im realy thick.
but im guesing the second is the fith and the third is the seventh????
dont laugh if im wrong please :-[
[I don't know the posh name for the seventh is] quote
I usually refer to it as the Leading note mory
im realy thick.
Ah! Just noted that Gypsy Lad is 'respected sage' - words grandmother eggs and suck come to mind! :|bl
You're not an idiot. I've updated my post a bit.
The standard perfect cadence is I IV I V I. The blues have I IV I V IV I.
I find myself in sessions using this one a lot (right hand chording + bass)
I vi IV V = G Empull Cpull D on a D/G
I find myself in sessions using this one a lot (right hand chording + bass)
I vi IV V = G Empull Cpull D on a D/G
That's the lower part to an interminable duet that newish pianists learn (usually C Am F G). Oh the (happy?) hours we've had playing that through with our kids! I was relieved of "playing the bass end" when our daughter worked out how to record multi-tracks on the electric piano - now she can duet with herself. Sounds good to start with. Gets a bit wearing after the 20th time through .... >:E
future TOTM ? >:E
I find myself in sessions using this one a lot (right hand chording + bass)
I vi IV V = G Empull Cpull D on a D/G
That's the lower part to an interminable duet that newish pianists learn (usually C Am F G). Oh the (happy?) hours we've had playing that through with our kids! I was relieved of "playing the bass end" when our daughter worked out how to record multi-tracks on the electric piano - now she can duet with herself. Sounds good to start with. Gets a bit wearing after the 20th time through .... >:E
so when do you play it ?Whenever it sounds good. There's no right or wrong chords. On a one-row you can manage with just two. In general try the I-chord (e.g. D) and if it doesn't sound right anymore try the V (A-chord). If that doesn't work try the IV (G-chord). Next in line is probably vi (B-minor). So the three-chord-trick is the top three of most used chords, but you could also use the top 2 (or 4 or anything else).
Love it otherwise known as find the ladyI think you'll find that's 'Find the Low D'...
boom boom! ;DLove it otherwise known as find the ladyI think you'll find that's 'Find the Low D'...
future TOTM ? >:E
:o
I'm hopeful that it'll fail on both filters - Clive's shortlist and overall voting! :Ph
I find myself in sessions using this one a lot (right hand chording + bass)
I vi IV V = G Empull Cpull D on a D/G
the changes fit Blue Moon too, although you might need to stretch things in the middle eight :-\
peter g - im only a respected sage cos i talk alot! ;D
can any one explain it to me? ???Not so much an explanation, as an illustration: the rows of your A/D/G are nicely lined up to give you the three chord trick for the middle row (D).
what it all comes down to is building a style - i play dartmoor / gypsy style which basicly thumps the bass and runs up and down the rowshould i just keep playing to the old styole or move it on?
Of course the same can be said for those who gain much pleasure from cross rowing - there is no reason why they can't also learn the (different) benefits of 'old style' on the row playing which can be either very rhythmic or very smooth according to the wishes & skills of the driver!
Of course the
If you are 'arranging' rather then just playing alonfg to a tune - why not a bit of both- variety is the source of spick in these matters?
totally agree - a lot to be said for experinenting with everything rather than trying to copy somebody elses style,
george
Isnt that one the standard minor? Ionian is major 8)[I don't know the posh name for the seventh is] quote
I usually refer to it as the Leading note mory
Well that's what I've called it and it's not as posh as the others. I think (from a wikipedia trawl) that the flattened seventh is the subtonic and these terms came before the aeolian was standardised as the major scale. Perhaps?
...should i just keep playing to the old style or move it on?
Well that's what I've called it and it's not as posh as the others. I think (from a wikipedia trawl) that the flattened seventh is the subtonic and these terms came before the aeolian was standardised as the major scale. Perhaps?Isnt that one the standard minor? Ionian is major 8)
the trick when playing using mainly the DG bass with a bit of C if in key of G and just the DA bass when in the key of D is to play the bass notes very short & crisply ( staccato if yhou like) i.e. tap the buttons with your chosen rhythm as if they are red hot.
This technique means that whatever dischords occur are unlikely to be heard as they will only be around for a fraction of a second. It also suits on the row playing (&one row playing) as it leaves wide open the scope for right hand if it is played mostly or completely on the row, which is not always the case when the right hand fingering accross the rows is governed totally by the desire to get better bass harmony.
george
I find myself in sessions using this one a lot (right hand chording + bass)
I vi IV V = G Empull Cpull D on a D/G
Seems to fit loads of folk tunes and is more 'interesting' and 'progressive' than the 3 chorder.
It would appear we both like a minor chord early in a progression ..
but are avoiding any sense of "ii V I" .. which would make us jazz guitarists ;)
| That's more or less standard analysis. Pignol & co measure chords in terms of their "tension" relative to the scale in play. That zing in the dominant V chord comes from the clash (eg D7) between its F# and C notes - each is a #4 (tritone) interval from the other. At this point almost anything works. So Norbert will talk of the smooth field of tonic and some 'foothills' as we play whatever ii, VI or vi chord takes our fancy, and the summit of V. As with his native Alps, that summit is unstable and demands resolution back to tonic. Perfect cadence 8) | (http://chrisryall.net/img/tensiongraph.png) |
But we are presently some way from the 'British' 3-chord trick which is a reference to playing a more or less steady G, C, D7, G riff against any G tune. There's a lot of that 'built into' the left end of a melodeon.
when playing on the outer treble row is the button furthest from my chin on the outer bass row a I or a IV ?
when playing on the outer treble row is the button furthest from my chin on the outer bass row a I or a IV ?
If I've worked that out correctly, it's IV on push and I on pull.
The same buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the inner treble row.
The other outer bass buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the outer row, and...
V on push and II on pull when playing on the inner row. (the latter not used much unless we're heading for or already in the outer row key)
:Ph :|glug
Just one of the joys (?) of the melodeon is that the two main treble row keys have their bass IV chords in quite different places.
If I've worked that out correctly, it's IV on push and I on pull.
The same buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the inner treble row.
The other outer bass buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the outer row, and...
V on push and II on pull when playing on the inner row. (the latter not used much unless we're heading for or already in the outer row key)
:Ph :|glug
Just one of the joys (?) of the melodeon is that the two main treble row keys have their bass IV chords in quite different places.
Whatever works for you... eventually you'll do it automatically by ear, including working out which row to play the tune on - especially when playing in the outer row home key you need to cross to inner row to get IV and V chords on 3 notes. Many melodeon players don't bother.
... Many melodeon players don't bother.
.. and i'm one of them! I think the Em as a substitute for the G works quite often, and gives a subtle extra flavour to the accompanyment, occasionally it does not work, in which case leave the chord out or substitute an A.
The trouble with with "minor key" is a it's a rather nebulous description. There are different scales in common use all described as minor keys, and each tends to have different sets of chords that are likely to fit:It's often VII as well, instead of V
Aeolian mode and classical minors usually work with the same I-IV-V family of chords as major keys, except the classical scales are likely to need the V chord to be a major to fit in with sharpened leading note, e.g. E major for a tune in A minor.
Dorian mode tends to be "two chord trick" with I and VII (e.g. Em and D for a so-called E minor tune) and several other chords are likely to be useful: III (major) especially, maybe V and IV depending on the tune. Dorian tunes often move into the major key based on the 3rd note of the (original Dorian) scale anyway.I love to be able to get IV in here, as that is the one which makes it sound the most Dorian (due to IV being Major instead of Minor).
For other modes, it's open season as there isn't enough established repertoire to determine what sounds "normal".For Mixolydian i found it's often just I and VII (with some IV and V).
Please correct me if i am wrongThere's no wrong or right here. The term "three chord trick" simply refers to the minimum three chords with which you can busk your way though almost anything on a guitar (with a capo to change keys). It's a useful simplification for beginners, but even with only three chords, you have to use your ears to work out which goes where, and they don't work for everything so you do have to lean more chords eventually.
This is what i deduced from my own playing, not from a book or anythingExactly! :|glug
I have read up about the differences between the different modes a few times, not least on other threads on melodeon.net, but I still find it very difficult to identify which minor mode is being employed in a given tune.
By the way (and totally off topic!), does anyone know what L'Anternaire means? It doesn't appear in my French dictionary and Google Translate can make nothing of it.
ive got a bit lost on this thread! (about 3 pages ago !)
ive got a bit lost on this thread! (about 3 pages ago !)
I must admit, I am generally with Tommy on this. I haven't read the whole thread, but music theory beyond the very basics is a new topic for me and most comments assume far more knowledge and understanding than i presently have. Tommy's responses at the beginning of the thread reflect how I feel.
There's a lot of knowledge here, but people who have that level of knowledge and can present it understandably to someone who has none are very rare, And usually underpaid!
But I shall keep plugging away!