Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 07:15:35 PM

Title: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 07:15:35 PM
can any one explain it to me?  ???
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on June 27, 2011, 07:26:06 PM
If you are in G then the three chord trick is the tonic (G), the dominant (D) and the sub-dominant (C). I think that the three chord trick is one of the great evils of music theory, as it closes peoples horizons far too much.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 07:28:41 PM
so how does it work / how do u do it and whats the tonic for a d and g??? i want to add more lilt to my oom pah dartmoor bass
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 07:31:13 PM
sorry u told me g!
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: jb on June 27, 2011, 07:31:35 PM
It's a well-known short con (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_chord_trick).
You place the three chords face down on the table. Turn one face up to reveal it to the mark, then face down again.
Now re-arrange the three chords quickly, and get the mark to put money on which is the previously-revealed chord.
With a combination of sleight of hand, misdirection, and various scams involving the assistance of a shill or two, you can make it impossible for the mark to place a winning bet on the correct chord.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on June 27, 2011, 07:52:29 PM
So the three chord trick for G is G, D and C.
The three chord trick for D is D, A and G.
The three chord trick for A is A, E and D.

Hopefully you can see a pattern emerging? ;)
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 07:56:34 PM
im realy thick.
but im guesing the second is the fith and the third is the seventh????
dont laugh if im wrong please  :-[
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on June 27, 2011, 08:01:32 PM
im realy thick.
but im guesing the second is the fith and the third is the seventh????
dont laugh if im wrong please  :-[


The order that I've given them is the tonic (I), the dominant (fifth V) and the subdominant (fourth IV).

So in the scale of G you have:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
G A B C D E F#

The tonic is the first note of the scale and is called I.
The supertonic is the second note of the scale and is called II.
The mediant is the third note of the scale and is called III.
The subdominant is the fourth note of the scale and is called IV.
The dominant is the fifth note of the scale and is called V.
The submediant is the sixth note of the scale and is called VI.

I don't know the posh name for the seventh is :|bl The seventh is complicated for historical reasons, as there is the flattened seventh and the natural seventh.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 27, 2011, 08:03:30 PM
 im such an idiot

so when do you play it ?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: mory on June 27, 2011, 08:05:12 PM
Love it otherwise known as find the lady
each note in a scale can have a chord built on it using the other notes in the scale . In natural harmony lets take your D scale, the chord built on the first note will comprise the notes D F# A  or 1st 3rd 5th  notes of the scale giving us Dmajor, the next note is E the 2nd note of the scale the chord built on this will be E G B or 2nd 4th 6th notes of the scale giving us Eminor, this carries on up the scale giving us a chord per note of the scale in this case D Major, E minor, F#minor, G major, A Major, B minor, C#diminished, the three chord trick (its not really a trick by the way, just a simple way of I.D.) comprises the first or Tonic/root D Major, the Fifth A Major or Dominant and the Forth G Major or sub Dominant this is applicable to any Major scale. I have a neat little diagram I use to help I'll try and upload it  

by the way in the process we have happily identified the other natural harmony chords in that key
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on June 27, 2011, 08:10:43 PM
You're not an idiot. I've updated my post a bit.

The standard perfect cadence is I IV I V I. The blues have I IV I V IV I.

For folk music, an easy way of getting into it is to play along the row, thumping away at G/D (the bisonoric nature of the instrument will mean that you are playing the right chord at the right point). When the music has a C or an E in it in a significant place (i.e. at the beginning of a bar) then play your C bass/chord. Similarly if there is a passage which plays Cs, Es and Gs in some order then play it there. The nice thing about it is that the subdominant fits everywhere, I like to finish sections on it (well, I like to finish sections with the subdominant chord and the dominant bass). So experiment and if it sounds nice then keep it. All these rules and conventions are designed to make it sound nice, if it doesn't then throw them out of the window. The important thing is not to spend a long time learning all this stuff (although it becomes more useful the further you get, as it's a useful framework on which to hang your thoughts) but to find out what you think is musical and what isn't.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: mory on June 27, 2011, 08:35:57 PM
[I don't know the posh name for the seventh is] quote

I usually refer to it as the Leading note  mory
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on June 27, 2011, 08:51:56 PM
It's one of those things that I vaguely know, then forget..... and have to dig out written notes to remember it again.
Don't worry gypsy lad, there's many that wonder about it too!
( holds up hand!)  ;)
Q
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on June 27, 2011, 09:00:47 PM
[I don't know the posh name for the seventh is] quote

I usually refer to it as the Leading note  mory

Well that's what I've called it and it's not as posh as the others. I think (from a wikipedia trawl) that the flattened seventh is the subtonic and these terms came before the aeolian was standardised as the major scale. Perhaps?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Neil_M on June 27, 2011, 09:10:20 PM
I think that for some of us the theory side is way over the top, you've probably already found that G, D and C chords sit nicely together just by playing them. I don't know if you have to play them in a specific pattern to obtain the 'trick'? Probably not.
After all, Status Quo did ok with just three chords.  ::)
I'll get me coat...
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 27, 2011, 09:18:15 PM
As an unreconstructed rock 'n' roll guitarist & bass player from way back the 3-chord trick is second nature. Think of a 12-bar blues - you start with the tonic chord ("Well I woke up this morning......!!") - let's say G for argument's sake; then the next phrase ("Yeah I woke up this morning..." how many times do blues singers drop off again before getting up??) uses the subdominant chord - in this case C - before returning to the tonic. Then the last 4 bars (the bit about having no money/woman/drink/job/car or whatever) utilises the dominant -D- and subdominant -C- before resolving on to the tonic, G. 95% of rock'n'roll standards use the 3-chord trick  - Blue Suede Shoes, Shake, Rattle & Roll, Roll Over Beethoven - you name it. Now, about the 4-chord turnaround....... ;D
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Martin J on June 27, 2011, 09:28:05 PM
Here's a handy chart of the three chords plus the relevant minor.  It's more or less self explanatory. Find the key you are playing in on the outside circle and then read that segment.

Away you go   :||:
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 27, 2011, 09:54:56 PM
im realy thick.

Nope, not at all. You've just become curious and you need to join up the things you are playing with the theory behind it, I hope it's not too tough a journey!  (:)
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Peter G on June 27, 2011, 10:36:42 PM
iYou may already have sussed this out but It's worth noting that to get the G when playing in D on the D/G you generally have to cross row so you get the appropriate notes on the push ( - invitation for someone who actually understands this stuff to embellish!  >:( )
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Peter G on June 27, 2011, 10:38:53 PM
Ah! Just noted that Gypsy Lad is 'respected sage' - words grandmother eggs and suck come to mind!  :|bl
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 27, 2011, 10:46:59 PM
Ah! Just noted that Gypsy Lad is 'respected sage' - words grandmother eggs and suck come to mind!  :|bl

I'm a 'Hero Member' but that just means I've made x number of posts  ;)
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: LDbosca on June 27, 2011, 11:10:19 PM
You're not an idiot. I've updated my post a bit.

The standard perfect cadence is I IV I V I. The blues have I IV I V IV I.


I hate to be a terrible pedant but only the "V I" part of the first and the "IV I" of the second is the cadence, I suppose you'd call the full thing a progression...or the three chord trick! (:)
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Ollie on June 28, 2011, 12:01:37 AM
Also IV I is plagal, not perfect.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: nfldbox on June 28, 2011, 02:15:24 AM
Not to dumb it down but you really need know nothing. Play most tunes and you will find the three chords that fit. If you are using only three chords the wrong one will sound a bit of a clanger when you make the wrong choice.
Music theory will give you a more intelligent understanding of what you are doing but you don't usually need it to use the three chord trick.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 28, 2011, 08:47:40 AM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G

Seems to fit loads of folk tunes and is more 'interesting' and 'progressive' than the 3 chorder. You also can very the pull chords in particular, eg an F# (G row) spices both a C chord or Em, but don't use it every time through. Or if you make the D a D7 pull all sorts of play through lines emerge.

PS   just to add that Em is 3 adjacent buttons outer row, starting E.
       then move y'r ring finger (only) to inner row (B>C) - keep pulling = C chord
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: zubz on June 28, 2011, 09:30:18 AM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G


That's the lower part to an interminable duet that newish pianists learn (usually C Am F G). Oh the (happy?) hours we've had playing that through with our kids! I was relieved of "playing the bass end" when our daughter worked out how to record multi-tracks on the electric piano - now she can duet with herself. Sounds good to start with. Gets a bit wearing after the 20th time through ....  >:E
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Sandy on June 28, 2011, 09:43:27 AM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G


That's the lower part to an interminable duet that newish pianists learn (usually C Am F G). Oh the (happy?) hours we've had playing that through with our kids! I was relieved of "playing the bass end" when our daughter worked out how to record multi-tracks on the electric piano - now she can duet with herself. Sounds good to start with. Gets a bit wearing after the 20th time through ....  >:E

future TOTM ?  >:E
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: zubz on June 28, 2011, 09:49:37 AM
future TOTM ?  >:E

 :o

I'm hopeful that it'll fail on both filters - Clive's shortlist and overall voting!  :Ph
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Alison Scott on June 28, 2011, 10:31:20 AM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G


That's the lower part to an interminable duet that newish pianists learn (usually C Am F G). Oh the (happy?) hours we've had playing that through with our kids! I was relieved of "playing the bass end" when our daughter worked out how to record multi-tracks on the electric piano - now she can duet with herself. Sounds good to start with. Gets a bit wearing after the 20th time through ....  >:E

For years I had one of those disassociated hazy memories of learning that, and then playing it for hours, on a piano in the grand hallway of a grand building somewhere, sometime. There was a garden as well and we picked daisy chains, so it was probably May. I must have been about 8 or 9 at the time. I realised only a few months ago that that was Halsway Manor.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Simon on June 28, 2011, 10:43:17 AM
so when do you play it ?
Whenever it sounds good. There's no right or wrong chords. On a one-row you can manage with just two. In general try the I-chord (e.g. D) and if it doesn't sound right anymore try the V (A-chord). If that doesn't work try the IV (G-chord). Next in line is probably vi (B-minor). So the three-chord-trick is the top three of most used chords, but you could also use the top 2 (or 4 or anything else).
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Alison Scott on June 28, 2011, 11:14:30 AM
Love it otherwise known as find the lady
I think you'll find that's 'Find the Low D'...
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: mory on June 28, 2011, 02:15:00 PM
Love it otherwise known as find the lady
I think you'll find that's 'Find the Low D'...
boom boom! ;D
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on June 28, 2011, 03:47:28 PM
peter g - im only a respected sage cos i talk alot!  ;D
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Alison Scott on June 29, 2011, 10:20:05 PM
future TOTM ?  >:E

 :o

I'm hopeful that it'll fail on both filters - Clive's shortlist and overall voting!  :Ph

Further to this, it is of course Heart and Soul, and it turns out that the degenerate irritating-piano-duet version of it is pretty achievable (in G rather than C) on a melodeon. Don't ask me how I know this. I am just debating whether to put this on my 'things to work up properly' list or not. So deffo my vote for ToTM.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: smiley on June 30, 2011, 03:38:38 AM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G

the changes fit Blue Moon too, although you might need to stretch things in the middle eight  :-\
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Graham Spencer on June 30, 2011, 05:04:50 AM
the changes fit Blue Moon too, although you might need to stretch things in the middle eight  :-\

And are, indeed, the "4-chord turnaround" I referred to lightheartedly earlier in this thread, and generally fit the remaining 5% of rock'n'roll standards............


Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Peter G on July 01, 2011, 06:47:23 PM
peter g - im only a respected sage cos i talk alot!  ;D

So hope for us all then! :||:
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Matthew B on July 02, 2011, 01:05:46 PM
can any one explain it to me?  ???
Not so much an explanation, as an illustration: the rows of your A/D/G are nicely lined up to give you the three chord trick for the middle row (D).   
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: mory on July 02, 2011, 01:32:35 PM
  (' denotes flat)

C' G' D' A' E' B' F C G D A E B F# C# G# D# A# B#

Pick a Key, the one either side plus the note you picked are the three chords, ie,                                              in the key of  C= FCG     in the key of  E=AEB etc,   Dominant to the right Sub-dominant to the left                  

This is the circle of fifths well known to P.A. players as that's the basis of their basses (:) mory
( that's catchy " the basis of their basses" ....... )

Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 02, 2011, 06:08:07 PM
It might interest you to note that - listening to some recordings of Bob Cann - he often played his converted Club like a one-row, sticking on the I & IV chords and just pumping out a rythm.  Most beginners tend to do this as it's not too offensive so long as the tune is plyed with some lift! The use of chord V is more open to interpretation and taste than the other two.  Of course, when playing in D the availability of a G chord is dependant on whether the tune will allow you to cross onto the G row, unless you have a twelve bass with G on the pull.

Other styles such as the cross chording or approximating chords which aren't available on an eight bass, suit some tunes, especially French for example.  For me, these extensions work when playing for performance, but not for dance music.

The other day we had three boxes playing together for Morris.  As we changed into the second tune, in E min, one went into quasi French basses and another (having forgotten his hearing aid) stayed on the G basses, so ended up playing bass in D!  What a row!

Rob.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 02, 2011, 06:18:59 PM
i was listening to how mark bazely plays the bass and i dont think he jumps about too much. it struck me that his bass note seemed to act as a sort of drum notching out time if that makes sense
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: george garside on July 02, 2011, 10:09:33 PM
the trick when playing  using mainly the DG  bass with a bit of C  if in key of G and just the DA bass when in the key of D  is to play the bass notes very short & crisply ( staccato if yhou like) i.e. tap the buttons with your chosen rhythm as if they are red hot.   

 This  technique means that whatever dischords occur  are unlikely to be heard as they will only be around for a fraction of a second.  It also suits   on the row playing  (&one row playing) as it leaves wide open the scope for right hand chords  played mostly or completely on the row, which is not always the case when the right hand fingering accross the rows is governed totally by the desire to  get better bass harmony.

george
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 02, 2011, 11:33:21 PM
what it all comes down to is building a style - i play dartmoor / gypsy style which basicly thumps the bass and runs up and down the rowshould i just keep playing to the old styole or move it on?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: george garside on July 03, 2011, 11:43:12 AM
what it all comes down to is building a style - i play dartmoor / gypsy style which basicly thumps the bass and runs up and down the rowshould i just keep playing to the old styole or move it on?

its entirely a matter of choice and there is absolutely nothing wrong with playing what you call 'old style'  which I am a firm fan of! -- however there is absolutely no reason why you can't experiment wi;th other styles of playing  as additions rather than replacements and  only if you really want to & not bnecause you feel under pressure  to conform in some way or other with the style(s) some others prefer. 

Of course the same can be said for  those who gain much pleasure from cross rowing  - there is no reason why they can't also  learn the (different) benefits of 'old style' on the row playing  which can be either very rhythmic or very smooth according to the wishes & skills of the driver!

george - who tends to keep cross rowing to semitone boxes to avoid nasty accidents! ;D
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 03, 2011, 12:40:38 PM
Of course the same can be said for  those who gain much pleasure from cross rowing  - there is no reason why they can't also  learn the (different) benefits of 'old style' on the row playing  which can be either very rhythmic or very smooth according to the wishes & skills of the driver!

If you are 'arranging' rather then just playing along to a tune - why not a bit of both- variety is the source of spick spice in these matters?

Incidentally George, how would you play a C#/D/G?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: george garside on July 03, 2011, 04:18:15 PM
the short answer is I would't as I would  become totally confused & have more than my fair share of nasty accidents!   To me the BCC# (particularly with stradella bass) offers many advantages over other 3 row systems..  not least being the ease of playing in all 12 major keys. 

To me the great advantage of an 8 bass DG is its  r simplicity & light weight coupled to   the amount of rhythm , harmony & general 'umph' that can be got out of  it albeit  mostly in DG & related miners + a wee bit of A from time to time.  Much of this is, I feel, lost when a third row be it C# or assorted choice of accidentals is added along with another 4 bass buttons.    Its at that point that I think it well worth moving   into BCC#land!  Thats what suits me but  long may we  remain a 'broad church'

george
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: george garside on July 03, 2011, 04:20:18 PM
Of course the

 If you are 'arranging' rather then just playing alonfg to a tune - why not a bit of both- variety is the source of spick in these matters?

 

totally agree - a lot to be said for experinenting with everything rather than trying to copy somebody elses style,

george
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 01, 2011, 12:53:30 AM
[I don't know the posh name for the seventh is] quote

I usually refer to it as the Leading note  mory

Well that's what I've called it and it's not as posh as the others. I think (from a wikipedia trawl) that the flattened seventh is the subtonic and these terms came before the aeolian was standardised as the major scale. Perhaps?
Isnt that one the standard minor? Ionian is major 8)


Theory is all great ofcourse, and very useful to be able to talk about stuff and generalize things. But for people starting to think about these things i always empasize that it is all built up empirically. They first found out what sounds nice, and only after that they built the theory around it. If the theory can help you find what sounds nice it's useful. If you can find out yourself, by trying what sounds nice that's perhaps even better.
First learn to speak, before learning to read and write. so to speak, heh.

Also it's late and i am tired, so i might have had to rethink the stuff i wrote. sorry if so  ::)
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 02, 2011, 04:40:44 PM
...should i just keep playing to the old style or move it on?

Both!  By all means move your own personal style on, encompassing tunes and ornamentations from a more diverse catchment.  But that doesn't mean that you won't still be able to play a dance tune in the local style!  You're right about Mark Bazeley's style. The sleeve notes on one of the CDs comment on the sound of a box coming from the church porch - but you couldn't tell whether it was Bob Cann playing or Mark.  It's handed down through the family.  Bounce or lift is considered THE most important aspect to a player's skills.

I guess that's why so many of us relish playing a 4-stop, even if we can't get it to sound like DTN's playing (annoyingly skilled barsteward).

Rob.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Owen Woods on September 02, 2011, 07:13:49 PM
Well that's what I've called it and it's not as posh as the others. I think (from a wikipedia trawl) that the flattened seventh is the subtonic and these terms came before the aeolian was standardised as the major scale. Perhaps?
Isnt that one the standard minor? Ionian is major 8)

Oops :|bl
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: IanD on September 02, 2011, 07:28:04 PM
the trick when playing  using mainly the DG  bass with a bit of C  if in key of G and just the DA bass when in the key of D  is to play the bass notes very short & crisply ( staccato if yhou like) i.e. tap the buttons with your chosen rhythm as if they are red hot.   

 This  technique means that whatever dischords occur  are unlikely to be heard as they will only be around for a fraction of a second.  It also suits   on the row playing  (&one row playing) as it leaves wide open the scope for right hand if it is played mostly or completely on the row, which is not always the case when the right hand fingering accross the rows is governed totally by the desire to  get better bass harmony.

george

Staccato basses is one style which works, there are many others. As a melodeon/guitar/bass player I often think bass lines rather than chords, and rarely use the type of staccato basses referred to -- I more often play more extended notes which may go across the "normal" rhythm, and almost never play standard repeating "oom-pah" basses.

This does mean being able to decouple left and right hands to some extent, playing what bass/guitar might play on the left hand against the tune on the right hand. The extreme example of this is probably Old Cheshire Rounds where the rhythm is completely different on each hand.

Ian
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 06, 2011, 02:17:57 PM
I find myself in sessions using this one  a lot (right hand chording + bass)

    I  vi  IV  V   =  G Empull Cpull D  on a D/G

Seems to fit loads of folk tunes and is more 'interesting' and 'progressive' than the 3 chorder.

For some reason i find myself often using I iii IV V (In D/G terms in G => G Bm C D).
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 06, 2011, 02:48:15 PM
It would appear we both like a minor chord early in a progression ..

but are avoiding any sense of "ii V I" .. which would make us jazz guitarists  ;)
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 06, 2011, 10:31:35 PM
It would appear we both like a minor chord early in a progression ..

but are avoiding any sense of "ii V I" .. which would make us jazz guitarists  ;)

Yeah :-)


BTW, when talking about the 3chord"trick" i always find it helpful to get the functions of the chords in the discussions as well.
I dont think i use all the correct terms, so please correct me.

the I i explain as "at ease" or "a state of rest". In storytelling terms "once upon a time, in a land far from here our hero...etc"
the IV would be something like "something happens" "some uneasyness". In storytelling terms: "it appears a lord Voldemort is trying to get himself together again"
the V: "the moment it was all about", or something like that. In storytelling terms: Our hero slays the dragon in a heroic battle.
(and then I again, for "and they lived happily ever after")

:-)
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 07, 2011, 08:42:02 AM
That's more or less standard analysis. Pignol & co measure chords in terms of their "tension" relative to the scale in play. That zing in the dominant V chord comes from the clash (eg D7) between its F# and C notes - each is a #4 (tritone) interval from the other. At this point almost anything works.

So Norbert will talk of the smooth field of tonic and some 'foothills' as we play whatever ii, VI or vi chord takes our fancy, and the summit of V. As with his native Alps, that summit is unstable and demands resolution back to tonic. Perfect cadence 8)
 
 (http://chrisryall.net/img/tensiongraph.png)

But we are presently some way from the 'British' 3-chord trick which is a reference to playing a more or less steady G, C, D7, G riff against any G tune. There's a lot of that 'built into' the left end of a melodeon.

[edit] Wouter (below) - you are perhaps missing the key point to the trick -  the "any G tune" bit.    There isn't a choice!
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 07, 2011, 08:51:16 AM
But we are presently some way from the 'British' 3-chord trick which is a reference to playing a more or less steady G, C, D7, G riff against any G tune. There's a lot of that 'built into' the left end of a melodeon.

I do't think we are far of the 3chord-trick. It helps people understand when and why you would chose for your C for example.
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 10, 2011, 06:00:12 PM
perhaps i am missing the point. I dont understand what you mean with your last comment. Oh wait, it could be i  was thinking in gc-box-terms. Replace "c" with IV.

What i meant to say is: when playing on your outer-row you can play many tunes in D just on you outerrow, but then you will only hit I (D) en V(A). This is not wrong, but you can use the interpretation presented above for chosing the moment for your IV (G). This will change your direction and you will have to go to your innerrow.

Mailing frommy mobile now, so bit messy. Do i make sense?
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 11, 2011, 09:24:09 AM
Anyone puzzled about the Latin .. chords on our diatonic melodeon scale are numbered. Lower case = minor.

 I G,   ii Am, iii Bm,  IV C,  V D7, vi Em, vii F#mb5

The last one does get used. Though it ain't very folk. I'm on phone too, Bromyard

So the "trick" is I, IV, V, I.  In this notation, in any key.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: AnnC on September 11, 2011, 01:56:10 PM
 Apologies for what might seem a 'dim' question from a novice  :|bl but on an 8 button bass which buttons do the numbers apply to please?  

 for example when playing on the outer treble row is the button furthest from my chin on the outer bass row a I or a IV ?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Anahata on September 11, 2011, 03:49:45 PM
when playing on the outer treble row is the button furthest from my chin on the outer bass row a I or a IV ?

If I've worked that out correctly, it's IV on push and I on pull.
The same buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the inner treble row.

The other outer bass buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the outer row, and...
V on push and II on pull when playing on the inner row. (the latter not used much unless we're heading for or already in the outer row key)
  :Ph :|glug

Just one of the joys (?) of the melodeon is that the two main treble row keys have their bass IV chords  in quite different places.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 11, 2011, 03:53:33 PM
when playing on the outer treble row is the button furthest from my chin on the outer bass row a I or a IV ?

If I've worked that out correctly, it's IV on push and I on pull.
The same buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the inner treble row.

The other outer bass buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the outer row, and...
V on push and II on pull when playing on the inner row. (the latter not used much unless we're heading for or already in the outer row key)
  :Ph :|glug

Just one of the joys (?) of the melodeon is that the two main treble row keys have their bass IV chords  in quite different places.


completely correct. Assuming you are playing in regular major. ( you could be playing in other modes, but normally, yeah correct )
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: AnnC on September 11, 2011, 05:41:49 PM

If I've worked that out correctly, it's IV on push and I on pull.
The same buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the inner treble row.

The other outer bass buttons are I on push and V on pull when playing on the outer row, and...
V on push and II on pull when playing on the inner row. (the latter not used much unless we're heading for or already in the outer row key)
  :Ph :|glug

Just one of the joys (?) of the melodeon is that the two main treble row keys have their bass IV chords  in quite different places.


  Thankyou, one of the guitarists who plays in sessions locally will sometimes call the chord sequences in numbers,( 1, 4, 5, 1) and memorising the pattern for the bass buttons is going to help so much (as long as he's playing in the same key as me );D

  There's a pile of fairly simple tunes in G/C (including Nellie the Elephant  ;D) and related minors sorted out to try on the melodeon when it arrives tomorrow and the neighbours have been warned   :|||: >:E
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Anahata on September 11, 2011, 06:23:31 PM
Whatever works for you... eventually you'll do it automatically by ear, including working out which row to play the tune on - especially when playing in the outer row home key you need to cross to inner row to get IV and V chords on 3 notes. Many melodeon players don't bother.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 12, 2011, 07:36:47 AM
Thinking of a progression in | I | vi | V7 | I | terms pays off when you move 'off piste' in terms of melodeon keys.  eg Yesterday I fell in with what I call the 'Malvern lot ' and their dulcimer player did that fast close harmony two fiddles tune (don't know its name) ex Token Women. It arrived in C, then into D, but I was able to keep going.  Note the "tune & development", incidentally - this was the closest they got to a medley  ;)

But generally ..

  In G:   G  C*  D**  G
  In D:   D  G*  A**  G

is the trick.  Harmonically it's very beneficial to 'feel' these as the subdominant* and dominant** chords in their respective keys.  As Anahata alluded - you've got to start training your ear if it is to become automatic.

We've also talked about ii chord (Am in G) and vi (Em in G).  These are also sub-dominants as they have some musical tension against the G scale. Both are available both ends, and they make an equally acceptable (tho' not classic skiffle) 3 chord trick.

There is in practice only one 'dominant' and that is the V7 chord.  If you play a simple D it 'feels' soft. Add in a  C note, as bass or (better) as pull on G row and you'll feel its instability - it wants to resolve to G - hence the name.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: brianread on September 12, 2011, 12:24:42 PM
Whatever works for you... eventually you'll do it automatically by ear, including working out which row to play the tune on - especially when playing in the outer row home key you need to cross to inner row to get IV and V chords on 3 notes. Many melodeon players don't bother.


.. and i'm one of them!  I think the Em as a substitute for the G works quite often, and gives a subtle extra flavour to the accompanyment, occasionally it does not work, in which case leave the chord out or substitute an A. 
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on September 13, 2011, 06:40:29 PM
ive got a bit lost on this thread! (about 3 pages ago !) chris - have you got a youtube channel that you show all this stuff on? id be interested to see it
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Kennymac on September 26, 2011, 12:04:09 PM
Western music has a natural progression and the structure which the 3-chord trick reflects naturally when you listen to the chord progression.... this is a generalisation and there are always exceptions to the rule but it allows you to play with other musicians without necessarily knowing the tune, only the key they are playing in.

If you thumb through a guitar book for example and look at the chord symbols on top of a song you will see the sequence of chords – they tend to follow the I-IV-V and relative minor (VI) pattern.[/b]

So, if a tune/song is in the key of C, you will have

C, F, G and relative Aminor chords (use your thumb on your left hand to count the first chord and as you count up the notes, your ring finger and little finger will correspond to chords F and G and the sixth note is an A but, this is played as the Aminor (listen to the sounds - it sound natural).

To test the pattern again... the key of G would have the following sequence of chords:

G, C, D and Eminor and so on.
 
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Kautilya on September 26, 2011, 07:35:04 PM
Just daydreaming that one day, in the distant galactic future, a scientist will come up with a way  for someone to show how to play a three-chord trick by capturing the sound in their kitchen (utility room, cellar) perhaps even a "moving picture" to show their fingers as they press the buttons on their reedbox.

Then maybe a way will be found to transmit them through space to others in their sitting rooms (bathrooms, sheds) who can see and hear them and copy them to play.

As the sage George Confucius is alleged to have written with his quill : a single squeeze in the ear'ole is worth a thousand pigeon posts. :||: >:E :|||:
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Rob2Hook on September 27, 2011, 01:55:19 PM
... Many melodeon players don't bother.


.. and i'm one of them!  I think the Em as a substitute for the G works quite often, and gives a subtle extra flavour to the accompanyment, occasionally it does not work, in which case leave the chord out or substitute an A. 

Depending on the tune, both approaches can work - in fact, if the style of the tune is more one-row, then using the E bass as a substitute for the natural G maj accompaniment can be more suitable than crossing to the G row to get the G on the push.   Some tunes will happily accept both treatments, so playing solo or for a ceilidh it allows a change of style instead of a more repititious rendition.

Rob.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 27, 2011, 02:42:24 PM
I've been following this thread with interest as my knowledge of musical theory has a few holes in it. I understand the three chord trick in major keys and can use it (and move beyond it) fairly instinctively, but I am less certain about it in minor keys. I don't find E minor too difficult, but I am playing increasingly in D minor and G minor these days and finding a bass line in these keys is less than intuitive to me. Trial and error gets me there eventually, but it would be useful to have a basic explanation of how the three chord trick works in minor keys.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Anahata on September 27, 2011, 03:23:45 PM
The trouble with with "minor key" is a it's a rather nebulous description. There are different scales in common use all described as minor keys, and each tends to have different sets of chords that are likely to fit:

Aeolian mode and classical minors usually work with the same I-IV-V family of chords as major keys, except the classical scales are likely to need the V chord to be a major to fit in with sharpened leading note, e.g. E major for a tune in A minor.

Dorian mode tends to be "two chord trick" with I and VII (e.g. Em and D for a so-called E minor tune) and several other chords are likely to be useful: III (major) especially, maybe V and IV depending on the tune. Dorian tunes often move into the major key based on the 3rd note of the (original Dorian) scale anyway.

For other modes, it's open season as there isn't enough established repertoire to determine what sounds "normal".
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 27, 2011, 04:12:04 PM
Thanks for the explanation, Anahata. I was hoping that there would be something simple that I could remember easily, but, as so often, I seem destined for disappointment.  :(

I have read up about the differences between the different modes a few times, not least on other threads on melodeon.net, but I still find it very difficult to identify which minor mode is being employed in a given tune.

Currently, I am trying to work out an interesting bass line for L'Anternaire with the A music in D minor and the B music in D major. I guess I shall just have to listen to the track on the Live en Flandre CD over and over again (I can think of worse fates!)

For anyone else interested in learning this beautiful tune, here is the ABC.

X: 73
T:L'Anternaire
C:Paris, Chabenat, Claeys, Decombel  
M:3/4
L:1/8
R:Waltz
Z:Julian Scott
K:Dm %Transposed from GM
DE||F2EFGE|F2E2DE|F2EFGE|AGFEDE|F2EFGE|
F2E2DE|F2EFGE|A4DE|F2EFGE|F2E2DE|F2EFGE|
AGFEDE|F2EFGE|F2E2DE|F2EFGE|A4A=B|:
K:D
A2GFEG|F2D2CD|EDEFGA|F2E2AB|
A2GFEG|F2D2CD|EDE=F EC|1D4AB:|2D4D2|]
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on September 27, 2011, 04:40:22 PM
The trouble with with "minor key" is a it's a rather nebulous description. There are different scales in common use all described as minor keys, and each tends to have different sets of chords that are likely to fit:

Aeolian mode and classical minors usually work with the same I-IV-V family of chords as major keys, except the classical scales are likely to need the V chord to be a major to fit in with sharpened leading note, e.g. E major for a tune in A minor.
It's often VII as well, instead of V
Dorian mode tends to be "two chord trick" with I and VII (e.g. Em and D for a so-called E minor tune) and several other chords are likely to be useful: III (major) especially, maybe V and IV depending on the tune. Dorian tunes often move into the major key based on the 3rd note of the (original Dorian) scale anyway.
I love to be able to get IV in here, as that is the one which makes it sound the most Dorian (due to IV being Major instead of Minor).

For other modes, it's open season as there isn't enough established repertoire to determine what sounds "normal".

For Mixolydian i found it's often just I and VII (with some IV and V).

Please correct me if i am wrong, if you know better. This is what i deduced from my own playing, not from a book or anything,
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Anahata on September 27, 2011, 08:17:04 PM
Please correct me if i am wrong
There's no wrong or right here. The term "three chord trick" simply refers to the minimum three chords with which you can busk your way though almost anything on a guitar (with a capo to change keys). It's a useful simplification for beginners, but even with only three chords, you have to use your ears to work out which goes where, and they don't work for everything so you do have to lean more chords eventually.

Quote
This is what i deduced from my own playing, not from a book or anything
Exactly!  :|glug
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2011, 08:24:20 AM
I have read up about the differences between the different modes a few times, not least on other threads on melodeon.net, but I still find it very difficult to identify which minor mode is being employed in a given tune.

All (except one!) minor scales have a flattened 3rd note and so that doesn't help you. There is then a 'secondary' minor note, number 6.  In "Em"

   E   F#   Gflat'n'd 3 A    B    C##4th D   E  "dorian"

   E   F#   Gflat'n'd 3 A    B    Cnat     D    E  "aolian"

To "feel" which - just mentally, or with fingers, run up the scale in use to note 6.  If it's C (G row) you are in classic minor. Quite a lot off chords work, including pull D7 as that's "V" chord in G diatonic

If it is C# (D row) then you are in the more 'folky' Dorian mode and Anahata's 2 chord trick always works. There are other chording options but frankly they don't lie too well on the D/G left end. The Dorian feels "brighter" - one way to look at is is a minor bottom end with 'blue' major top end.   The #6 in dorian is also sometimes called its "characteristic (aka sensitive) note"

I know I rabbit on about this too much, but it really is fundamental  - our left end chords change so significantly. Thus effort learning to recognise which if the 2 available minor modes you're in pays off long term.  

  "A minor" on a D/G is fundamentally Dorian unless you invoke "accidentals" = not a problem

May I "again"offer http://chrisryall.net/modes/ - the bit on "concept of majorness or minorness" near the bottom lays this out and there are .mid files to allow you to hear the differences.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 28, 2011, 12:53:40 PM
Thanks, Chris. As a result of your last post, it suddenly clicked into place. I now understand the difference between three of the minor modes (aeolian, dorian and mixolydian), which is definite progress. I shall follow the link back to your earlier explanation in the hope of deepening my understanding.

Now, back to working out a pleasing bass line for the D minor part of L'Anternaire...

By the way (and totally off topic!), does anyone know what L'Anternaire means? It doesn't appear in my French dictionary and Google Translate can make nothing of it.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: jb on September 28, 2011, 01:20:46 PM
By the way (and totally off topic!), does anyone know what L'Anternaire means? It doesn't appear in my French dictionary and Google Translate can make nothing of it.

Google gives many more hits with Lanternaire than with L'anternaire, including a few youtube clips such as this one (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YFm6I6sR50), which seems to contain a visual clue.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2011, 01:29:02 PM
Thanks, please note that mixolydian (blue/flattened 7th) is considered a 'major' as it has a 'true' third note.

I've not met an Anternaire either. Googling only gets the mazurka -  so it's probably made up. There is a mountain "Anterne" near Mont Blanc, but I'll see what my fat "Robert Collins" dictionary at home says.



[edit]  JB's right - seems to be a track on/?off this CD http://www.maniadb.com/artist.asp?p=388060 - suggesting that the Paris/Chabanat sleve notes might be the source of confusion?
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 28, 2011, 01:53:32 PM
Yes, I did wonder whether mixolydian was a minor mode for that very reason. Thanks for confirming my suspicions.

I believe that the tune comes from Aveyron, which is nowhere near Mont Blanc, so it is unlikely to be named after someone living around Mont Anterne. Your suggestion that the apostrophe has found its way into the name of the tune by accident sounds very plausible to me. If my French has not failed me (as it often does!), un lanternaire could be a lamplighter. Alternatively, it could mean a dawdler or a time waster (from the verb lanterner).  
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Accordion Dave on October 27, 2011, 03:04:01 AM
This discussion makes my head spin. Just play around with the buttons until the harmony sounds right. I can't explain how to play what you folks call a "melodeon" but I am getting some good sounding music out of my various one and two row instruments these days. Come to think of it, I can't explain how to play the paino accordion either, but I keep getting better at it which is I guess us all that matters.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Accordion Dave on October 27, 2011, 03:05:07 AM
That's piano accordion. No pain just fun.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: malcolmbebb on October 27, 2011, 08:27:44 AM
ive got a bit lost on this thread! (about 3 pages ago !)

I must admit, I am generally with Tommy on this. I haven't read the whole thread, but music theory beyond the very basics is a new topic for me and most comments assume far more knowledge and understanding than i presently have. Tommy's responses at the beginning of the thread reflect how I feel.
There's a lot of knowledge here, but people who have that level of knowledge and can present it understandably to someone who has none are very rare, And usually underpaid!
But I shall keep plugging away!
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Cooper on October 27, 2011, 05:04:17 PM
ive got a bit lost on this thread! (about 3 pages ago !)

I must admit, I am generally with Tommy on this. I haven't read the whole thread, but music theory beyond the very basics is a new topic for me and most comments assume far more knowledge and understanding than i presently have. Tommy's responses at the beginning of the thread reflect how I feel.
There's a lot of knowledge here, but people who have that level of knowledge and can present it understandably to someone who has none are very rare, And usually underpaid!
But I shall keep plugging away!

Not sure if this thread isindeed that useful for people just starting on the subject. I know i wasnt writing with that in mind ;-)
W
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Strigulino on October 27, 2011, 05:12:50 PM
I think a lot of the threads on this forum I have tagged in my brain as "must look at later when I have aced the basics".  The reason why you "practice" a musical instrument, or medicine, or law, is that there is an assumption that you are always learning.  Trying to improve.  When you are good at some aspect of something, find something new to get your teeth into.

Zen and the Art of Melodeon Playing.
Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: george garside on October 27, 2011, 08:55:51 PM
Whilst the various attempts to explain of the three chord trick  by reference to musical theory  & dot reading are quite correct the are possibly of limited interest to what is probably the majority of 'melodeon' players  who have neither the desire or intention  study musical theory or dot reading  and who prefer and aften develop considerable experise playing in the traditional by ear/from memory mode.  The latter type of player relies heavily on using the ears handily provided by the maker to maximum effect  - in other words if it sounds right it is right.

NOw to the 3 chord trick  ( with both beginners &non readers in mind!)   The 3 chord trick when playing a tune in G on the G row  requires chords and dbass notes  C, G & D to be played on the bass end of the box in order to provide an element of both harmony & rhythm between the bass (accompanyment) and treble (tune)  sidesof the box.

NOw it so happens ( refer to any DG bass chart either on this forum or in any tutor book)  that the bottom two outer buttons  on the bass end play the note (the UM) and the chord ( the PA) o G when the bellows are pushed and D when the bellows are pulled. i.e. the direction of the bellows at an;y particular time in a tune will automatilacally select D or G without you needing to make a choice and leaving ;you to concentrate on   playing a suitable accompanying rhythm using just those two buttons.

It also so hapens the the bottom two insisde ( next to the bellows) bass buttons plsy the note & chord of C  on both the push & pull of the bellows, & this is the third note used in the 3 chord trick.

Therefor for the key of G the bottom 4 bass buttons will do the necessary. The next question is how to choose between the outside 2 buttons which play G or D  and th;e inside two buttons which play C.  Rather than worrying about what goes with what it is very useful to try todevelop an intuitive way of making the choice. Therefor (best strt with a low tune) ply a rhythmic accompanyment using the D/G buttons untill something sound not quite right. When this happens try the C?C buttons which should improve things a bit. Wen the C buttons don't sound quite right go back onto the D?G buttons and continu;e untill it gets a bit iffy again at which point change onto the C/C button.& continue swapping on this basis throughout the tune.

There is a great deal more that can be done in the way of bass harmony etc but the above should form a reasonable intro to the 3 chord trick for those who prefer 'eary to theory!'.

(disclaimer - it is much easier to demonstrate than to write about so apologies for any confusion caused!)

george



Title: Re: 3 chord trick
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on October 27, 2011, 10:35:30 PM
I think your bracketed comment could have answered the original question George!  ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal