Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: risto on November 16, 2007, 10:57:01 AM
-
I just finished transcribing the first 32 measures of The Silver Spire from Sharon Shannon's set Glentown intending to play it with the B/C. This tune generally appears to be in Dmaj but Sharon playes it in Emaj. I'm guessing she plays it with C#/D box using B/C fingerings in D. Any good advise to be considered if I play it in Emaj?
Here's Sharons version if someone is interested:
X:1
T:Silver Spire
L:1/8
M:4/4
K:E
EG G/G/G EG Bd | ee ef ge BG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | AG FE DF B,D |\
EG G/G/G EG Bd | ee ef ge BG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | FB, DF E3D |\
EG G/G/G EG Bd | ed fe ge BG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | AG FE DF DF |\
FE E/E/E GE GB | ed ef ge BG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | FB, DF E2 DC |\
B,C DE FG AF | GE FG AB cd | ec c/c/=c ^cB ef| ge ag fB df |\
ef ge df Bd | ee ec BG EG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | FB, DF E2 DC |\
B,C DE FG AF | GE FG AB cd | ec c/c/=c ^cB ef| ge ag fB df |\
e/e/e be df Bd | ee ec BG EG | A/A/A cA Ge BG | FB, DF E3D |\
W:As played by Sharon Shannon
X:2
T:Silver Spire
L:1/8
M:4/4
K:D
DF F/F/F DF Ac | dd de fd AF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | GF ED CE A,C |\
DF F/F/F DF Ac | dd de fd AF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | EA, CE D3C |\
DF F/F/F DF Ac | dc ed fd AF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | GF ED CE CE |\
ED D/D/D FD FA | dc de fd AF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | EA, CE D2 CB,|\
A,B, CD EF GE | FD EF GA Bc | dB B/B/^A B=A de| fd gf eA ce |\
de fd ce Ac | dd dB AF DF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | EA, CE D2 CB,|\
A,B, CD EF GE | FD EF GA Bc | dB B/B/^A B=A de| fd gf eA ce |\
d/d/d ad ce Ac | dd dB AF DF | G/G/G BG Fd AF | EA, CE D3C |\
W:As played by Sharon Shannon but in the normal Dmaj
EDIT: Fixed the topic so that if more tunes are sent it's easier to find them if the title is first.
Ah, the right forum would have been 'Tunes' I guess...
-
The obvious piece of advice would be, get a C#/D box! Not trying to be fatuous... with four sharps, playing the tune in E on a B/C seems like an unnecessary challenge. The other piece of advice would be - practise, practise, practise.
To give yourself a break, you could try it in C on your B/C and experience the simple pleasures of C#/D style playing...
-
Just gave this a quick tryout in F# major on my C#/D - interesting!
I think the key to making this workable is intelligent use of the magic notes - which in your case are conveniently the 1st and 5th degrees of the scale, i.e. E and B.
For example I'd play the first E (in E G#/G/G) on the pull on the outer row - same direction as your G#. Then in bar 2 I'd play the first e on the push as part of a nice but unusual triangle (d#-e-f#), and then in the second half of the bar I'd play g#eB on the pull. And so on.
Is there any reason why you want to play it in E other than as a skill-developing exercise? You're not likely to meet many others who do play it in that key... Sharon Shannon excepted. Oh...
-
Just gave this a quick tryout in F# major on my C#/D - interesting!
Isnt' it! I got hooked with her version and I think it sounds much better in E than in the D lower.
Is there any reason why you want to play it in E other than as a skill-developing exercise? You're not likely to meet many others who do play it in that key... Sharon Shannon excepted. Oh...
B/C is chromatic, so some keys may be harder than the others but it should work, shouldn't it. This is a good tune to get to know the E scale. Why Sharon plays it in E is an interesting question.
-
Why Sharon plays it in E is an interesting question.
No big puzzle to my mind - either a) she learned the tune in B/C fingering or b) prefers the way it comes out in B/C fingering and she i) likes the brighter sound of the tune in E or ii) couldn't be bothered to change boxes to have it come out in the proper key.
Bit like that YouTube clip of Dermot Byrne playing Bunker Hill in B-mix - it seems an extraordinary key to choose to play the tune in, until you consider that it's B/C A-mix fingering but played on a C#/D.
Why does Joe Burke play Bonnie Kate in C, or Billy McComiskey play Humours of Tulla in C, or Josephine Marsh play The Boogie Reel in C (all on B/C boxes)? Because they sound better played on the row seems to be the obvious answer.
Why do C#/D players tend to play Sporting Nell or New-mown Meadows in E and B/C players tend to play them in D? Same fingering in each case, and it works well!
-
Why Sharon plays it in E is an interesting question.
Because they sound better played on the row seems to be the obvious answer.
Ay-ay, sir! Couldn't be the other way around.