Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Flanna on June 27, 2011, 04:44:30 PM
-
Considering the types of music I play I am not too keen on the traditional "um-pa" bass sound (bass-chord, bass-chord etc.) I would like to try bass notes only.
I am thinking of a unisonic bass side with no chords. The treble side is D/G acc. Most important keys (in order of importance) are; G maj, D maj, E min, B min, A maj, A min, F maj and C maj.
The physical layout is 12 buttons in a 4 x 3 grid.
What would be a good layout for the notes?
-
Sounds like you're considering a variant on the freebass system used on some Continental and middle/eastern European instruments. I confess I know little about the system, but Googling "accordion freebass" (or "free bass") might give you some ideas to start you off.
Graham
-
Sounds like you're considering a variant on the freebass system used on some Continental and middle/eastern European instruments. I confess I know little about the system, but Googling "accordion freebass" (or "free bass") might give you some ideas to start you off.
Graham
Yes, that's what I would like to have. Could it be done with just 12 buttons though?
-
You might consider Hohners chord free/ bass only layout as a starter for 10, its seems to work quite well.
For a CF box
F/C Bb/G# C/G F#/B
Eb/Bb D/A A/D E/C#
-
You might consider Hohners chord free/ bass only layout as a starter for 10, its seems to work quite well.
For a CF box
F/C Bb/G# C/G F#/B
Eb/Bb D/A A/D E/C#
For a D/G box that translates as:
G/D C/Bb D/A G#/C#
F/C E/B B/E F#/Eb
-
You might consider Hohners chord free/ bass only layout as a starter for 10, its seems to work quite well.
For a CF box
F/C Bb/G# C/G F#/B
Eb/Bb D/A A/D E/C#
For a D/G box that translates as:
G/D C/Bb D/A G#/C#
F/C E/B B/E F#/Eb
Thanks. These look interesting. Much better than using half the buttons for chords.
I was wondering if it is possible to make a practical unisonic (same note push/pull) layout.
-
How about:
B - F# - C# - G#
G - D - A - E
Eb - Bb - F - C
On that your home row would be the middle one. The middle row is a major third above the bottom row and the top row is a major third above the middle row. If that makes sense. This makes playing in G-A and Eb-F dead easy, C and E slightly less easy and the top row a little more tricky, as you have to switch between top and bottom rows, rather than middle and others.
That's a layout which I have literally just thought of, but that's one option for you.
-
How about:
B - F# - C# - G#
G - D - A - E
Eb - Bb - F - C
Looks sensible. Has a slight look of stradella about it.
Offhand, which is always risky, I guess I'd go for C-G-D-A as the middle row, with everything else relatively the same.
-
Have you looked at Marc Serafini's Darwin bass layout? It's 24 bass including chords, but you could just do the two bass note rows.
-
I've put this on an old poker work thats been a sort of experimental box thats had DG DD# BC and currently C#D and its worked with all of them
Chin D G C F Knee
F#B E A
A#D#G#C#
Basicly its a circle of fifths set out with the slight offset like a P.A. it has a LMM with one M as the default with the other M and L brought in with stops I've had a bit of fun with it it's easy to make chords Major minor or just first and fifths I've had some quite Hurdy Gurdy drone and burdon sort of sounds by keeping a button pressed as they are single (same both ways) as I say abit of fun there . mory
I have intended to change a M for a H as on a previous experiment I found it to produce some very interesting effects
-
You'll all have to forgive me if I sound a bit sceptical but I reckon you'd have to be playing at a hell of a high level to need such a specialised layout. John Spiers often plays with just bass notes on what I assume is a completely normal box bass layout to fantastic effect - like his track on Banquet of Boxes. As many have said on these forums, a melodeon by it's nature requires work rounds and compromises and sometimes the best results are those that make the most of it's inherent limitations, IMHO. On the other hand, each to their own...I'll get me coat, eh? :|bl
-
How about:
B - F# - C# - G#
G - D - A - E
Eb - Bb - F - C
Looks sensible. Has a slight look of stradella about it.
Offhand, which is always risky, I guess I'd go for C-G-D-A as the middle row, with everything else relatively the same.
Which notes are on the middle row depends on what keys you want to play in. Having the middle row start on G enables you to play in flats and sharps easily, but limits higher sharps and higher flats. Having the bottom row start on G makes higher sharps much easier, but at the cost of the flats. If you have the middle row start on a different note then different keys would be easier. I'm presenting the concept (which is the same as Mory's) rather than this particular implementation.
-
Which notes are on the middle row depends on what keys you want to play in.
Yes, and also on what kind of bass runs you want while playing in those keys. If you're playing in G major, for example, you might be interested in playing sequences from the G-major scale. I think this would be easier with C-G-D-A as the middle row.
Hmm, that's true. You are probably right there, as it would restrict G to just two rows.
-
You'll all have to forgive me if I sound a bit sceptical but I reckon you'd have to be playing at a hell of a high level to need such a specialised layout.
Certainly Trikitixa players, even beginners, use a unisonoric 12 bass layout rather than what many of us would consider to be "standard." And there are other traditions (like "Gaita Ponto"(sp?)) in which a unisonoric stradella bass system is combined with diatonic treble.
-
With a standard bass layout oom-pah isn't compulsory, there are lots of ways of mixing up the left-hand accompaniment. Part of the challenge of the melodeon is making the best of what you've got, and while the more elaborate left-hand layouts offer more possibilities to be musical, there's a danger of losing the essential charm of the basic 8-bass instrument.
-
Well what people are saying is that you have to accept the limitations of their instrument. Whilst this is perfectly reasonable, what is wrong with designing a system which has different limitations? I understand that the standard 8 bass has limitations and charm. It might be that this layout has charm as well.
This is an attitude which I find all over the place and I really don't understand.
-
This is an attitude which I find all over the place and I really don't understand.
I agree completely! And one could very well reply to Howard (above) that the 8 bass, two-row instrument unnecessary waters down the charm of a one-row, two-bass instrument!
-
mouth organ anyone ;D
-
or theres always Al's bass one and do away with the treble >:E
-
This is an attitude which I find all over the place and I really don't understand.
I agree completely! And one could very well reply to Howard (above) that the 8 bass, two-row instrument unnecessary waters down the charm of a one-row, two-bass instrument!
Lately, you've been convincing me of that very thing!
-
I play a Loffet 18 bass. A lot of the time I play bass notes and no chords. It gives quite a practical "free bass". I can also hint at chords including diminished and 7ths that are not available on a normal box. Switching off the low bass keeps the sound nice and clear and cuts down on air usage. I've often mused on the idea of a unisoric free bass.
-
or theres always Al's bass one and do away with the treble >:E
Or shruti box. Anything else is just overly sophisticated.
Sorry, forgot the Maultrommel. Add buttons and you ruin the simplicity of the free reed.
-
The same idea could be applied to a Hohner single row 2 spoon box, that is, remove the chords and replace them with a unisonic IV bass note (e.g. an F bass for a C box).
I put up a thread a few days ago which discussed this possibility in the context of adapting a single row Hohner HA112 in C to play tunes in A minor.
-
I'd rather miss the natural chord changes going from push to pull which to me is much of what a melodeon is about. As for 'um-pa' .. well just don't play 'um-pa'. There are loads of threads on this forum about lightening one's left end.
For what's being discussed so far - isn't it more sensible to purchase something with a Stradella bass, or even a CBA ???
-
... For what's being discussed so far - isn't it more sensible to purchase something with a Stradella bass, or even a CBA ???
My idea is to have something very small and light weight with D/G melodeon treble side and 12 bass buttons for free bass use. I already have a Roland CBA and although it is not large by CBA standards I find it to be too big and too heavy. A melodeon is the ideal size for me, I just prefer free bass to one button chords.
From watching many fine Irish melodeon players I see that if they use the bass side at all, it is often in a free bass style rather than the bass-chord style. Of course this can be done with the existing notes but why waste half the buttons when they could all be bass notes?
-
Ahah. It makes vastly more sense if you are playing Irish - essentially melody rather than chord structured.
-
Flanna, I've been thinking along the same lines. Having basses and ready made chords makes it very easy to play simple oom-pah type accompaniment, but the more adventurous you want to be the harder it gets with 8 or even 12 traditional melodeon basses. If you have 12 unisonoric bass with no chords then you've got all the notes and the only question is how to arrange them, which I think was your original question, which has not really been fully addressed.
There are several possible layouts for your 3 x 4 grid, the one I would look at first would be:
B F# C# G#
G D A E
Eb Bb F C
where the intervals are fifths along the rows, and major thirds between the rows, you could alter the starting point of the pattern to any other note.
You could also use a subset of the Wiki/Hayden (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicki-Hayden_note_layout) layout, which really needs a diagonal layout to get its full advantages:
C D E F# G# A#
G A B C# D# E#
and you need to use a 2 x 6 grid to get all the notes into a 12 bass but its nice in other ways: whole tones along the rows, fifths along one diagonal, fourths along the other.
-
... For what's being discussed so far - isn't it more sensible to purchase something with a Stradella bass, or even a CBA ???
My idea is to have something very small and light weight with D/G melodeon treble side and 12 bass buttons for free bass use. I already have a Roland CBA and although it is not large by CBA standards I find it to be too big and too heavy. A melodeon is the ideal size for me, I just prefer free bass to one button chords.
From watching many fine Irish melodeon players I see that if they use the bass side at all, it is often in a free bass style rather than the bass-chord style. Of course this can be done with the existing notes but why waste half the buttons when they could all be bass notes?
exactly the thinking behind my lay out (:) mory
I think we addressed it quite well Theo ;D
-
[..one could very well reply to Howard (above) that the 8 bass, two-row instrument unnecessary waters down the charm of a one-row, two-bass instrument!
Indeed. The two-row is more than two one-rows stuck together (and somehow a one-row is more than just half a two-row), it opens up more possibilities and different ways of playing. The more the box is expanded, whether by adding more treble rows or more basses, the more it moves away from what i think of being essentially "melodeonistic" towards "accordionism". Nothing wrong with that, perhaps, but it does change the characteristics of the instrument and how it's played, and you just have to be aware of that.
The OP's reasons for considering a different bass layouts seemed to be based more on a desire to avoid oom-pah than to explore wider musical possibilities, and my point was that it is possible to avoid oom-pah whilst still retaining the essential charactistics of the basic instrument.
-
I think we addressed it quite well Theo ;D
Sorry Mory, you are quite right I should have read the whole thread, but I've been busy fending off spammers.
-
I like the idea of a chordless bass.
How about one based on the Hayden duet concertina layout:
Eb F G A B C#
Ab Bb C D E F#
5ths and 4th are alway close to each other, so are all the notes in the scale of one key, and if you extend the layout (which you can, logically in all directions) you can make it fully transposing i.e. same pattern in any key like a continental CBA.
-
There are several possible layouts for your 3 x 4 grid, the one I would look at first would be:
B F# C# G#
G D A E
Eb Bb F C
where the intervals are fifths along the rows, and major thirds between the rows, you could alter the starting point of the pattern to any other note.
Ukebert already suggested that layout.
But, as I also suggested earlier, if you're thinking of this pattern then in my opinion the following variant would be better, especially for playing in G major:
E B F# C#
C G D A
Ab Eb Bb F
-
...
You could also use a subset of the Wiki/Hayden (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicki-Hayden_note_layout) layout, which really needs a diagonal layout to get its full advantages:
C D E F# G# A#
G A B C# D# E#
and you need to use a 2 x 6 grid to get all the notes into a 12 bass but its nice in other ways: whole tones along the rows, fifths along one diagonal, fourths along the other.
Thanks Theo. That looks like a very useful layout. Perhaps it could be slightly changed to centralize the most used notes...
A# C D E F# G#
E# G A B C# D#
Now I can imagine this layout being very easy for simple free bass on a D/G melodeon.
And then I saw this...
I like the idea of a chordless bass.
How about one based on the Hayden duet concertina layout:
Eb F G A B C#
Ab Bb C D E F#
5ths and 4th are alway close to each other, so are all the notes in the scale of one key, and if you extend the layout (which you can, logically in all directions) you can make it fully transposing i.e. same pattern in any key like a continental CBA.
I'm going to have a good think about this one too... It could indeed be extended (as can Theo's) to make it more flexible without adding any more reeds, just some duplicate buttons.
-
If you go this way I'd suggest a 'musical' (4ths) layout rather than 'alphabetical' - even if you are playing a bass run I suspect it'll be more fluid - your fingers won't clash so much :|glug
-
...
You could also use a subset of the Wiki/Hayden (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicki-Hayden_note_layout) layout, which really needs a diagonal layout to get its full advantages:
C D E F# G# A#
G A B C# D# E#
and you need to use a 2 x 6 grid to get all the notes into a 12 bass but its nice in other ways: whole tones along the rows, fifths along one diagonal, fourths along the other.
Thanks Theo. That looks like a very useful layout. Perhaps it could be slightly changed to centralize the most used notes...
A# C D E F# G#
E# G A B C# D#
Now I can imagine this layout being very easy for simple free bass on a D/G melodeon.
And then I saw this...
I like the idea of a chordless bass.
How about one based on the Hayden duet concertina layout:
Eb F G A B C#
Ab Bb C D E F#
5ths and 4th are alway close to each other, so are all the notes in the scale of one key, and if you extend the layout (which you can, logically in all directions) you can make it fully transposing i.e. same pattern in any key like a continental CBA.
I'm going to have a good think about this one too... It could indeed be extended (as can Theo's) to make it more flexible without adding any more reeds, just some duplicate buttons.
They are both really part of the same pattern, full details on the Wiki Hayden link
-
Sorry Theo, I didn't spot your earlier post.
Yes, they are all basically the same. It's partly a question of which buttons to have at the centre, and hence which group of keys will have exactly the same fingering for a scale.
-
Sorry Theo, I didn't spot your earlier post.
Yes, they are all basically the same. It's partly a question of which buttons to have at the centre, and hence which group of keys will have exactly the same fingering for a scale.
Haha, I did the same with early posts by others! This thread must deserve some sort of prize for non-sequiturs.
-
Sorry Theo, I didn't spot your earlier post.
Yes, they are all basically the same. It's partly a question of which buttons to have at the centre, and hence which group of keys will have exactly the same fingering for a scale.
Haha, I did the same with early posts by others! This thread must deserve some sort of prize for non-sequiturs.
Hmm... Would the prize be enough to finance the new free-bass melodeon? :P
-
I think we addressed it quite well Theo ;D
Sorry Mory, you are quite right I should have read the whole thread, but I've been busy fending off spammers.
Is that spam spam spam spam spam egg chips and spam or spam spam spam spam spam spam egg beans and spam or just spam spam spam spam spam spam and spam? sorry couldn't resist it ::) mory
-
Ukebert already suggested that layout.
But, as I also suggested earlier, if you're thinking of this pattern then in my opinion the following variant would be better, especially for playing in G major:
E B F# C#
C G D A
Ab Eb Bb F
Yeah, after some thought I think that that's a much better layout than the one I proposed.
-
After many coffees and a little thought may I suggest the ..
DEC#A#F CAF#Eb BAbG
layout ::) (sorry - nursing a hangover) :|glug
-
To Flanna:
I think the arrangement that you show in reply 33 is just right. Well I would wouldn't I that is exactly the way the bottom two rows on my concertina are arranged. This brings the keys of D & G right into the middle 4 consecutive buttons of the 2 rows; move one button to the right for A & E, and one button to the left for F & C. Even with a comprehensive addition of chromatic "helper buttons" on the melody side, is about as many keys as can be comfortably played on a D/G melodeon. Chromatic runs don't present any problem: you never run out of fingers as you do on some Duett concertina systems. If you intend to go beyond this it does help to have a few enharmonic links e.g Eb linked to D# and Ab linked to G# for instance.
If I remember rightly I think you have mentioned that you play the Treble side with your left hand; this arrangement of bass notes works equally well with the Bass in the right hand side.
On the finer points of design it is best not to put the buttons too close to palm of the hand; a little space can be very helpfull.
Inventor.
-
Thanks for all your suggestions. I've given it careful thought and this is what I think would work best for me:
Bb C D E F# G#
Eb F G A B C#
This layout would make it very easy to play all the major and minor scales normally encountered on a D/G melodeon. The major and minor triads would also be very easy to play, with 3 fingers.
I really like the way many players of Irish music use the bass notes without the chords and I am thinking of using the same style with all my melodeon playing. I play quite a lot of Scottish tunes and I think they would sound really good without the chords.
-
Looks a useful arrangement.
But I'm a bit puzzled, given that your initial post said that the physical layout is 4x3.
Well, I like the 4x3 layout for conventional bass/chord setup. Having read the replies to this thread I think that the Hayden system in a 6x2 layout would be perfect for a small free-bass layout.
-
Recommend you use a the same button size and spacing as is used on a fullsize piano accordion rather than that used on Melodeons, or 12 Bass Trichords and small 12 only bass piano-accordions.
An 8 bass button melodeon I have just measured was 78mm width x 32mm front to back with 12mm dia. buttons; Trichord was 120mm wide x 27mm f to b & 9.5mm buttons. A piano-accordion bass six and a half buttons wide was 96mm wide x 17mm f to b with 7mm dia. buttons. This spacing is very similar to that used on Hayden Concertinas, and I always recommend at least 6mm diameter buttons. You would be able to play major and minor chords with only 2 fingers not 3 if you so wished.
In general I also find that I use Ebs more than I use D#s (I have both on my concertina) but I was thinking what might be most central to a D/G Melodeon.
Inventor.