Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: TedK on June 17, 2011, 07:53:35 PM
-
Hello everyone,
I have been learning the D/G melodeon for about 6 months now, I think its going pretty well. I'm 32, quite new to folk music but have always been musical so I have many years of experience in playing guitar, keyboards (and a few other things at times) which has definitely been a big help.
I have been wondering however, if there is any reason for certain people's preferences for using 1 or 2 shoulder straps? I started off learning on quite a large Galotta which came with 2 straps, and though I've since acquired a smaller Hohner club and a Sandpiper I have continued to use 2. I'm starting to worry if this might be a bad habit to get into, particularly as I've noticed that many of the really good players (John Kirkpatrick, Spiers) seem to use only one.
So are there any great advantages to using one strap that I'm missing out on, or is it just a matter of preference?
-
Hi Ted,
Welcome aboard the good ship Melnet!
I've been going just under a year, and immediately used 2 straps when I first started. With 2 straps I find the box just sits there, so I can stand up, stretch my legs, sit back down, go for a wonder in the garden etc etc. Having previously always used my knee to rest a concertina on, and only be able to play and hold it for short periods, I find this freedom quite wonderful!
It also allows me to play it whilst having the weight taken totally on my shoulders, freeing up my arms nad hands to simply press the buttons.
One day I might simply press them in roughly the right order :|bl
I think it is down to personal preference, though the contortions I see some melodeon players going through in order to keep the box on their shoulder whilst still trying to play makes me wonder how people only use 1 strap ???
....but I'm sure others out there will say they hate to be 'strapped in'
cheers
Q
-
Definitely a matter of personal preference, there's no right or wrong way here. We even have (at least) one member who doesn't use shoulder straps at all!
-
I use two if I play my Connemara III (probably why I don't play it very often), one for all my other boxes with the exception of my pokerwork (because I have no spare strap) and 1 row which I play with a thumb strap only. So what ever floats your personal boat!
-
I've noticed that many of the really good players (John Kirkpatrick, Spiers) seem to use only one.
So are there any great advantages to using one strap that I'm missing out on, or is it just a matter of preference?
It's an essential presentation if one wants to be a 8) professional
;)
Mind you - JK doesn't try throwing his BCC# box around with just one strap.
-
i think it depends on preference, i use two!
-
Personally, I use a single shoulder strap and no thumb-strap; my first melodeon came witth a single strap, so that was how I learned and I've never seen any reason to change. In the early days I used the thumb-strap (because the box came with one) but later discovered it was easier (for me) to dispense with it. Down to personal preference - whichever you feel most comfortable with.
Graham
-
You could do worse than look through the many youtubes of members here to see the 101 different styles of holding the box
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,totm.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,totm.html)
-
Interesting cross-topic with The Mustard Board- Double use of my response.
When I started playing box a few years ago, I started with one strap. Then I commenced lessons with John Williams who is a proponent of two straps. In fact, sometimes the left strap slips down, and I am back to playing one strap. He reminds me to use it at that point.
His point is the that the two straps imprve the stability of the fingerboard side of the box, and prevents supporting the bass side of the box on the left leg which bolluxes up the air flow and bellows technique
So who wants to start talking about playing cross legged or feet flat on the floor which is where The Session's topic morphed from.
-
Interesting cross-topic with The Mustard Board- Double use of my response.
When I started playing box a few years ago, I started with one strap. Then I commenced lessons with John Williams who is a proponent of two straps. In fact, sometimes the left strap slips down, and I am back to playing one strap. He reminds me to use it at that point.
His point is the that the two straps imprve the stability of the fingerboard side of the box, and prevents supporting the bass side of the box on the left leg which bolluxes up the air flow and bellows technique
So who wants to start talking about playing cross legged or feet flat on the floor which is where The Session's topic morphed from.
I don't think there's ever been any danger of my left knee (+leg) following the bass end, it'd be a rather odd thing to do with your knees opening and closing all the time ???
Anyhow, personally, I've always used one strap and if possible sit down. I've never got on with having the melodeon strapped up close, it feels cramped and awkward. I like a more relaxed position with top of the box about six inches or so forward, resting (the treble end!) on my left leg and usually up against my right leg giving the tension on the single strap. Yes, this is a very common set-up.
One of the reasons I like it is because of "the stability of the fingerboard side of the box". :P
-
..it also prevents wear on the back of the bellows from rubbing against sharp clothing (belt buckles,etc). I'm also a single strapper.
-
When I got my first melodeon 6 months ago it came with one strap, I found it awkward having to hold the treble end on the push - didn't feel very natural. Quite a revelation getting the second strap, made a huge difference to my learning process, much more stability. I'd recommend any beginner to give two straps a try.
-
My norm is double strap when standing playing for morris. Single strap when seated.
One row - one strap or thumb strap.
I learnt with one strap, but started using two straps comparatively recently as found I was sometimes getting back pains when playing standing for a length of time.
BTW From my memory - John Spiers uses 2 straps , Pete Coe a single long strap, and Tony Hall (when I saw him last) used bailer twine!!!!!!
Andy
-
Started with two straps but ended up using one strap for erm...practical reasons.
-
As I remember from the last time this thread was going 'round, 1 strap="cool", 2 strap="uncool".
For playing standing, 2 are the way to go, for most (including yrs trly).
If sitting, does not matter much.
-
I find that playing left-handed and therefore using the lower half of the buttons in the main (lower both in terms of height and pitch - surely that means left-handed is the correct way to play?), if I only use one strap the box has too strong a tendency to rotate about my thumb on "push." If I could position the thumb higher up (where it would go playing right handed, for example), this would be cured.
Maybe I need a LL-reeded DG box and play in the upper octave? I'd quite like to try a one-row in the upper octave and see if it helps. I can't stand trying it for long on Lilly. Even the dog objects to the squeaky high notes - and she's deaf!
-
Personally, I favour one and a half.....
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1032.0.html
-
I also play left handed, usually standing up. My melodeon is small and light weight (it's an Yvus). I always use 2 straps. However, I play the melodeon in the Irish style position, extremely to one side (in my case the right side) with the edge of the treble keyboard central on my chest. This puts most of the weight onto one strap and would cause the other strap to keep falling down, so I also use a back-strap to keep the 2 straps together at my back. (Back-straps are often used by players of heavy accordions to keep the straps from working their way off the shoulders).
-
Thanks for your replies everyone, I guess I will stick with the 2 straps. I must admit I think that 1 strap kind of looks cooler!
-
I must admit I think that 1 strap kind of looks cooler!
Oh they all say that ;)
-
I must admit I think that 1 strap kind of looks cooler!
Oh they all say that ;)
It feels cooler too 8)
Gone from two straps to one and a half straps to one strap and the box is getting further away from me. Must be the thumb strap next >:E
-
I must admit I think that 1 strap kind of looks cooler!
Oh they all say that ;)
It feels cooler too 8)
Gone from two straps to one and a half straps to one strap and the box is getting further away from me. Must be the thumb strap next >:E
one and a half straps?
-
I must admit I think that 1 strap kind of looks cooler!
Oh they all say that ;)
It feels cooler too 8)
Gone from two straps to one and a half straps to one strap and the box is getting further away from me. Must be the thumb strap next >:E
one and a half straps?
yes.......where one is a sort of 'off the shoulder number' ::)
(:)
-
one strap for dance playing,change box goes so much faster.
two straps for busking and marching,hard to play standing with one strap.
Thumb strap is for old men with polyester pants.
-
Thumb strap is for old men with polyester pants.
:o
Ermm... no, I don't think so. I don't think Katie Howson or Jeannie Harris would agree with you :(
-
The thumbstrap is useful for a quick start when returning from the bar/toilet/etc to find everyone half way through your favourite tune. I have even been known to play my single voice Oakwood just using the thumbstrap while standing up - but wouldn't fancy it with anything much heavier!
Martin
-
Back in the day when I was the box player for our dance band, I used to use 2 straps so I could stand up and cavort about. I developed (i.e. like to think I 'invented') a 2 strap/one shoulder method whereby the left strap is slightly too long. Put both straps on as normal, lift the left strap over the head so it too comes over the right shoulder and you have a steady right hand without the left strap falling into Sandy's 'off the shoulder' stylee, which otherwise I found to be a problem. If anyone's keen to adopt this method - and it has been known! - I'll p'raps demonstrate it on YouTube sometime. It's possible that this is the same method as some others have described but I must admit that some of the descriptions left me baffled and bamboozled. 's all academic now as I'm nearly always sat so only use one strap in as louche a fashion as possible. 8)
Small edit for typo.
-
The thumb strap comes in handy when your palms are sweaty (I know TMI) stops my hand slipping off the treble end. ;)
-
My two strap/one shoulder method is now available for viewing - check out the Recording and Videos section if you fancy giving it a go.
-
Bearing in mind the travails I've had over the past two years what with bad shoulders, elbows and hands...
I started off using two straps standing and one sitting down although I found that the left hand strap was always falling off so I got a back strap. this worked well while using a Tommy but when I upgraded to a Trilly (about 4.3kg) I found that even with the extra weight and back strap trying to play loudly for morris I found that the left shoulder still fell off about halfway through each dance. As a result I seemed to knacker my right shoulder, which got better eventually but at the expense of my left elbow and hand.
Since then I have gone back to using the Tommy for morris with one strap which, I was surprised to find, I feel really comfortable playing. When I play the Trilly, I only use one strap and do so sitting down.
In my case, what I think it all comes down to is that in trying to use two straps I could never get them set up so they were in a stable comfortable position so I compensated by contorting my body into ever stranger shapes to try and keep the think in place. So my advice would be to, yes, do what you feels right but be constantly aware that you may be storing up problems later
-
Having had neck and back strains over many years, when I started playing 3 years ago I was concerned I might not be able to cope with the weight of the box/and or would have to contort myself (with one strap) to accommodate a playing position. I found 1 strap difficult so switched to two, but had difficulty with scuffing the bellows with the buckle of the left strap Then some kind melneter posted some instructions from an accordion site about how to adjust two straps to make them sit evenly (one being longer than the other). I found it really useful and I now have syatem which avoids this and back pain , thus I can concentrate more on playing :||: Can anyone find it? (:)
-
PS Not often you see the words 'morris' and 'cool' in the same paragraph ;D
-
Peter:
Sorry to correct you, but the reality is that 'morris' and 'cool' *do* go together.
If you've tried to dance out on a " Summer's Night" sometime over that last 3-4 summers, you'll discover the morris is always cool.....verging on bl**dy freezing ;D
....not to mention damp!
;)
Q
-
My two strap/one shoulder method is now available for viewing - check out the Recording and Videos section if you fancy giving it a go.
I tried this tonight and am impressed! It works as well sitting or standing and I'll keep with it. It gives a bit of movement but keeps the right hand steady. But is it cool or not?
-
My two strap/one shoulder method is now available for viewing - check out the Recording and Videos section if you fancy giving it a go.
I tried this tonight and am impressed! It works as well sitting or standing and I'll keep with it. It gives a bit of movement but keeps the right hand steady. But is it cool or not?
Whether it's cool or not depends on how much style you can put into your jiggling about while playing. ;D BTW I'm seriously pleased that someone's tried and found it useful. That's at least 2 converts I've got to it in the space of only 30 odd years. I'd be amazed if others haven't also come up with it, but I can vouch for the fact that I discovered it independently lots of years ago.
-
As I understand it part of John J Kimmel's fantastic ability's related to his not using any straps and a definite part of that was his right hand (yes right hand) bellows technique apparently he employed a little left but mainly right bellows movement, the no straps effect is something employed in Irish and Cajun Melodeon (1 row) not by all but certainly by some and Concertina players, well at least the freedom to move both. If I've got it right I believe straps on melodeon (1 row) were banned in competition in Ireland, there is a great clip on you tube of a guy playing a 2 row box with great effect with no straps, I'll try and find it. The effect of tapping on the right hand buttons and allowing the bellows to move with that action is I think well known by concertina players (it works on both sides) at least. Personaly I prefer the box to be firmly anchored but then again I only play seated these days, mory
-
As I've said previously here, I use 2 straps and find it comfortable.
Sometimes they slip a bit and feel like they're coming off, not a problem if sitting cos you can wriggle them back between tunes.
My morris friends have a short strap across the back to prevent this when playing for morris, and it 'came with the box' and are black leather matching the rest of the straps.
Anyone know if you can buy the short linking strap separately?
....in a 'natural light brown Castagnai leather' shade?
Just curious!
Q
-
To paraphrase the words of a song I once heard - Is 2 straps one too many or 1 strap one too few?
Adds nothing to the discussion, I know.
Nigel
-
As I've said previously here, I use 2 straps and find it comfortable.
You've said that (:) mory
-
I've got to repeat myself, but one and a half really is the answer for me! I've just played at a dance al evening, and although I'm not young, I came away with no aches and pains, no RSI, just comfort and easy playing, and all that with a heavy box. If you just haven't got it, send me a PM, I'll try to explain how it works one-to-one.
-
As I've said previously here, I use 2 straps and find it comfortable.
Sometimes they slip a bit and feel like they're coming off, not a problem if sitting cos you can wriggle them back between tunes.
My morris friends have a short strap across the back to prevent this when playing for morris, and it 'came with the box' and are black leather matching the rest of the straps.
Anyone know if you can buy the short linking strap separately?
....in a 'natural light brown Castagnai leather' shade?
Just curious!
Q
You can buy them from Bernard Loffet, through his website. Very quick response, and very reasonable prices. I have several, and they do the job well...
-
ohhh.....thanks Guy!
I'll take a look, but I will have to be *very careful*.....
some of his boxes look knee tremblingly lovely :|||:
thanks for the tip
Q
-
Sorry to correct you, but the reality is that 'morris' and 'cool' *do* go together.
If you've tried to dance out on a " Summer's Night" sometime over that last 3-4 summers, you'll discover the morris is always cool.....verging on bl**dy freezing ;D
....not to mention damp!
;)
Q
Yes so I have found :D
Lovely session with 2 other morris teams a couple of weeks ago on Portland Island - force 6? gale coming in off the sea. I had a famoily of Australians with me - they said it was freezing, but the dancing was 'cool' ; I told them it was cool and the dancing was hot!
;D