Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Tunes => Topic started by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 10:23:08 AM

Title: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 10:23:08 AM
Is it possible to play 'If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go ' on a standard 2 row melodeon? Or do you need one of those fancy ones with extra rows? ;)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Lester on June 16, 2011, 10:43:12 AM
Looks achievable as it has a key sig of Bmin (D) with no accidentals

X: 1
T: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go
M: 3/2
L: 1/8
R: three-two
K: Bmin
|: F2B2- B2d2 c2B2 | A2c2- c2e2 d2c2 |
d2f2 f2e2 d2A2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 edcB A2c2 B4 ||
|: f2B2- B2g2 f4 | bagf e2d2 c2B2 |
G2B2 B2d2 c2A2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 edcB A2c2 B4 ||
|: B,2D2- D2F2 B2F2 | E2G2- G2c2 A2c2 |
B2d2 d2F2 D2C2 |1 EDCB, A,2 C2 D2 C2 :|2 EDCB, A,2 C2 B,4 ||
|: d2B2- B2G2 E2A2 | edcB A2 f2 d2 F2 |
B2G2 G2E2 F2D2 |1 EDCB, A,2 C2 D2 C2 :|2 E4 F4 B,4 ||
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 10:47:22 AM
Any advice on where to start? As I have accidentals rather than low notes. Do I need to play it in upper octave?
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Lester on June 16, 2011, 11:12:42 AM
On mature reflection you appear to be missing one note you need ie the Low B (B, in the ABCs).  Think you may find many thread here bemoaning the lack of that note
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: howard mitchell on June 16, 2011, 11:26:32 AM
You're missing just the low B but, as the tune already has a very wide range, if you move it up an octave you'll fall off the dusty end.
How about moving some of the tune up an octave to avoid the low Bs. 

Like this -

X: 1
T: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go
M: 3/2
L: 1/8
R: three-two
K: Bmin
|: F2B2- B2d2 c2B2 | A2c2- c2e2 d2c2 |
d2f2 f2e2 d2A2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 edcB A2c2 B4 ||
|: f2B2- B2g2 f4 | bagf e2d2 c2B2 |
G2B2 B2d2 c2A2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 edcB A2c2 B4 ||
|: B2d2- d2f2 B2F2 | E2G2- G2c2 A2c2 |
B2d2 d2f2 d2c2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 edcB A2 c2 B4 ||
|: d2B2- B2G2 E2A2 | edcB A2 f2 d2 f2 |
B2g2 g2e2 f2d2 |1 edcB A2 c2 d2 c2 :|2 e4 f4 B4 ||


Next problem, do you have a B minor chord or can you remove the thirds.

Howard
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 16, 2011, 11:40:17 AM
Is it possible to play 'If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go ' on a standard 2 row melodeon?
 
Ah - if only there were such a thing as a "standard"  2-row melodeon!  Of the three I play regularly, two are fourth-button start and one is third-button, and the two 4th-button boxes have slightly different arrangements at the lower end.  I suppose my old Hohner C/F is probably nearest to "Standard" (ie as on a from-the-factory Pokerwork, for instance) - but even that has low notes on one row and accidentals on the other!  (:)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Theo on June 16, 2011, 11:59:41 AM
Sarah,  it's a great fiddle tune,  as long as you can manage the high B, fourth finger, on the E string.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 12:04:00 PM
Sarah,  it's a great fiddle tune,  as long as you can manage the high B, fourth finger, on the E string.
If by manage it mean sound like a cat that's got its tail caught in a door....
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: xgx on June 16, 2011, 12:18:42 PM
you could always find a piper to play along with you ;D
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Ellie on June 16, 2011, 12:25:38 PM
On mature reflection you appear to be missing one note you need ie the Low B (B, in the ABCs).  Think you may find many thread here bemoaning the lack of that note

On the other (literally!), you do have that nice low B available for use... It hardly notices - I use that as a fudge for Dark Island, which has an irritating low C natural.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 16, 2011, 12:33:40 PM
In my humble opinion this is one of the very finest tunes of all in the repertoire of English traditional music. It is very dark and has tremendous power and 'guts'. The key of Bm is at first tricky on a D/G melodeon, as it frequently involves some unfamiliar row-crossing, but once you have learned the basic technique of Bm it can serve you in good stead for many other tunes.

Also in my humble opinion, it is fairly essential to play those low B notes in the correct octave if at all possible, in order to preserve the dark feel of the tune. If you don't have the low B on the RH side, then play the B bass on the LH side whenever it comes. I play this tune very successfully using this technique on my D/G Lilium, which sadly does not have the low B on the RH, but I have to admit that it is more powerful on an instrument with low B, and also preferably with extra basses/chords to allow you the F#m chord.

I've included a version of the tune which is as given in both 'A Northern Lass' and 'John of the Green - The Cheshire Way', and which I have worked out chords and fingering with the kind help and advice of Brian Peters in his Sheffield-based melodeon group workshop sessions. The chords given actually work very well indeed, and it is worth spending some time working out the bellows directions and cross-rowing sections required in order to enable these chords to be played.

A great tune: tricky to play well, but intensely rewarding too. Perhaps it ought to be a Tune of the Month candidate sometime.

X:1
T:If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go
M:3/2
L:1/8
R:Triple-time hornpipe
K:Bmin
P:A
"Bm"F2B2 B2d2 c2B2 | "F#m"A2c2 c2"A"e2 d2c2 | "Bm"d2f2 f2e2 d2c2 | "A"edcB "F#m"ABcA "Bm"B4:|
P:B
"Bm"f2B2 "G"B2g2 "Bm"f4 | "G"bagf "Em"edcB "F#m"A4 | "G"G2B2 "A"ABcA edcB | "Bm"F2B2 "F#m"ABcA "Bm"B4:|
P:C
"Bm"B,2D2 D2F2 F2D2 | "Em"E2G2 "A"G2c2 "F#m"c2A2 | "Bm"B2d2 d2F2 F2D2 | "Em"E4 "F#m"F4 "Bm"B,4 :|
P:D
"Bm"d2B2 "G"B2G2 "Em"G2E2 | "A"c2A2 "(F#m)"A2F2 "D"F2D2 | "G"B2G2 "(Em)"G2E2 "D"F2D2 | "Em"E4 "F#m"F4 "Bm"B,4 :|
W:
W:Sources:
W:1. John of the Green - The Cheshire Way, compiled by John Offord
W:2nd ed. 2008, Green Man Music, London.
W:
W:2. A Northern Lass - Traditional Dance Music of North-west England, compiled by Jamie Knowles.
W:Dave Mallinson Publications 1995 (out of print)
W:
W:Notes for players of D/G melodeons:
W:1. If low B is not available on the RH, play the B bass on the LH.
W:2. Chords: These are mostly as they appear in 'A Northern Lass', but with slight amendments
W:worked out by Brian Peters and Steve Dumpleton.
W:3. Chords in brackets in the 'D' music are alternatives and may be omitted if desired.
W:4. If the chord of F#m is unavailable, play a chord of A instead.
W:5. If the chord of Bm is unavailable, play Bm7 instead.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 12:41:31 PM
After enjoying the challenge of mr beveridges maggott....wanted to give IYWNHMTLMG a try as I think its an interesting tune....and a bit of an ear worm.

Also in my humble opinion, it is fairly essential to play those low B notes in the correct octave if at all possible, in order to preserve the dark feel of the tune. If you don't have the low B on the RH side, then play the B bass on the LH side whenever it comes. I play this tune very successfully using this technique on my D/G Lilium, which sadly does not have the low B on the RH, but I have to admit that it is more powerful on an instrument with low B, and also preferably with extra basses/chords to allow you the F#m chord.
F#m ?
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 16, 2011, 12:46:22 PM
F#m ?
Yes - that's what I wrote.  There's nothing mysterious about it. F# minor is the relative minor of A major.
The tonic chord of F#m is made up of the notes F# A C#.

Melodeons with 12 or 18 bass/chords on the LH usually have F#m as one of the chords.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on June 16, 2011, 12:47:53 PM
F#m ?
Yes - that's what I wrote.  There's nothing mysterious about it. F# minor is the relative minor of A major.
The tonic chord of F#m is made up of the notes F# A C#.

Melodeons with 12 or 18 bass/chords on the LH usually have F#m as one of the chords.
ah, okay so I don't have one of those...so don't have to worry about that.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Ellie on June 16, 2011, 12:48:27 PM
Thanks for the chord suggestions Steve - will definitely give them a go (I'm been meaning to give my F#m chord a workout for some time, and this'll do nicely!).
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Anahata on June 16, 2011, 01:05:20 PM
My YouTube Video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTvxvv16QxU) of it is on a Salterelle 2.5 row, but actually the only thing I use that my Oakwood 2-row hasn't got is an F# bass note for the penultimate note of the last two sections. But I can and do regularly play it in sessions on the Oakwood, substituting a D bass for the F#.

Also the Saltarelle gives me a low octave voice which adds a very fitting darkness to the tune.

You do need a low B, which you get on any 4th button start box, or a 3rd button start without accidentals.
(or cheat by using a bass note, not the first time that's been suggested)
You also don't really want a B major chord : thirds coupled out or B minor.

There are no accidentals, but there's a lot of row crossing and getting all those chords in the last section take a bit of practice.

In my humble opinion this is one of the very finest tunes of all in the repertoire of English traditional music.
Indeed. I love it to bits.  :-*

Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Anahata on June 16, 2011, 01:15:15 PM
P.S. just looked at Steve's ABC.
My version is, I think, the one in A Northern Lass
Not having an F#m chord, this is what I do chord wise:

A part
Bm - - | A - - | Bm - - | A - Bm |
B part
Bm -/Em Bm | G Em A | G A - | Bm A Bm |
C part
Bm - - | Em - A | Bm - - | (E)* (D) B |
D part
Bm G Em | A D Bm | G Em D | (E) (D) B |

*(E) and (D) are bass notes without chords
Plain bass notes work well as a variant, bare fifths (thirds out) work well too.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Sandy on June 16, 2011, 04:19:29 PM
My YouTube Video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTvxvv16QxU) of it is on a Salterelle 2.5 row.

I love this tune at this tempo.
 (:)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: GbH on June 17, 2011, 12:59:50 AM
As I remembered liking this tune from hearing some while ago. I thought I try learning it tonight and recording the result.  My attempt has turned out to be a bit more 'rubato' and dirge-y than I'd expected, so I might try again at some point.  I was quite pleased with how the video and recording aspects turned out, even though I didn't do anything much different from usual.    ???

Anyhow, for now, what I managed is here at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teaY6ZX4Khw (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teaY6ZX4Khw), if it's of any interest to anyone trying to learn it too (maybe a lesson in not what to do...).
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 17, 2011, 05:56:12 AM
On mature reflection you appear to be missing one note you need ie the Low B (B, in the ABCs).  Think you may find many thread here bemoaning the lack of that note

Not tried this particular tune but when I was still playing my Castagnari Lily - well it had a low B note push on the left .. so I  .. just played it.  Maybe that's a cheat, but frankly in a session or performance I don't think anyone much notices which end the sound is coming from  ;)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on June 17, 2011, 06:28:50 AM
My YouTube Video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MTvxvv16QxU) of it is on a Salterelle 2.5 row
I love this! If I wanted to play this on a G/C would I need it in e-minor?
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 17, 2011, 10:38:13 AM
If I wanted to play this on a G/C would I need it in e-minor?
Yes - the fingering for Em on a G/C box would equate to Bm on a D/G box.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Tyker on June 17, 2011, 02:15:23 PM
Does anyone play the Bb version from the Vickers manuscript?
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Marje on June 17, 2011, 06:09:15 PM
This is great, I've been meaning to learn this tune for a while and I'm picking up lots of tips. I'm working on the version given by Steve, with his helpful tips: 
In my humble opinion this is one of the very finest tunes of all in the repertoire of English traditional music. It is very dark and has tremendous power and 'guts'. The key of Bm is at first tricky on a D/G melodeon, as it frequently involves some unfamiliar row-crossing, but once you have learned the basic technique of Bm it can serve you in good stead for many other tunes.

I have a box with low notes but no accidentals and just the standard 8 basses. This means I can get the low B, but not the F#m chord.

But here's a workaround that works for my box: on the D row I have a low C# on the pull. If I play this along with the F# and the A chord, it adds the missing 3rd of the F# minor in those penultimate chords of the C and D music. For the other instances of F#m, the A chord sounds fine, but in those stressed ones, the F#m is better.

At least, this is the theory. I can't actually play it with any fluency yet, but at least I know now what I want to do!
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Kautilya on June 17, 2011, 08:17:05 PM
Is it possible to play 'If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go ' on a standard 2 row melodeon? Or do you need one of those fancy ones with extra rows? ;)
This any use to sort it out?
You can switch notes around and up and down high and low by toggline the arrow buttons.

Also, put cursor on keyboard, hold down and drag left or right if the keys to be plonked jump out of sight...

http://www.list-of-chords.com/F%23-minor.php
 (:)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Marje on June 18, 2011, 08:33:27 AM



But here's a workaround that works for my box: on the D row I have a low C# on the pull. If I play this along with the F# and the A chord, it adds the missing 3rd of the F# minor in those penultimate chords of the C and D music. For the other instances of F#m, the A chord sounds fine, but in those stressed ones, the F#m is better.



Bad form to reply to self, but I was of course talking out of the back of my neck there. The note which I borrow from the D row to add is not C# but F#. I am a bit lazy about the theory side of things, but whatever, this seems to work.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: rees on June 18, 2011, 08:48:42 AM



But here's a workaround that works for my box: on the D row I have a low C# on the pull. If I play this along with the F# and the A chord, it adds the missing 3rd of the F# minor in those penultimate chords of the C and D music. For the other instances of F#m, the A chord sounds fine, but in those stressed ones, the F#m is better.


I think you were right first time. You have a full F# minor chord in the right hand pull, comprising C# F# and A.

Bad form to reply to self, but I was of course talking out of the back of my neck there. The note which I borrow from the D row to add is not C# but F#. I am a bit lazy about the theory side of things, but whatever, this seems to work.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Ziachmusi/Louise on July 01, 2011, 08:03:18 AM
So LTD how's it going?. I'm trying but not progessing very well >:(
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: ladydetemps on July 01, 2011, 09:42:38 AM
So LTD how's it going?. I'm trying but not progessing very well >:(
Not progressing really....turned out to be a little too difficult at the moment. Think I need to get more familiar with D row first.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Anahata on July 01, 2011, 10:53:32 AM
It is not by any stretch of the imagination an easy tune to play. I gave up on it several times before really getting my teeth into it.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 01, 2011, 08:29:45 PM
Anahata: Your last comment about taking several goes to this tune is very reassuring.
I've not tried this tune, ( yet! ) but have several ' on the back burner' and keep going back to them, each time hopefully getting a bit further with them. Then I seem to hit a plateau, or sometimes try so hard they somehow get worse!
At this point I let them lie for a while.
It is reassuring it happens to others too!
cheers
Q

ps... it looks like another tune where if mastered, you will by necessity, have learnt a lot.
I'll pencil it in for the long dark evenings of winter  ;)
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: GbH on July 01, 2011, 10:21:26 PM
I can't say I found too much difficulty in actually learning the notes for this tune - much of it seemed to drop under the fingers from the start.  Yet, I still don't really understand how it's supposed to be played.  Instinctively, to me, it feels like it should be slow, so that those progressions can really be savoured.  Yet, by not really having much of a knowledge of folk music, I've really no idea for what or whom such a tune would have been written for.  Is it supposed to be played for some sort of dance? 
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Anahata on July 02, 2011, 12:26:01 AM
I think it's a 3/2 hornpipe, but one with fewer notes and less syncopation than most.
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: TomB on July 02, 2011, 12:41:26 AM
Here's a version by Bellowhead, pretty nippy  :||:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SDTya9bj6ag
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: Alan Morley on July 15, 2011, 07:30:20 PM
Any progress with the tune LDT ?
Title: Re: If You Will Not Have Me, You May Let Me Go....question
Post by: theSmoiler on August 05, 2011, 11:28:01 PM
I first heard this played by Tom Kitching - cracking English fiddler - at Bridgnorth when we first met about 10 years ago. It's a cracking fiddle tune - bound to be some videos of Tom and young fiddler Robbie Sherratt playing this on YouTube. Will look some out, as I very much hear their versions as 'definitive' in some way - along with the way Jenny Coxon plays it on hammered dulcimer.

Diane
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal