Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Daddy Long Les on July 14, 2011, 06:46:52 AM
-
I'm having my very top F# retuned to G# (on the pull) and my tuner wants to know what I want the push note to be. I'm thinking that a Bb would be useful. Both of these notes are going to be medium pitched and so competely out of sequence.
I need the G# as it's missing in the D major section of the Bluebell Polka.
Any suggestions? Please let me know ASAP as this happening later today.
Many Thanks
Les
-
Being a bit dense - "very top F#" which row? and is that top "nearest your chin" or top "highest pitch"?
Kind of guess that is is the chinmost on the D row in which case the normal "accidental" button on a Hohner is G#/Bb
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21acc.gif (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21acc.gif)
-
Any suggestions?
F natural on the 5th staff-line.
-
No I'm fairly sure Les is describing having the highest pitch (dusty end) button retuned on pull from high F# to middle G#, i.e. turning it into an extra accidental button at the other end.
That's what I think he means, and it reminds me of Adrian Murfitt's (Wide Glide Band, etc.) setup with a pair of accidental buttons at both ends, with the result that he has all accidentals available over two octaves - a splendid idea!
-
No I'm fairly sure Les is describing having the highest pitch (dusty end) button retuned on pull from high F# to middle G#, i.e. turning it into an extra accidental button at the other end.
That's what I think he means, and it reminds me of Adrian Murfitt's (Wide Glide Band, etc.) setup with a pair of accidental buttons at both ends, with the result that he has all accidentals available over two octaves - a splendid idea!
Yep - high-pitched end of G row. (Pull) Top F# replaced by middle G# and (Push) B replaced by ?
-
Yep - high-pitched end of G row. (Pull) Top F# replaced by middle G# and (Push) B replaced by ?
Whatever you think you'll need next!
Obvious possibility is B flat, but D# in opposite direction to existing accidental is also worth considering.
I think Adrian's box is quite different from that:
G row: low F / Low D# ...... mid F / mid D#
D row: mid G# / mid Bb ...... high G#/high Bb
-
for the B part of bluebell polka (played on D row) G# can be replaced by swift G nats and few listeners will even notice - its all part of the art of faking . On athe other hand the F naturel in the C part 3rd & 4th bar is (to me ) impossible to fake due to its prominence in the tune, which is presumably why many DG players play the C part (KEY OF C) in the key of G
Same goes for diatonic mouthie playing. When the late Will Atkinson played Caddam Wood you actually heard the non existant C#'s & F#'s - some who heard him swore that he was using a chromatic mouthie.
george