Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: davidd on July 13, 2011, 02:32:24 AM
-
HI, I was wondering why there doesn't seem to be the equivalent of the Noel HIll concertina camp for the accordion. It seems to me that there would be more than enough payers and would-be players to fill the occasional school. It seems to be particularly hard to find a school, music week or the like for the less experienced player (which includes me). Perhaps there is a teacher who would like to follow Noel Hill's example even as far as using the same venues which appear to fit the bill quite nicely! Any takers?
David
-
While I know of nothing resembling the format of Noel Hill's camps, in the US you have a few summer schools for Irish music which provide a fairly intense week of instruction for B/C box players (which in an earlier post you say you are learning). There's one happening this very week, indeed, in East Durham NY, giving you the choice of lessons with Colm Gannon, Billy McComiskey, John Nolan or Patty Furlong... http://www.catskillsirishartsweek.org/index.html
Closely followed by this one with the excellent John Whelan teaching box: http://www.augustaheritage.com/irish.html
It would be nice to have something for the box as intense and methodical as Noel Hill's camps seem to be, but I think I'd go mad without other instruments around for relief. :-)
-
HI, I was wondering why there doesn't seem to be the equivalent of the Noel HIll concertina camp for the accordion. It seems to me that there would be more than enough payers and would-be players to fill the occasional school. It seems to be particularly hard to find a school, music week or the like for the less experienced player (which includes me). Perhaps there is a teacher who would like to follow Noel Hill's example even as far as using the same venues which appear to fit the bill quite nicely! Any takers?
David
As far as I know, there are no week-long courses specifically aimed at English melodeon players, but there are various weekend events. Probably the most well-known and well-attended is Melodeons at Witney which is held at the Henry Box School in mid-November every year. Many members of this forum have been in the past and some are regular attenders; it's a lovely social gathering as well as a great learning experience, and caters for all levels of players from near-absolute beginners to advanced players alike.
This year, MAW is on Saturday 12th and Sunday 13th November, but many people also congregate for a session on the Friday evening too. Highly recommended!
The [Instrument of your choice] at Witney weekends are run by Hands on Music, organised by ace English concertina player Dave Townsend.
Website is here (http://www.whitecottagewebsites.co.uk/homweekends/) but the Melodeons at Witney (http://www.whitecottagewebsites.co.uk/homweekends/melodeons.htm) part has not been fully updated yet. Keep looking for updates; alternatively, this forum will probably erupt with activity as soon as the booking opens (usually late July/early August).
-
Being somewhere round basic beginner standard on a good day, I found my first Melodeons at Witney last year to be rather hard work. Several months later, stuff from it is still dropping into place. I'll go again, and perhaps do some pure basic rather than the basic/intermediate that I got through booking late.
The idea of a week solid would be pretty daunting unless very well matched to the ability of the student at the outset and very well paced. A couple of days of being below standard but learning a bit is tolerable - a week might be frustrating.
I'm told that it's quite difficult to pitch the level of these events because nearly everybody, whatever their level, calls themself "intermediate".
In terms of learning theory, how does doing a bit and then going away to practice compare with a crash course?
-
Melodeons at Witney sounds quite good, although the travel to England from the USA would be difficult to afford these days. The various Irish music weeks are more of what I am looking for, but most of them seem to be aimed at the intermediate player, which is more than I would be willing to call myself.
Oh well, with a lot of hard work and practice there is always next year!
David
-
There is usually a (French Canadian) box teacher at the Northern Week at Ashokan.
-
In terms of learning theory, how does doing a bit and then going away to practice compare with a crash course?
Both methods have benefits for would be players with differing temperements. The doing a bit & then practising works very well for those who have the tenacity to stick with it through the early stages even though progress is inevitably slow for most people. Without such tenacity it is easy to lose interest & the box finishes up on top of the wadrobe! This method works particularly well along with regular lessons which help to maintain motivation.
On the other hand the 'crash course for beginners' method ( which I will as usual be doing at Whitby Folk Week this year) has the advantage that in a very short time ( 4 workshoips at Whitby) most newcomers to the box will be familier with & able to opperate the 'controls ' reasonably but not necessarily well! and will be able to manage ( with varying finesse! ) 3 or four simple tunes. They then go away hopefully with enthusiasm fired up sufficiently to get stuck into the lifelong diatonic learning curve without the benefit of regular tuition.
george
-
There is usually a (French Canadian) box teacher at the Northern Week at Ashokan.
Yes, but he plays his accordion left handed and upside down. :o
There is also usually a teacher of diatonic accordion in the french style at Lark Camp on the west coast.