Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on July 06, 2011, 10:13:19 AM
-
>:( Had to go to the doctor's today. He reckons I've pulled some muscles in my left side - I'm very sore around the ribcage. He says it's more than likely the pulling of the bellows on my melodeon have caused this. Anyone else ever had this?
Such a nuisance as I'm going to have to give up for a few days!!
-
How violently were you playing?? :o
-
How violently were you playing?? :o
Well, the piece I'm working on has got a lot of fast push/pulls. I've only got an Erica. Do more expensive melodeons have an easier bellows action?
-
How violently were you playing?? :o
Well, the piece I'm working on has got a lot of fast push/pulls. I've only got an Erica. Do more expensive melodeons have an easier bellows action?
Well having tried to play same tune on pokerwork then my castagnari I'd say there was a difference...but then I'm a weakling. ;)
I know I can play faster tunes on the tommy than I can on for example my one row....the one row makes my arms ache after one tune.
-
At last - an excuse to splash out on that Saltarelle Pastourelle 3 that I've been promising myself!! ;) ;) ;)
-
At last - an excuse to splash out on that Saltarelle Pastourelle 3 that I've been promising myself!! ;) ;) ;)
Also new boxes I find stiffer to play than older ones...I think its called playing it in. But I'm no expert.
-
At last - an excuse to splash out on that Saltarelle Pastourelle 3 that I've been promising myself!! ;) ;) ;)
Possibly, Les - but 'fraid last time I played an Erica it had a much easier bellows action than my PIII - on the other hand the Erica was probably about 30+ years old! On a slightly less frivolous note I suspect there are some good non-playing exercises you could do to alleviate and prevent future strains. There are much more expert people than me round here who can probably advise what they are. As part of tai chi warm ups we often raise one arm above the head and stretch sideways to the other side - this might help. Buy the PIII anyway - you know you're going to succumb at some point! ;D
-
At last - an excuse to splash out on that Saltarelle Pastourelle 3 that I've been promising myself!! ;) ;) ;)
Possibly, Les - but 'fraid last time I played an Erica it had a much easier bellows action than my PIII - on the other hand the Erica was probably about 30+ years old! On a slightly less frivolous note I suspect there are some good non-playing exercises you could do to alleviate and prevent future strains. There are much more expert people than me round here who can probably advise what they are. As part of tai chi warm ups we often raise one arm above the head and stretch sideways to the other side - this might help. Buy the PIII anyway - you know you're going to succumb at some point! ;D
Tai Chi - I always wanted to try that - it looks so soothing! Steve - that was the wrong answer about the PIII - you were supposed to say that this would solve all my problems and I couldn't possibly manage without one!!!! ;) ;) ;) Please let me know if you ever see one going any cheaper than the Eagle Music price of £2,699. I guess most people, once they've got one, tend to keep them forever. Can't say I blame them. Ok - time to get the banjo out!!...... >:E
Just tried the arm over the head stretching thing - my dog is looking at me as though I've gone mad!!! ;D
-
Les,
Number 1 - take up tai chi - it's brilliant! I'm starting teaching it (despite my advancing years!) for the first time in September - you could come to my weekly class in Ambleside - possibly a bit of a long round trip for you though.
Number 2 - Put a notice in 'Buy and Sell' - some melnetters have that many boxes that they wouldn't notice having one less! Some MAD affected member might be willing to reduce their holding by letting a PIII go. Make sure it's a good one though - according to the recent Saltarelle thread it sounds as though individual ones differ a lot. Mine's about 8 years old and I've never had a problem with it apart from the LH buttons being a bit clackety but you'd probably not notice this having played Hohners!
-
Les,
Number 1 - take up tai chi - it's brilliant! I'm starting teaching it (despite my advancing years!) for the first time in September - you could come to my weekly class in Ambleside - possibly a bit of a long round trip for you though.
Number 2 - Put a notice in 'Buy and Sell' - some melnetters have that many boxes that they wouldn't notice having one less! Some MAD affected member might be willing to reduce their holding by letting a PIII go. Make sure it's a good one though - according to the recent Saltarelle thread it sounds as though individual ones differ a lot. Mine's about 8 years old and I've never had a problem with it apart from the LH buttons being a bit clackety but you'd probably not notice this having played Hohners!
Can you point me to the Saltarelle thread you mentioned?
-
Here it is, Les. It might put you off wanting a Saltarelle but I still like both of mine. On the other hand, having regretted letting my Hohner pokerwork go when I got my PIII, Mike Rowbotham is currently restoring a Hohner pressed wood for me. I'm hoping that I'll be able to stop at 3 melodeons and not succumb completely to MAD. After all, I've only got 3 electric and 2 acoustic guitars. ;D;)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4077.0.html
-
Here it is, Les. It might put you off wanting a Saltarelle but I still like both of mine. On the other hand, having regretted letting my Hohner pokerwork go when I got my PIII, Mike Rowbotham is currently restoring a Hohner pressed wood for me. I'm hoping that I'll be able to stop at 3 melodeons and not succumb completely to MAD. After all, I've only got 3 electric and 2 acoustic guitars. ;D;)
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4077.0.html
Blimey - just ploughed through the whole thread - looks like it's a bit of a lottery buying a Saltarelle. I guess if you get a good one that's great, if not - it could be a bit of a nightmare!! :-\
-
Blimey - just ploughed through the whole thread - looks like it's a bit of a lottery buying a Saltarelle. I guess if you get a good one that's great, if not - it could be a bit of a nightmare!! :-\
I think it's worth bearing in mind that some of the criticisms probably come from people who've never owned one! My Pastourelle was the first one I happened to have a go on in the Music Room and I bought my L'Elfique over the phone from Eagle. I've had a bit of a problem with a bass note on the latter but Theo sorted it out this week - it was a slightly dodgy valve which Theo reckoned could occur on any box. So having taken pot luck I've had 100% success with my 2 and I really like the 'saltarelle sound'. If they're good enough for Squeezyjohn and Anahata they've got to be good enough for me!
-
Les, have you considered the possibility that it is your technique rather than your instrument that is causing the problem?
-
I'm hoping that I'll be able to stop at 3 melodeons and not succumb completely to MAD. After all, I've only got 3 electric and 2 acoustic guitars. ;D;)
Is that all? You're not trying hard enough.... ;D
-
Les, have you considered the possibility that it is your technique rather than your instrument that is causing the problem?
Ha ha - "a bad workman shouldn't blame his tools". Yep point taken!! ;)
-
I wasn't trying to be flippant. I see a lot of what seem to me to be completely unergonomic and energy-wasting ways of waggling and flapping bellows around, especially for fast in-and-out passages. Watch how good players do it. It ought to look easy, and if it looks easy, it almost certainly is.
-
I wasn't trying to be flippant. I see a lot of what seem to me to be completely unergonomic and energy-wasting ways of waggling and flapping bellows around, especially for fast in-and-out passages. Watch how good players do it. It ought to look easy, and if it looks easy, it almost certainly is.
That's fine Steve! I'm more than happy to get advice from anyone who cares to dispense it. Let's face it - I'm a real beginner and unless I listen to what people have to say I'm not going to improve am I?. I probably have been "waggling and flapping" a bit too much and when I get better I'll look into the ergonomics of my bellows action. Thanks for your help! (:)
-
Les, I really shouldn't be encouraging you - see what I did there? A bit of co-beginner counselling? But if you REALLY REALLY need YET ANOTHER melodeon, then don't be put off Saltarelles. I may be biased, but I love my Nuage, and everyone who handles it says what a good sound it has and lovely to play.
TAi Chi will get your core strengthened which in turn will help with everything else on your skeleton, but it's probably position and technique which accounts for your aches and strains. I find my left thumb aches!
-
I know I get a 'clicky' wrist/finger when I play and its 'cold'....and sometimes my elbow aches if I play for a long time. But other than that haven't had problems since getting the tommy.
-
No "Tommy upsets" then....... :D
-
It does sound to me that the problem is not entirely the fault of the instrument. It's much more likely to be the result of you not being sufficiently relaxed, it's very easy to tense all sorts of muscles without being aware you are doing it.
I play lots of quoit quick dance tunes with plenty of places where there are lots of bellows reversals, and the only time I suffered injury was when I played a big Castagnari for a few years. I don't have any problems like that from playing my hohner for 2 or 3 hours for a dance
-
It does sound to me that the problem is not entirely the fault of the instrument. It's much more likely to be the result of you not being sufficiently relaxed, it's very easy to tense all sorts of muscles without being aware you are doing it.
I play lots of quoit quick dance tunes with plenty of places where there are lots of bellows reversals, and the only time I suffered injury was when I played a big Castagnari for a few years. I don't have any problems like that from playing my hohner for 2 or 3 hours for a dance
Thanks Theo, that makes a lot of sense!
-
I wasn't trying to be flippant. I see a lot of what seem to me to be completely unergonomic and energy-wasting ways of waggling and flapping bellows around, especially for fast in-and-out passages. Watch how good players do it. It ought to look easy, and if it looks easy, it almost certainly is.
I concur.. If somebody foresees a series of 'violent' ins and outs coming they have got it wrong. Rapid ins & outs they may be but never 'violent ' ones. If a series of notes is looming ahead that involves a succession of ins & outs gradually work the bellows in to as near closed as possible prior to the series of ins & outs & and then use wrist rather than arm movement for fine control of bellows direction eg in the run down in harvest home if played on the row on a DG box. Too great a bellows extension causes the bellows to try & waggle which wastes energy & doesnt sound right good either.
george
-
I mostly concur with George, just wish to add that I find it much easier to control this fast bellows with the bass end moving straight in and out, and not in an arc.
-
Two words: WARM UP!
Playing the melodeon can be a demanding exercise, and warming up the muscles before playing is a good idea, like doing some stretches of the pectoral and dorsal muscles, arm rotation movements, ease up the shoulders, deep breathing...
-
I will have a Connemara III for sale shortly at a very reasonable price once I have finished making my new box. But it wont fix your injury as it is heavier to play than an Erica. I play my Erica for hours on end in the band but could not do that with the Connemara (is this a good sales pitch?).
-
It does sound to me that the problem is not entirely the fault of the instrument. It's much more likely to be the result of you not being sufficiently relaxed, it's very easy to tense all sorts of muscles without being aware you are doing it.
Lots of tension when learning instrument and tunes, especially early on. I often get a neck/shoulder ache. Things have improved though with more familiarity of the basses and general playing.
cheers
Sandy
(:)
-
Blimey - just ploughed through the whole thread - looks like it's a bit of a lottery buying a Saltarelle. I guess if you get a good one that's great, if not - it could be a bit of a nightmare!! :-\
Take a look at the Serenellini 273 (http://www.jollybox.co.uk/Ser273D%20page.htm). Three voice LMM with twelve basses and you could have the third row set up as accidentals and reversals. Cheaper than Salterelle and very nicely made.
-
Blimey - just ploughed through the whole thread - looks like it's a bit of a lottery buying a Saltarelle. I guess if you get a good one that's great, if not - it could be a bit of a nightmare!! :-\
Take a look at the Serenellini 273 (http://www.jollybox.co.uk/Ser273D%20page.htm). Three voice LMM with twelve basses and you could have the third row set up as accidentals and reversals. Cheaper than Salterelle and very nicely made.
Sounds good - any audio or video of one of these that you can point me to?
Thanks
-
>:( Had to go to the doctor's today. He reckons I've pulled some muscles in my left side - I'm very sore around the ribcage. He says it's more than likely the pulling of the bellows on my melodeon have caused this. Anyone else ever had this?
Such a nuisance as I'm going to have to give up for a few days!!
Hi Les,
I know you have seen a doctor, from your entry. When I get those pains in my side, usually the left. It is actually a back problem. Those nerves can go right around and give distress where you would not consider it being a back injury.
As for the Tai-Chi or more properly Taiji. If you can find a good teacher? You will find a rejuvenation of balance and flexibility. Taiji is actually part of Tradition Chinese Medicine. The Shaolin monks, who fought using what is known as Kung Fu used Taiji as training methods. Developing the Taiji for the royal family as keep fit exercise. Originally 102 moves the standard was shortened to 24 form. This was done by communists to structure competitive sports, within Kung Fu. In the west it is thought of as, for old people and women? I am finding in my mid-sixties, that it has helped me to lose weight, lower blood pressure, etc. Plus, the big plus; my balance and flexibility, bending and twisting ability are all substantially improved. To see my teacher's videos, on Youtube, Dr Pauline Bao.
Cheers and best wishes for recovery,
Jamie
------------------------
-
Sounds good - any audio or video of one of these that you can point me to?
Not of that model I'm afraid but there are many examples of three voice, two row, eight bass Serenellinis on youtube. Oddly enough they don't seem to have a 2 1/2 row 12 bass available in Britain (if indeed they make one at all) that I can find.
It has been confirmed that my old Primo was made by Serenellini (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBStsqW3Oxk) but it's a three voice, two row, LMM eight bass so it won't compare favourably with a 2 1/2 row 12 bass in terms of what it can do but if you like the sound of the box they do seem to be quite consistant. As a new player I hope you can forgive a fellow (average) guitarist for being less than able on the melodeon!
-
Oddly enough they don't seem to have a 2 1/2 row 12 bass available in Britain (if indeed they make one at all) that I can find.
They certainly do make the 273 in a 12-11-4 configuration. I'm always going on about mine. If British dealers can't supply one, I suggest the problem lies between the chair and the keyboard or the telephone.
(As a footnote gripe, an apparently respected melodeon dealer in England went out of business a few years ago, complaining that too many people were ordering direct from the factory. About a year earlier, I ordered direct from the factory because despite repeated requests this very same dealer failed to contact Serenellini to ask about a 2½ row 273. And having contacted them, I took delivery of mine in about 6 weeks.)
I would add that the 273 is a pretty hefty box and I'm not sure I'd go recommending it to anybody complaining melodeon-related injuries. Great machine, though.