Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Keithypete. on July 13, 2011, 10:54:00 PM

Title: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Keithypete. on July 13, 2011, 10:54:00 PM
 I've just noticed this model on the Castagnari website. It looks a bit special, really special!!! The bass buttons look like they are arranged stradella style. Does any one know if this is the case? Anyone tried one?

LINK: http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=58 (http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=58)
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: EeeJay on July 13, 2011, 11:04:20 PM
Seems to take a lot of features from Bertrand Gaillard's Saphir model (http://www.gaillardaccordions.com/accordeon-saphir.html) (18 bass version)... flat keyboard... switchable 2v R/H... raked bass keys...

Ed J
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 14, 2011, 02:36:29 AM
I've just noticed this model on the Castagnari website. It looks a bit special, really special!!! The bass buttons look like they are arranged stradella style. Does any one know if this is the case? Anyone tried one?

LINK: http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=58 (http://www.castagnari.com/index.php?strparam=&language=uk&sz=301&id=58)

I'm trying to figure out why it has 2 switches on the bass side --- maybe one switches the low bass on, the other switches it off? Surely this could be accomplished with a single switch?
The treble side apparently has a lever -- making LM configuration a possibility.
This is also the first time I've seen the Castagnari "flat" 3-row keyboard -- looks great!
I like it! Except I don't think that Wenge would be my choice of wood for a three-row.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 14, 2011, 07:26:36 AM
I'm trying to figure out why it has 2 switches on the bass side --- maybe one switches the low bass on, the other switches it off? Surely this could be accomplished with a single switch?
The switches will either control the low bass reeds, or the thirds in the chords, or both. If they operate a rocker-type mechanism similar to that found on other larger Castagnari models, e.g the Handry and Mory, then two switches are indeed needed, one to turn on the effect, the other to turn it off. So the Handry and Mory each have four switches to control the low bass reeds and the thirds in the chords. But it is possible that the mechanism on this particular box is somewhat different, allowing a single switch to be 'on' or 'off'.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Clive Williams on July 14, 2011, 11:39:48 AM
Given the number of reeds on the left hand, I'd be prepared to guess that it's a thirds-less design, removing the need for 2 buttons from the standard mechanism, so the two buttons probably just kick the low reed in and out.

Elsewhere on the site, what do people think of the Sordina? Am I right in thinking it's glorified Castagnari cornflake packet cardboard stuck behind the grill?  :D
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 14, 2011, 12:38:45 PM
The switches will either control the low bass reeds, or the thirds in the chords, or both. If they operate a rocker-type mechanism similar to that found on other larger Castagnari models, e.g the Handry and Mory, then two switches are indeed needed, one to turn on the effect, the other to turn it off. So the Handry and Mory each have four switches to control the low bass reeds and the thirds in the chords. But it is possible that the mechanism on this particular box is somewhat different, allowing a single switch to be 'on' or 'off'.

I realized that, Steve (and that is how my Jacky works), but there is a good reason for it to work that way when there are low basses AND thirds, whereas when there are only low basses (it is a 2 voice bass so I assume there are no thirds), the same could be accomplished with one switch (click once, on, click again, off) -- if the four switch Handry/Mory/Jacky/etc worked that way, you would sometimes need to click two buttons to get the voicing that you want. With the Mas, there is only one factor that changes.  But I'm sure that there is a mechanical reason -- like a single switch would require a heavier touch -- or convenience, since the maker already has this style of switch in its inventory.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Clive Williams on July 14, 2011, 01:01:38 PM

I realized that, Steve (and that is how my Jacky works), but there is a good reason for it to work that way when there are low basses AND thirds, whereas when there are only low basses (it is a 2 voice bass so I assume there are no thirds), the same could be accomplished with one switch (click once, on, click again, off) -- if the four switch Handry/Mory/Jacky/etc worked that way, you would sometimes need to click two buttons to get the voicing that you want. With the Mas, there is only one factor that changes.  But I'm sure that there is a mechanical reason -- like a single switch would require a heavier touch -- or convenience, since the maker already has this style of switch in its inventory.

The main problem with a single on/off button of this design is that it's impossible to tell whether the current state is on or off by looking at it, and you have no way of checking without playing a chord and trying to judge whether thirds are in or out, for example. Quite hard to do on a noisy stage and distracting in any concert situation. With the current Castagnari 4 button bass switches, you can't tell what setting you're on, but you can press a button to go to a certain state - so pressing button 2 always kicks thirds in and the low reed out, regardless of what your setting was... so you don't need to play a chord to be confident thirds are on or off - just press button 2, and you're good to go.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 14, 2011, 01:22:39 PM
I realized that, Steve (and that is how my Jacky works), but there is a good reason for it to work that way when there are low basses AND thirds, whereas when there are only low basses (it is a 2 voice bass so I assume there are no thirds), the same could be accomplished with one switch (click once, on, click again, off)

Given the number of reeds on the left hand, I'd be prepared to guess that it's a thirds-less design, removing the need for 2 buttons from the standard mechanism, so the two buttons probably just kick the low reed in and out.
Ah yes - that will be it. Sorry - I missed the two reeds specification on the LH (and therefore no thirds) when I made my original reply.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: robriki on September 17, 2011, 08:52:34 PM
Just when I got my new Saltarelle Callimaque, Castagnari does the model I would have wanted from them.... :-\
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 18, 2011, 10:23:27 AM
I played one in July - Sandro was exhibiting his new baby proudly on 'stall number 1' at Chateau d'Ars festival (http://www.rencontresdeluthiers.org/en/luthiers.php).  It was labelled as a 'Modele Matris', and was in cherry.

I remember it as being nice to play - I think its bass end was in 9 lots of chords.   

No it isn't stradella - it's extra basses.  Gaillard offers  {9x2 chords}, and {fully chromatic both ways (inner row have to be single notes)} 18 bass systems, and seems to have led this innovation.  I decided to commission the latter from Frans van der Aa, but I recall the Matris/Mas was a bit cheaper.

I think it will do well.

Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Cooper on September 18, 2011, 07:29:15 PM
Had this been on the market earlier, it would have been a contender for my cuurent Gaillard. Too bad it wasnt on earlier.

On the Gaillard the 2 buttons on the left hand side are for
 
1 - Low basses in/out
2 - removing the tonica from the chord. leaving only the fifth, so you can play melodies. in theory ;-)

W
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: ceemonster on September 19, 2011, 03:25:48 AM
A propos of nothing---Tallship, the EC in your moniker photo is so gorgeous.  i guess it is a wheatstone aeola? a treble or another configuration?  it is really beautiful....
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: rees on September 19, 2011, 11:22:41 AM
I'm about to order one of these for stock.

So................... you guys decide the layout (and don't take all day about it)  >:E
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: rees on September 20, 2011, 11:48:16 AM
Still waiting (hums and drums fingers) ........... yawn.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Clive Williams on September 20, 2011, 01:06:33 PM
You'll need a bass layout. You could do something conventional and well understood like the JMC layout... or you could do this:

Code: [Select]
G#/C#  Eb/Bb    F#m/F
C/C    Bm/Bm    Em/Em
G/G    D/D      A/A

Go on. Dare you.  ;D
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: rees on September 20, 2011, 05:47:23 PM
All submissions gratefully received. Many thanks Clive.

Going back to the bass switch thing, I should describe the switch system on my GCF by Marc Serafini. Made in 2003 this accordion is very similar to the Castagnari MAS. Two voice, three row treble with 18 basses.

There are two left hand stops.
Two voice bass, low and mid. The back stop removes the low bass leaving a single voice mid.
Two voice chord, root and third. Not a fifth in sight! The front stop removes the root leaving a single voice third.

So instead of removing the thirds as per normal, this one leaves it in, on its own.
What you end up with is a weird take on the stradella counter bass system.
It certainly works and is very intuitive. Great box.

Maybe the MAS is set up like this. Who knows? - we're talking Castagnari here.  >:E
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Pete Dunk on September 20, 2011, 09:13:33 PM
A propos of nothing---Tallship, the EC in your moniker photo is so gorgeous.  i guess it is a wheatstone aeola? a treble or another configuration?  it is really beautiful....

Whoops, sorry for the slow reply! It is indeed a Wheatstone Æola, a 1927 56 key tenor/treble. The metal ends were sent to a chap in Sheffield who buffed them up and then lacquered them which is why it look so shiny and new! Here pictured with my 1916 model 21 and a Jack baritone.

(http://i279.photobucket.com/albums/kk137/p_m_dunk/General/ThreeTinas.jpg)
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 21, 2011, 11:44:52 AM
You'll need a bass layout. You could do something conventional and well understood like the JMC layout... or you could do this:

Code: [Select]
G#/C#  Eb/Bb    F#m/F
C/C    Bm/Bm    Em/Em
G/G    D/D      A/A

Go on. Dare you.  ;D

Nice idea, Clive. I can see the logic behind it and I am very tempted by it, but I would alter the inside row. On the right hand of my boxes, my G#s are all on the pull, my Bbs are on the push and my Fs are on the pull (I also have a C# reversal), so my inside row of basses would read C#/G#  Bb/F  Eb/F#m.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Clive Williams on September 21, 2011, 12:07:13 PM
You'll need a bass layout. You could do something conventional and well understood like the JMC layout... or you could do this:

Code: [Select]
G#/C#  Eb/Bb    F#m/F
C/C    Bm/Bm    Em/Em
G/G    D/D      A/A

Go on. Dare you.  ;D

Nice idea, Clive. I can see the logic behind it and I am very tempted by it, but I would alter the inside row. On the right hand of my boxes, my G#s are all on the pull, my Bbs are on the push and my Fs are on the pull (I also have a C# reversal), so my inside row of basses would read C#/G#  Bb/F  Eb/F#m.

Fair do's guvnor - you'd certainly want to wire that row to your accidental, and I have to admit I didn't put a lot of thought into what direction I'd put chords in that inner row - it's just a starter for 10. Things that coloured my thought process:

- F on pull, because like you, that's where I have my Fs too.
- F# on push, again, because that's where mine currently is. I know plenty of people currently have F#m on the pull, and there's very good reasons for that especially when playing in F# blues scales, which if I remember Chris's discussions a while back, can be played on the treble entirely on the pull. I like it on the push because when I play in D, I can use the chord sequence D->F#->G on the basses, much like I'd go G->B->C if I was playing in G.
- Eb on push to allow fit with the Eb accidental which I usually have on the push so it fits with a neutral B chord
- Try to avoid putting 'clashing' basses on the same button - for example, by F# and F chords on my Mory are on the same buttons - this is fine if you play really accurately, but you have to be really careful to get off that bass on short bellows reversals, even for a single short note, because the clash of chord really jars. Em and Bm don't clash though, so if you're playing an Em sequence, and have to do a quick push for a note, generally if you can get away with the quick burst of Bm chord if you don't get your finger off the bass button in time. So that's why I paired Eb with Bb and G# with C#. Your chords would work just as well, apart from the Eb/F which would clash, but not as badly as my F#/F combination.

As to which direction the Eb/Bb/G#/C# chords should be, I really don't know. I'd probably try to fit them in with playing in Dm and Gm, but that very much depends on your accidentals and which way they go.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 21, 2011, 12:33:46 PM
I had never previously considered an 18-bass box, but this thread has started me thinking in that direction. My last post was a response to Clive's suggested layout, but I have since decided to start with a tabula rasa and work out an 18-bass layout from scratch that would suit me. This is what I have come up with so far.

C#/G#       Gm/Am         B/Dm

  C/C          Bm/Em        Bb/F

  G/D            D/A           Eb/F#m

The outer and middle rows are what I have on my Castagnari Benny and are fairly standard. The inner row might also be fairly standard for all I know, since I have never seen an 18-bass layout for a D/G box with a row of accidentals. Any comments on the wisdom or otherwise of this layout would be appreciated.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Clive Williams on September 21, 2011, 12:43:37 PM
One quick thought the Dm/Gm/Am chords would be redundant on a MAS, since it's (probably) a 3rd's less design all chords would be modal. On a Handry 18 however, I can see why you'd want them, though personally I'd probably switch the 3rds off if I wanted to play in Dm and use those chords for something else.

There's an 18 bass D/G layout courtesy of Rees here:

http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/Evo%20note%20plan.jpg

... and I think Bernard Loffet's site also has an 18 bass layout (in G/C so you'd have to transpose it) that he recommends here:

http://diato.org/pdf/3r18b-2.pdf

Both of these layouts assume a 3rds-less bass.

Cheers,

Clive
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: squeezy on September 21, 2011, 02:10:28 PM
On my Loffet 18 bass - I added the extras around my existing 12 bass config (the same as Saltarelles normally come with)

E/C#  Bb/G#  Eb/F#
C/C    B/E      F#/F
G/D    D/A     A/G

What it has going for it is that the core remains familiar (at least to some box players) - some of the patterns using the new notes are similar to those used on a 12 bass system e.g. G to Bb for tunes in G minor is a similar shape to G to B in G major and B to Eb(D#) is a major third in the same pattern on the push as G to B or D to F#.  The E/C# buttons are incredibly useful for playing in A and E major.  The right hand side on mine is Loffet's standard system which is very sensible and an extension to a whole row of most Castagnari layouts for 2½ rows. 

       Eb/F      E/G#   Bb/D  Eb/Eb  E/F    Bb/G#  Eb/D  E/Eb   Bb/F
    B/C    D/F#    G/A    B/C    D/E    G/F#    B/A    D/C    G/E    B/F#
F#/B   A/C#   D/E    F#/G   A/B   D/C#  F#/E    A/G    D/B   F#/C#   A/E

As always there are a few annoyances on this layout - the right hand's inability to play a Bb and F in the same direction is my biggest one which could be rectified (it should be on the push like the left hand) - but you'd probably lose something else to do it. Also there's no C reversal.

I like this system because with no thirds on the LHS you are able to play the following full chords right and left:

Major: G(both)/D(both)/A(pull)/C(pull)/F(pull)/Eb(push)/E(pull)/B(push)/F#(pull)/G#(pull)/C#(pull) - and Bb(push) with only 2 notes - no F.

Minor: G(push)/D(pull)/A(pull)/C(pull)/F(pull)/E(both)/B(push)/F#(pull)/G#(pull)/C#(pull) - only Bb and Eb minor missing in their full forms.

With those chords available - it should be technically possible to play in almost every key while still maintaining a core D/G box - I'm miles away from being on top of the system in all it's possibilities - but I did learn to play a song for Jim Moray in B major pretty successfully and with Bellowhead I use it to play in C minor and a song called widows curse which jumps from G# to C at one point.  These outlandish keys are certainly possible - but difficult and sometimes awkward.  But if you're looking for perfection in every key on a 3 row - that instrument has been invented and it's not a melodeon!

Cheers

Squeezy

Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Graham W on September 21, 2011, 02:53:32 PM
The right hand side on mine is Loffet's standard system which is very sensible and an extension to a whole row of most Castagnari layouts for 2½ rows. 

       Eb/F      E/G#   Bb/D  Eb/Eb  E/F    Bb/G#  Eb/D  E/Eb   Bb/F
    B/C    D/F#    G/A    B/C    D/E    G/F#    B/A    D/C    G/E    B/F#
F#/B   A/C#   D/E    F#/G   A/B   D/C#  F#/E    A/G    D/B   F#/C#   A/E


That's interesting, that is Francois Heim's G/C/Acc layout (or at least one of his) transposed to D/G - so well tried and tested. In it's G/C form I believe it's also one of Castagnari's standard 3 row layouts.

I've got it on a GC Rik and it's great; I'm no good on music theory but it seems to me that both accidentals and reversals generally fall very conveniently and intuitively to finger, and my DG will be changing to this layout when the reeds eventually make it to the UK.

Graham (W)
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 21, 2011, 04:30:58 PM
One quick thought the Dm/Gm/Am chords would be redundant on a MAS, since it's (probably) a 3rd's less design all chords would be modal. On a Handry 18 however, I can see why you'd want them.

I was thinking in terms of a layout with thirds with a view to designing and building my own box (thread drift alert!). However, 18 basses with thirds may be a bit large and cumbersome. An alternative I am considering would have 14 bass buttons with no thirds and would be laid out in two rows of six buttons and an inner row of just two buttons. Has anyone come across a bass confuguration like this?

The layout I have in mind is:

           C#/G#

C/C        B/E        Bb/F

G/D       D/A        Eb/F#

Can anyone see any drawbacks to such a layout?
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 21, 2011, 06:34:38 PM
Pignol had a 14 bass once - 12 chords and 2 buttons bass only.  They were in 2 rows of 7 (I think an early Gaillard)

As for your layout - well I 'feel' those D chords as being musically one side of the C/G set, and the Bb/F ones on the other side. So I'd do that and have my C/C G/D in the middle.  It sort of makes more 'chord' sense to my brain.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 21, 2011, 10:53:43 PM
Thanks for your input, Chris. The instruments that most of us made on Emmanuel Pariselle's course also had 14 basses in two rows of 7. The main disadvantage of this system is that it disturbs the pairings of bass note and chord because you have an odd number of buttons on each row. This was why I thought of putting the two extra buttons on a third row.

Your idea of putting the C/C and G/D basses in the middle of the layout rather than at the bottom is an interesting one that had not occurred to me. I need to think about the pros and cons of that. Does anyone else have any opinions about this suggestion?
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 22, 2011, 04:50:37 AM
Quote
The instruments that most of us made on Emmanuel Pariselle's course also had 14 basses in two rows of 7. The main disadvantage of this system is that it disturbs the pairings of bass note and chord because you have an odd number of buttons on each row.

I have two Saltarelles with this system, and I don't find that to be much of a problem, because I mainly use the extra buttons for bass runs and passing diminished chords, but most frequently the outside F#/C# button as a 'pinky' alternative to the first finger, so that you get the thirds for the D major and A major chords when using the RH D row, which is a very useful effect to use.

However I think there is a slight technical problem in that the odd number of buttons means that the low bass cut doesn't work on buttons 13 and 14, because of how the blanking holes work.  I can see there might be ways round that, but I suspect that was the reason why this layout was discontinued.  A pity, because I would only want to use this cut rarely, and otherwise it works very well for me.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 22, 2011, 07:45:35 AM
I need to think about the pros and cons of that. Does anyone else have any opinions about this suggestion?

See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,1972.0.html - 12 bass survey couple of years ago
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Bob Ellis on September 22, 2011, 11:27:59 AM
Thanks for the link, Chris. That discussion must have been just before I joined the group and I missed it when browsing old threads.

While it is interesting and I can see the logic, I don't think I shall be employing a layout with the G/D and C/C basses in the middle of a 12 bass system because I would find it difficult to adjust from the layout I have on my current 2.6 and 3 row boxes. The box I am thinking of building next year (alternatively, I might go to Chateau d'Ars and order one from Serafini, Gaillard or Loffet) will need to have a core of G/D, D/A, Eb/F# on the outer row and C/C, B/E, Bb/F on the inner, which is what I have on my other boxes.

Having read the thread Chris drew to my attention, I am now wavering between a 16 bass and an 18 bass layout.

The 16 bass system would be:

C#/G#      C/C       B/E        Bb/F

  A/G        G/D       D/A        Eb/F#

The 18 bass system would be:

A/G        E/C#       F#/G#

C/C        B/E         Bb/F

G/D       D/A         Eb/F#

Can anyone see any drawbacks with either of these systems? My main worry with an 18 bass system (apart from the weight) would be how easy it would be to reach the inner row.
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Chris Brimley on September 22, 2011, 11:59:17 AM
Quote
Can anyone see any drawbacks with either of these systems? My main worry with an 18 bass system (apart from the weight) would be how easy it would be to reach the inner row.

Yes, I wondered about this too, but watching 18 bass players, they seem to manage it OK.  I think the difficulty I might find is in preserving the flow of the LH accompaniment, if I needed to change wrist position.  My experience of the 14 bass system is that it's quite a stretch for certain combinations - at its worst getting from Bb chord to Eb bass (inner row, either end button in my setup) involves quite a jump, but you only rotate your hand, the wrist stays in much the same place.  You do get used to this fairly quickly, and I've developed a technique of knowing which buttons I'm on by extending my left pinky at the start of a piece of music.  I'm not sure whether the 16 bass idea would be as easy unless you have very large hands - really the only practical way to use all the bass and chord combinations would be to move the LH wrist position, I would think, much as PA players have to.  In order to do that, you'd probably have to develop a technique of supporting the LH end with your left thigh occasionally - again you'd probably develop that automatically after a while, but I must say I haven't, and I can see that it might disturb the flow again, particularly if you slip to the wrong position..
Title: Re: Castagnari 'MAS'
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 23, 2011, 04:44:29 PM
I've been following this out of idle curiosity, plus an insight into boxes other than a standard 2 row D/G.

I clicked on the Castagnari site to see what all the fuss was about.
Is it me or have they changed the models and pictures of their range?
P'raps it's just me, but they seem more crisp and bright than I remember......
or is it me just lusting  >:E
Q
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal