Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Accordion Dave on June 14, 2011, 03:21:43 AM

Title: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Accordion Dave on June 14, 2011, 03:21:43 AM
I have not mastered the ability to carry on conversation whilst playing the accordion or melodeon.

I also have difficulty when people try to hand me something. What do they expect me to do with the object?

I spoke with two people after an event, mentioning my inability to "multitask". They were totally unaware that that should cause an interruption in my playing.

One of the gentleman played the accordion as a child. I have seen the photographs. 

I mentioned this to a couple of people after an event where I played the piano accordion and melodeon.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: nfldbox on June 14, 2011, 08:38:35 AM
However, one of the skills Suzuki teachers sometimes use is having a conversation while playing. If you know the instrument well enough and the piece well enough you can do it. (of course with a big old Hohner, you'll have to shout.)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 14, 2011, 11:19:35 PM
I have not mastered the ability to carry on conversation whilst playing the accordion or melodeon.

Sadly this means that you are normal.

Quote
I also have difficulty when people try to hand me something. What do they expect me to do with the object?

Think outside the box, you have teeth, you don't need teeth to play a melodeon.

Quote
I spoke with two people after an event, mentioning my inability to "multitask". They were totally unaware that that should cause an interruption in my playing.

They were women.

Quote
One of the gentleman played the accordion as a child. I have seen the photographs.

He was 'gifted'  ::)

Quote
I mentioned this to a couple of people after an event where I played the piano accordion and melodeon.

Speaking to outsiders is, well, erm, unwise.  ;)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Accordion Dave on June 15, 2011, 01:01:39 AM
No, they were both men.

One is a bartender who had no clue that carrying on a conversation with a musician whilst he is playing could be a problem.

The other gentleman took accordion lessons as child but does not play at all now that he is an adult.   

Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alison Scott on June 15, 2011, 10:58:44 AM
Talking while playing appears to be one of my 2011 developmental areas. I managed, during the session last night, to say some things like 'this one's easy to pick up really' and 'E minor' and so on. But I can't do things like answer questions (even easy ones like 'what would you like to drink').
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Simon on June 15, 2011, 11:43:15 AM
Think outside the box, you have teeth, you don't need teeth to play a melodeon.
That's what I thought about guitar as well, but Jimi Hendrix was quite good at it. Then again, if you can play the melodeon with your teeth you've probably got a hand left to take whatever people are handing you.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Dunny on June 15, 2011, 11:47:59 AM
I find I can say the odd word, but only if I pick the right moment. What's odd, is that the particular moment is random!

What really does impress me is the whistle player at our local session being able to say the equivalent of b****r when she messes up, but whilst still playing..............
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Lin Leighton on June 15, 2011, 01:08:31 PM
I cant even shout "hup" or "change" or "out" yet, I totally lose the playing if I even try to, thak goodness for lifting the foot up   :|bl :|bl
Lin
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: ladydetemps on June 15, 2011, 02:14:22 PM
If there's a long note I can say hmmmm and nod my head. And that's about it.
Trying to work on saying 'I knnnnoooowwww' when mum calls me for dinner.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ellie on June 16, 2011, 12:19:09 PM
I cant even shout "hup" or "change" or "out" yet, I totally lose the playing if I even try to, thak goodness for lifting the foot up   :|bl :|bl
Lin

I managed to shout 'change' AND carry on into the next tune without making a hash of it for the first time ever on Tuesday night - there's hope for me yet...!
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 16, 2011, 01:26:59 PM
An embarrassing error to which I have been known to succumb is to shout "Change" and then fail to do so because I have failed to disengage the 'automatic mental pilot'.  :|bl
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: brackenrigg on July 04, 2011, 09:43:13 PM
You should be able to signal to the rest of the room that you are going to change key (bodge a 7th) or that you are about to finish (modify the tune).
If people don't notice, they are either playing too loud, or head-down/eyes-shut. (None of which are recomended)

If you practise talking whilst playing, you will be able to annoy everyone else.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Martin J on July 04, 2011, 10:33:07 PM
With every new tune you learn practice saying "mine's a pint thank you"  :|glug

Anything beyond that is just showing off.  ;D
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: forrest on July 04, 2011, 10:41:36 PM

The other gentleman took accordion lessons as child but does not play at all now that he is an adult.   


Perhaps he decided that conversing was more to his liking...... ::)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: squeezy on July 04, 2011, 10:58:25 PM
I genuinely don't think it can be done.  I've yet to meet a box player who can compose a sentence and say it while playing, there are precious few of us who have overcome the "melodeon face".

However - on nearly every other instrument that doesn't use the mouth - I've seen examples of people talking and playing.  That goes for piano accordion players too.  I know people can learn to sing songs while playing which uses a different bit of the brain to speech and I know I can bark rudimentary words while playing so I've come the the possibly rash conclusion that the bit of the brain which allows you to think push/pull and process that information is the same one used for grammar or very close to it and that just doesn't allow one to do both.

Please prove me wrong!  I doubt anyone will put funding behind a research project concerning the area of the brain used in diatonic free reed instruments, so we may never know.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Clive Williams on July 04, 2011, 11:15:54 PM
The only chap I know who can do this; my mate Chris Shaw from GIGCB. Many years of busking on the South Bank apparently; he can quite happily chat/banter while playing away. Me, I can't do it for toffee. In fact, I quite often build gaps into my arrangements so I can shout change/out, etc.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Michael Eskin on July 04, 2011, 11:57:12 PM
I've been at this for 20+ years about about I can say is "Hup" and "One more time", and even that's a challenge.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ellisteph on July 05, 2011, 07:49:48 AM
Those of us old enough and lucky enough to have seen Bob Cann playing for a dance will know that he actually called whilst playing. Multitasking at it's very best.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Anahata on July 05, 2011, 05:55:23 PM
Those of us old enough and lucky enough to have seen Bob Cann playing for a dance will know that he actually called whilst playing. Multitasking at it's very best.

I did that once when our caller lost her voice and every member of the band had to choose a dance and call it, to give the caller's voice a rest.
Nobody had told me it was impossible...

Dave Jolly is sometimes a one-man-band caller + melodeon player.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: zubz on July 05, 2011, 06:23:11 PM
Given that the consensus seems to be "this is too difficult for mere mortals", can I suggest a change to the "Position" tag ... I see some are declared as "Good Talker" ... could be amended to "Good Talker, but not while playing melodeon!"  :D
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: squeezy on July 06, 2011, 01:44:06 PM
I think calling works in the same way as singing because one word or phrases are not using the grammatical centres and can be incorporated in to the music.

We have had one example of someone who can "chat away" while playing which is a first for me, I've never encountered anyone who actually constructs and says sentences while playing melodon.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alison Scott on July 06, 2011, 04:17:54 PM

We have had one example of someone who can "chat away" while playing which is a first for me, I've never encountered anyone who actually constructs and says sentences while playing melodon.

Squeezy

Pretty amazing, that. My daughter deliberately comes to find me when practising and asks me questions so she can laugh at the resulting effect on my speech. I always think this is what it must feel like to be a stroke victim; often I know *exactly* what I want to say in my head, and nevertheless I cannot form the words. I'll be thinking 'yes, I'm going to do this for another fifteen minutes and then supper will be ready'; after a bit of gurning, I finally manage to stammer out 'yes...eating....soon...'
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ellie on July 06, 2011, 04:32:38 PM
We have had one example of someone who can "chat away" while playing which is a first for me, I've never encountered anyone who actually constructs and says sentences while playing melodon.

Ray Langton can as well - at a workshop at the weekend, we were all playing, and he started (trying) to converse with us. Needless to say, he didn't get any replies and the tune fell apart! I don't think it's impossible - there have been occasional times when someone has asked me a question and I have been able to answer. However, thinking back, I think that thinking (as it were!) is the problem - these responses happened *without* thinking, if you see what I mean. More general chitchat rather than meaningful phrases. Does that make sense to anyone? (Unfortunately I don't get the opportunity to practise this any more now I live on my own!)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: ladydetemps on July 06, 2011, 04:42:10 PM
I have enough trouble conversing without playing the melodeon, let alone while playing one. lol!
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Kautilya on July 06, 2011, 04:46:53 PM

We have had one example of someone who can "chat away" while playing which is a first for me, I've never encountered anyone who actually constructs and says sentences while playing melodon.

Squeezy

Pretty amazing, that. My daughter deliberately comes to find me when practising and asks me questions so she can laugh at the resulting effect on my speech. I always think this is what it must feel like to be a stroke victim; often I know *exactly* what I want to say in my head, and nevertheless I cannot form the words. I'll be thinking 'yes, I'm going to do this for another fifteen minutes and then supper will be ready'; after a bit of gurning, I finally manage to stammer out 'yes...eating....soon...'
Fear ye no! Here is another Scot(t)-playing melodeoniste who can talk the hind leg of Macgintosh's donkey and could be a model for all us when he finally overlaps toon and talk.  Especially good too for those wantin' to gie inta th'accent before takking the weans on a highland holiday fling.

He's only had 197 views so let's see if we can encourage him  to reach mu-clear fusion of voice and box and he might get some sales commission from Hohner Scotland and Pete Coe
I really like the type of toons he plays and will look him up next time I am over the border   :||: :|||:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OPSBt1fHV8
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: summerstars on July 06, 2011, 07:15:14 PM
He's only had 197 views so let's see if we can encourage him  to reach mu-clear fusion of voice and box and he might get some sales commission from Hohner Scotland and Pete Coe
I really like the type of toons he plays and will look him up next time I am over the border   :||: :|||:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2OPSBt1fHV8

What a wonderful 7 1/2 minutes - including the advertisement for our very own Theo and Melodeon.net

Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: george garside on July 07, 2011, 10:06:05 AM
I find this thread very comforting as any attempt at an utterence (and I have made many attempts!) stops the tune dead or buggers it up completely. Even shouting 'out' at the end of a dance set doesn't work. ( I mean just before the end as I could do it at the end but everybody else would obviouslyover run!)  I find that increasing the volume on the penultimate bar works well as a  signal  and doesn't require people watching for a leg being stuck in the air or whatever.

Perhaps a talking/calling while playing workshop would be worthwhile  even if only ru;n on a sort of mutual basis.

george :-X
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ollie on July 07, 2011, 10:39:43 AM
I've never actually tried, so I just gave it a go. I found I could just about hold a conversation with an imaginary person whilst playing Speed the Plough.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Fidjit on July 07, 2011, 11:56:26 AM
I've never actually tried, so I just gave it a go. I found I could just about hold a conversation with an imaginary person whilst playing Speed the Plough.

Imagination
Yes Ollie, but did you get an answer.

I even imagine I'm playing the right tune sometimes.
People that talk to me whilst I'm playing always look askingly for a reply.
Nope. Can't play and converse.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Lin Leighton on July 07, 2011, 12:28:13 PM
nope Ollie, thats cheating ....... because you were asking the questions as well as answering them so you knew exactly what you would need to say, instead of listening to a "cold" question from a second person, and then having to think of the reply whilst playing    :o
in sessions I have learned to slow down and emphasise the last few notes in order to let others know the tunes are finishing, but that would be useless for dancers ...... unless they can dance in slow motion  haha   :M
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: george garside on July 07, 2011, 01:44:47 PM
Lin, thats on similar lines to my going louder on the last 2 bars of the last tune. It works fine for dancers as callers sometimes give an indication to dancers eg last time through    or  a nod to the bandleader  to indicate that the end is nigh,  This is particularly usseful on  dances of indeterminate length. It also works fine on non set dances eg a bog standard do your own thing old tyme waltz - I watch the dancers for sighns of buggerdness & finish a tune with louder last 2 bars + a twidlle at the end for the dancers to do a adignified sort of swing!    But  me   talking definately not although I suppose I may be able to  talk to myself which is what Ollie has effectively done!

george ;D
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: David J on July 07, 2011, 02:12:22 PM
Quote
I genuinely don't think it can be done.  I've yet to meet a box player who can compose a sentence and say it while playing, there are precious few of us who have overcome the "melodeon face".


Well it gives me great comfort to know that Squeezy also gurns while playing. I shall mention this next time someone laughs at me.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: squeezy on July 07, 2011, 04:27:06 PM
I've tried to turn it in to a smile, but it still doesn't look quite right  ;D
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alan Morley on July 07, 2011, 05:00:36 PM
Now if I could only play and call a dance at the same time........................ ::)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Peter_T on July 07, 2011, 06:03:54 PM
Now if I could only play and call a dance at the same time........................ ::)

Which of course brings us to Playing while dancing (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rzRdgsquak)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: george garside on July 07, 2011, 07:47:41 PM
no chance!

george ::)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Kautilya on July 08, 2011, 02:32:21 AM
no chance!

george ::)
Git practising!  (And go see yr gob tactic post - I failed to hit post button yesterday....but sorting it now for Bull Bay)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rt-Lay92dUI&NR=1
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Peter_T on July 08, 2011, 03:46:27 PM
no chance!

george ::)
Git practising!  (And go see yr gob tactic post - I failed to hit post button yesterday....but sorting it now for Bull Bay)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rt-Lay92dUI&NR=1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hauz1TvNBvQ&feature=related shows the rehearsal. Is that Ellie of this parish? There's Ian from West Wales  with the magnificent beard and pony-tail - was trying to remember his name yesterday - walking across the foreground.

How many others can be identified?
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 08, 2011, 11:01:44 PM
Dancing while playing (are we off piste yet LDT?) is relatively easy. What IS hard however, is anything requiring use of the hands, such as Swords, Hankies, Women etc. It is also not always easy to perform certain manoeuvres like the rapper back flip. Otherwise - a doddle.  :|bl  :|glug
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ollie on July 09, 2011, 12:40:03 AM
nope Ollie, thats cheating ....... because you were asking the questions as well as answering them so you knew exactly what you would need to say, instead of listening to a "cold" question from a second person, and then having to think of the reply whilst playing    :o

That's a fair point. I tried it tonight with a real person, and found I still could. It was a little broken as a conversation, as I was playing and the other person was dancing, but I managed it nonetheless.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alan Morley on July 09, 2011, 07:06:33 AM
I realised yesterday that I can play a melody and sing the song at the same time - must be because the two things are connected.

I'm stuffed when I have to break the link and play and speak something totally unconnected with the tune.... :||:
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: IanD on July 09, 2011, 11:20:13 AM
I genuinely don't think it can be done.  I've yet to meet a box player who can compose a sentence and say it while playing, there are precious few of us who have overcome the "melodeon face".

However - on nearly every other instrument that doesn't use the mouth - I've seen examples of people talking and playing.  That goes for piano accordion players too.  I know people can learn to sing songs while playing which uses a different bit of the brain to speech and I know I can bark rudimentary words while playing so I've come the the possibly rash conclusion that the bit of the brain which allows you to think push/pull and process that information is the same one used for grammar or very close to it and that just doesn't allow one to do both.

Please prove me wrong!  I doubt anyone will put funding behind a research project concerning the area of the brain used in diatonic free reed instruments, so we may never know.

I do it all the time while playing for Smiffs, usually to extract the urine out of somebody who's made a cock-up or to ask the audience to encourage leapfrogees to stand up higher.

Maybe it's just a matter of having the tune ingrained into your DNA by having played it for years, thus leaving some spare brain capacity for banter.

Ian
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: siamsa on July 09, 2011, 03:11:19 PM
I have always found it hard to converse whilst playing even after many years of playing. I play a three row B/C/C# and can just about shout out a key change, yet I know three excellent three row players (B/C/C#) who front bands or work as a one man band and seem to be able to chat when playing.  Each one also sings as he plays.  Here is an example of one on a recent TV Talent Show on an Irish speaking TV Station.  Patrick O'Sullivan.  Incidentally this guy also plays guitar so maybe that helps. :||:
http://youtu.be/FEikUErZmwM
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alan Morley on July 10, 2011, 08:38:57 AM
<clipped>

  Incidentally this guy also plays guitar so maybe that helps. :||:
http://youtu.be/FEikUErZmwM

Playing guitar doesn't help me...it's easy enough when playing ryhthm guitar, but playing a lead break and chatting...impossible...
I don't know if bass player can do it as they really play a melody line......must be same a playing a lead break...

Alan
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: george garside on July 10, 2011, 12:53:51 PM
I have always found it hard to converse whilst playing even after many years of playing. I play a three row B/C/C# and can just about shout out a key change, yet I know three excellent three row players (B/C/C#) who front bands or work as a one man band and seem to be able to chat when playing.  Each one also sings as he plays.  Here is an example of one on a recent TV Talent Show on an Irish speaking TV Station.  Patrick O'Sullivan.  Incidentally this guy also plays guitar so maybe that helps. :||:
http://youtu.be/FEikUErZmwM

looks to be an interesting BCC# mengascini ? 60 bass - anybody know anything about it - is it a stock model or a conversion of a 3 row continental etc etc

george
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: siamsa on July 11, 2011, 12:36:32 AM
The Mengascine box featured is a B/C/C#. I have heard that Mengascine have also made a four row box tuned B/C/C#/D. A bonus for three row players when it comes to playing the Flat keys.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Lin Leighton on July 13, 2011, 11:34:28 AM
O K Ollie  I accept defeat  :-\
Lin
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: george garside on July 13, 2011, 11:51:07 AM
Lin, we could  attempt the impossible at Whitby!

george ;)
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Lin Leighton on July 13, 2011, 12:16:06 PM
Hi George
Right .. heres what to do ..
at your slow and stead session in whichever pub is still surviving at Whitby we could all practise together, all the room shout "change" and "Hup" during every tune, hopefully at the right time too!!  ;D    by the end of the week we may just have got there!!   >:E
lin
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Alison Scott on July 13, 2011, 01:54:56 PM
I've tried to turn it in to a smile, but it still doesn't look quite right  ;D

You've definitely fooled some people -- I saw a thread (possibly on your forum) about how much fun you always seemed to be having when playing, and I thought 'ahah! Pretty sure this is the rictus grin version of melodeon face'.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: GuyWyatt on July 13, 2011, 04:45:06 PM
Quote
I do it all the time while playing for Smiffs, usually to extract the urine out of somebody who's made a cock-up or to ask the audience to encourage leapfrogees to stand up higher.

Maybe it's just a matter of having the tune ingrained into your DNA by having played it for years, thus leaving some spare brain capacity for banter.

Ian

Ian is understating the case.  I have seen him play whilst being interviewed by a TV crew.  Scary stuff.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: brackenrigg on July 24, 2011, 09:39:01 PM
dead easy to talk whilst playing. zzzzzzzzz
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Pete Dunk on July 25, 2011, 01:04:11 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hauz1TvNBvQ&feature=related shows the rehearsal. Is that Ellie of this parish? There's Ian from West Wales  with the magnificent beard and pony-tail - was trying to remember his name yesterday - walking across the foreground.

How many others can be identified?
Chas (Fidgit) was in that lineup
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Ollie on July 28, 2011, 11:25:35 PM
I genuinely don't think it can be done.  I've yet to meet a box player who can compose a sentence and say it while playing, there are precious few of us who have overcome the "melodeon face".

However - on nearly every other instrument that doesn't use the mouth - I've seen examples of people talking and playing.  That goes for piano accordion players too.  I know people can learn to sing songs while playing which uses a different bit of the brain to speech and I know I can bark rudimentary words while playing so I've come the the possibly rash conclusion that the bit of the brain which allows you to think push/pull and process that information is the same one used for grammar or very close to it and that just doesn't allow one to do both.

Please prove me wrong!  I doubt anyone will put funding behind a research project concerning the area of the brain used in diatonic free reed instruments, so we may never know.

I do it all the time while playing for Smiffs, usually to extract the urine out of somebody who's made a cock-up or to ask the audience to encourage leapfrogees to stand up higher.

Maybe it's just a matter of having the tune ingrained into your DNA by having played it for years, thus leaving some spare brain capacity for banter.

Ian

I think that's a very good point. I did it again whilst playing for the b****y Winster Processional last weekend; it was the 20somethingth time through the tune, so my fingers knew exactly what they were doing.
Title: Re: CONVERSING WHILST PLAYING
Post by: Andy Next Tune on July 29, 2011, 07:16:20 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hauz1TvNBvQ&feature=related shows the rehearsal. Is that Ellie of this parish? There's Ian from West Wales  with the magnificent beard and pony-tail - was trying to remember his name yesterday - walking across the foreground.

How many others can be identified?
Chas (Fidgit) was in that lineup

...and I'm No8....
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal