pinkie for spoons and lower part of thumb for the air spoon. I find you need to work the air valve a lot more with these type of boxes.  Generally my hand doesn't go as far through the bass strap as with a multi bass instrument.
I ignore the thumb strap and usually use the Morris clench on the right hand, or if playing in the upper octave have the edge of the button board resting in the crook between index finger and thumb. That way you can keep the strap taut and retain control.

I actually found the concertina worst for wiggling about. I ended up writhing around the room as it felt like it was trying to get away.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 09, 2011, 12:24:09 PM
I found it impossible to fit two straps to a 4-stop, so the essence of control is placing the thumb behind the keyboard and pushing forward against the strap - rather like tensioning a single point sling on a rifle (good principle for holding a camera steady, too).

The left hand requires the strap to be the right length for you.  Ideally, it should allow you to slide your hand in easily so it becomes comfortably tight as you curl your fingers round to the spoons.  Having small hands, I often operate the air spoon with the root of my thumb, though I find it best to use it as little as possible.

Rob.

Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 09, 2011, 12:48:00 PM
I haven't been playing a four-stop one-row for very long - I have a Junior Martin Cajun box in C. Like you, Nick, I had difficulty in holding it comfortably at first, but by trial and error and plenty of practice I seem to be getting more comfortable with it.

I always play sitting down and I use a shoulder strap that is long enough to angle the box forward a little. I also use the thumb strap and, after some trial and error, fixed on a method of putting the thumb through the strap and twisting it round so that it sits firmly on the edge of the fingerboard in such a way that the thumb strap remains in tension and my thumb anchors the right hand end of the box securely.

I don't put my left hand as far through the bass end strap as I do with my three-row boxes so that the bass of my thumb is in the right position to operate the air button comfortably. I play the basses with my index finger and my little finger because I have fairly small hands. I find that I tense up if I try to grip the protruding bass bar with my second and third fingers, so I let them waggle freely.

This works for me, but it does not hold the box quite as firmly as I am able to do with my three-row boxes. Nevertheless, I find it reasonably comfortable and quite playable using this method.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 09, 2011, 01:03:24 PM
.....I play the basses with my index finger and my little finger because I have fairly small hands. I find that I tense up if I try to grip the protruding bass bar with my second and third fingers, so I let them waggle freely.

Ah that's interesting, Bob. I found just the opposite. Once I started using my spare fingers to grip the bass-end box, everything stabilised nicely, even when standing. But - as you say - we all find our own individual way of managing the instrument.

I found it impossible to fit two straps to a 4-stop.....
Um.... why - what is the problem?
I have three 1-row 4-stop instruments - all slightly different design, but I have the facility to put two straps on each of them. I use a standard Hohner double strap bracket on my Hohner 1-row 4-stop in G, and a ring-type bracket on my other two instruments. When playing standing up, I like to use two straps, but for sitting down I will use one strap or sometimes even none.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 09, 2011, 03:35:31 PM
One of the things I love about the box, is everyone does their own thing.  I recently treated a well known German classical violin teacher who could tell by watching any player what "school" they had been taught in.  Needless to say his method was the best.

Thanks for lots of ideas.  My box which is probably Eastern European, looks similar to a Welty Cajun and has big buttons rather than spoons.  The air button seems to sit under the thenar eminence to give it its correct anatomical term, or the fleshy pad at the bass of the thumb.  Its a totally different feel to a 3 Row.  Next step is to experiment with the tension of the left hand strap.  On my 3 Row I keep on the loose side, but this doesn't seem to work for the 1 row.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Tufty on June 09, 2011, 08:22:17 PM
I always use the thumb strap on the one row, although I never do with other boxes. All of the traditional players seem to have used it and Tufty Swift recommended it. For me it just seems to help get the sound I want, which is very different from what I want out of a two row.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Andy Next Tune on June 09, 2011, 10:01:50 PM
Now using my G 4 stop for morris a lot more to balance the Costalotti sound.
So finding I'm now playing single strap with thumb strap when standing, and mainly without thumb strap if parked on a seat.

But definitely try playing some tunes just on the thumb strap - surprising the different feel it gives to a tune.

Left hand - needed to pick a box up to find out what I did.....
Basically 'anchor it' using pressure from thumb and little finger, combined with strap itself.
Air button - lean on it with base of thumb. Bass spoons, first and ring finger.
And I'm sure that all changes at times.

Andy
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 10, 2011, 12:06:42 AM
To see how to play a one-row without using a shoulder strap, check out the second programme in the World Accordion to Phil series, in which Marc Savoy can be seen to good effect playing one of his own Cajun boxes.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: mrdibbs on June 10, 2011, 12:15:11 AM
I´m new to the one row box as well, and I have found that it is important to keep the thing as anchored down as possible... meaning, don´t let the box itself move around.ç

If you can cross your right leg over and brace it against your inner thigh, that would help too... i saw that someone else mentioned leaning it forwards a bit- I do this a bit as well, which puts some tension on the shoulder strap to keep it in place better!
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Rob2Hook on June 11, 2011, 10:38:29 AM
I found it impossible to fit two straps to a 4-stop.....
Um.... why - what is the problem?
I

Well, yes, Steve.  I should have said I couldn't do it effectively.  I did manage to get two straps on it, eventually, but there's precious little space for a double strap bracket and I didn't find it stabilised it like it does with a two row - the box is just so narrow it waggles around using the straps as a pivot!  Also, with two straps I had the box up on my chest and that made it uncomfortable to press forward to control it (too great an angle on the wrist).

Nice timing for this post, though.  I must make a phone call to see if I can borrow my Max back for the local village fete today - apparently it has been touring in Germany with Random.  Hope it has picked up a few new polkas!

Rob.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 11, 2011, 11:14:21 AM
3 days into one row ownership and I am happy as a pig in sh**.  Sitting with left leg over right with the accordion braced against my right thigh and the shoulder strap for extra security seems to work.  Left hand is happier now I've got the wrist strap right.

I've spent a lot of time I should have been working, playing through Oscar Woods and Percy Brown favorites and dipping into some Quebecois tunes I downloaded.  It is a fascinating experience playing music that was conceived totally around the one row concept as opposed to the cross row style I am used to.  I sense I am going to have a completely different relationship with all my boxes from now on.

Have to start saving for a Wesson Clipper or similar quality one row, or maybe one in C and one in D.............
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Anahata on June 12, 2011, 09:24:56 AM
I've spent a lot of time I should have been working, playing through Oscar Woods and Percy Brown favorites and dipping into some Quebecois tunes I downloaded.  It is a fascinating experience playing music that was conceived totally around the one row concept as opposed to the cross row style I am used to.  I sense I am going to have a completely different relationship with all my boxes from now on.

Have to start saving for a Wesson Clipper or similar quality one row, or maybe one in C and one in D.............

At least! The East Anglian polkas go well with the the Hohner bass growl; the Quebecois will benefit from the speed of a Castagnari Max,  a Wesson Clipper or similar high end box. You can't have too many 1-rows!


Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: mory on June 12, 2011, 10:05:44 AM
Theres a wealth of real expert guidance in the form of you tube vids, its quite easy to have a look and then try and emulate the couple of different forms, after that I think as with most of this stuff its just a question of familiarity. Try, try and try again seems to work for most, being a bit obsessive compulsive seems to help too and as I understand you have already suffered from M.A.D a sure fire indicator of the former, good luck and good practice. mory
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: OwenG on June 12, 2011, 12:51:42 PM
One thing that I've found that helps with stability and also with all round one-row playing is to ensure that you've got good control over your bellows and don't waggle them around too much.

What I try and do, and I'm sure the advice was on here somewhere, is to use the bellows like a hinge to squeeze the air over the reads. I imagine that I'm holding a book by the covers with the spine furthest away from me and am opening and closing it using my left hand; this way you find you get the control from your upper arm rather than your wrist. When you need extra air you can use the air button to shoot out a bit before working your way back in.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 12, 2011, 10:00:16 PM
Quote
use the bellows like a hinge to squeeze the air over the reads

That makes a HUGE difference.  Its radically different to what I've done before.  On the 3 row box, I hinge the bellows from the bottom and, playing a lot on the pull, just let it open with gravity.  On the one row I'd got into the habit of pumping the bellows which was hard work on the left arm and made the whole box jump around.

Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 12, 2011, 10:47:43 PM
One thing that I've found that helps with stability and also with all round one-row playing is to ensure that you've got good control over your bellows and don't waggle them around too much.

What I try and do, and I'm sure the advice was on here somewhere, is to use the bellows like a hinge to squeeze the air over the reads. I imagine that I'm holding a book by the covers with the spine furthest away from me and am opening and closing it using my left hand; this way you find you get the control from your upper arm rather than your wrist. When you need extra air you can use the air button to shoot out a bit before working your way back in.

I've had to try that because it seems to me to be a pretty strange way to use the bellows on a one row. The whole essence of one row playing to me is getting that that "bounce" in the bellows. Get a solid hold on the left-hand end (not a death grip!) and a relaxed left arm that can do the rapid bellows changes needed. Every bellows change is just a prelude to the next change, and as for the use of the air button. Well, it defies description. I'm not sure that can be taught, it really has to be experienced. I use it pretty much all the time, making little adjustments, releasing it on longer runs in one direction, for volume, rythmic effects and bellows control etc. For instance, in quick in-out-in-out runs it can smooth out the volume changes, keep better control of the bellows and help you relax.

I think that being able to relax is the key. Tension in the shoulder, arm and wrist really kill everything and you end up tired and and sore. Those who try too hard tense up and the muscles start working against each other. There is no fluidity in the movement and the bellows changes become more difficult.

Edit: removed stray word.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: OwenG on June 13, 2011, 08:55:49 AM

Oh well, it works for me. I guess the point is ensuring that you are in control of the bellows.


I think that being able to relax is the key. Tension in the shoulder, arm and wrist really kill everything and you end up tired and and sore. Those who try too hard tense up and the muscles start working against each other. There is no fluidity in the movement and the bellows changes become more difficult.


Definitely.
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 14, 2011, 12:36:21 PM
One row adventure temporarily suspended because a pallet just fell off.   :'(
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: mory on June 14, 2011, 08:15:53 PM
I'd definitely take that up with the seller, especially if its a dealer, they are usually pretty good when it comes to this sort of thing, I'd get straight on that phone, any one we know   >:E Tee Hee I'm sure he will help you get it sorted, mory       ( hi Theo)  ::)
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Theo on June 14, 2011, 09:22:46 PM
I'd definitely take that up with the seller, especially if its a dealer, they are usually pretty good when it comes to this sort of thing, I'd get straight on that phone, any one we know   >:E Tee Hee I'm sure he will help you get it sorted, mory       ( hi Theo)  ::)

I'll be collecting it off Nick tomorrow for remedial work.

Of course it could be operator error, :o Judging from questions here he has no idea even how to hold it,  ;D he might have been hitting the buttons with a stick instead of using his fingertips.  That's the sort of dangerous error people make if they watch too much Morris.  :M
Title: Re: One Row advice
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 14, 2011, 11:06:34 PM
 I was half way through the Heel and Toe Polka, not sure which part of my foot hit the pallet.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal