Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: sandwich on June 21, 2011, 03:28:32 PM

Title: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 21, 2011, 03:28:32 PM
I'd like to clear the following points about tuning after getting slightly confused by 2 different sellers. Apologies in advance if these questions are tedious, but I'm dying to put in my order for a box but am at my wits end trying to figure out the specifications.

I was playing a lovely 3 voice Serenellini the other day which was described as being tuned 20 cents apart. I quite liked the broad, rich quality of the sound. Would this be described as very wet tuned or would this be categorised as swing tuning?

Is it the case with a 3 voice box that one reed is tuned to concert pitch (440), and the other 2 reeds are tuned slightly differently? For instance, looking at another brand of box I was advised that the sound I wanted might be 443 or 443-and-a-half. What does this mean exactly?
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: waltzman on June 21, 2011, 03:38:29 PM
'Twenty cents apart at A440' is a precise way to describe a tuning.  'Wet' and 'swing' are subjective.  Most people I think would consider 20 cents to be a fairly wet tuning. 
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Theo on June 21, 2011, 03:54:52 PM

Is it the case with a 3 voice box that one reed is tuned to concert pitch (440), and the other 2 reeds are tuned slightly differently?

With a three voice box you could have two quite different setups, even before you consider the tremolo aspect of the tuning.  You can have three reeds in the same midrange, often described as MMM,  or one reed an octave lower described as LMM.  Once you have established which of those you are looking at then you can start talking about tremolo, but to be honest its usually best just to trust your ears and just choose a box you like the sound of without worrying about the technical spec.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: diatonix on June 21, 2011, 04:01:36 PM
Of course, de gustibus non est disputandum, but +20 Cent makes more sense at A220Hz. At A440Hz I might suggest +17 Cent and at A880Hz about +14 Cent. When tuning a pleasantly wet 3 voice tremolo I tend to tune the lower reeds at slightly more than half these values: e.g. -14 Cent / - 12 Cent  /  - 8 Cent.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on June 21, 2011, 04:25:11 PM
Of course, de gustibus non est disputandum, but +20 Cent makes more sense at A220Hz. At A440Hz I might suggest +17 Cent and at A880Hz about +14 Cent. When tuning a pleasantly wet 3 voice tremolo I tend to tune the lower reeds at slightly more than half these values: e.g. -14 Cent / - 12 Cent  /  - 8 Cent.

Could you at least say where the place of business is where you do such careful tuning? Other people on the forum who are in "the business" at least indicate who they are and where people can contact their business.  Peter Hyde, Bryan LaFleur, Theo Gibb, Rees Wesson, Lester Bailey, each of these people in the melodeon business has at least an indication of their business in their signature (or name!), if not a link.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 21, 2011, 04:39:31 PM
Quote
When tuning a pleasantly wet 3 voice tremolo I tend to tune the lower reeds at slightly more than half these values: e.g. -14 Cent / - 12 Cent  /  - 8 Cent.
Well I would take issue with that, A=440 at a tuning of +/- 20 cents is NOT too wet for me, in fact when tuning my trichord 3 voice for Scottish music I've gone to a considerably wider margin than that. I am, of course, just a humble amateur. But half those values would be for me waay too dry. So I'd agree with Theo - and say let your ears do the choosing.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 21, 2011, 05:26:37 PM
Well I would take issue with that, A=440 at a tuning of +/- 20 cents is NOT too wet for me

I didn't think the 20 cent apart sounded too wet either (at least not on the Serenellini that I played).

I take the point about letting your ears decide, but it's not always possible as I have been limited to playing the accordions that were on sale and discussing the type of sound I wanted with the sellers. Discussing the sound I was after, Mairtin O'Connor said something about me maybe wanting tuning of 443 to 443 ½. Does this represent a "wet" sound?
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 21, 2011, 05:36:12 PM

Is it the case with a 3 voice box that one reed is tuned to concert pitch (440), and the other 2 reeds are tuned slightly differently?

With a three voice box you could have two quite different setups, even before you consider the tremolo aspect of the tuning.  You can have three reeds in the same midrange, often described as MMM,  or one reed an octave lower described as LMM.
Is the 8'-8'-16' configuration less common than MMM? Which configuration would you recommend? Are there adv/disadv for either? This is one question that I didn't think of asking
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 21, 2011, 05:46:27 PM
You might find this helpful too:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,voices_tunings.html
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Theo on June 21, 2011, 05:49:18 PM
Is the 8'-8'-16' configuration less common than MMM? Which configuration would you recommend? Are there adv/disadv for either? This is one question that I didn't think of asking

It's really down to what sound you prefer.  Having a low voice clearly gives a lower sound! It also gives the possibility of a wider range of sounds if you have stops/couplers. Possible disadvantages were discussed at length in this recent thread:
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6769.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6769.0.html)
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: waltzman on June 21, 2011, 06:05:12 PM
Discussing the sound I was after, Mairtin O'Connor said something about me maybe wanting tuning of 443 to 443 ½. Does this represent a "wet" sound?

This would be the reference frequency by which all the 'on pitch' reeds are tuned and doesn't have anything to do with the wetness of the tremolo.  Historically (and currently) I think many accordionists liked their accordions tuned slightly sharp.  It tends to make it sound brighter as I understand it and it would also compensate for the tendency of the reeds to flatten in pitch when played forcefully.  I think the base frequency for the standard tuning of all Corona II's is slightly sharp....maybe 441.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Theo on June 21, 2011, 06:16:05 PM
Discussing the sound I was after, Mairtin O'Connor said something about me maybe wanting tuning of 443 to 443 ½. Does this represent a "wet" sound?

This would be the reference frequency by which all the 'on pitch' reeds are tuned and doesn't have anything to do with the wetness of the tremolo.  Historically (and currently) I think many accordionists liked their accordions tuned slightly sharp.  It tends to make it sound brighter as I understand it and it would also compensate for the tendency of the reeds to flatten in pitch when played forcefully.  I think the base frequency for the standard tuning of all Corona II's is slightly sharp....maybe 441.

Mairtin may have meant 443 for the high reed ie 440 for one reed 443 for the other.  You probably need to ask him to clarify what he meant.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 21, 2011, 07:01:32 PM
Quote
Discussing the sound I was after, Mairtin O'Connor said something about me maybe wanting tuning of 443 to 443 ½. Does this represent a "wet" sound?
Varying the frequency between the reedsets would of course produce various results. If the middle set were tuned to 440hz and the top set 443+ then that would produce, in my opinion, a nice 'warble' - though again (and this is purely my opinion and it's all in the ears of the beholder!) I wouldn't consider it a terribly wet sound.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: waltzman on June 21, 2011, 07:09:30 PM

Mairtin may have meant 443 for the high reed ie 440 for one reed 443 for the other.  You probably need to ask him to clarify what he meant.

Yes.  What was I thinking?  That's more likely what he meant.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 21, 2011, 07:58:28 PM
Mairtin may have meant 443 for the high reed ie 440 for one reed 443 for the other.  You probably need to ask him to clarify what he meant.
Yep I think that's what he meant. But if it's 3 reeds would it mean 440 for 2 reeds and 443 for the other (either MML or MMM)....or am I making sense?

Also, if the reeds are 20 cent apart, as mentioned earlier, what would that represent in terms of a 440 number? Again, I know I'm not really making sense here but I hope you can decipher what I'm trying to get at
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 22, 2011, 07:11:37 PM
When you have LMM reeds the L reed is tuned exactly one octave lower than the 440 M reed the other M reed is tuned sharp to give the tremolo. MMM reeds are usually tuned with one reed at 440, one reed slightly flat and the other slightly sharp.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 22, 2011, 11:30:29 PM
When you have LMM reeds the L reed is tuned exactly one octave lower than the 440 M reed the other M reed is tuned sharp to give the tremolo. MMM reeds are usually tuned with one reed at 440, one reed slightly flat and the other slightly sharp.
Thanks for that, wasn't sure if the L reed was tuned slightly off (sharp or flat).  So if I ask for "demi-swing: 12 cents at A=440" with LMM, that should give me a nice softish sound in MM and a broad full sound in LMM, would you say?
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 23, 2011, 12:11:28 AM
So if I ask for "demi-swing: 12 cents at A=440" with LMM, that should give me a nice softish sound in MM and a broad full sound in LMM, would you say?

You will get a broad full sound in LMM, whether you get a 'nice softish sound' in MM is pretty subjective, the beat rate won't be huge but it will be noticable. I've no idea if 'demi swing' is halfway between swing and wet or swing and dry! I think you need to listen to lots of recorded boxes and decide which sounds closest to your favourite sound. An accordion tech will be able to take it from there.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: old geezer on June 23, 2011, 03:52:36 AM
copied from another thread;

"Three mid range reeds are almost always tuned with one at concert pitch, one above and one below.

An additional possibility here is that the high reed and the low reed may be tuned a different offset from the middle reed, eg you might have (in cents) -6, 0, +12 or various other combinations.  This give a more complex pattern of interference between the three pitches resulting in a richer set of harmonics."


I've had my MMM Corso tuned to this suggestion, and to my ears it's very good
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Theo on June 23, 2011, 08:08:12 AM
When you have LMM reeds the L reed is tuned exactly one octave lower than the 440 M reed the other M reed is tuned sharp to give the tremolo.

Not necessarily.  It depends which reed combinations your couplers/stops give.  If it includes an LM setting then that pair should be in unison because a beat between reeds an (almost) octave apart sounds bad to most people.

If you do not have a possibility of hearing just LM then the L reed can be between the offset of the two M reeds.  

Thanks for that, wasn't sure if the L reed was tuned slightly off (sharp or flat).  So if I ask for "demi-swing: 12 cents at A=440" with LMM, that should give me a nice softish sound in MM and a broad full sound in LMM, would you say?


What Tallship says is spot on:
Quote
I think you need to listen to lots of recorded boxes and decide which sounds closest to your favourite sound. An accordion tech will be able to take it from there.

But would just add that you don't just have to listen to recordings.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Steve_freereeder on June 23, 2011, 08:39:42 AM
Also, if the reeds are 20 cent apart, as mentioned earlier, what would that represent in terms of a 440 number? Again, I know I'm not really making sense here but I hope you can decipher what I'm trying to get at
The answer is that the relationship between cents offset and the frequency difference in Hertz (your '440 number') is not linear, but logarithmic across the range of notes. If you wanted a constant tremolo rate of, say 4 beats per second (a moderately wet sound) across the range, you need a larger cents offset for the lower notes than you do for the upper notes. This is because the cents offset and the frequency difference (which controls the tremolo rate) vary according to the following formula:

c = 1200 × log2 (f2 / f1)

where c = the cents difference between the two reeds and f2 & f1 are the frequencies of the two reeds in Hz.

If you are confident in using Excel spreadsheets it is not hard to generate a listing of the cents offset required to give any required tremolo rate across the range, but for now, just to illustrate the effects of that logarithmic formula, here are some examples of the cents offset required to give a constant tremolo rate of 4 beats per second for the note A in different octaves:

A2 (110 Hz) Cents offset: 61.8
A3 (220 Hz) Cents offset: 31.2
A4 (440 Hz) Cents offset: 15.7
A5 (880 Hz) Cents offset: 7.9
A6 (1760 Hz) Cents offset: 3.9

This listing assumes one reed is tuned to the note 'at pitch' and the second reed is tuned sharp. You can see how the offset required decreases as the pitch of the note gets higher.

If you were discussing your tuning requirements with a competent tuner, it would normally be sufficient to state the tremolo rate required at A = 440 Hz, and then leave it up to their expertise to apply that across the range of the instrument.

Whether or not you wanted a constant tremolo rate across the whole range is a different matter again and depends on the personal preferences of the player. As far as I am aware, based on my somewhat limited experience of tuning, most instruments have a slower tremolo rate for the lower notes and a somewhat faster tremolo rate for the higher notes, with a relatively smooth transition across the range (known as 'tuning on the curve' I believe). It just sounds better when done that way. But other people here may have their own ideas and preferences.
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: HallelujahAl on June 23, 2011, 09:09:39 AM
Quote
c = 1200 × log2 (f2 / f1)

where c = the cents difference between the two reeds and f2 & f1 are the frequencies of the two reeds in Hz.
Wow, it's been such a long time since I've used logs - and there I was learning stuff that I thought would never be useful!
 ;D
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: Mcgrooger on June 23, 2011, 01:13:15 PM
I've just read most of this thread before thinking 'Why? - I've not a clue what any of it means!' But I would go with the adage 'if you like it, go for it!'. ;D
Title: Re: Question about tuning: 3-voice box
Post by: sandwich on June 23, 2011, 02:41:46 PM
The answer is that the relationship between cents offset and the frequency difference in Hertz (your '440 number') is not linear, but logarithmic across the range of notes. If you wanted a constant tremolo rate of, say 4 beats per second (a moderately wet sound) across the range, you need a larger cents offset for the lower notes than you do for the upper notes.


Cheers for a very comprehensive reply Steve. Almost ready to take the plunge. It's a 3 voice box and I would like a moderately wet sound, not a particularly wet sound...just a slightly less dry and more traditional-accordion sound than I'm hearing from a lot of modern Irish playing. I won't get a chance to play the instrument again and won't be dealing with a tuner. I'm going to request the following:

"LMM with around 4 beats per second (15.7 cents offset at A=440), tuned on the curve"

How's that grab you? By the way, is it relatively costly to get the tuning adjusted on a box?
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal