Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Dazbo on June 15, 2011, 01:07:46 PM

Title: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Dazbo on June 15, 2011, 01:07:46 PM
Almost three years ago now (I can't believe it) I started a poll on which companies' boxes we owned.  I'm sure most of us have since added to or removed from our collection so I thought it appropriate to run it again.  Remember this is a poll of makers not of numbers owned so only one vote per option. 

Please note that these are instruments that are owned by you on the 1st of June this year.

If you select any of the Other categories please state who the maker is in a post.

You should be able to change your votes but I believe you will need to remove them first and do them again.

I'm sure the poll will need tweaking so please post if you've got any problems
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Lester on June 15, 2011, 01:25:59 PM
The current list for Tune/Theme of the month throws up this list:

Baffetti Binci
Beltuna Alex
Beltuna Samuel 3
Beltuna Sara
Bernard Loffet
Boxeen
Casali B/C/C#
Castagnari Benny
Castagnari Dony
Castagnari Giasco
Castagnari Giordy
Castagnari Hascy
Castagnari Laura
Castagnari Lilium
Castagnari Lilly
Castagnari Max
Castagnari Mory
Castagnari Nik
Castagnari Sander
Castagnari Tommy
Co op L'Armonica Stradella
Dallape Club
Dancemaster 1 Row
Dancemaster C#/D
Delicia Popular
Dino Baffetti Black Pearl
Dino Baffetti Carnival 
Excaliber A/D/G
Gabbanelli
Gaillard
Guerrini Claudia
Heligonka
Hero 7 button
Hohner 1 Row 4 Stop
Hohner 1140
Hohner B/C/C#
Hohner Club
Hohner Club III
Hohner Club IV
Hohner Club Victoria
Hohner Compadre
Hohner Corona
Hohner Corso
Hohner Double Ray
Hohner Echo III
Hohner Echo IV
Hohner El Rey Vallenato
Hohner Elysium II
Hohner Erica
Hohner Liliput
Hohner Merlin
Hohner Morgane
Hohner Panther
Hohner Pokerwork
Hohner Preciosa
Hohner Pressed Wood
Hohner Shand Morino
Hohner Trichord
Hohner Victoria Club
Isis
Mengascini
Oakwood
Paolo Soprani
Pariselle 1 Row
Pistelli
Pistelli Teramo
Primo
Roland FR18
Saltarelle 1 Row
Saltarelle Bouebe
Saltarelle Cheviot
Saltarelle Connemara II
Saltarelle Connemara III
Saltarelle L'Elfique
Saltarelle Nuage
Saltarelle Pastourelle II
Saltarelle Pastourelle III
Saltarelle Swift
Saltarelle Tramontane
Serenellini 233
Serenellini Selli
Strasser Steierische
Streb
Weltmeister 1 Row
Weltmeister 86W
Weltmeister Cajun
Wesson Clipper
Wilkinson Excelsior
Zero Sette 1 row
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: howard mitchell on June 15, 2011, 01:30:52 PM
My "other" is a Dallape.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Petave on June 15, 2011, 01:57:42 PM
 I have a Meinel Herold CF Club. Very nice too. Pete
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 15, 2011, 02:00:05 PM
The current list for Tune/Theme of the month throws up this list:

Baffetti Binci
[...]
Zero Sette 1 row


I recorded a "Theme of the Month" tune on a Melodie.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 15, 2011, 02:05:25 PM
My 'other' is a Manfrini 2-row 3-voice D/G.

Also - does my 1-row 4-stop like wot I made on Emmanuel Pariselle's melodeon making course count as 'self-build' or 'Pariselle'?
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: ladydetemps on June 15, 2011, 02:06:57 PM
My 'other' is a Manfrini 2-row 3-voice D/G.

Also - does my 1-row 4-stop like wot I made on Emmanuel Pariselle's melodeon making course count as 'self-build' or 'Pariselle'?
You could call it a 'Steve'. ;)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 15, 2011, 02:25:10 PM
Also - does my 1-row 4-stop like wot I made on Emmanuel Pariselle's melodeon making course count as 'self-build' or 'Pariselle'?

That is funny, Steve, the same question popped into my head as I saw "Pariselle" on the list.
I know other instrument builders who have taught courses and have had reservations about their name being attached to the instruments, because they really aren't the same as the ones with the name/brand attached.  At the same time, it seems fair and accurate to give the hat tip to the person who designed the instrument and in some cases prepped the parts, and supervised the building, because surely the instrument bears the imprint of Pariselle and differs from one that you would have built without the guidance of the master.  Perhaps "Pariselle/self-build" would be proper?
-Andy
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Ollie on June 15, 2011, 03:07:07 PM
The current list for Tune/Theme of the month throws up this list:


You have the Erica listed, but missed out Erika.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: patrickcavanagh on June 15, 2011, 05:49:52 PM
My OTHER is a "Learner" (Chinese-made, designed/endorsed by Billy McComiskey)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: NeilA on June 15, 2011, 07:02:36 PM
My other is an Yvus
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Keithypete. on June 15, 2011, 07:39:42 PM
   My 'Other' is apparently a Borsini, but they apparently don't make diatonic. Hmmmmmm??? 'Other' will suffice.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Nick Hudis on June 15, 2011, 07:47:33 PM
My other is a badged "Studio" and is probably an East European Cajun style 1 row in C.  Looks, plays and sounds a bit like a Weltmeister.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: mory on June 15, 2011, 07:52:32 PM
My other is a badged "Studio" and is probably an East European Cajun style 1 row in C.  Looks, plays and sounds a bit like a Weltmeister.

I had one of those but the pallet fell off  (:) mory


sorry couldn't resist it  >:E
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: TomB on June 15, 2011, 08:27:34 PM
My 'other' is a Co op L'Armonica Stradella.. is that a make??  :||:
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 15, 2011, 09:04:36 PM
my other is " gabbanelli 507 " aka fat elvis
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: rees on June 15, 2011, 09:52:14 PM
My 'other' is a Co op L'Armonica Stradella.. is that a make??  :||:

It is and a good one too.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Andy Simpson on June 15, 2011, 10:17:45 PM
I've got a Koch presswood that's basically a Hohner in all but name, would that count as "other"?.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on June 15, 2011, 10:35:55 PM
I have two "others", an Excelsior (2 row 3 voice) and a Zero Sette (1 row 4 stop).
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Noodle on June 16, 2011, 01:52:10 AM
Quote
You may only select up to 37 options.
Made me smile

Anyway, my boxes are listed in my signature. Added my contribution to the poll though
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: nemethmik on June 16, 2011, 07:29:50 AM
My 'other' is a Co op L'Armonica Stradella.. is that a make??  :||:
It is and a good one too.
Is this maker the same as Cooperfisa (formerly Cooperativa), Vercelli? I have an excellent Cooperfisa accordion.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Bananayogi on June 16, 2011, 09:22:21 AM
My Other (Cajun) is a Larry Miller Bon Cajun.

And very nice it is too :)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Alan Morley on June 16, 2011, 10:09:17 AM
My other is:

ISIS/ Excelsior Chiltern D/G Three Voice
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 16, 2011, 10:14:23 AM
My 'Other' is apparently a Borsini, but they apparently don't make diatonic. Hmmmmmm??? 'Other' will suffice.
I'm not sure if they made any two row models but I have a Borsini B/C/C# so they did make diatonics.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 16, 2011, 10:16:30 AM
My 'other' is a Borsini
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: rees on June 16, 2011, 10:25:28 AM
My 'other' is a Co op L'Armonica Stradella.. is that a make??  :||:
It is and a good one too.
Is this maker the same as Cooperfisa (formerly Cooperativa), Vercelli? I have an excellent Cooperfisa accordion.

Unlikely. Stradella and Vercelli are two towns approx. 120km apart.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Bob Ellis on June 16, 2011, 10:33:41 AM
My Other (Cajun) is a beautiful blue Junior Martin in C.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Eoin on June 16, 2011, 11:06:26 AM
My other is an Orfeo BC with 12x3 Stadella. :Ph
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Dazbo on June 16, 2011, 12:56:08 PM
Where someone has several boxes from same maker - these are under-represented here.

True, but I was unable to figure out if it was possible to have a poll of manufacturers and also indicate the numbers owned.  It might be possible to do it as a series of questions, one for each maker, but that would probably end up as long as the recent census for >:(
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on June 16, 2011, 01:41:36 PM
My "Other" is a Scarlatti, now cured of lung disease!  ;D  :|glug  :||:  :M  :|bl
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: strad on June 16, 2011, 02:32:50 PM
My other is a Stephanelli which is what I started with and good as a session box where I don't worry too much about what is happening around me.

Nigel
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: LDbosca on June 16, 2011, 03:18:55 PM
I was very bold and I clicked "Gaillard," even tho it's 3 or 4 weeks away...sorry, I'm just very excited!!

And if all is going well after a week of playing it I've decided that I'm going to order a second one!
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: mory on June 16, 2011, 03:21:29 PM
Now theres true addiction  (:) mory
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: LDbosca on June 16, 2011, 06:53:44 PM
Ha, none of yer "I bought another Hohner today," GIMME THE FANCIEST ONE YE GOT!! ;D

In all seriousness though, the Gaillard's the box I want to be playing for the rest of my life as it is (IMHO) the finest two row box you can get. What if something happened to my first one? He won't be making them forever. Plus, I'll get the second in Eb (C/C#), which should be fun. :|||:
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: WendyG on June 16, 2011, 08:08:02 PM
My "other" is an orange 2-row I. Busilacchio in B/C.

Wendy
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 16, 2011, 11:49:12 PM
My "other" is an orange 2-row I. Busilacchio in B/C.

Wendy

Photo please!  ;D
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Theo on June 17, 2011, 12:00:31 AM
My "other" is an orange 2-row I. Busilacchio in B/C.

Wendy

Photo please!  ;D

In this post (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6442.msg80618.html#msg80618)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 17, 2011, 06:01:42 AM
I was very bold and I clicked "Gaillard," even tho it's 3 or 4 weeks away...sorry, I'm just very excited!!  And if all is going well after a week of playing it I've decided that I'm going to order a second one!

This sounds very much like a 'see you at Chateau d'Ars' to me.  Are you doing the whole festival?
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: LDbosca on June 17, 2011, 11:55:08 AM
I was very bold and I clicked "Gaillard," even tho it's 3 or 4 weeks away...sorry, I'm just very excited!!  And if all is going well after a week of playing it I've decided that I'm going to order a second one!

This sounds very much like a 'see you at Chateau d'Ars' to me.  Are you doing the whole festival?

I had thought I'd fly over to get the box and go to one of the festivals that Bertrand attends but I've decided to save the money and just have it shipped. As it happens I've stumbled upon a bit of work superintending and correcting the Irish state examinations so it worked out well...Bertrand promised to send the box before he departs for the festival anyway! (:)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: robriki on June 17, 2011, 05:08:35 PM
The other is a big unplayable Sonola...
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: upmine3 on June 17, 2011, 05:33:56 PM
And Hohner is the winner. ;D
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: LDbosca on June 17, 2011, 05:35:17 PM
And Hohner is the winner. ;D

Now now, it's quality, not quantity  :P
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 17, 2011, 05:51:32 PM
And Hohner is the winner. ;D

Now now, it's quality, not quantity  :P

I've just had to carry out some small repairs to my ageing Saltarelle (for the price of which, at the time, I could probably have bought 3 Hohners) and I have to say I've been surprised at the relatively poor build quality once you get inside the beast, especially compared with old Hohners.  It's a lovely box to play, it speaks easily with a light action and is smooth and sweet-toned, but there's no craftsmanship.  Them what knows tell me it's a rebadged Serenellini.  Makes me wonder about the "quality" of relatively upmarket melodeons.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: LDbosca on June 17, 2011, 06:26:42 PM
Ha,who knows. I get the impression Saltarelle's don't have the prettiest inards alright, I wonder how they compare to Castagnaris in that respect. People on this forum who know more than I do about these things suggest that Saltarelle are unconcerned with this attention to detail and more with trying to make a buck. Be that as it may, my Saltarelle's seriously earned its keep, almost nothing gone wrong with it except a broken air button once and a slight clicking on one of the right-hand keys. Not bad since its had regular practice session of 1-4 hours on it, its been my exclusive giggin box for about 4 or 5 years and its had some nasty falls.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 17, 2011, 07:11:43 PM
Yes, I don't dispute they're good tough boxes - mine's been reliable for over 20 years and it's worked hard for its living, in bands and playing for morris in all sorts of weather. I don't regret buying it in any way. The repairs I had to do were the result of dropping it on to a tiled floor in Limassol folk club; I picked it up, played my couple of numbers and put it back in its case. After that I played an open-air ceilidh with it, a couple of spots at Paphos folk club, and used it in a couple of morris practices. Then sitting at home running through a few tunes I noticed a slight escape of air, which turned out to be a loosened corner joint in the treble end - presumably the corner on which it had landed in the folk club. Glued and clamped, the joint emerged as strong as ever and the leak is cured; I replaced a few iffy valves while I had the box apart.  They're strong, they're pleasant to play and they have a sound that I like - they're just not, as you say, very pretty inside......all the Hohners I own are better finished internally.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: StupidFingers on June 18, 2011, 12:07:36 PM
I've got two others.

The first is an Excelsior Chiltern.

The second is marked "Worldmaster" which I know translates to "Weltmeister", but whether it really is a Weltmeister or just a cheap knock-off, I do not know.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: ACE on June 18, 2011, 02:52:47 PM
Only one other, Excelsior Mini Special D/G. The hand finished reeds really make it a nice sounding box. I do have another in my dreams, the new midi roland.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 18, 2011, 03:50:14 PM
Ha,who knows. I get the impression Saltarelle's don't have the prettiest inards alright, I wonder how they compare to Castagnaris in that respect.
Castagnari instruments are superbly constructed and beautifully finished, both externally and internally.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: upmine3 on June 19, 2011, 01:23:23 PM
Ha,who knows. I get the impression Saltarelle's don't have the prettiest inards alright, I wonder how they compare to Castagnaris in that respect.
Castagnari instruments are superbly constructed and beautifully finished, both externally and internally.

Yes indeed here's the inside of my Castagnari.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/2074705916/in/photostream (http://www.flickr.com/photos/14636356@N08/2074705916/in/photostream)
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: Mike Averill on June 19, 2011, 07:28:56 PM
The other is a big unplayable Sonola...
My other is a Sonola too, although its definately playable, just in the wrong key. Classic 4 voice sound and grey as well, Any one got a spare P. Soprani badge? Awaiting an airvalve rebore and retune up a semitone to C#D.

My other other is a Tonella BCC# but we wont talk about that.
Title: Re: Which Make Is Your Box? (Revisited)
Post by: savantuk on June 20, 2011, 12:00:38 AM
My other is an Excelsior, or should that be Pigini??
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal