Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Harmonicatunes on June 15, 2011, 01:23:22 PM
-
So far, my efforts with the single row have left the bottom button largely untouched. I wondering if it is feasible to change the notes on it.
In particular, for a single row in C, the bottom pull note is a G, which repeats on the 2nd push button. This gives a nice G7 chord on the bottom 4 pull buttons.
However, for me, I would like the bottom pull note to be raised to an A. A lot more tunes would become possible. Presumably this would be a simple mod.
Now for the next change. The bottom push button is a low E, doesn't get much use. At least, not by me. However, if it could instead be a high G#, then you could play in A minor.
So. Is it possible to have the bottom reed with an A on the pull and a G# on the push. This G# would be almost an octave higher than the pull note, allowing the A minor scale.
My guess is no. Such a combination would be impossible on a harmonica, as the respective slot lengths wouldn't match. Even if possible, the A/G# reedblock would probably need to be custom made.
If the local experts could fill me in here I'd be glad.
-
So. Is it possible to have the bottom reed with an A on the pull and a G# on the push. This G# would be almost an octave higher than the pull note, allowing the A minor scale.
My guess is no. Such a combination would be impossible on a harmonica, as the respective slot lengths wouldn't match. Even if possible, the A/G# reedblock would probably need to be custom made.
I think that the more usual ("usual" isn't the right term, sorry) solution to this sort of desire for customization would be to actually add an extra button to the bottom of the keyboard (with corresponding lever, pallet, and hole), and add an extra chamber to the reedblock. Then the bottom chamber of the current reedblock can remain large for the low A, and the extra chamber will be smaller for the "accidentals," and you could choose a second accidental in addition to the G#. I know it sounds extreme but the Dominican players that I saw/heard in NYC have been doing this (adding an extra button/lever/pallet/hole/reedblock chamber) to Hohner Ericas.