Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: gawski on July 31, 2008, 11:18:10 PM

Title: polka box?
Post by: gawski on July 31, 2008, 11:18:10 PM
What keys are best for playing American style polka music on a two row box?
George
Title: Re: polka box?
Post by: Rob2Hook on August 05, 2008, 12:14:55 PM
I'm fascinated!

What is American style polka, then?  I have visions of the old Western movies - the cavalry officers dancing with their ladies... a banjo and a fiddle miraculously sounding like a symphony orchestra... ;D

Put me out of the misery of my ignorance, please!
Title: Re: polka box?
Post by: gawski on August 10, 2008, 07:31:18 PM
What i mean by american stule polka music is: Polka music that originated in Chicago Ill, that is a slower style of POLKA BEAT.( 120 beats per minute, give or take ). The instruments normally used in a band are: The CHEMNITZER concertina or the piano accordeon, drums, bass, clarinet, trumpet. It is amuch slower beat than the IRISH polkas,
Title: Re: polka box?
Post by: butterfingers on August 16, 2008, 01:47:23 AM
 My knowledge of American Polka music is limited [I am aware that there are different styles, Chicago, Minnesota, etc..]. I think you may need a box that has a "helper" row in addition to the 2 main rows in order to play the "accidentals"...notes not in the major scale you're in, i.e. an F sharp in the key of C etc. The German Club accordions have this feature, but they may be be too slow in response and mellow in tone for polka music. I recall Walter Ostanek of St.Catharines, Ontario [Canada's Polka King] playing strange boxes from Yugoslavia [Slovenian Tuning?] that sounded great and seemed to have more melodic capabilities than a standard 2-row[ perhaps they had a "helper row"'and a few significant buttons thatgavethesame tone, whether you were pushing or pulling] the Irish B/C instruments coud play all of the notes, but I haven't heard of anyone using them for North American polka music...in any case a standard 2-row would be able to play some of the repertoire, one just has to weed out which tunes are possible or not and then start to work within the limitations...all the best
Title: Re: polka box?
Post by: Matthew B on August 17, 2008, 03:29:22 PM
George,

My guess is that you'll find you can get to a lot of those Chicago style polkas on a couple of club boxes.  A C/F and a Bb/Eb would probably do the trick.  The Gleichton shows up on the Slovenian boxes, but on two or three rows, I think.  So a lot of the chord possibilities are similar. 

I think there is a heated debate between the Slovenian and Polish polka guys about how to do it right.  The details of this important question have so far eluded me. 

You might want to contact the folks at this site http://www.concertinamusic.com/ (http://www.concertinamusic.com/), they're really nice people.  They have lots of sheet music, and a collection of resources not dissimilar to the things posted here.  For example "How to find the key of your concertina".

They are, as a community, somewhat eccentric and specialized.

SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal