Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: joe on August 01, 2008, 12:35:04 PM
-
any ideas?
-
Classical.
(Not the same thing, but I was surprised yesterday to find how nicely "Carolan's Concerto" goes on a one row.)
"Nearer home," I'm not sure I've ever been wholly convinced by a slow air played on any push-pull instrument.
Tom
-
inappropriate?! I don't think there is one!
I've heard great accordion in hiphop, reggae, african music, dance (techno type not celidh type!). aswell as all the genres you'd expect it.. - Trad Irish, Cajun, klezmer..
..and I play it in a punk rock band!
(For me the most inappropriate is probably english folk music ;) hahah, how to not make friends on a melodeon forum lesson one!! )
mm maybe some airs sound a bit clunky on a press draw...But I've heard some lovely ones..
-
Classical.
" ," I'm not sure I've ever been wholly convinced by a slow air played on any push-pull instrument.
Tom
I find that both the DG & the BC(C#) lend themselves particularly well to slow airs due probably to the exellent dynamic properties of the instruments. The same of course will apply to any one row box. The bellows reversals between notes should not create a problem if done sensitively. Indeed playing slow aires (on the row) is a good way of developing good bellow control. Sir Jimmy Shand recorded a number of slow airs on a hohner erica C#D box very effectively.
george
-
One possible reason for Tom's scepticism towards slow tunes on a box may be partly do to the natural preference for beginners to favour slow tunes. Naturally its easier to get all the right notes in the right order in a slow tune, but I've found that to really produce a good performance on a slow tune requires more musicianship than to be able to belt out a lively reel, polka or jig. Also I find there are fewer performance opportunities, as slow tunes tend to turn into a shapeless mush when played in a session.
-
The Ring Cycle?;D
And that makes me wonder if history would have been changed if Richard had written it for melodeons as it is hard to feel warlike with a box round your neck. Imagine the Kaiser's Army Band, they would have minced like Python. ???
Old Bill.
-
I'm probably just a bit over-picky (and mainly a fiddle player!) I'm mainly thinking of Irish music, haven't listened to any Scottish airs on box for a while, but I'm thinking of even such lovely players as Josephine Marsh, Niamh Ni Charra and Martin Quinn in comparison with the likes of Matt Molloy and Liam O'Flynn!
Tom
-
yeah I'm with Theo there..
slow airs are are the hardest tunes to play well....therefore a real test of the players ability..
I think its the same with all instruments
try some Mairtin O'Connor.. or Conor Keane..
-
Mairtin O'Connor comes closest, of what I've heard! ;D
(Sorry, I didn't mean to point this thread in the wrong direction.)
Was it Mairtin O'Connor playing box on De Danaan's "Arrival of the Queen of Sheba in Galway"? Perhaps classical would work well after all.... Anyone "serious" examples that prove it can be done?
Tom
-
Was it Mairtin O'Connor playing box on De Danaan's "Arrival of the Queen of Sheba in Galway"?
I believe so...
Perhaps classical would work well after all.... Anyone "serious" examples that prove it can be done?
There's Johnny og Connolly's take on a Bach solo violon sonata or partita - it's on a record he made with Charlie Lennon. Amazing stunt - only one passage where you can hear him struggling to get all the notes in without losing the flow. But, apart from the novelty value, and the sheer technical achievement, a bit of a pointless exercise - it sounds awfully lame next to a violinist's rendition.
Speaking of De Dannan, I really enjoy Hey Jude and the Queen of Sheba, but they should have stopped there. Have you heard their "Hibernian Rhapsody" (spoof of the Queen hit)? Embarrassingly awful.
-
Classical.
At Melodeons at Witney , last year , there was a workshop which performed a Pavane by Susato .
Stunning !
-
There is a really nice Elizabethan Medley on Tony Hall's album Mr Universe. First tune is a lute piece. Not exactly classical, but not quite traditional or pop either. Tony makes it sound like the melodeon must have existed in 16th century England. Has inspired me to try to arrange some of my old lute repetoire, now I no longer play the instrument.
Bet you couldn't play Schonberg's, atonal 12 note row stuff on a D/G although it might be possible on a chromatic box, but who'd want to play that stuff anyway. so guess that avant-garde, "crash bang tinckle" music wouldn't bring out the best in a melodeon (or any instrument)
-
Now here's a crunch collision - human beatbox and melodeon. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZuHeXRO3-Q)
Must take enormous concentration to keep both things going on at once.
It kind of works, but looks somewhat odd...
Like he's chewing a wasp... ;D
Ed J
-
Have joined in with morris sides who dance to some strange tunes for the melodeon, such as Nellie the elephant,and Lilly the Pink, Achy Breaky heart,and the William Tell overture do these count as unusual tunes for the melodeon? What have other people played or attempted which is not folk
-
Now here’s a crunch collision - human beatbox and melodeon. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ZuHeXRO3-Q)
Must take enormous concentration to keep both things going on at once.
It kind of works, but looks somewhat odd...
Like he’s chewing a wasp... ;D
Ed J
Brilliant!!!
Just hope his box is waterproof! :-X
-
Of course we can play anything on a melodeon with enough effort, straining and gurning (wasp eating) but why do we want to. The joy of music is that instruments are different and compliment each other. I've never heard a fiddle get a melodeon rhythm, they just don't have the capacity in the instrument. Inappropriate genre's are possibly lullabies although I've seen many babies sleep through melodeon performances (along with some adult audiences). Slow airs, which would encompass certain song accompaniments, have already been mentioned but I think Theo has the handle on it. There really aren't any inappropriate genres but there are definitely some inappropriate renditions, not always by beginners.
Martin
-
I find it a bit sad that quite a few morris musicians (but by no means all) can only play the tunes their morris side uses. The only tunes, pieces, compositions or whatever that are innapropriate are those that it is totally impossible to play half decently on the box. EG some accordion examination 'test pieces' would be impossible to play (exactly as written which is what a test piece is about) on a melodeon or even on a chromatic BCC# because some of the written right hand chords are not available - anad on the Dg even less so. However this does not mean that the tune is innapropriate as it may well be possible to play it in a modified form - and it may even sound better than when played 'correctly as wriitten - which really means one buggers version~! Personally I like to make a tune sound the way I want it to
george ;)
-
The only place I can think of that I'd prefer not to hear another melodeon is any ensemble/session/band where more than about a quarter of the musicians are box players. I like sessions where there are loads of fiddles, the occasional banjo, mandolin or guitar, a double bass or piano and a couple of other box players, and preferably the box players should take it in turns to play the bass end.
Ducks and runs for cover :o
-
Sligtly off-topic, perhaps, in that here we're talking about a piano accordion group, but not worth another thread.
Here in Minneapolis, MN, USA, there is a piano accordion group which is forming a band to rehearse a playlist of tunes which they might perform at public events, parades, nursing homes, etc. On the tune list is: "All I Have to Do Is Dream" (Everly Brothers hit from the 50's), "Wipeout" (1963 surf rock hit), "Can't Help Falling in Love With You" (made popular, as I recall, by Elvis Presley), and.........."Macarena"! Perhaps all interesting enough when you consider their place in pop music history, but why they need to be recapped by an ensemble of twelve accordions, I can't quite figure. I think the "novelty" might perhaps wear off before the first intermission.
Bob
-
The only place I can think of that I'd prefer not to hear another melodeon is any ensemble/session/band where more than about a quarter of the musicians are box players. I like sessions where there are loads of fiddles, the occasional banjo, mandolin or guitar, a double bass or piano and a couple of other box players, and preferably the box players should take it in turns to play the bass end.
Ducks and runs for cover :o
as a rule of thumb I think sessions tend to be better on the ear is not dominated by any particular type of instrument - my worst nightmare as a session leader is to have a room full of bohrans and only me to play the tune!. In reality its never happened & in the main no particular instrument has constituted more than 20% of the gathering.
As a n enthusiast of all types of box I dislike the sound of accordion bands & orchestras - as to box plaayers takiing it in turn to play the bass end I would certinly apply this to some players whether on 8 bass melodeon of 120 bass accordion- however thia is more to do with some players lack both skill and empathy, in a session (and at most other times in my opinion) the bass should contribute a nice unobtrusive rhythm throughout the proceedings - unfortunately many do just the opposite &, to quote a well known professional from the north east , play turgid bass - which just about sums it up.
george - also taking cover ;)
-
Thanks George, I hope it's not just you and me versus the massed melodeon players of the world :D
-
You're not on your own. The second melodeon joining a session should only be allowed to play seconds and the third to arrive should get the beers in.
George, I had you nightmare thrust on me. A nameless box player had been giving bohran lessons and brought his beginners class of twelve to one of my sessions.
Martin
-
12? I thought I was unlucky with 6 at one session I was at .. although at the time there were only 4 other musicians, 1 1/2 Bodhrans per normal instrument can sound pretty poor. At other times I have been at sessions with 1 melodeon, 1 fiddle and about 12 Guitars all playing their own chord arrangements!
If there is more than one melodeon playing the melody, the tune can lose a lot of it's rhythm and feeling. A bit of clever counter melody can make a tune sound fantastic!
-
If there is more than one melodeon playing the melody, the tune can lose a lot of it's rhythm and feeling.
[/quote]
thats because some players don't make any attempt to follow the person who started the tune , even though this can be difficult in some sssions, particulaarly in long narrow rooms. and also they don't actualy listen to themselves so you finish up with every body playing with him (or her) self, so to speak.
Taken to extreme this can result in musical battles anad high jacking of tunes to a different speed altogether from that at which somebody started it. This can apply particularly if a relative beginner plucks up the courage to start a tune & plays at a lightly slower speed than would the self styled 'experts'. We all had to start somewhere and I consider it discourtious to do anything other than support the player by playing at their speed. Another silly smartarse stunt is for somebody to follow the slow & shaky tune with a fast version of it. Another inconsiderate stunt is for experienced players to not make any attempt to join in with a tune they consider to be beneath them, leaving the newcomer to struggle on , make a balls of it or give up! Tricks like this do nobody any credit and can have the effect of putting a newcomer completely off session playing .
In my book session playing is about veriety and there is no such thing as a proper session tune or for that matter an improper one! Sessions are about playing so that as many as possible can join in and dare not concert performances . those who wish to show off their solo expertise are better off in a 'singaround/playaround' type of event where it is the norm for each participant to have the oportunity of doing a spot. We all had to stat somewhere & we should take pride in encouraging session newcomers to make a start.
george- definately not ducking to avaoid the flack!
-
Back to where we started off ,I've just tried to play along with The Monroe Brothers on Weeping Willow and found it impossible because of how their instruments are tuned on the record - I think it's somewhere around A400. Never mind!
Chris-the-confused.
-
Back to where we started off ,I've just tried to play along with The Monroe Brothers on Weeping Willow and found it impossible because of how their instruments are tuned on the record - I think it's somewhere around A400. Never mind!
Time for a bit of electronic pitch bending?
Ref George's most recent post - Hopefully we'd all agree wholeheartedly! This is a subject that gets chewed over endlessly over at thesession.org.
As regards both that, and earlier comments about too many of one instrument in one session, I was at a couple of really nice sessions a few weeks ago. An overwhelming majority of melodeons could have been too much, BUT with lovely musicianship and "good session manners" all round, they were a real pleasure, and I say that as a fiddler! It probably made a difference that most of those present were used to playing for/accompanying one of the more "technical" traditional dance styles.... (That was why we were all there.)
Referring back to my earlier comments about not being satisfied with slow tunes on the box, I've since realised that I'd forgotten Mr Cutting. I take it all back!
Tom
-
Back to where we started off . . .
One of the things I've always found appealing about squeeze-boxes of all kinds is their amazing versitility: perhaps not all musical idioms lend themselves to the "standard" two row D/G melodeon --- which we are reliably informed has only been around for about 60 years. It seems that whenever a strong need exists to express someone's musical vision some clever tinkerer simply adds a button or two, tweaks a reed, changes a tuning, reinvents an old layout, builds a midi box and presto! Suddenly "appropriateness" is redefined. Earlier today I was listening to a French CD called "Squashbox". All Zulu, Xhosa and Sotho South African concertina and accordion players with retuned instruments, doing wild stuff I never would have imagined possible.
So I'll argue there is no such thing as an "inappropriate" genre. Rather, there are sometimes temporary mismatches between box capabilities, player abilities, and choice of repetoire. But it usually gets fixed after a bit.
-
Chris can become unconfused. It has long been common practice when making recordings to change speeds to either tighten the sound or enhance rhythm etc. If your recording was pre digital then there was always a resultant key (or partial key) change. Ebors advice good - digtally do what you want with it.
-
If this can be done on a one row nothing is inappropriate or impossible.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvxVvVSpbrw&feature=related
Who can recognise the most tunes in this medley
or how about this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YLwvUWw8qw&feature=related
Envious Martin
-
We used to play at Broadstairs to support the children's clown at the bandstand each morning. Apart from some key bending to match our playing to his singing, he would always issue a challenge for the last day. During a jig, we would have to change to a chosen genre, e.g. Gilbert and Sullivan or Rock & Roll... Believe me, Bad Moon Rising at dance speed is a little weird on a D/G box!
-
Of course we can play anything on a melodeon with enough effort, straining and gurning (wasp eating) but why do we want to.
Well, in the case of beat box/wasp eating I can see why. But...Morris Dancing? I don't get it.. :-\
-
Just back from Sidmouth where I have been stalking Tony Hall. At one of his concerts he performed "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen. What a dude he is.
-
Speed is another issue. Started playing sessions again - as a guitarist (as opposed to formal dances) - session players now seem to take it as a point of honour to play everything at about twice feasible dance speed - WHY? - or am I just getting old ;D
-
Speed is another issue. Started playing sessions again - as a guitarist (as opposed to formal dances) - session players now seem to take it as a point of honour to play everything at about twice feasible dance speed - WHY? - or am I just getting old ;D
and can detract greatly from the tune by so doing! Every tune has a 'natural speed' and most sound much better played that way. Another problem with the fashion of 100mph sessions is that it excludes many (quite good) players from joining in and leaves beginners with absolutely no chance. It could be that some sessions use the 100mph trick to exclude what they see as less good players. Me - I just like tunes played at a nice steaady speed as intended by whoever thought them up in the first place so that most players are in with a chance of joining in & enjoying the event. If anybody is at whitby folk week next week I will be running two such sessions in the middle earth pub. For some strange reason both sessions are programmed for wednesday! 1 to 3 pm and t'other 5 to 7 pm
george ;)
-
As I wait for my C/F Hohner to arrive, it occurs to me that one of the singers in our group just loves to sing The Blues.
So, speaking of genres, how well do you reckon my Melodeon would sit in that genre?
Would the fact that you can't actually BEND notes be the biggest drawback?
Cheers
Ptarmigan
-
Would the fact that you can't actually BEND notes be the biggest drawback?
Cheers
Ptarmigan
[/quote]
you can on a single voice box
george
-
Bending notes -
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=488.msg3714#msg3714
Brian Peters makes an excellent job of blues on melodeon.
-
Blues is easy on any diatonic box. On a C/F instrument play mostly pull notes based around a pentatonic scale in G or E minor.
Strangely enough it sounds best if you avoid the notes C and F!
At Sidmouth, I was teaching Mally how to do it, now he's gone blues and zydeco mad - expect a book from him in the near future! ;)
-
Thanks for that info guys.
I had heard that it was easy to bend notes on the draw, on a Harmonica, but didn't think that could be done on a Melodeon.
However, I am delighted to be proved wrong.
Yes, I really do enjoy learning something new, every day. :D
Cheers
Ptarmi
-
Jazz, definitely jazz. But then again any instrument is inappropriate for Jazz.
Did I mention Jazz? It's got to be jazz.
But then again it's got to be jazz.
-
Japanese Kabuki accompaniment.
I just don't see it working...
But then I saw this:
http://www.amazon.com/This-Iz-Japanese-Kabuki-Rock/dp/B0012PGN94
And my head hurt...
-
any instrument is inappropriate for Jazz.
:-[ What about piano, bass, drums, brass, and woodwinds? These do pretty stinking well.
But yes...please no folk instruments for jazz...PLEASE. :P
-
Lee Scratch Perry (Jamaican reggae artist and producer) once said:
"The bass is the brain, the drums are the heartbeat. Everything else is a distraction"
I always take solace in that quote when assaulted by twenty melodeons thrashing Princess Royal at quadruple tempo.
.................. and what's wrong with jazz on folk instruments? The banjo has been at it for yonks.
Try melodeonist Luke Daniels for starters. Also, Tony Hall plays a few Humphrey Littleton tunes. Cool. 8)
Now, folk on jazz instruments gets up my nose (Brass Monkey are the exception). Bloody sax players on the folk scene sound like they'd be better off with a kazoo!!!! Rant, rant, etc. >:(
-
.................. and what's wrong with jazz on folk instruments? The banjo has been at it for yonks.
Only dixie-style and ragtime...please (but, I would call that jass, anyway..)
-
Haha I'm with Rees there!
There are a few good players that can do Jazz on the box. As for other instruments - Jazz fiddle?...that Stéphane Grappelli was pretty good! ;)
But yes the other way around is horrible... folk sax ?! horrid.
-
But the violin is an orchestral instrument--and therefore a traditional jazz instrument! (kind of). No, no, no!!!...no "jazz" on folk instruments I tell you!
-
But yes the other way around is horrible... folk sax ?! horrid.
Folk sax and clarinet can be pretty damned good, especially in a session. We had a young girl have a go at morris on a sax. It sounded good, but she couldn't handle playing in G and D on an Eb instrument. Brain damage :(
-
C melody sax is a nice way round that problem.
-
Yuk! ;)
-
Frank Trumbauer still sounds good to me!
-
Sorry ,didn't mean to slag off the C melody, Frank is indeed the man.
It's just that I become catatonic when I hear one in a ceilidh band or morris side.
Still, takes all sorts. ;)
-
.................. and what's wrong with jazz on folk instruments? The banjo has been at it for yonks.
Bloody sax players on the folk scene sound like they'd be better off with a kazoo!!!! Rant, rant, etc. >:(
Just three things before I kill you in a very painful way Rees, >:(
1) The banjo was originally used in jazz only because the guitar was lost in the early acoustic recordings so the 'jo was substituted, initially for recording only.
2) You are the same guy who offered me a couple of tunes with my tenor at the Mayor's Thames Festival gig aren't you? I now have to re-file Cajun and Zydeco from my 'Folk/French/Afro American' category into 'Jazz', very difficult at my time of life.
3) Please refrain from using archival slang terms like 'yonks'. It makes me feel young again and not, as I prefer, a crotchety old git.
Old Bill.
-
Now then our Bill, just before you exterminate me, please allow me a few last words, a cigarette and a plane ticket to Bolivia.
1. We have a local farmer who is a great jazz guitarist but prefers to play his six string banjo in loud sessions.
2. I'm a big fan of the sax in Zydeco which is essentially black rhythm and blues played on accordion. Clifton Chenier regularly used a sax player in his Zydeco band as does Buckwheat Zydeco and occasionally Joe le Taxi.
Cajun music no, that's redneck territory.
3. Wakey, Wakey, the six-five special coming down the line. I asked the witch doctor, oo ee oo ah ah, if you miss this one you'll never get another one, beedy beedy bom bom and other items from my gander-bag. 8)
-
Now "C" Soprano would be really good - but I don't think I've ever seen one round the patch. Bb Soprano does not give too many problems anyway.
-
Twice in one day. You really are trying to bring on the heart attack, aren't you Rees?>:(
1) Amongst us pickers or semi-picker pedants, the banjo is the five string instrument with the third string normally tuned to G as a starting point. All other forms need an adjectival prefix, e,g, long arm, zither, ukele or in your quoted example, guitar banjo.
2) Harry Simoneaux is surely Cajun rather than Zydeco. As a further thought most of the good Cajun artists are dead, not that I'm dropping any hints Rees. ;) Over tight collars and embarrassment leads to red necks.
3) Living in Croydon is like living in the past, we have six Archbishops of Canterbury snuggled up in the Parish Churchyard, a local shop that has some Quad HiFi in stock and the Whitgift Almshouses. You could provide an improved image for us Brythonic Celts by adopting a more modern speech form.
4) Still maintain that the Special Hell for Musos would be a compulsory Ring Cycle with an all melodeon orchestra.
Falseknight, presumably still on the road,
Young Adolphe did design two ranges of saxophone, the Bb/Eb range originally for Military Band use and the C/F for Orchestral use.
Please, and this is an appeal to everyone, do not post the obvious reference to saxophones, recorders or indeed some melodeons. ;)
Old, grumpy, pedantic Bill.
-
The perfect instrument for jazz is, obviously, the acoustic air guitar followed by air banjo and air drums preferably played somewhere north of Spitzbergen.
-
OK, it's confession time. I PLAY THE BANJO TOO!!!
5 string G tuning.
I call it my "download banjo" because in the old days when I was tied to a dial-up connection I used to play it a lot. It sat by the computer and I strummed happily away waiting for things to happen on screen. Now in these these broadband times it hardly ever comes out of the case. Shame really.
I've been trying to get the hang of frailing for years. Bayou Seco stayed here and gave me a four day frailing lesson - all I got was bleeding fingers.
I did once have a lesson from Martin Carthy who demonstrated the style, bum, titty, etc. He told me to do that for ten days and I'd have it.
Later, Karen Cater saw that I was still struggling and gave me the same lesson. She told me to practice for 3 days and I'd have it. I told her that Martin had said it would be ten days. She said it takes Martin Carthy ten days to tune a banjo! ;D
-
I just remembered where I used to play my guitar all the time, and that was also whilst waiting for websites to load. Those little moments have now been lost....
-
Harry Simoneaux is a Cajun person who plays Swamp Pop music not Cajun music.
I am a Welsh pedant (don't say peasant) who plays Zydeco music not Cajun music. :P
Bring back dial-up, then I could spend even longer on this forum.
-
Bring back dial-up, then I could spend even longer on this forum.
You're welcome to my 'broadband'...loads of time to play waiting for anything to load :D
-
The perfect instrument for jazz is, obviously, the acoustic air guitar followed by air banjo and air drums preferably played somewhere north of Spitzbergen.
Darren,
I've often heard that used by people unable to improvise. ???
Just remember it has been a part of music since time immemorial. The concertos always had a bit at the end for improvs and the continuo was the prequel to the chord sequence given to pianist, guitarist and bassists, who, in time honoured fashion, are left to get on with it.
Old Bill.
-
I call it my "download banjo" because in the old days when I was tied to a dial-up connection I used to play it a lot. It sat by the computer and I strummed happily away waiting for things to happen on screen. Now in these these broadband times it hardly ever comes out of the case. Shame really.
The dial up delay gave me the time to learn to play the melodeon! On really slow days I could play 2xA & 2xB at beginners speed before the requested page had loaded.
The banjo is top of my list as my next instrument to learn - how pleased the neighbours are that I now have broadband!
Claire
P.S. I have just "spell checked" this and it offered meltdown to replace melodeon!!!
-
Surely it's time for the Top-Level Music Lovers/Noise Abatement Coalition to do for the banjo what they did for the melodeon twenty years ago, i.e. use state-of-the-art viral-marketing brain-washing techniques to convince players that they've worked so hard with their old loud Hohners, and are obviously so innately musical that that they owe it to themselves to hand over the cost of a reasonable second-hand car for a hand-made Italian instrument that just happens to be three orders-of-magnitude quieter. It worked brilliantly on melodeon players for a long time, and the rest of the world really appreciated the (relative) peace and quiet even if it is just starting to wear off. But will banjo players be as gullible? Only time will tell...
-
Regrettably not.
Banjo players (my main problem is tenor players who think all Irish tunes in D are actually in A) have spent, since time immoral, unfeasible amounts of money on loud wrecks, or even more money on custom built instruments which emulate 60 year old wrecks.
If you've ever played in a session led by tenor banjo players in their chosen keys - you would declare themnon-traditional and cast them to outer darkness.
The violinist I play with most in dance bands (she objects to fiddler) will not use melodeon players. I have stand up battles trying to get some urgency or drive out of her chosen PA players - you know the conversation -we've got a bass player and a drummer - you don't need 120 bass, 10 couplers and a stand!
If I got chance,I'd like to set up the session from hell - all the 4 stop singles, the tenor banjos and the big PAs and let them work together - 5 of each ;D
-
...since time immoral
The whole of banjo playing AND accordian playing can be perceived as immoral! :P
-
I agree with George Garside and Theo.
Of course it can be done and with excellence. However, it is more than just a collection of notes and has as much to do with expression, passion and a feeling for what is trying to be conveyed.
One example that springs to mind is Tony MacMahon playing "AISLING GHEAL" and PORT na bPUCAI on the "I gCnoc na Grai" album (Gael Linn CEFCD 114). Both these slow airs are played with MacMahon's usual ability to play from within himself. Watching him play shows the passion of his musical expression that he is trying to convey (successfully I might add) through the medium of his soul, his fingers and his faithful old Hohner.
I know of several technically brilliant musicians but irrespective of the instruments they are playing, a slow air played without feeling does nothing for me personally.
This of course is not restricted to the playing of slow airs. I remember a classically trained violinist (with a good reputation within his own particular classical cohort) who came to Whitby folk week back I think in about 1996 who sat in on several Irish sessions armed with his fiddle and several tunebooks including small portable music stand who brought the music to a standstill on several occasons. Not because he was a "cut above" but because he was missing the whole point. Granted, his playing from the dots could not be faulted. Note perfect, spot on timing et ceter et cetera. However, in terms of musicality there just wasn't any. Period.
The last I heard of him was that he was "shown the door" in several sessions at Otley festival the following year. By all accounts he could not understand what he was doing wrong. All it required was a quiet word or two. "Play from the soul; not the paper".
Mike.
-
Would the fact that you can't actually BEND notes be the biggest drawback? you should hear me bend notes as a begginer i oftem bend the wrong note into the right one, ken
Cheers
Ptarmigan
you can on a single voice box
george
[/quote]
-
I remember seeing one Mr Kennedy playing with Croke a few years back. On the one hand, he made the stuff that good folk fiddlers pull off as incredible barnstorming look easy. On the other hand, he had absolutely no soul whatsoever. And this is a man who is known in the classical community for taking liberties with the timing.
On the other hand, I've suffered through an awful lot of pedestrian, mid paced versions of English folk songs being dragged through the mire by people who can be seen to hesitate for a moment before each change of chord/position. That doesn't do a lot for me either! I think the melodeon has a great sound, and I'd be very interested to hear it in certain forms of Jazz. I'm having trouble imagining Thelonius Monk lines on a diatonic instrument, but hey, that's a challenge, right?
-
OLD THREAD WARNING
any ideas?
I was wondering if its sacrilage to want to play pop, ska or heavy metal on a melodeon....I rather fancy having a try at some 'madness' and 'mettalica' tunes.
-
I was wondering if its sacrilage to want to play pop, ska or heavy metal on a melodeon....I rather fancy having a try at some 'madness' and 'mettalica' tunes.
I destroyed Nirvana's 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' for my teenage kids by playing it on the Ukulele ;D Funny how they went off Nirvana after that ???
AL
Anyway, I'm off to play Hawkwind's 'Silver Machine' on my D/G - really could do with a Streb in order to get some real AMPLIFICATION< REVERB<DISTORTION etc.,
-
I was wondering if its sacrilage to want to play pop, ska or heavy metal on a melodeon....I rather fancy having a try at some 'madness' and 'mettalica' tunes.
I destroyed Nirvana's 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' for my teenage kids by playing it on the Ukulele ;D Funny how they went off Nirvana after that ???
Nirvana are one of my fave bands....is there a vid of this rendition of yours on youtube at all? ;)
-
Nirvana are one of my fave bands....is there a vid of this rendition of yours on youtube at all?
Frayed knot :D and you genuinely wouldn't have liked it!
AL
-
Nirvana are one of my fave bands....is there a vid of this rendition of yours on youtube at all?
Frayed knot :D and you genuinely wouldn't have liked it!
AL
you should hear me murder 'come as you are' on guitar. :o
-
If this can be done on a one row nothing is inappropriate or impossible.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvxVvVSpbrw&feature=related
Who can recognise the most tunes in this medley
or how about this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YLwvUWw8qw&feature=related
Envious Martin
Wow! Absolutely enchanting.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvxVvVSpbrw&feature=related
Very lovely - Marcel Messervier gives an excellent demonstration of 'melodeon eyes' - particularly through the slower, lyrical passages.
-
I destroyed Nirvana's 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' for my teenage kids by playing it on the Ukulele ;D Funny how they went off Nirvana after that ???
AL
Heh, I taught myself James Hill's arrangement of Ave Maria on my uke a few years back. That part of it that I coudl handle at any rate.
The only real drawback to the melodeon is the lack of chromatics. I feel sure that classical, rock, blues and all sorts could be played successfully on it, as long as the notes were there.
-
Marcel Messervier gives an excellent demonstration of 'melodeon eyes' - particularly through the slower, lyrical passages.
Actually, that's Raynald - Marcel is the one with the full head of hair.
-
I was wondering if its sacrilage to want to play pop, ska or heavy metal on a melodeon....I rather fancy having a try at some 'madness' and 'mettalica' tunes.
I destroyed Nirvana's 'Smells Like Teen Spirit' for my teenage kids by playing it on the Ukulele ;D Funny how they went off Nirvana after that ???
Nirvana are one of my fave bands....is there a vid of this rendition of yours on youtube at all? ;)
Glorystrokes, not unknown to several posters here, have been known to playSmells like TeenSpirit coupled withShepherds' Hey They call it Smells Like Shepherd's Pie. Way to go chaps!!
Baz
-
For many years, one of my favourite bands has been the Cardiacs, a somewhat eccentric 'pop group' that tend to baffle many but have a hard core of very loyal fans. If you've not seen or heard of them before, have a look at this old, but still startling, introduction >:E
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlfWoWHHRNA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlfWoWHHRNA)
Anyhow, over the years, they've released a fair number of albums, either under their own name or as side projects. So, here's my version of one of their more obscure tracks, from an album simply titled Mr And Mrs Smith And Mr Drake. The original track was called To My Piano From Mr Drake, but I couldn't really call it that on my video, could I?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vnBPZ2fEq8 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6vnBPZ2fEq8)
There's actually some more of it too, but I think that might have been a bit much for the video (i.e. neatly getting around the fact that I'm still struggling to arrange some of it...).
Anyhow, regardless of the unusual source, I still think it's a fun tune to play.
-
One Word "Opera"
-
I still think that Morris is a most inappropriate thing for the melodeon. Given the amount of wet weather we get over here no melodeon should ever be made to undertake outdoor pursuits. Trying to convince folk to let me play my cornet for Morris though is very difficult - TA RA!
AL
-
I may be about to experience the ultimate melodeon challenge. I've been invited to a boogey woogey session. No idea what they will play. Any thoughts on suitable material. I like Winifred Atwell but that's probably rag time. I don't hold great expectations for the sucess of this project, tips or suggestions welcome.
-
My Grandfather used to play from time to time with a boogie woogie group on his concertina. I can't imagine playing it on melodeon though, the flattened fourths would be tricky. Assuming that they use blues scales in boogie woogie, I don't know much about the genre.
-
Mr. Spiers demonstrated a good boogie beat using only the bass end at a workshop at The House three years back.
-
'For many years, one of my favourite bands has been the Cardiacs, a somewhat eccentric 'pop group' that tend to baffle many but have a hard core of very loyal fans. If you've not seen or heard of them before, have a look at this old, but still startling, introduction'
'Somewhat eccentric' might be something of an understatement GbH, but definitely interesting!
-
'Somewhat eccentric' might be something of an understatement GbH, but definitely interesting!
Well, I guess it's all relative!
(p.s. if you liked the first one, see how many different time signatures you can spot here - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pp3m4a8eFJY&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pp3m4a8eFJY&feature=related))
-
1940 Concertina Solo - Mozart's (Gloria in Excelsis)
played by Adjutant Bramwell Thornett on the concertina back in 1940 (The Salvation Army)
It's brilliant and somehow wrong at one and the same time!
AL
http://www.regalzonophone.com/audio/MF292%20-%20Concertina%20Solo%20-%20GLORY%20TO%20GOD%20IN%20THE%20HIGHEST.mp3 (http://www.regalzonophone.com/audio/MF292%20-%20Concertina%20Solo%20-%20GLORY%20TO%20GOD%20IN%20THE%20HIGHEST.mp3)
-
1940 Concertina Solo - Mozart's (Gloria in Excelsis)
played by Adjutant Bramwell Thornett on the concertina back in 1940 (The Salvation Army)
It's brilliant and somehow wrong at one and the same time!
AL
http://www.regalzonophone.com/audio/MF292%20-%20Concertina%20Solo%20-%20GLORY%20TO%20GOD%20IN%20THE%20HIGHEST.mp3 (http://www.regalzonophone.com/audio/MF292%20-%20Concertina%20Solo%20-%20GLORY%20TO%20GOD%20IN%20THE%20HIGHEST.mp3)
We sang that in my school choir I recall :D Played extremely well, but I know what you mean ;)
-
Great playing. The bit where it goes from chords 1 - 4 -1 -5 three times, sounds very like some Zulu Township Jive recordings that I have.
-
Great playing. The bit where it goes from chords 1 - 4 -1 -5 three times, sounds very like some Zulu Township Jive recordings that I have.
Isn't the missionary/Army link where the squashboxes are supposed to have entered the Zulu tradition (mind,Michael Caine didn't have to fight any at Rourke'sDrift (:) )
-
Great playing. The bit where it goes from chords 1 - 4 -1 -5 three times, sounds very like some Zulu Township Jive recordings that I have.
Isn't the missionary/Army link where the squashboxes are supposed to have entered the Zulu tradition (mind,Michael Caine didn't have to fight any at Rourke'sDrift (:) )
Exackerley! :||:
-
I'm not so sure about my beloved Salvation Army introducing 'Jive' anywhere :D
But yes, I'm a concertina playing SA officer and married to a South African officer and can confirm the truth to the story to the best of my knowledge - hence my YouTube name of mrsquashbox
AL
-
Great playing. The bit where it goes from chords 1 - 4 -1 -5 three times, sounds very like some Zulu Township Jive recordings that I have.
Isn't the missionary/Army link where the squashboxes are supposed to have entered the Zulu tradition (mind,Michael Caine didn't have to fight any at Rourke'sDrift (:) )
Not many people know that!
-
Hi LeFonque - from what I've been told it seems that the Army missionary officers who travelled around Africa took their concertinas with them and hence the development. My Father in law was just such a man and still plays now. However, I should point out that the Anglo-Zulu war took place in 1879, and since the Salvation Army was still only in its infancy at that time (having been founded just 11 years earlier) its highly unlikely that Michael Cane et al would have faced brave fiercesome Zulu warriors descending on Rorke's Drift armed with Wheatstone & Lachenal concertinas! Melodeon's? Possibly...
;D
AL
-
What fascinates me about the Zulu-Concertina connection is not just that the instruments showed up, but that they then turned out to be so well suited to an existing musical need. From what I understand, the concertina of choice for the Zulus was a cheap mass-produced instrument that could fairly easily be modified into a more suitable tuning (whatever that might be). And that it could be played while walking, so that a miner traveling a few hundred kilometers home could sing as he went, to pass the time. This kind of squeeze-box serendipity seems to be pretty common: A random Bandoneon in a Buenos Aires pawnshop, a German one-row in New Orleans . . . And then there's I. K. Dairo's Hohner 4-stop . . . Another gift of missionaries, I believe.
-
What fascinates me about the Zulu-Concertina connection is not just that the instruments showed up, but that they then turned out to be so well suited to an existing musical need. From what I understand, the concertina of choice for the Zulus was a cheap mass-produced instrument that could fairly easily be modified into a more suitable tuning (whatever that might be). And that it could be played while walking, so that a miner traveling a few hundred kilometers home could sing as he went, to pass the time. This kind of squeeze-box serendipity seems to be pretty common: A random Bandoneon in a Buenos Aires pawnshop, a German one-row in New Orleans . . . And then there's I. K. Dairo's Hohner 4-stop . . . Another gift of missionaries, I believe.
Interestingly I shall be putting up for sale shortly (in order to further another musical project) a metal-ended Wheatstone 48 key English Concertina that was specifically produced for a Salvation Army Officer who took it overseas. With its original Wheatstone wrist straps (I've put on new thumbstraps) it really looks the business. It's brass-reeded - but these are top period (1930/1)Wheatstone reeds and plays great with plenty of bite - helped also by the 8 fold (!) set of bellows on it. I don't know what part of the tropics it was sent out to but thank God it came back to UK in great condition. I've simply retuned it to concert pitch, replaced all pads & valves + put said 8 fold set of all black leather bellows on it. So if anyone's looking for a SA Missionary concertina with a possible Zulu connection (although it could just as easily have gone out to the far East) in the near future pm me... (:) I do still play it quite regularly in my ministry, and will be loath to see it go but have recently been blessed with a steel reeded instrument.
AL
-
Inspired by some of the earlier comments on this thread, I've had a go at arranging and playing Phantom Of The Opera. No, not the LLoyd-Webber composition, but a British heavy metal classic of the same name. Well, it's either that or a soundtrack to an old energy drink commercial.
I suspect a few people - heavy metal fans and 'traditional' melodeon players alike - might get a bit upset with this one!
<< Video removed, pending possible re-shoot. Mistakes were bugging me. Sorry. >>
-
Inspired by some of the earlier comments on this thread, I've had a go at arranging and playing Phantom Of The Opera. No, not the LLoyd-Webber composition, but a British heavy metal classic of the same name. Well, it's either that or a soundtrack to an old energy drink commercial.
I suspect a few people - heavy metal fans and 'traditional' melodeon players alike - might get a bit upset with this one!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ItJVguttJA (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ItJVguttJA)
is that what you really look like? Never knew you were a victorian cyberman. ;)
Will you be playing 'Run to the hills' next...I like that song.
-
is that what you really look like? Never knew you were a victorian cyberman. ;)
Will you be playing 'Run to the hills' next...I like that song.
Well, I suspect that one ropey Iron Maiden cover is more than enough for any box player's repertoire. Yes, even victorian cybermen have their limits.
Maybe you could start working on Run To The Hills yourself?
-
is that what you really look like? Never knew you were a victorian cyberman. ;)
Will you be playing 'Run to the hills' next...I like that song.
Well, I suspect that one ropey Iron Maiden cover is more than enough for any box player's repertoire. Yes, even victorian cybermen have their limits.
Maybe you could start working on Run To The Hills yourself?
I can't even get 'in and out the dusty bluebells' right...I doubt Run to the Hills is within my talents.
-
I can't even get 'in and out the susty bluebells' right...I doubt Run to the Hills is within my talents.
I guess you'll never know until you try. Go on, no-one's looking...
-
ill have to try "Run to the Hills"... ive got "Black Night" by Deep Purple in the repertoire..
i was trying out "Apache" this afternoon .. thats a bit of a challenge ;D
-
I can't even get 'in and out the dusty bluebells' right...I doubt Run to the Hills is within my talents.
Maybe, but - on the other hand - it may be more interesting than those dusty bells. :)
-
No heavy metal but a bit of Beatles
http://www.onmvoice.com/play/6136
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
-
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
Yes, I've thought the same thing before now. It's a fantastic tune. I'm not at all sure it would be easy to make that work on an unaccompanied box, though.
-
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
Yes, I've thought the same thing before now. It's a fantastic tune. I'm not at all sure it would be easy to make that work on an unaccompanied box, though.
you gave me an idea for a cartoon
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/unaccompmelod.jpg)
-
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
Either the link is wrong or you'll need at least a Streb for this orchestral piece, preferably linked to a moster, high quality synth for best effect >:E
-
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
Either the link is wrong or you'll need at least a Streb for this orchestral piece, preferably linked to a moster, high quality synth for best effect >:E
No, not the wrong link, just a slightly misleading one. Here's a video featuring the original Metallica version - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lljBSQdlvY&feature=related (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lljBSQdlvY&feature=related) or, alternatively, one where they perform it with a full orchestra http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAsA00-5KoI (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAsA00-5KoI).
-
After my previous false start, I've now had another go at recording Iron Maiden's Phantom Of The Opera. Last time around, there were too many mistakes, but worse than that, something about it didn't feel at all right. So, I dumped it. Given the genre of the original, maybe this wasn't surprising, but not to be defeated, I decided to go back to the drawing board and give it another go anyway. So, other than the intro (can't really be changing that, can I?), it's now got a very different feel, even though much of it is basically the same notes.
So, here it is - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page).
Guy
-
Very theatrical...in fact I think I prefer your version to Iron Maiden's original!
AL
-
I'd like to be able to play this though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_4515PnZmc
bit of mettalica
Yes, I've thought the same thing before now. It's a fantastic tune. I'm not at all sure it would be easy to make that work on an unaccompanied box, though.
you gave me an idea for a cartoon
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/unaccompmelod.jpg)
v cute cartoon, you are a clever girl!
-
After my previous false start, I've now had another go at recording Iron Maiden's Phantom Of The Opera. Last time around, there were too many mistakes, but worse than that, something about it didn't feel at all right. So, I dumped it. Given the genre of the original, maybe this wasn't surprising, but not to be defeated, I decided to go back to the drawing board and give it another go anyway. So, other than the intro (can't really be changing that, can I?), it's now got a very different feel, even though much of it is basically the same notes.
So, here it is - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page).
ooh that one sounds much better. :) Looking at your vids mine seem a little boring.....I'll have to liven them up a bit.
Hmmmm..maybe I'll dress up in my gibson girl (edwardian) outfit and play 'Lambeth Walk'or 'oh dear what can the matter be' ? ;)
you gave me an idea for a cartoon
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v28/imbored22001/unaccompmelod.jpg)
v cute cartoon, you are a clever girl!
Thank you....the cartoons are another little hobby of mine.
-
After my previous false start, I've now had another go at recording Iron Maiden's Phantom Of The Opera. Last time around, there were too many mistakes, but worse than that, something about it didn't feel at all right. So, I dumped it. Given the genre of the original, maybe this wasn't surprising, but not to be defeated, I decided to go back to the drawing board and give it another go anyway. So, other than the intro (can't really be changing that, can I?), it's now got a very different feel, even though much of it is basically the same notes.
So, here it is - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8dXd-eWmyzk&feature=channel_page).
ooh that one sounds much better. :) Looking at your vids mine seem a little boring.....I'll have to liven them up a bit.
Hmmmm..maybe I'll dress up in my gibson girl (edwardian) outfit and play 'Lambeth Walk'or 'oh dear what can the matter be' ? ;)
I don't know if it's just a coincidence or not, but the videos I've done without the costumes and sillyness have been the least watched. I guess my playing isn't good enough yet to stand up on its own, without visual distractions. Anyhow, putting some extra effort into what the videos look like is quite fun to do, regardless. It's certainly worth a go, if you're in the mood for it.
-
I guess my playing isn't good enough yet to stand up on its own,
G
I hope that you'll forgive me, but the above is pants! Your theatricality is great fun - but your playing is very good - at least as good as the drama. Mind you, you're not the only person on this forum who hides behind a silly costume (http://hallelujahal.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/leaning-on-a-lampost2.jpg?w=303&h=394)...
AL ;D
-
I guess my playing isn't good enough yet to stand up on its own,
G
I hope that you'll forgive me, but the above is pants! Your theatricality is great fun - but your playing is very good - at least as good as the drama. Mind you, you're not the only person on this forum who hides behind a silly costume (http://hallelujahal.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/leaning-on-a-lampost2.jpg?w=303&h=394)...
AL ;D
Thanks for the comment, Al, but I find it hard to think like that about my playing. When putting something up on YouTube, I'm aware that I'm putting my videos alongside others by players from all over the world. I know that many such people have a great deal of melodeon experience, confidence and knowledge of their chosen genres - none of which I can lay any great claim to. I'm happy that I've improved a lot over the last year, but still don't feel I have the sort of control, discipline and assurance that I see and admire in others. Also, as was evident with the initial version of 'Phantom', I'm still learning the hard way as to what works and what doesn't.
Guy
p.s. why was I secretly a little disappointed that your link didn't bring up a picture of some morris dancers? ;D
-
why was I secretly a little disappointed that your link didn't bring up a picture of some morris dancers?
I did think about it >:E
AL
-
I guess my playing isn't good enough yet to stand up on its own,
G
I hope that you'll forgive me, but the above is pants! Your theatricality is great fun - but your playing is very good - at least as good as the drama. Mind you, you're not the only person on this forum who hides behind a silly costume (http://hallelujahal.files.wordpress.com/2009/05/leaning-on-a-lampost2.jpg?w=303&h=394)...
AL ;D
Thanks for the comment, Al, but I find it hard to think like that about my playing. When putting something up on YouTube, I'm aware that I'm putting my videos alongside others by players from all over the world. I know that many such people have a great deal of melodeon experience, confidence and knowledge of their chosen genres - none of which I can lay any great claim to. I'm happy that I've improved a lot over the last year, but still don't feel I have the sort of control, discipline and assurance that I see and admire in others. Also, as was evident with the initial version of 'Phantom', I'm still learning the hard way as to what works and what doesn't.
Guy
p.s. why was I secretly a little disappointed that your link didn't bring up a picture of some morris dancers? ;D
I tried filming myself the other day and playing it back I was struck immediately by my lack of precision and control. My playing has always been rather wild and flamboyant, I can't help but wish it was different :(
And I spent a happy half hour or so looking through your videos last week. I especially liked the juggling and the yo-yos. Fantastic stuff.
-
And I spent a happy half hour or so looking through your videos last week. I especially liked the juggling and the yo-yos. Fantastic stuff.
(:)
-
Would it be possible to play some T-rex songs?