Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Pete Dunk on June 27, 2011, 07:16:18 PM
-
PS Nice to have a thread where we can be positve and helpful about this instrument without the purist back-stabbing previously encountered - could we actually have our own sub-board thus enabling multi threads within it?
A Luddite free zone? 'Other Instruments' has been pilloried, gimme a break. Nobody posting in this thread will see 50 again (I think) so we can't even call it an Old Fart Free Sub-Forum. All of that said I like the idea of a Modern Technology sub-forum. Yes, we should have electronic instruments in it, but it should also include digital recording, video technology and stage hardware topics so it's not exclusively midi controllers and we can take advantage of the many and varied talents shown by members here.
DaveW - I'll see you at the stand in Mersham on Wednesday with a bit of luck. :-)
Pete
Edit: typo - what else!
-
I do think it's interesting; there are plenty of boxes that people have strong opinions about but I think the Roland is unique in that the people who own it are feeling so beleaguered on melnet that they need a walled garden. Perhaps a sub-forum is the thing; particularly if the setup is so complex on the Roland that it takes a lot of getting used to. That sort of thing is very well suited to a forum.
-
I do think it's interesting; there are plenty of boxes that people have strong opinions about but I think the Roland is unique in that the people who own it are feeling so beleaguered on melnet that they need a walled garden. Perhaps a sub-forum is the thing; particularly if the setup is so complex on the Roland that it takes a lot of getting used to. That sort of thing is very well suited to a forum.
Luv the garden analogy...
the walls do help deter the occasional vandalism but naturally there will always be pests and weeds ...
A weed is simply a plant growing in the wrong place :-*
-
I do think it's interesting; there are plenty of boxes that people have strong opinions about but I think the Roland is unique in that the people who own it are feeling so beleaguered on melnet that they need a walled garden.
However unlike most of our boxes the Roland has a large number of technical issues and it seems like s good idea to have one clean thread where these can be talked about rather than having to wade through lots of "call that a melodeon" type posts which seem to occur.
Steve
-
However unlike most of our boxes the Roland has a large number of technical issues and it seems like s good idea to have one clean thread where these can be talked about rather than having to wade through lots of "call that a melodeon" type posts which seem to occur.
Steve
I agree. Does anyone round here have a Roland *and* a Streb? I'd be very interested to hear about how the technical set up compares. (I've been very lax about fiddling with my Streb; I know there's a lot more that's possible in terms of bellows response and so on).
-
Does anyone round here have a Roland *and* a Streb?
summerstars does as he bought my old Streb
-
Does anyone round here have a Roland *and* a Streb?
summerstars does as he bought my old Streb
Unfortunately I sold it to by the Roland -
In essence the streb feels closer to a melodeon than the roland but the ability to finely tune falls very much in favour of the Roland.
However the biggest difference being the melodeon sound sets in the Streb - infinitely better than the five reed sets and variations provided by the Roland, however the non-accordion sounds in the Roland are likewise infinitely superior.
I have had my roland 5 months now and am only just beginning to get used to it, and am still working on getting it setup exactly the way I want it be - I don't regret the purchase, but would warn people that it can take a while to warm to it - a half hour session in the shop will not be enough to even scratch at its abilities
-
I do think it's interesting; there are plenty of boxes that people have strong opinions about but I think the Roland is unique in that the people who own it are feeling so beleaguered on melnet that they need a walled garden. Perhaps a sub-forum is the thing; particularly if the setup is so complex on the Roland that it takes a lot of getting used to. That sort of thing is very well suited to a forum.
Alison, I don't think beleaguered is the right word (especially as I have trouble spelling it) There seem to be only a few Fr18's about and the programming can be complicated - I had very useful advice from Hallelujah Al, Melodeon Mitch and Summerstars and hope to trawl up some more from other owners and maybe to pass on any useful stuff I find for myself.
If folks want to knock the way the thing sounds that's OK by me. It needn't be under the heading 'user group' though. Some of the negative comments in here have put the thing in perspective, which is great.
At 8pm I was playing a bit of Klezmer on the trumpet (that's the electronic trumpet, with melodeon fingering, called fr18) - I thought I was Grecia Farfel ;D best wishes DaveW
-
...I thought I was Grecia Farfel ;D
'It' can do that, I thought I was Acker Bilk 8)
-
>
However the biggest difference being the melodeon sound sets in the Streb - infinitely better than the five reed sets and variations provided by the Roland,
>
That's quite surprising, given the Roland's choice of twelve different accordion sets, each with eight treble and three bass registers and, on four of the treble registers (with two or three 8' reeds), 15 different tremolo/musette settings. I assume the accordion sets on the FR-18 are the same as the equivalent ones on the FR-3 and FR-7. I thought the accordion sounds of the FR-3 were marvellous, e.g. the ability to "play" Bugari Classic or Excelsior Jazz (Jack Emblow, anyone?). I mostly used the Hohner Morino (D. Folk) set, with occasional diversions into Maugein (French) or Steirische (Alpine). I would have thought that, with a bit of experimenting, it would be possible to get sounds to suit anyone.
-
>
However the biggest difference being the melodeon sound sets in the Streb - infinitely better than the five reed sets and variations provided by the Roland,
>
I assume the accordion sets on the FR-18 are the same as the equivalent ones on the FR-3 and FR-7. I thought the accordion sounds of the FR-3 were marvellous, e.g. the ability to "play" Bugari Classic or Excelsior Jazz (Jack Emblow, anyone?). I mostly used the Hohner Morino (D. Folk) set, with occasional diversions into Maugein (French) or Steirische (Alpine).
Personally I am reasonably happy with those sounds - the criticisms are that they are accordeon sound sets NOT Melodeon Sounds!
-
Personally I am reasonably happy with those sounds - the criticisms are that they are accordeon sound sets NOT Melodeon Sounds!
Having heard an fr7, the accordion sounds on there sound similar to the FR18 sounds.
Can I ask Summerstars if he has the full number of accordion sets - Mine seem short in number, but it may be that I just can't find them I count eight I think.
best wishes
[/quote]
-
Dave,
You should have 12 accordion sets, 3 on each of the 4 treble registers. See p 24 of the manual. (Unless you have over-written any of the 3 sets on register 4. I'd recommend keeping the "D.Folk" set on that register; that should be the Hohner Morino sound).
-
Bill,
Thanks for reply. I've found how to work a few more voices and wondered what D-folk was (Deutsche Folk?). There is probably a way of saving that one, Morino is a sacred word amongst the b/c/c# brotherhood. I have some um-pah polkas which I play and as an exercise was trying to set up something suitable, tuba bass and Czech accordion sound?
Keeping track of these favoured sounds may well be difficult.
-
Well it was a nice try, splitting the non-users who were simply chatting about the FR18 from the users who actually have one. It's gone a bit wrong though eh? >:E
-
I lay the blame at your door you devil you >:E
-
I see the the original thread has shed loads of readers
-
I notice that Accordionjo (aka The Music Room) is selling these for £1399 on eBay or less if you make them an offer with a free bag for the first five sold. I was kind of interested until I read that the total Waveform RAM was a pathetic 64 MB!! No wonder some of the sounds appear a little weak, bearing in mind that the 64 MB is shared by all those other sounds - organ, drums, banjo etc. I would have preferred to see something like 1GB for melodeon samples alone. What is the waveform memory of a Streb I wonder?
-
At least for the accordion sounds, it isn't just a simple sample player, you might want read up on Roland's acoustic instrument modeling before making a premature and incomplete judgement of the instrument just based on sample library size. I have an FR-18 and it sounds quite good to me now that I've really dialed in the settings for the style of accordion music I play. The non-accordion orchestral sounds built-in the FR-18, while fun, really aren't the selling point, at least not to me. I would agree they are just OK, better to run the FR-18 into a dedicated synth module if you don't care about accordion sounds.
-
I tried a Roland virtual piano accordion at a music store, but once I found out that the price was FAR beyond what I wanted to spend, I moved on to auditioning second hand conventional accordions.
Feel free to move this to a new category called "People who have tried a Roland but can't justify the expense."
-
Hi,
apologies re any cross posting. I just posted a similar request on the BCC# forum. Im aware that Roland accordions has ceased production of the Roland FR 18, however Im also aware that there are quite a few members on here who have purchased and /or tried models. I'd be interested to know how folks found them to play. Particularly in comparison to a 'normal' BCC#. The bass end looks like a diatonic style base as used on melodeons which would seem to limit their usefulness (for me). The same 'problem' seems to be true for the Streb emelodeon (http://www.streb.co.uk/eml_about.htm) re bass ends. (I guess that a stradella base end could be constructed for a price?) Can the bases on either be tweaked to a mini Stradella? Any info/ views would be helpful.
Thank you
Euan
-
apologies re any cross posting. I just posted a similar request on the BCC# forum. Im aware that Roland accordions has ceased production of the Roland FR 18, however Im also aware that there are quite a few members on here who have purchased and /or tried models. I'd be interested to know how folks found them to play. Particularly in comparison to a 'normal' BCC#. The bass end looks like a diatonic style base as used on melodeons which would seem to limit their usefulness (for me). The same 'problem' seems to be true for the Streb emelodeon (http://www.streb.co.uk/eml_about.htm) re bass ends. (I guess that a stradella base end could be constructed for a price?) Can the bases on either be tweaked to a mini Stradella? Any info/ views would be helpful.
Thank you
Euan
I play my fr-18 as bcc# for international dance. Two tablatures set up too give bass es F - E and Eb - Dm. It took ages to decide what to do on the left hand. European music uses minor keyts often and that influenced my choices. So: outer row, alternate bass note, Centre row bass note, inner row major or minor chord.
I use the other two user sets fo D/G 21/2 diatonic. My brain is addled by all this and fr-18 sounds are not too melodious but it's fun when you play with other competent musicians. Lack of diatonic bounce and complex layout are balanced by having a fully chromatic right hand
DaveW