Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: Chris Ryall on June 30, 2011, 08:46:32 AM

Title: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Chris Ryall on June 30, 2011, 08:46:32 AM
Then there is a third level where players try to make the melodeon sound modern or jazzy by going beyond the "obvious" chords and playing bass lines that typically don't fit some of the time, and then resolve. It's a bit like the weird things organists sometimes do on the last verse of a tedious Victorian hymn tune in a desperate attempt to make it sound "better than it is". It seems to consist sometimes of gratuitously replacing a chord that fits with one that doesn't just for its own sake and I have to say that mostly I don't like that style very much, though some people here rave about it. Also there are some recently composed tunes (I'm thinking especially of the late Robin Griggs of Pig Dyke Molly, because I know some of those tunes well) where conventional three-chord-trick really doesn't cut it and the oddly fitting harmonies are part of the tune. Maybe it's sour grapes because I can't do it :'(

(Bet he can)! Anyway - he's something our own Ed has on his facebook http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4wLrDQuTrY - love it or loath it! Defo more than 3 chords in use here, and I guess it does have bit of a Messiaenic edge to it ...
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: EeeJay on June 30, 2011, 04:23:23 PM
Then there is a third level where players try to make the melodeon sound modern or jazzy by going beyond the "obvious" chords and playing bass lines that typically don't fit some of the time, and then resolve. It's a bit like the weird things organists sometimes do on the last verse of a tedious Victorian hymn tune in a desperate attempt to make it sound "better than it is". It seems to consist sometimes of gratuitously replacing a chord that fits with one that doesn't just for its own sake and I have to say that mostly I don't like that style very much, though some people here rave about it. Also there are some recently composed tunes (I'm thinking especially of the late Robin Griggs of Pig Dyke Molly, because I know some of those tunes well) where conventional three-chord-trick really doesn't cut it and the oddly fitting harmonies are part of the tune. Maybe it's sour grapes because I can't do it :'(

(Bet he can)! Anyway - he's something our own Ed has on his facebook http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4wLrDQuTrY - love it or loath it! Defo more than 3 chords in use here, and I guess it does have bit of a Messiaenic edge to it ...

Ohh yes... that clip. >:E

I know it's 'marmite' music... and I love it for what it is... the whole edginess of the first two minutes, and then this kind of minimalist chord-scape... for me, there's snippets of JS Bach and Steve Reich in there...

I understand Anahata's gripe by melodeonists just randomly shunting obtuse chords in (just because they're there)... especially so in sessions, where you have rhythm/chord players already... if the general mix already sounds good, just leave the bass out, or bring it in/out for best effect. The key to good spontaneous music is light and shade, and listening where/how to pull back/hammer down...

Ed J
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Anahata on June 30, 2011, 05:46:54 PM
I understand Anahata's gripe by melodeonists just randomly shunting obtuse chords in (just because they're there)... especially so in sessions

Aaagh! that's reminded me of one such who turned up (once) at a regular session and did just that - I'd forgotten...
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Anahata on June 30, 2011, 05:50:38 PM
something our own Ed has on his facebook http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4wLrDQuTrY - love it or loath it! Defo more than 3 chords in use here, and I guess it does have bit of a Messiaenic edge to it ...

That's not quite the kind of thing I was complaining about. I quite liked that, but it's unapproachable on a two row 8 bass melodeon. And it was very well played, but to me it's accordion music and might as well be played on a CBA instead.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: EeeJay on June 30, 2011, 08:35:27 PM
I quite liked that, but it's unapproachable on a two row 8 bass melodeon.

Right enough. A lot of players in France/Italy seem to be taking the 3 row 18 bass route - principally because it offers them greater facility in moving between parallel major/minor keys. Where bagpipes are usually a key part of the tradition, this is sort of useful. Then... you get the players who like to strrrretch the system to it's limits...

And it was very well played, but to me it's accordion music and might as well be played on a CBA instead.

Probably so... but the diatonic based system still gives such an inherent drive/pulse that a chromatic machine intuitively lacks. Personally, I like this new sub-species of extended box. A lot of what's done on them (by people like Milleret, Pignol, LeTron, etc.) I would term as PostTrad music... very thematic, extended and pretty cerebral. Certain bits of it I don't 'get' (or like particularly, to be honest), but the bits I do like tend to make one rethink a lot of what the instrument is capable of...

Ed J
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 01, 2011, 07:50:30 AM
Like that concept of "post trad" - seems to sum this genre up rather well. Also takes me back to 'traditional' v 'revivalist' bickering in the late 60's. I was still in short trousers so missed the better invective but it was said you'd get chucked out for playing anything self penned in Ewan McColl's club (interesting in view of his own output, but never mind)!

Back to topic ... when I started I noticed melodeon players putting in the odd C chord in Em key Irish music. Always sounded wrong to me, and I've since learned the correct 'dorian' chord needs to be something with C#.  But frankly it's become almost mainstream over the last 20 years. Is this what Anahata means. Or is it an example of diatos in Irish sessions 'changing the tradition'.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: sandwich on July 01, 2011, 02:47:49 PM

it's unapproachable on a two row 8 bass melodeon

maybe a 2 and a half row could do the trick
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 01, 2011, 03:09:38 PM
For fancy stuff or a blues feel you need a box with the 'non-main-scale-notes', so called  "accidentals" in ideally 2 octaves and importantly a D/E reversed button (if its a D/G) ... well, that more or less describes yer standard 2row+5.  

Commonly a 3 row system then just extends this up the octaves.  A B/C/C# will have its own chord shapes on which other must advise.  A CBA system is of course 'no problem'.

But actually to do effective full chording in 'D' or 'G' all you need is a D/E reversal.  Agree - full chords don't suit many folk tunes, but even on a G C D7 C 'trick' substituting in the odd minor to get harmonic flow eg  |G > Em7 | Am > Am7 | D7 - | G -  | isn't exactly alien technology?  And some tunes love it.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: mory on July 01, 2011, 05:18:15 PM



And it was very well played,



how can you tell? ;D
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Cooper on August 30, 2011, 12:47:04 PM
(Bet he can)! Anyway - he's something our own Ed has on his facebook http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4wLrDQuTrY - love it or loath it! Defo more than 3 chords in use here, and I guess it does have bit of a Messiaenic edge to it ...
MEGACOOL!

Back to topic ... when I started I noticed melodeon players putting in the odd C chord in Em key Irish music. Always sounded wrong to me, and I've since learned the correct 'dorian' chord needs to be something with C#.  But frankly it's become almost mainstream over the last 20 years. Is this what Anahata means. Or is it an example of diatos in Irish sessions 'changing the tradition'.
I actually love that low VI in dorian melodies, but i never found any theory on it (or on other modes and their accompaniment) coudl you point me to some?
I tried the normal VI in dorian melodies btw, because i thought that would make more sense when thinking about it, but i just don't like it tbh,
W
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Martin J on August 30, 2011, 06:02:36 PM
Definitely Marmite, I'm pressing the hate button, three minutes of arpeggios followed by three minutes of bellows shake.  Shame really because his manual dexterity shows he can play very well, just not my sort of music.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on August 30, 2011, 06:30:55 PM
it was said you'd get chucked out for playing anything self penned in Ewan McColl's club.

Said by whom, as "they" are talking nonsense.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Lyn on August 30, 2011, 07:56:06 PM
Nope, sorry, but scales and four-finger exercises do not a performance make. (IMHO) A mere beginner's view, and I'm probably missing the finer subtleties, but not for me.
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Cooper on August 30, 2011, 08:00:14 PM
It's always fun to see how different opinions can  be :-)
W
Title: Re: more than 3 chord 'trick'
Post by: Randal Scott on September 10, 2011, 11:45:22 PM
Wow.  Phillip Glass on melodeon.  Wonderful.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal