Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Alan Morley on June 14, 2011, 11:47:03 AM

Title: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on June 14, 2011, 11:47:03 AM
I keep visiting this guy's site on You Tube, in this video he's obviously been influenced by our very own 'GbH'..

While we have people going daft about French tunes, this Frenchman is showing us how to play Irish on a one row - isn't life strange at time.. ::)

http://www.youtube.com/user/gpoutoux#p/u/2/HbmI9-uLwMA (http://www.youtube.com/user/gpoutoux#p/u/2/HbmI9-uLwMA)

Alan
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Gary P Chapin on June 14, 2011, 03:12:11 PM
I noticed this in France.  There was a whole slew of Frenchfolk completely gobsmacked by Irish tunes.  I was very welcome when I took out my tin whistle and did a few of the rigs and jeels with them.  Also, there was a large contingent devoted to English Country Dance.

Also, I would never deny that life is strange, but I wouldn't call Mel.Net a representative sample of the popularity of French tunes.  It's still pretty lonely over here in Maine, playin' the French stuff.

Philosophical stuff aside (Aristotle: A Treaty on the Strangeness of Life), that's a great video.  Every since hearing Tom Doherty's "Take the Bull by the Horns," I have loved Irish music on the one row.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: nfldbox on June 14, 2011, 03:32:14 PM
Poutoux is excellent but look for Christian Maes.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: siamsa on June 14, 2011, 05:14:36 PM
Well I knew a few box players who were shy but this is taking it a bit far ;D However they played both jigs very well. :||:
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Gary P Chapin on June 14, 2011, 05:21:27 PM
I really like the mask thing.  I've been thinking of doing it because I think my Melodeon face is just too grim for the music I'm playing.  Maybe when I do street playing this summer.  Our own GbH has inspired me greatly in this.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 14, 2011, 05:23:18 PM
Note - no speeding up - "le vice anglais"

Also, there was a large contingent devoted to English Country Dance.

If that's contredanse anglais then it's even worse than you thought  - that's Playford. Thought technical and difficult in Britain - these mecs do it simply calling the figures as they go - no walk through - at dance full speed.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Theo on June 14, 2011, 06:25:01 PM
Note - no speeding up - "le vice anglais"

Also, there was a large contingent devoted to English Country Dance.

If that's contredanse anglais then it's even worse than you thought  - that's Playford. Thought technical and difficult in Britain - these mecs do it simply calling the figures as they go - no walk through - at dance full speed.

Doesn't surprise me.  Many people in England who do well known country dances from the UK seem unwilling to take risks.  I once responded to a request for suggestions to develop/improve ceilidhs at Whitby Week by suggesting an occasional ceilidh without a caller.  There are hordes of people at Whitby Week who know scores of dances, why waste time with walk throughs?   As long as roughly half the people in each set know the dance the rest can pick it up.  The suggestion was met with disbelief that such a thing could be possible.  People manage in Ireland and Scotland.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on June 14, 2011, 06:42:01 PM

Doesn't surprise me.  Many people in England who do well known country dances from the UK seem unwilling to take risks.  I once responded to a request for suggestions to develop/improve ceilidhs at Whitby Week by suggesting an occasional ceilidh without a caller.  There are hordes of people at Whitby Week who know scores of dances, why waste time with walk throughs?   As long as roughly half the people in each set know the dance the rest can pick it up.  The suggestion was met with disbelief that such a thing could be possible.  People manage in Ireland and Scotland.

I once did a gig with a barn dance band who played English Country Dance tunes, and we had a caller, we got booked at a Scottish wedding.

At the outset, our caller got everyone on the dance floor and tried to explain the dance, and was met with the attitude - 'Just play the tune - we all know the dances....'

We started with Dorset Four-hand reel, and all the Scottish dancers looked blank at each other and we got paid off.......

Alan
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: waltzman on June 14, 2011, 07:10:52 PM
In the US contradancers really enjoy "no walk through" dances and some of the best callers will change a dance on the fly by calling just enough ahead of time to keep the dance flowing.  It's a challenge and great fun.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: brianread on June 14, 2011, 07:37:12 PM
We went to a Whapweasel Celidh at Sidmouth a few years ago, they just said - this tunes goes to (e.g.) "Nottingham Swing", and we all danced.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: GbH on June 15, 2011, 08:00:43 AM
Oh - I've just spotted that I'm mentioned here.  Given the thread's original title, I hadn't really  expected that.

I really like what Gilles did in that.  The masks themselves are simple, but when paired with his large beard, the effect is really striking.   Also, the fact thst there are two of them doing it adds something more to the effect, too.

I don't know how much Gilles has seen my videos or whether he might have been influenced by them in any way.  Really, though, what I've done isn't anything new.  As far as I can tell, quite a lot of forum members here use unusal costumes, make-up and even, sometimes, masks in their own performing activities.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Theo on June 15, 2011, 08:07:30 AM
We went to a Whapweasel Celidh at Sidmouth a few years ago, they just said - this tunes goes to (e.g.) "Nottingham Swing", and we all danced.


That's the way to do it!
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 15, 2011, 08:52:57 AM
In the US contradancers really enjoy "no walk through" dances and some of the best callers will change a dance on the fly by calling just enough ahead of time to keep the dance flowing.  It's a challenge and great fun.

 ... in England we walk through complex sets of figures at approximately quarter speed, then again slightly faster, then again if we are lucky 'just to sort out set 3'.   On the traditional encoded command "first couples back to the top of the set" the band then starts up and we get to dance for five minutes.  The walk through took ten.  :|glug
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Theo on June 15, 2011, 09:56:30 AM
... in England we walk through complex sets of figures

Complex? dead simple compared with Irish sets where the whole "set" can last 20 minutes including half a dozen "figures" that are each on a par with a single English or Scottish country dance, and usually involve several changes of rhythm between jig, polka, reel, hornpipe.   All done without a caller.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Alison Scott on June 15, 2011, 11:08:58 AM
We went to a Whapweasel Celidh at Sidmouth a few years ago, they just said - this tunes goes to (e.g.) "Nottingham Swing", and we all danced.


The better callers spot, at the better festivals, where they've got a room full of regular dancers and will start the easier dances uncalled. "Does anyone not know Nottingham Swing"? And "Rosa" is often uncalled, because everyone knows it now and it's a couple dance anyway. But one of the things I sometimes find tedious about English ceilidh is that so many of the dances are simple and are called at great length to a room full of people, 90% of whom know it already. On the other hand, that adds to the glorious accessibility of it all.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: waltzman on June 15, 2011, 12:36:03 PM
... in England we walk through complex sets of figures

Complex? dead simple compared with Irish sets where the whole "set" can last 20 minutes including half a dozen "figures" that are each on a par with a single English or Scottish country dance, and usually involve several changes of rhythm between jig, polka, reel, hornpipe.   All done without a caller.

Yikes.  American contra dance is even simpler than the English country dancing.  The dances are independent of the tunes and there is a relatively small repertoire of figures that are mixed together in different ways to create the dance.  So once you've learned the repertoire of figures it's relatively easy to just follow the caller at speed.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Martin J on June 24, 2011, 11:32:52 AM
gpoutoux's Channel has featured in other thread's on melnet.  The one thing that always amuses me is his total self assurance which leaves his wife/accompanist to catch up or do the best she can - and boy does she do well.  She is very good and supports his playing to a T.  Perhaps it's many years of experience and playing together but to me she stands out.
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Martin J on June 24, 2011, 11:38:17 AM
Thought I should just add this one (http://www.youtube.com/user/gpoutoux#p/u/5/Uvw_1jnPr8I).  Gbh's nose and doesn't she look pleased at having to wear it  :D
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on June 24, 2011, 01:38:31 PM
gpoutoux's Channel has featured in other thread's on melnet.  The one thing that always amuses me is his total self assurance which leaves his wife/accompanist to catch up or do the best she can - and boy does she do well.  She is very good and supports his playing to a T.  Perhaps it's many years of experience and playing together but to me she stands out.

She is a cracking player too, pity there's no video of her on her own....
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 24, 2011, 02:41:42 PM
... in England we walk through complex sets of figures at approximately quarter speed, then again slightly faster, then again if we are lucky 'just to sort out set 3'.     :|glug

Do we? Not in any of the bands I've played in or called with over the last 40 years or so.  Once through, as briefly as possible, then get on with it to the music and it will sort itself out in the first turn-and-a-half or so - even with novice PTA-style crowds. 
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Alan Morley on June 24, 2011, 03:47:22 PM
... in England we walk through complex sets of figures at approximately quarter speed, then again slightly faster, then again if we are lucky 'just to sort out set 3'.     :|glug

Do we? Not in any of the bands I've played in or called with over the last 40 years or so.  Once through, as briefly as possible, then get on with it to the music and it will sort itself out in the first turn-and-a-half or so - even with novice PTA-style crowds. 

You haven't seen me trying to dance.......... :-[

Almo
Title: Re: Frenchman playing Irish Tunes
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 24, 2011, 07:13:10 PM
Hey - if the music's good enough, you'll dance!! ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal