Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on June 18, 2011, 11:16:51 PM
-
The recent poll 'Which Make is Your Box' (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7205.0.html) caused Keithypete to enquire about the Borsini B/C/C# I have that's awaiting repair. Pictures were requested and I thought I might as well share them with you all and perhaps other people may add other information and pictures. Borsini no longer produce any diatonics and I have no idea when this one was made. I'll open the box up and take some internal pics on another day. This box has no registers btw so it's pretty basic. The pics can be viewed in greater detail on Photobucket (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/).
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0558.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0557.jpg)(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0556.jpg)
-
Here is a photo of the Borsini BCC# I had until earlier this year. It is a 4v (LMMM) treble, 43 key, 7 treble couplers; 120 bass, 5v, 4 couplers. It dates from the late 1970s.
From the style, yours is possibly from the 1950s-60s. It looks as though it has a stepped keyboard and mushroom buttons (?) - so could have been made on a 3-row CBA base.
-
Tallship - a very nice looking box. Have you had it playing at all or has it always been poorly? How many sets of reeds does it have?
This Borsini is very different to mine. Apart from the fact that mine has five couplers on the treble side and two on the bass, it is obviously a different model. Flat keyboard is another obvious difference.
Photos here: http://www.flickr.com/photos/keithypete/with/5593786338/
I would really like to know IF mine is a Borsini, and whether or not it started out life as a B/C/C#, as Tallship's did.
Bill - nice box also. Possibly more similar to mine, although mine only has 12 melodeon-style bass.
-
As a quick reply my Borsini has a deeply stepped keyboard, it's a fairly recent(ish) acquisition and I've not tried to play it as I've no idea how to! I thought I might have a go at restoring this myself but the briefest of inspections tells me it's beyond my limited capabilities. I'm open to offers! :|glug
-
These pictures remind me greatly of the blue-grey Borsini that Bill Powrie played in the early fifties, with his brother Ian Powrie prior to his National Service, and with Jim Cameron and his Scottish Dance Band after his demob. from the RAF. When he was called up, his place in Ian Powrie's band was filled by Jimmy Blue. Whether his box had a stepped keyboard or not I don't have any idea, as we are talking about 60 years ago, and I was 18 and more interested in girls than button boxes at that time.
These names won't mean a great deal to English readers, but mature Scottish members may recognise them. Google Bill Powrie and you will find a not very good picture of him with his accordion partially in the frame.
PL
-
Here is a photo showing Bill Powrie holding a box identical to Tallship's. It's the Jim Cameron Band line-up, probably from the late 1950s.
-
Tallship - a very nice looking box. Have you had it playing at all or has it always been poorly? How many sets of reeds does it have?
It's very short of air (bellows gaskets very compressed) so I've not really tried to play it, it has three sets of treble reeds, MMM
-
Here is a photo showing Bill Powrie holding a box identical to Tallship's. It's the Jim Cameron Band line-up, probably from the late 1950s.
Many thanks for the pic Bill, very interesting indeed. Might I ask if there is a higher resolution version that you could email to me? I ask because I think I can see something in the picture that would show that not only is mine identical but that it is very possibly the same instrument! Trouble is when I try to zoom in to get a proper look the picture goes straight into pixelation, obscuring the detail I'm after.
Pete.
-
Hi Pete,
Yes, I had to reduce size and quality to get below the 256k limit for attachments. PM or email me your email address (mine is below my profile pic) and I'll send you a better copy.
Bill
-
I was thinking I would need to take a close up pic tomorrow but after looking at the three I'd already taken it was obvious I'd be able to zoom in without loosing too much quality. So here's the pic showing a dark patch around the word Castelfidardo, this is a patch of paint(!) It looks to me like Bill Powrie's box has the same kind of dark patch in the same place, coincidence? I'm hoping Bill can compare this with the original picture and take an educated guess. :D Larger version of the pic is here (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/?action=view¤t=Borsini4.jpg).
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/Borsini4.jpg)
-
I enlarged your original pick to 150% the part thats the same angle of the box as in the pick from Bill, enlarged that one to150% as well, if you flick between the two they look identical, the lower mark in the marble finish on the same side is the same as well, mory
-
Thanks mory, I did try the same thing but as soon as I enlarged the old photo the coarseness of the pixels made it difficult for me to make any kind of objective comparison. I must say though that my gut feeling is that this is the same box.
-
I must say though that my gut feeling is that this is the same box.
I do hope so - be nice to get it restored and playing again?
AL (:)
-
I do hope so - be nice to get it restored and playing again?
AL (:)
Indeed so. I have to say this is a turn of events I hadn't envisaged. I bought this box a while ago from a melnet member with health problems that meant they wouldn't be playing our kind of boxes again. I meant to take a good look at it and decide if I could take on the B/C/C# system along with the Stradella basses, but I've been too tied up in other things to evaluate it properly and thought about moving it on. I've attracted an immediate response, straight forward and genuinely interested in buying the box for what it is. Now I find it might just be quite an oddball box with a provenance, overall effect on me is zilch because I don't play this system and now realise I probably never will. I'd love to pass it on to a player of the system who showed an immediate interest and is happy to get it restored but I'm now wondering if I should contact the original seller and offer to sell it back at cost. Life gets tiresome at times!
-
I have to admit I thought of making you an offer for it - however the impending wedding of daughter no.1 is proving to much of a strain upon current finances :o - and anyway, Mrs. Hallelujah would never allow yet another box into the house ;D
But I really do hope that you find a suitable home for it!
regards, AL
-
I have peered at the photo in my book through a magnifying glass and compared Bill Powrie's accordion with Pete's, and I'm convinced they are the same. Not only does Bill Powrie's have a similar dark area around the word "Castelfidardo", but there are several areas of the celluloid marbling on the treble side which look identical (I've detailed these to Pete via email).
The photo of the Jim Cameron Band is from a book "Who's On The Dance Music Tonight? 1945-1970", by James L. Helm of Ayr, published in 1998. I was speaking to Jimmy last night at the weekly Scottish Country Dancing in Troon, and he was fair tickled that a photo in his book was being used in a bit of accordion detective work.
Bill
-
You guys are spinning a fascinating yarn. Thanks for sharing it with the rest of us!
-
The photo of the Jim Cameron Band is from a book "Who's On The Dance Music Tonight? 1945-1970", by James L. Helm of Ayr, published in 1998. I was speaking to Jimmy last night at the weekly Scottish Country Dancing in Troon, and he was fair tickled that a photo in his book was being used in a bit of accordion detective work.
Bill
Drifting off topic quite a lot...
Do you regularly go to the Scottish dancing in Troon? I lived in Troon for a while as a child, and my parents have a flat there, visit regularly and are keen Scottish country dancers. Ian & Christine McDonald.
-
Hi Alison,
Small world! Yes, I go along to Troon most weeks (May to August) - not to dance, but to listen to the bands. Ayr branch RSCDS have weekly summer dances at Troon, with live bands, and this coincides with the three local Accordion & Fiddle clubs having a summer break. A fair number of local accordion players go along to sit up in the balcony of Troon Concert Hall, listen to the bands, watch the dancing and, most importantly, have a right good blether over tea and biscuits at the interval.
-
I know this is adding to the thread drift, but wasn't there a live broadcast from Troon for the 'Take the Floor Show' with Robbie Shepherd recently? Sounded like a good gig!
AL
-
I know this is adding to the thread drift, but wasn't there a live broadcast from Troon for the 'Take the Floor Show' with Robbie Shepherd recently? Sounded like a good gig!
AL
Yes, back in February, and I contrived not to be there! It featured Ian Muir's band. His was also the band at the Troon dancing last week. Ian is the head accordion tutor for the Scottish Music course at the RSAMD in Glasgow, and the man who taught me the Stradella bass (I'm still struggling to implement all he showed me!).
-
I know this is adding to the thread drift
Feel free to drift away! In true melnet fashion the main business of the thread is over in that three people agree that I have an old box that once belonged to a pro player. I also think that Bill Young's opinion (expressed in an email) that while this is all very interesting it doesn't affect the value of the box because Bill Powrie was just a pro player not a solo star (or Starr!) is very true, so I won't be contacting the chap I bought it from.
-
I have peered at the photo in my book through a magnifying glass and compared Bill Powrie's accordion with Pete's, and I'm convinced they are the same. Not only does Bill Powrie's have a similar dark area around the word "Castelfidardo", but there are several areas of the celluloid marbling on the treble side which look identical (I've detailed these to Pete via email).
.....and he was fair tickled that a photo in his book was being used in a bit of accordion detective work.
Bill
Bill and Tallships and Mory - Yes this detective work is good stuff - family trees for accordions!
- now I have this Paolo Soprani b/c/c# ;D which I bought via the west country shop (was it Hyde Accordions?) in 1996. Previous owner lived in Jersey. Do any of you fancy taking that one on? Bill has played it briefly. Photo evidence could be supplied, but DNA sampling might be difficult.
Best wishes to all DaveW
-
Bill and Tallships and Mory - Yes this detective work is good stuff - family trees for accordions!
- now I have this Paolo Soprani b/c/c# ;D which I bought via the west country shop (was it Hyde Accordions?) in 1996. Previous owner lived in Jersey. Do any of you fancy taking that one on? Bill has played it briefly. Photo evidence could be supplied, but DNA sampling might be difficult.
Hi Dave,
I fancy that would be a taller order. There have probably been far more Paolo Soprani BCC#s made than Borsinis. However, there may be fewer like yours (5 coupler, 96 bass) than the more common ones like mine (9 coupler, 80 bass), so possibly someone can throw some light on its history. It might be worth while starting a new thread with some pictures.
We were able to get where we did with the Borsini thanks to xnsman remembering Bill Powrie playing one.
Bill
-
We were able to get where we did with the Borsini thanks to xnsman remembering Bill Powrie playing one.
Bill
[/quote]
Hello Bill and Pete
When we meet, you can tell me how to start a new thread :-\. Meantime I send a piccie of the Paolo, not hoping for results, more to see how it is done (http://) - Oh well, I failed on that one, picture files too big at 456kb I think best wishes Dave W
-
Just to round things off here are a few pics of the inside of the Borsini. Larger pics here (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/).
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0564.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0567.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0563.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0562.jpg)
-
Hello Bill and Pete
When we meet, you can tell me how to start a new thread :-\. Meantime I send a piccie of the Paolo, not hoping for results, more to see how it is done (http://) - Oh well, I failed on that one, picture files too big at 456kb I think best wishes Dave W
Starting a new thread is easy enough, just go into the discussion forum you want put the thread in and look for the tabs at the right hand side above the list of topics, click on 'New Topic' and away you go.
Posting pics is a little harder, you'll have to either edit your images to reduce the file size or upload the files to a host site like Photo Bucket and link to the images which is what I do :||:
-
Starting a new thread is easy enough, just go into the discussion forum you want put the thread in and look for the tabs at the right hand side above the list of topics, click on 'New Topic' and away you go.
Posting pics is a little harder, you'll have to either edit your images to reduce the file size or upload the files to a host site like Photo Bucket and link to the images which is what I do :||:
[/quote]
Thank you Pete, these must be useful skills, but suddenly I'm busy on other matters - The Roland fr18 was delivered on thursday! >:E
Perhaps I need to start be another thread on that the other one on the suject seem to have run out of steam!
best wishes
-
I'm really glad I asked for a picture of your Borsini tallship, what a story it turned out to be. It hasn't proved quite so interesting in regards to my 'so-called' Borsini. As a last ditch plea for some info - doesn't anyone recognize my three-row. It is tuned G/D/A at the moment but I think it might have been a B/C/C#, with its two rows of pallets operated by three rows of buttons. Fingers-crossed.
-
More pics, this time it's the keyboard. As usual larger/ better quality pics here (http://s279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/). You can also see the three bits of celluloid that are missing, all from the right hand edge of the keyboard, it doesn't affect the playability in any way but it is a shame.
(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0568.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0569.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0570.jpg) (http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/Borsini/DSCN0571.jpg)
-
Recent (today) observations. The air valve is utterly pathetic! Holding it open for several seconds is required to fully open the bellows and 'leaking while you are playing' just doesn't seem to work at all. Conclusion: box designed for player skilled in controlling air without needing a massive suck/blow valve!
The tuning is largely quite respectable in terms of pitch but the vibrato offset is pretty wet. Many notes are slow to start and 'burble' quite a lot but the old leather valves are so badly distorted they probably never close fully, this combined with the badly compressed bellows gasket is robbing the reeds of air, keeps them pretty slow. Some notes (very few to be fair) are drastically off key, noticeably the C in the high octave on the C row which plays B - pretty well to be honest, as if it's deliberate. Given that this was probably a pro players box is there any reason for tuning the high C to B?
Before too long this box will probably be in the hands of a B/C/C# player capable of evaluating it properly. ::)
-
Recent (today) observations. The air valve is utterly pathetic! Holding it open for several seconds is required to fully open the bellows and 'leaking while you are playing' just doesn't seem to work at all. Conclusion: box designed for player skilled in controlling air without needing a massive suck/blow valve!
Or that it was definitely based on a CBA... they have pathetic air valves.
-
Or that it was definitely based on a CBA... they have pathetic air valves.
Yep, as an English concertina player with an instrument that has an air valve that isn't strictly required (other than to close the bellows if you're so unskilled as to end the piece in the wrong position) I understand what you're saying. Why would an experienced B/C/C# player buy such an instrument though? Also I'm surprised that I cannot find another picture of a three row Borsini anywhere, CBA or otherwise. Pretty odd that.
-
Although it doesn't clearly show it in this clip, Robert Nairn has very economical and efficient bellows movement which suggests little reliance on a the air button.
.. easy.........for such an accomplished player as Robert ;)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VwL7o1YrItQ
(a few other instruments thrown in for good measure ...)
-
Just to round off the story, Bill Powrie's nephew, who is also called Bill Powrie, now has the Borsini as well as his uncle's Shand Morino. I'm sure Bill won't mind me quoting part of his email as the story is better told in his own words.
Just wanted to let you know that John Crawford has restored The Borsini and I played it yesterday!
It has new reeds and we found a FD number from Forbes of Dundee on the bellows. Unfortunately, John only has the Forbes Charts that tell the dates of sale for the Morino. I contacted two ex Forbes repair men but no joy. Still waiting a reply from Borsini ,as we found no. 12 on treble and no. 11 on bass, which should tell them the year of manufacture. Boxes were fully assembled , then the reeds taken out until delivery as they could go out of tune,if left in. As they were hand made the craftsman will have picked up the wrong side , so there will be an opposite pair kicking about somewhere.
John also found his own initials inside the bellows in his "usual place" and the date 1972 from when he last repaired it!
Malcolm ( Mac ) Harcus contacted Robbie Shepherd after my email was read out, and we have now spoken twice on Skype. He was with Bill on the very first day he got the Borsini in 1944,45 and they played together at the Perth Academy school dance with it in that same year, when Bill was 13 or 14.
I am taking it to an exhibition of Button Boxes in Glamis today and it goes back to finish off restoration ( bellows leak) on Monday to John in Freuchie.
All's well that ends well! :D
-
The old box is in full playing fettle again, Ian Cruikshanks playing The Polish Polka on Bill Powrie's 1940's Borsini B/C/C# (https://www.dropbox.com/s/4z8d7lzfz880ps5/Polish%20Polka.mp3).
-
Luv that sound!
-
It could have been yours Graham!
-
I know!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Mutter, mutter, mutter ;D
-
The old box is in full playing fettle again, Ian Cruikshanks playing The Polish Polka on Bill Powrie's 1940's Borsini B/C/C# (https://www.dropbox.com/s/4z8d7lzfz880ps5/Polish%20Polka.mp3).
Well done Pete for your part and the ending/new beginning. All the Best mory
-
Well done Pete for your part and the ending/new beginning. All the Best mory
Thank you for your kind words mory but I feel as if I did very little!
Pete.