Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: The Blues Viking on June 15, 2011, 07:12:13 AM
-
Something's been bugging me, and music theory class was a hell of a long time ago.
I know that if I use the C major scale as an example, the related Natural minor scale is A minor. Likewise, I know that there are also related Harmonic and Melodic minor scales, and that from C major these are G and D, but I cannot for the life of me remember which is which! Any help?
TBV
-
Something's been bugging me, and music theory class was a hell of a long time ago.
I know that if I use the C major scale as an example, the related Natural minor scale is A minor. Likewise, I know that there are also related Harmonic and Melodic minor scales, and that from C major these are G and D, but I cannot for the life of me remember which is which! Any help?
No - that's not quite right.
For any major scale, the relative minor is found by shifting three semitones down from the key note, so for C major the relative minor scale is A minor, regardless of whether it is the harmonic, melodic or the 'natural' modal version. The key signature for a minor scale is the same as its relative major scale, but accidentals are added within the scale where necessary.
The notes for A minor are:
Natural minor A B C D E F G A' both ascending and descending.
Harmonic minor A B C D E F G# A' both ascending and descending.
Melodic minor A B C D E F# G# A' (ascending) and A' G F E D C B A (descending). In the melodic minor, the descending scale notes are those of the relative major.
Edited to add more info., crossing with Anahata's post above/below
-
I know that if I use the C major scale as an example, the related Natural minor scale is A minor.
OK so far...
Likewise, I know that there are also related Harmonic and Melodic minor scales, and that from C major these are G and D
No, you're off the rails there. Starting from C major, all your minor scales start on A.*
Harmonic changes the G to a G#
Melodic changes F and G to F# and G# on the way up, and leaves than as naturals on the way down.
It helps to bear in mind that "melodic" and "harmonic" are only ways of actually playing scales - if you're writing a tune in A minor, there are no rules about whether your F and G are natural or sharp and you can mix them up in whatever way sounds most musical.
*Yes, I know about Dorian mode, but that's a red herring...
-
Perhaps what is confusing is that most people would find D minor the easiest minor key to play on a C row because the full D minor chord is available on the pull. A minor (the true relative minor of C) is a a little trickier because there are more bellows changes.
The D minor key you play in on the C row is another species of minor key different to the natural, harmonic and melodic minors. It has the notes:
DEFGABC
This scale is known as the "Dorian Mode" and is common in a lots of folk songs and dance tunes. Brigg Fair is a good example and so is the jig Ten Penny Bit.
The equivalent dorian scale starting on A has the notes
ABCDEF#GA
Which you couldn't play on a C row without cross to the G row or accidental buttons depending on your box.
The majorness or minorness of a tune is mainly determined by the third note of the scale. In a major key it is four semitones up from the key note, in a minor key it is only three semitones. Hence the natural minor, harmonic minor, melodic minor, dorian mode (and one or two other scales as well) can be described as "minor" keys because they all have that charcteristic "sad" sounding minor third as opposed the bright major third of the major scale.
In mainstream classical music (and they are the folks who invented music theory) its nice and simple, because you just have major and minor. Harmonic and melodic minor are just variations of the basic minor idea. In traditional music there are lots of different scales, particularly when you look across the world as a whole, and people just played them rather than theorising about them. This is why explanations can be a little confusing.
-
In mainstream classical music (and they are the folks who invented music theory) its nice and simple, because you just have major and minor.
Well, if you ignore a few obscure composers like Beethoven...
-
Yup - it's far more compex than that. All notes bar first can contibute to minor feel. Here's the 'simple' folk version
http://chrisryall.net/modes/ - scrole to 'the concept of majorness or minorness'
Note that even the 4th is flattened in the fully 'altered' scale.
Thanks to Anahata for his green red herring. But that's to step over quite a common pitfall. The concept to avoid on a D/G is what Nick says. Our folkie E minor scale (D row pull) is actually dorian, whereas Em is 'relative' to the G scale. The difference being C# instead of C. I don't personaly find 'relative' minor a useful concept on our instument, though I think in terms of modes all the time.
Relative minor is however very useful in Blues. If you play E blues :|glug over G chords you get major Blues and so on - all to do with the pentatonics underlying them.
-
For what it's worth.. according to wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minor_scale) the dorian is a minor scale as well (with minor scale defined as anything with a tonic, minor third and perfect fifth). Of course minor feel is something different than a minor scale.
-
Thanks, all. I have decided two things:
1. I need to go back to school for another music theory class.
2. It ain't worth it.
TBV
-
Thanks, all. I have decided two things:
1. I need to go back to school for another music theory class.
2. It ain't worth it.
TBV
It's not as complicated as you think, there's plenty of stuff on this thread that you didn't ask about, such as dorian mode etc. While I'm sure you'll want to know about it and come across it at some point, ignore it if its confusing you!
-
You never know too much and you never know when something you thought futile can help you!
-
You never know too much and you never know when something you thought futile can help you!
You're right but I believe it's best to keep things simple at first and build it up, purely to prevent people being intimidated by a concept or idea and failing to grasp it and so deciding not to bother with it. It's like if you're teaching accordion, I reckon the aim of the first lesson, apart from how to hold the instrument etc., should be to have the student playing some sort of tune at the end of it, not necessarily a scale or the layout of the instrument. That way they feel that they're able for it and that confidence will help them progress and tackle more complex aspects of playing.
I spent the last year doing a qualification as a secondary school music teacher, which involved a year teaching in a school, and I found that ensuring success at the very start through simplifying concepts was essential to class engagement with topics. While we're very lucky to have people on this forum who are willing to share their vast knowledge of different topics, I think many suffer from the problem that I had when I started teaching, which was presuming that I could teach topics the way I learned and understood them...after about three painful months I found it wasn't!
-
There is a trite little saying in the profession I work in: "offer people an experience not an explanation"
Or perhaps truer to say: offer an experience before an explanation.
We can all enjoy the experience of playing in minor modes without knowing what they are: after all how old were you when you first sang the Drunken Sailor? Explanations can take many forms and can enrich our experience by satisfying the part of our mind that is curious about things, or opening up new possibilities, say in writing tunes.
I remember as a lad of about 15 sitting at the piano with the explanation of modes in the introduction to one on Cecil Sharp's English folk song collections and deliberately trying to improvise tunes in different modes, or play familiar tunes in the wrong mode. The feel for tonality this gave me has stayed with me through the diverse musical adventures I have enjoyed in the following 35 years.
-
There is a trite little saying in the profession I work in: "offer people an experience not an explanation"
Or perhaps truer to say: offer an experience before an explanation.
That's a good one alright, I'll remember that (:)
-
There is a trite little saying in the profession I work in: "offer people an experience not an explanation"
Or perhaps truer to say: offer an experience before an explanation.
That's a good one alright, I'll remember that (:)
It kind of fits in with something else I heard about teaching and learning:
"Tell me, and I will forget. Show me, and I will remember. Involve me, and I will understand."