Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Howard Jones on July 18, 2011, 08:04:50 PM

Title: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 18, 2011, 08:04:50 PM
Having recently spent more hours than I care to admit to playing English tunes in sessions at ECMW and Bradfield, it seems to me that we're now playing them a lot faster than we used to.  I think this has been creeping up on us for a number of years, but it now seems to have reached the point where we're in danger of losing the 'swing', and the room to improvise and express the music, that used to be such a feature. 

I'm probably as guilty of this as anyone, as I discovered a few months ago when the Electropathics got together to rehearse for our first reunion gig in 20-odd years.  I've 'borrowed' a few of their old sets to play with Albireo, and when in rehearsal I started these off at my usual tempo I met with an immediate complaint from Alan Rawlinson that I wasn't playing at "trombone speed". 

The point about English music (Southern English anyway) was that the tunes were often unremarkable in themselves, it was the swing and rhythm which could be put into them which made them special.  We seem to be in danger of losing that.  So this is a plea to slow things down a bit.

Or is it just me?
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 18, 2011, 10:33:57 PM
..... it now seems to have reached the point where we're in danger of losing the 'swing', and the room to improvise and express the music, that used to be such a feature. 

The point about English music (Southern English anyway) was that the tunes were often unremarkable in themselves, it was the swing and rhythm which could be put into them which made them special.  We seem to be in danger of losing that.  So this is a plea to slow things down a bit.
I am with you on this - the laid-back pace, and the swing and room to improvise it enables are what I love most about English ceilidh music (but there are also lots of cracking great tunes). And it is a great contrast to the driving pace and "notey" tunes of lots of Scottish ceilidh music, of which I also play a lot.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Just4Fun on July 18, 2011, 10:58:12 PM
At a session last week, where English is often prevalent and standards tend to be reasonable, someone started Soldiers Joy at a pace that was slower than slow. Gradually everyone joined in and gradually the whole room started playing around with the rhythm and interpretation in one of the most enjoyable renditions I've heard. As a relative newbie it was a real pleasure to be a part of what is often a tune that is massacred by being played at roughly sixty eight million miles an hour.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Ga on July 18, 2011, 11:19:40 PM
I recently attended my first ever English session - populated by all sorts of instruments and singers, who obviously all knew each other well. On the whole, enjoyable, but I found many of the tunes stupidly fast, to the point of me having to drop out as I was aware I was making so many enforced errors.

I was politely asked if I wanted to start a tune, and did so, an old English favourite, played with a gentle lilt.  People joined in, but by the start of the 2nd time through it, it was accelerating massively, so I just shouted "Steadyyyyyyy", with a wry smile, and it all calmed down again - we played along nice and steady for another few times through, people started to play gentle harmonies, mess with the rhythm etc.  At the end of the night, one of the guys collared me, and thanked me for slowing it down, stating how much he enjoyed playing it when he actually thought about it.  We chatted, and worked out that most people end up belting through those tunes because they play them at home by themselves, and tend to just blast through them as part of their practice repertoire, and so , they end up playing at that ramming speed on nights out also.   

We decided there ought to be more people like me who take ownership of a tune they've started.  No need to be bolshy about it, but it's your tune, you set the pace, and if people have resorted to AutoPilot, then they may need a gentle friendly reminder that they should be concentrating ( A 6'6" 15st bloke shouting "Steadyyyyyy" counts as gentle in my book....).   We have the slow food movement, maybe this could be the slow toon movement?

Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: TomB on July 19, 2011, 12:19:45 AM
Oh no! Not this old chestnut again! "You're playing it too fast" "you're playing it too slow" "that's not the right speed". If the tune sounds good at the speed it is being played, then that's ok by me. If you are playing for dancing, the tune must reflect the dancers ability to dance to it. If you are playing in a session, don't expect the tunes played to be played 'as you play them'.
BUT..
Ga, well done for sticking to your guns. One thing that REALLY ANNOYS ME in sessions is when someone starts a tune and other players 'take over' the tune and speed it up to suit themselves. BL##DY IG####NT.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Malcolm on July 19, 2011, 07:23:30 AM
It's great that the English music scene is probably in ruder health now than it has ever been and I am convinced that that is due to its great diversity - reels, jigs, waltzes, hornpipes, polkas, marches - they're all there with tunes from the Mediaeval period to the present day being heard.  Similarly you can take just about any instrument into an English music session and play (although I'm still not persuaded that bodhran is really appropriate but that's just my personal prejudice).  Inevitably people are going to have their own views on what is the 'correct' speed: Many's the time I've sat back after a tune set and thought, "Crikey, that went at a bit of a lick" especially with jigs.  I really enjoy a lazy polka in the East Anglian style as it does have a roll to it that has a character all its own.  The important thing however is that the music is being played and developed so maybe it is a bit fast at times but if you're starting the tune and you have a thing about its pace then do try and stick to it.  Nothing wrong with an occassional "Steady" to keep people back on tarck.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 19, 2011, 08:49:29 AM
If you are playing for dancing, the tune must reflect the dancers ability to dance to it.
Well, that's another interesting point.  20 years ago we were playing more slowly for dances, and people seemed to cope.  I sense that there was more stepping back then (again, one of the characteristics of English ceilidh) which needed a bit more time.  I see less stepping now, but perhaps that's cause and effect and we're in a vicious circle - the dancers can't step because the tunes are too fast, the musicians speed up to suit the dancers... Or perhaps it's just the ceilidhs I play for.
Quote
If you are playing in a session, don't expect the tunes played to be played 'as you play them'.
Fair enough, it's up to the person starting a tune to set the speed.  My point is not about individual tunes, but a general style of playing the music which seems to be fading out.  I feel we're losing a lot of what used to make English music distinctive.  Malcolm described it above as "lazy" which is a nice description of it.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Theo on July 19, 2011, 08:59:23 AM
I feel we're losing a lot of what used to make English music distinctive.  Malcolm described it above as "lazy" which is a nice description of it.

I don't think its getting lost, at least not what makes Southern English style distinctive.   I live in Tyneside where there is a very different regional style, and  I notice a change in tempo when I visit anywhere from Yorkshire southwards,  the speed seems to gradually decrease from about Darlington all the way to Hampshire, where you van find that beacon of laid back southern style - The Bursledon Village Band (http://www.bursledonvillageband.co.uk/index.htm).
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 19, 2011, 09:03:07 AM
 the 'overspeeding'  of tunes in sessions  does not only apply to English style playing   and may come from the propensity some Irish sesssion players have for going like 'shit off a shovel'.  That s fine for a stage performance as some may be mightily impressed (& others not so!).  The main problem with flat out stuff is that there is a agreat danger of losing all semblence of musicality - phrasing, dynamics etc becoming a blur.  Another  problem is that it puts  many (good) players off joining in  and precludes tthose who just can't play, if thats what it is, at flat out speed.  Having said that theres no harm in a 'daft 10 minutes' of the 'who can keep up or play fastest'  stuff   as a bit of fun either at the end of a session or as a little interlude in the proceedings.

To me  open sessions should above all be inclusive and  incorporate tunes  covering a range of  natural speeds & degrees of complexity so that most people   get a reasonabale chance of  joining in.  I also strongly dislike  a tune being hijacked & speeded up, particularly if somebody newish to session playing has plucked up the courage to start a tune - It should be played at theeir speed even if its a bit slow & shakey - highjacking could easily put somebody off session playing for life.  I also dislike sessions being hijacked for what amount to solo performances  . Thats fine for singaround/playaround formats but not for inclusive sessions.


george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: rees on July 19, 2011, 09:32:16 AM
Roger Digby delivered a fine lecture on this very subject at Bradfield, last year.

I do cringe when I hear Oh Joe the Boat is Going Over played at double speed destroying every syncopation that Oscar Woods ever put into it. Boring, boring, boring.

Indeed, this is the reason that I don't go to so many English sessions these days.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 19, 2011, 09:46:00 AM
Every time I start Oscar woods jig in local session it gets speeded up into a superfast jig...I've started to pull the stop out on my melodeon when I start it and play it 'deliberately' and loudly in order to keep the speed I started it at. It actually worked the other week.

As someone who can only go at speed if I got the dots..and I'm trying to do without the dots I find the speed tunes extremely annoying as my brain can't process at that speed.


I did erm....post about this when I first started
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4246.0.html
As a beginner its very off putting to find tunes played fast so the notes merge into one long muddy sound.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Marje on July 19, 2011, 10:07:54 AM
If someone chooses to start a tune and play it fast, that's their choice, although I generally prefer the slower tempos. What is really annoying is if I start a nice bumpy jig (I can imagine me, or other people, dancing to it as I play, which helps me to keep it steady) and then another player speeds up the tune as we go along, so by the end it's just careering along with no discernible bounce to it. And unless all the players are very skilful in a fast tune, many of the notes may be lost along the way, leaving just one note in each triplet run or one beat in a bar.

It's easily done if someone gets excited, especially with jigs. Some people speed up on runs of notes, others do it by going on too soon to the next note or bar after a longer note. And some seem to do it quite deliberately, just to show off. All it takes is for one person to keep accelerating, and it's very difficult for the others to hold back.

I was once at a ceilidh where a band played too fast. What happened was that the dancers actually slowed down their steps, marking only half of the beats that they would have marked if the tune had been played at the right speed. The faster playing just resulted in a plodding dance-style - a slow trot rather than skipping or stepping.

I know sessions are not for dancing to, but the dance tunes we play usually sound best if they keep something of the character of the dance, And I notice that if someone compliments another player at the end of a set and says "really nice tempo!" they mean it was nice and steady, not nice and fast.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 19, 2011, 11:08:08 AM
A difficult subject, eh?  At one session I am accused of playing too fast, although when compared to the recordings of the dance bands from which I learnt the tunes, I am slowing them down!   When leading, I find I have to play without much variation or improvisation so as to avoid any confusion as to the tempo.  Tunes like Balquhidder Lasses are prime for being played too fast.  I find that, as said above, many players play the runs too fast and shorten the sustained notes, so they start the next bar too early.  I like to put in a few little ornaments that just don't work at speed, so I know whether I'm losing it and others have to wait for me (and the next bar)!

Strange how waltzes tend to be played so fast - hasn't anyone enjoyed wrapping their arms around a woman?  Not to be rushed...

Rob.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 19, 2011, 12:17:11 PM
On dance band speeds. I think it was ever thus. Many bands on the English dance circuit (this is far wider than festivals or dance clubs) are still playing too fast (and with a selection dominated by Irish, Scottish and American tunes, though that's a different subject). On the other hand I've had many conversations with a certain well-known caller who bemoaned the "super slow polka" craze that hit us, um, something over 20 years ago. It was tedious and pretty much undancable. Any speed-up from that is very welcome.

btw. Electropathics!!!! Yes :-)   That takes me back to some fun memories of a great band.

On sessions. So much is down to context. Personally, I think George has got closest to it with his idea of the occasional "mad 10 minutes" and generaly having a variety of natural speeds and degrees of complexity in a session. Lets not get too precious. The musicians are meant to be enjoying themselves after all.

I have to say, though, that if you are a "beginner" then you have to expect that the majority of stuff is going to be too complex or fast for you, even at dance speeds. It's true that tunes are often more difficult to play properly at a slower pace than at high speed. This is because every note has to be properly weighted/accented and the tune has to be more intimately known. However, this is not what beginners will do when playing very slowly and tentatively. It's good practice to indulge "beginners" but a session with too much of this quickly becomes dull and wearisome.

At my local weekly session we often deliberately set over the first part of the evening to encouraging less experienced players to play. They're encouraged to stop and start, ask questions and we have published a set of tunes and recordings for beginners in the past (must get those back on the website  :|bl ). We then go into the main session but still consciously throw in tunes that we know that particular less experienced players know or are learning since we don't want there to some sort of feeling of exclusion from the "proper session". In fact, I've personally learnt a lot from the "beginners" parts of the evening.

The perfect session? Heh, yeah, well I'm also the most skilled and considerate session player in the world as well.

^^ that's not true just in case you were wondering!

Oh, yes, and it is *extremely* rude to grab hold of someone else's tune and change it's speed and tempo (whoever they are). If someone likes playing Madame Bonaparte as a dotted hornpipe, then you damn well play it as a dotted hornpipe and not try to change it into a reel!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 19, 2011, 12:33:41 PM
Certainly there are different regional styles, and the events where I've been playing attract musicians from all over the country so there should be a good mix of these.  Some tunes actually benefit from being taken at a decent lick (although it reaches a point where in all but the most skilled hands the tune just becomes a mass of notes).  There's nothing wrong with playing some faster tunes where it's appropriate.  Playing slowly for the benefit of beginners is also a different question.

I'm not really blaming individual musicians for this (although I could name one or two... ;)).  It's more a collective increase in the tempo that seems to have affected the mass of English players of Southern English music.  Perhaps dahn Sarf it's still less prevalent (I've long been exiled in t'North), but like I said I've found this at national gatherings including well-known musicians.  I think we need to make more of a conscious effort to slow these tunes down.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 19, 2011, 12:45:22 PM
 Years ago attended a moouthie workshop run by the late Will ATkinson.  We all had to play a tune of our choice in turn  upon which Will passed judgement in his inimitable way.  My feeble attempt on a cheap chinnese mouthie resulted in the comment  'you   got 3 notes wrong ' I thought thats not too bad but then Will added ' and if you play it through 3 times thats nine!'.  Next bloke in line had a suitcase full of mouthies & claimed to be ex secretary of the british harmonica society or whatever it is.  He played  a hornnpipe quite ncely,I thought.     Will commented  ' Every tune has a natural speed and you'd  find it a lot easier to play at its natural speed.   That  'lesson'  was something I will never forget.

As to beginners & sessions there can be confusion between raw beginners on an instrument who will not be able to keep up even with a steady pace session   and those who have been playing a while , know a few tunes but are new to session playing & who may 'go to pieces' when under the pressure of trying to keep up even with English style jigs & reels.  When running sessions I try to accomodate neewcommers by  introducing some tunes that are naturally slow , so they sound right played slowly eg walltzes, slow aires and Scottish pipe marches ( Even the athol highlanders becomes maneagable when played as God intended at around 92 beats a mi;nute which is about as fast as one  could march for miles  - which is what pipe marches are composed so to do.)  Why is Athol Highlanders usually played at rapper speed in sessions. ( I do play it at rapper speed for rapper for which it works very well)

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Hello on July 19, 2011, 03:26:57 PM
A good coping strategy is to play every other note.  That way, for any given tune, you're only playing it half of it and at half the speed of everyone else.  It's particularly effective if you have a like-minded friend to play only the notes in between that you're not playing.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 19, 2011, 03:33:53 PM
This is a can of worms that we need to keep opening just to remind us.....
From various discussions in the past about how the village bands organised themselves during one of Roy Dommet's 'chats over a pint' in between his workshops, and maybe an early Townsend one on the Hardy manuscripts, I've had created an impression in me of 'one version' of how it was ..... this might well be a false illusion, but it's what is in my brain.
The case of the Hardy family has been mentioned when father and son played for the dances 'up the big house'. Tunes played for a long time, enough for the posh host and hostess to work all the way down longways sets to the bottom of the hall *and* back again, as was the custom. Therefore a simple tune would have been embellished, improvised etc to stop the band from going mad. You can't do that if the tune's going hell-for-leather.
Certainly down where I am, edge of Dartimoor, the Step-hop seems just....right! Whenever I dance it, I feel like it was made for me/us/Devon/Southerner etc. Step hops are lumpy, bouncy and relatively slow. You can't put anything into the dance unless the tune is at a speed where you can add the bounce etc.
I've thought about this recently, after a spate of speeded up tunes at my local session by a PA player, who seems to race everything. Thank goodness he wasn't around last time. >:E
I bow to the local knowledge expressed of the northern breatheren, which is quite interesting to hear. I only know what I know, and I know what I like, and that's quite slow!
my thrupennce!
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 19, 2011, 09:58:05 PM
As a dancer, I prefer to play at (eceilidh) dance speeds, with just the occasional mad half-hour, even on the fiddle.  :Ph
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 20, 2011, 08:42:58 AM
As a dancer, I prefer to play at (eceilidh) dance speeds, with just the occasional mad half-hour, even on the fiddle.  :Ph

But what is "eceilidh dance speed"?  As I pointed out earlier, dancers seem to have speeded up as well - whether it is the dancers trying to keep up with the musicians or vice versa is a moot point.  I discovered a few months ago that I'm playing for dances noticeably faster now than I did 20 years ago when I played the same tunes for dances with the Electropathics. 

The difference is that the dancers now are doing less stepping - possibly because the tunes are too fast.

I'm suggesting we should pause to take stock and look back at the origins of the e-ceilidh and English Country Music movements.  I'm not saying the music shouldn't progress, just that we seem to be losing what made it special both to play and to dance to.  It was that swing and rhythm which first attracted me away from Irish music, and I'd like to get it back.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 20, 2011, 08:47:34 AM
Every time I start Oscar woods jig in local session it gets speeded up into a superfast jig...I've started to pull the stop out on my melodeon when I start it and play it 'deliberately' and loudly in order to keep the speed I started it at. It actually worked the other week.

This is a perfect example.  The way Oscar played it was full of subtle variations of emphasis and rhythm, turning what is a fairly mundane melody into a fantastic tune.  Taken at speed it's impossible to bring these in, and it soon becomes boring.

Quote
As a beginner its very off putting to find tunes played fast so the notes merge into one long muddy sound.

Not just for beginners.  It's frustrating to hear excellent tunes rendered uninteresting by not allowing them room to "breathe".
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: ladydetemps on July 20, 2011, 08:59:27 AM


The difference is that the dancers now are doing less stepping - possibly because the tunes are too fast.

Can you explain what you mean by stepping? (I ask as someone who tries to head in the vaguely right direction yet always seems to be going/doing the wrong thing at the wrong time).
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 20, 2011, 11:32:03 AM
In my book, 'stepping' is exactly that what your feet are doing.
If you take a simple dance like Nottingham Swing, it is a step-hop dance.
i.e. your feet go left-hop, right-hop, left hop- right hop until the dance stops.
That is the stepping.
You continue this stepping all through the dance, whilst completing the figues of the dance.
The figures being 1st man right arm swings 2nd lady; 2nd man right arm swings 1st lady; 1st couples join across chausse down; move back around 2nd couples onto the next etc.... all whilst step hopping, 'stepping to the tune'.
Whatever speed the tune is played at means it sould be of a complimentary speed to allow you to accomplish the stepping ( wot your feet do ) whilst also doing the figues of the dance.
Step hop tunes should be slower, and bouncy allowing you to really bop and bounce along, whereas things like rant steps are faster.... etc etc.
Hope it helps
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Theo on July 20, 2011, 12:08:36 PM

Step hop tunes should be slower, and bouncy allowing you to really bop and bounce along, whereas things like rant steps are faster.... etc etc.
Hope it helps
Q

I agree, partly... it all depends on your dance style.

There is more than one way of doing a step hop.  The loping (galumpfing according to JK) southern style does need a rather slow and rock steady tempo, and also a really good back beat.  The Tyneside style is much quicker, and the hop becomes more of a bounce, and the step travels a much shorter distance.  That style gets exhausting if its too slow and works best with the Tyneside style dotted hornpipes.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 20, 2011, 12:30:01 PM
for the former I sometimes play waltzing matilda & click go the shears  for the latter perhaps keel row & reedsdale hornpipe

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 20, 2011, 12:57:38 PM
Yes Theo, I was thinking in terms of 'my' version played and danced down in Devon, though I prefer 'loping' to 'galumphing'  ;)
Makes me sound like some sort of yokel  ;D

It's the regional variations that also need to be considered, as you say, your type of step hop is different to mine.
Perhaps it's the cold north you require faster stepping to prevent freezing to the spot if you stay too long, where, down here nearer the Equator ..... >:E
take care
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Peter_T on July 20, 2011, 07:23:13 PM
I feel we're losing a lot of what used to make English music distinctive.  Malcolm described it above as "lazy" which is a nice description of it.

I don't think its getting lost, at least not what makes Southern English style distinctive.   I live in Tyneside where there is a very different regional style, and  I notice a change in tempo when I visit anywhere from Yorkshire southwards,  the speed seems to gradually decrease from about Darlington all the way to Hampshire, where you van find that beacon of laid back southern style - The Bursledon Village Band (http://www.bursledonvillageband.co.uk/index.htm).

And very nice to dance to, they are.

   
Oh no! Not this old chestnut again! "You're playing it too fast" "you're playing it too slow" "that's not the right speed". If the tune sounds good at the speed it is being played, then that's ok by me. If you are playing for dancing, the tune must reflect the dancers ability to dance to it. If you are playing in a session, don't expect the tunes played to be played 'as you play them'.
BUT..
Ga, well done for sticking to your guns. One thing that REALLY ANNOYS ME in sessions is when someone starts a tune and other players 'take over' the tune and speed it up to suit themselves. BL##DY IG####NT.


Friend of mine took her fiddle to local session. Been learning for a year in what someone else describes as a rather sheltered class/session. Started on, I think she said, Michael Turner's Waltz. 'Leader' takes over,, speeds up and looses her. He says afterwards 'You must know a different version'  and 'How long have you been playing? A month or so?' Mortified, she was.

[Hope I haven't told this in here before - may have been in Mudcat.]

I tend not to go to 'his' sessions unless to indulge on harmonica. Yet to take the Pokerwork along. Mostly clashes with choir or Morris anyway.

Sounds like an excuse to see how slow I can make Three around Three and see I can do by way of playing with rhythm.







Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 20, 2011, 07:50:47 PM
Last year I went to an English session in Devon (because I happened to be there and by chance had my box with me) with a load of players I had never met before.  They were a lovely bunch of people and I was made to feel very welcome, but my life, did they go at a lick!  Every tune, regardless of provenance, time-signature or character, went at a million miles an hour. One or two brave souls (me included) made an effort to start tunes in a nice gentle, laid-back groove, but by the first B music you were running to catch up.  What is it with these speed freaks? Do they have no concept of music?

BTW I'm a Midlander, so probably kind of neutral in the North/South divide...........
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Malcolm on July 21, 2011, 06:01:16 AM
I'll endorse that GPS.  If I play New Centenary March in North Devon it's a reel (and a pretty snappy one too) whereas if I play it here in sunny Sarfend on Sea, it's a swagger. I run a couple of music sessions at a festival in Devon and I too have noticed how everything seems to pick up pace no matter how steady I try to keep it.  There are a lot of fiddle players in the room so maybe that has something to do with it but maybe it's just the musical zeitgeist and you go with the flow.  Whichever, I'm just pleased to get people playing English music live in its spiritual home - the back bar of the pub!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Jon Loomes on July 21, 2011, 10:48:45 AM
I was at a session recently where the natural speed was fairly brisk - not a million miles an hour, but not exactly sluggish.  I was right at home, because it was about the speed I'd learned to play at from sessions in South London 10 -15 years ago.  However, one player insisted on dragging the tempo back all the time because they insisted that the tunes were too fast.  Said player is an extremely good musician and could have kept up easily, so it got me thinking:  Who is right?  Who decides "how fast" is appropriate? There's a good argument that "dance tunes should be played at dance speed", but if no one is dancing the social function of the music is different, so do different rules apply?  Is it necessary to play at a speed you think is historically/culturally correct for reasons of ethnomusicological preservation or is it better to follow natural pace of the session (does this allow the tradition to develop?)  Personally, I think "a bit too fast" is a lot better than "a bit too slow". Then again, what do I know? I guess a waltz played to fast sounds just as wrong as a 3/2 hornpipe played too slowly.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 21, 2011, 12:11:09 PM
Trouble is, a hornpipe for border Morris is a lot slower than for a barndance!  Waltzes, though, are for holding a partner - not to be rushed.

Rob.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 21, 2011, 12:25:13 PM
At a session, which is first and foremost for the enjoyment of the musicians and is not for an audience or dancers, it seems to me that the right speed is the one that enables them to get the most out of the tune. 

Perhaps what we are seeking to get out of tunes has changed.  In the early days of the English country music revival, it seemed to be all about what I refer to as the swing and the rhythm - getting into a groove and seeing where it took you.  This was in clear contrast to Irish sessions, which seemed to be all about speed, decoration, and showing off technical virtuosity.  English music seems to me moving in the latter direction. It's not that I dislike that approach as such, but it's nice to have both alternatives.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Theo on July 21, 2011, 12:48:27 PM
Waltzes, though, are for holding a partner - not to be rushed.


Even there you see there are plenty of ways of dancing a waltz at a whole range of different tempos.  Slow smoochy 'old time' waltzes like the valeta, and their modern counterparst such as Rosa, and the fast twirling French style and all sorts in betwen.

And as for holding your partner - slow waltzes can be done almost at arms length if you are that way inclined, but is essential that you hold your partner as close as possible for a fast waltz or the physics of the movement just doesn't work.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Sandy on July 21, 2011, 02:12:13 PM
I'm all for a pace that allows swing. I'd imagine a good session leader can pull people back once a tune has started and generally control things. I know from my own experience that it's easy in the early stages of playing to start a tune too fast  :|bl

Well I might get to a few festival sessions this summer, I hope they won't be too speedy and I prefer a little break between tunes  :|glug


Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 21, 2011, 02:12:53 PM
Surely, when playing in sessions (which is what this thread is supposed to be about), there can only ever be one right speed at which to play a tune. Whoever starts the tune, sets the speed and it is bad manners (not to mention selfish and inconsiderate) to speed it up, slow it down or hijack it in any other way. Etiquette dictates that the person who starts it 'leads' the tune and determines such things as the tempo, how many times through and whether or not to change to another tune.

If someone in a session fails to abide by this, they need to be told (politely) that they should follow the lead of the person who started the tune because they may be unaware that it is bad manners to do otherwise. If they still persist, they should be asked to leave.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Graham Spencer on July 21, 2011, 03:16:46 PM
If they were asked to leave in the session I mentioned, there'd have been 3 of us left after the other 20 or so had gone.......
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 21, 2011, 03:46:57 PM
Surely, when playing in sessions (which is what this thread is supposed to be about), there can only ever be one right speed at which to play a tune. Whoever starts the tune, sets the speed and it is bad manners (not to mention selfish and inconsiderate) to speed it up, slow it down or hijack it in any other way. Etiquette dictates that the person who starts it 'leads' the tune and determines such things as the tempo, how many times through and whether or not to change to another tune.

If someone in a session fails to abide by this, they need to be told (politely) that they should follow the lead of the person who started the tune because they may be unaware that it is bad manners to do otherwise. If they still persist, they should be asked to leave.

totally agree Bob.

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Marje on July 21, 2011, 04:14:08 PM
Surely, when playing in sessions (which is what this thread is supposed to be about), there can only ever be one right speed at which to play a tune. Whoever starts the tune, sets the speed and it is bad manners (not to mention selfish and inconsiderate) to speed it up, slow it down or hijack it in any other way. Etiquette dictates that the person who starts it 'leads' the tune and determines such things as the tempo, how many times through and whether or not to change to another tune.

I think most of us would agree with that, although some will nevertheless sulk if tunes are played at a speed they consider too fast/slow.

But what do you do if the person who starts the tunes is one of the speeder-uppers? Some people just don't seem able to stop themselves from accelerating away from a well-judged starting tempo.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Marje on July 21, 2011, 04:24:16 PM
I'm all for a pace that allows swing. I'd imagine a good session leader can pull people back once a tune has started and generally control things.



I don't think that's the case. Once a tune has speeded up, neither a session leader nor anyone else can do much to pull it back. (Or am I missing a trick? is there anything you can do, apart from tapping your foot on the floor, and playing the basses loudly and rhythmically?).

When all else fails, someone can shout "Steady!" or "Slow down!" but I've only done this in a situation where we're performing (I'm talking about session players getting together as a one-off "band" for occasions like a summer fete, or playing for informal dancing). I hesitate to do this, even though I can hear the tune gathering speed and I'm thinking, "But by the time we get to Morgan Rattler it'll be practically falling apart!" It seems a bit aggressive and bossy to shout at other players in a pub session, even if it's the session that I organise. I generally just go with the flow, even if the flow is constantly gathering momentum.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 21, 2011, 05:42:13 PM
I too find it can be the starter who wangs it along too fast, then it is hard to ask them to slow down. I've recently had a PA player constantly trying to push me when the usual main melodeon player ( steady influence ) couldn't make it. I even started a tune telling everyone it was going to be 'steady' and the person was still trying to push.
Bit like someone in your boot when you are doing the speed limit!
It just seems to be an ethos thing. It seems some people just want to play it flat out cos that's what they think is really good  :o
hey ho
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Bob Ellis on July 21, 2011, 06:02:01 PM
But what do you do if the person who starts the tunes is one of the speeder-uppers? Some people just don't seem able to stop themselves from accelerating away from a well-judged starting tempo.

I think they have the same right as everyone else to have the way they want to play respected. If someone has started a tune at a particular pace and then they speed up (either intentionally or unintentionally), my view is that they are leading the tune, so others in the session should follow their lead.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Theo on July 21, 2011, 07:08:12 PM
When others are pushing the speed up the only sensible thing is to stop playing and put your box down, have a drink, maybe go to the bar.  If a number of people do that the message will soon get across.  Its no pleaseure to play in that situation so there is nothing to loose.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Dunny on July 21, 2011, 07:12:59 PM

I think they have the same right as everyone else to have the way they want to play respected. If someone has started a tune at a particular pace and then they speed up (either intentionally or unintentionally), my view is that they are leading the tune, so others in the session should follow their lead.
[/quote]

I agree entirely Bob - as per our conversation in Isleworth!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Anahata on July 21, 2011, 07:15:16 PM
I'd imagine a good session leader can pull people back once a tune has started and generally control things.
I don't think that's the case. Once a tune has speeded up, neither a session leader nor anyone else can do much to pull it back.

I've tried that: it's very hard work and not much fun, it feels just as aggressive as shouting at people to slow down, and after a while I start wondering why I bother with the session at all if I'm not enjoying it...
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on July 21, 2011, 07:30:05 PM
i just like playing fast.  >:E
but i try to keep a sensible speed at sessions so everyone can join in, whats a sensible spead for a jig like major mackies?

http://www.youtube.com/user/smolt1451?feature=mhee#p/a/u/0/TP3vDCGI-tI

Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Rob2Hook on July 21, 2011, 11:16:21 PM
There are exceptions...  Quite often a relative beginner will start their only tune and nerves and pulse rate make them go off like a startled rabbit!  I've always found that the give away is that their rythm is jerky - so at least one can join in and play with the most rythmic style possible and emphasise the speed where they slow for the difficult phrases.  That's normally enough support for them to relax a bit and their playing improves.  Apart from anything else, it affirms that they don't have to race.

Rob.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Owen Woods on July 22, 2011, 09:56:00 AM
As a dancer, I prefer to play at (eceilidh) dance speeds, with just the occasional mad half-hour, even on the fiddle.  :Ph

But what is "eceilidh dance speed"?  As I pointed out earlier, dancers seem to have speeded up as well - whether it is the dancers trying to keep up with the musicians or vice versa is a moot point.  I discovered a few months ago that I'm playing for dances noticeably faster now than I did 20 years ago when I played the same tunes for dances with the Electropathics. 

The difference is that the dancers now are doing less stepping - possibly because the tunes are too fast.

I'm suggesting we should pause to take stock and look back at the origins of the e-ceilidh and English Country Music movements.  I'm not saying the music shouldn't progress, just that we seem to be losing what made it special both to play and to dance to.  It was that swing and rhythm which first attracted me away from Irish music, and I'd like to get it back.

I think that this is the moot point. My first attempt at playing directly for ceilidh dances (i.e. not being on the back row of a band but "in charge") was when our band held a calling workshop and I was the music. I found there that if I started a tune too fast, the dancers couldn't step, so walked it instead. This then felt too slow, so I ended up speeding up and speeding up until it was almost too fast for me to play it. The person leading the workshop then helpfully pointed out that if I'd started 10% slower then that would have been fine.

Since then I've led a fair few gigs and I'm getting the hang of it. It's one thing looking from the back and thinking to yourself "the leader is going a bit too fast", it's quite another thing to be doing it yourself! It depends very much on the caller, some of our callers call boring dances that are best played for at high speed. Those are the dances that get done at May Balls when everyone is drunk. Some callers though call lovely dances and it is so satisfying to ease it back, take it slower and watch the dancers respond. I love playing for hornpipes especially. One of our callers does a walking dance to a hornpipe and the first time that I tried leading it it was great, the dancers really got into it and were moving "to the groove", despite the fact that it was a pretty slow dance.

And yes, I know, a good ceilidh band shouldn't need a leader, but there are generally 10 of us on the lineup and we play in acoustically dubious halls... I've injured my knee stamping before now.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 22, 2011, 10:55:10 AM
We have found when dancing the morris, the difference between too fast, too slow and just right is sometimes only 1-2 beats per minute. Quite amazingly small, and that then gets knocked sideways if it's a 'big' event and adrenalin kicks in, so the side slows and tries to dance higher.
If you apply this logic to the ceilidh dance, for a given dance there is a small degree of variation for the dance that enables it to be danced enjoyably. Consequently the tune will be played within given tolerances - slightly faster/slightly slower depending in local differences at the time. By extending this thought, the tunes should be played relatively as originally intended, though as said we might have speeded up a bit within the memory of people here. This means the tune's inherant characteristics and built in chance to improvise, play around the melody etc. should be roughly maintained.
I think the thing we are all moaning about is when a session simply goes off with a F1 start, and continues to race the tune at an improbable speed.
That is when I start to loose interest, pick my nose, and generally pout  >:(
...but maybe I'm thinking about it too much  :D
cheers
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 22, 2011, 11:06:56 AM
I find it much easier to polay for experienced dancers  whether its ceilidh or morris  than for  a 'ceilidh' consisting of general public . With experienced danacers it is easy to start the music at a reasonable guestimate  of required speed & rhythm  and then to make fine  adjustents  ( within the first few bars)  by watching the best dancer & playing to his/her feet. If all goes well its a sort of 'floatation speed'  where the effort required by both dancers  is minimal.  This requires band members to listen to & stick  with the leader and watch the dancers

When faced with a room full of non ceilidh dancers  I find that with a bit of luck playing perhaps a little on the slow side, but with   a very strong rhythm   results in a sort of 'jaunty walk' .  As the evening progresses & they get the hang of things the speed can go up to a jaunty scramble reaching the destination being more important for the fun factor than how they got there.

for what its worth   the 1   exellent   books 'the ceilidh connection vol 1 to 4) give metronome speed for various dances  eg gay gordons 4/4 116,  6/8  100 ,strip the willow 126,highland schotttische 138,         dashing white sergeant 116, eghtsome reel 116, canaaadian barn daance 138, virginia reel  120 and interestingly  the air 'The cradle song@ 76 and the air Mrs Jamiesons favourite 40.

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Guy on July 22, 2011, 11:53:55 AM
I find it much easier to polay for experienced dancers  whether its ceilidh or morris  than for  a 'ceilidh' consisting of general public . With experienced danacers it is easy to start the music at a reasonable guestimate  of required speed & rhythm  and then to make fine  adjustents  ( within the first few bars)  by watching the best dancer & playing to his/her feet. If all goes well its a sort of 'floatation speed'  where the effort required by both dancers  is minimal.  This requires band members to listen to & stick  with the leader and watch the dancers

When faced with a room full of non ceilidh dancers  I find that with a bit of luck playing perhaps a little on the slow side, but with   a very strong rhythm   results in a sort of 'jaunty walk' .  As the evening progresses & they get the hang of things the speed can go up to a jaunty scramble reaching the destination being more important for the fun factor than how they got there.

george

I'd echo this wholeheartedly. We do a lot of private functions for inexperienced dancers, and then found that for regular ceilidhs we were playing everything too slowly without realising it, because it had become "normal" speed for a lot of dances. A lesson for me to keep watching and listening, I think!

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 22, 2011, 11:56:55 AM
I find it much easier to polay for experienced dancers  whether its ceilidh or morris  than for  a 'ceilidh' consisting of general public . With experienced danacers it is easy to start the music at a reasonable guestimate  of required speed & rhythm  and then to make fine  adjustents  ( within the first few bars)  by watching the best dancer & playing to his/her feet. If all goes well its a sort of 'floatation speed'  where the effort required by both dancers  is minimal.  This requires band members to listen to & stick  with the leader and watch the dancers

When faced with a room full of non ceilidh dancers  I find that with a bit of luck playing perhaps a little on the slow side, but with   a very strong rhythm   results in a sort of 'jaunty walk' .  As the evening progresses & they get the hang of things the speed can go up to a jaunty scramble reaching the destination being more important for the fun factor than how they got there.

for what its worth   the 1   exellent   books 'the ceilidh connection vol 1 to 4) give metronome speed for various dances  eg gay gordons 4/4 116,  6/8  100 ,strip the willow 126,highland schotttische 138,         dashing white sergeant 116, eghtsome reel 116, canaaadian barn daance 138, virginia reel  120 and interestingly  the air 'The cradle song@ 76 and the air Mrs Jamiesons favourite 40.

george

Interesting, I just timed myself with a "mental ceilidh" and got Gay Gordon's 4/4/ 112, 6/8 104, Strip the Willow 130, Dashing White Sergeant 116 (!), Virginia Reel 120 (!!) ... then I stopped myself as I have to go out  ::)
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Ellie on July 22, 2011, 12:16:53 PM
There are exceptions...  Quite often a relative beginner will start their only tune and nerves and pulse rate make them go off like a startled rabbit!  I've always found that the give away is that their rythm is jerky - so at least one can join in and play with the most rythmic style possible and emphasise the speed where they slow for the difficult phrases.  That's normally enough support for them to relax a bit and their playing improves.  Apart from anything else, it affirms that they don't have to race.

This is very true - as a beginner, when I first went to sessions, I really appreciated people who did this. In fact, I still have a tendancy to race off faster than intended, so I still appreciate another steadying influence!!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 22, 2011, 02:25:16 PM
The issue of playing for dancing is I think a bit more subtle - experienced dancers often prefer the music to be a bit slower because it allows them more opportunity to move with the music, especially if they can step to it.  It's inexperienced dancers who can't step who struggle with it being to slow, because they don't know what to do with their feet to fill the time available so you have to speed it up so they can walk or run.  it all depends on the dance of course. 

However my original point was about playing for sessions.  It doesn't have to be at F1 speed for it to be too fast to get the most expression into the music.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 22, 2011, 02:46:51 PM
one of my dislikes in sessions is pipe marches being played at  t :|blwice their natural speed  which  a piper  told me should be 92.  Athol highlanders sounds great at that speed & gives time to put some rhythm & expression into the proceedings.

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 22, 2011, 03:41:00 PM
When others are pushing the speed up the only sensible thing is to stop playing and put your box down, have a drink, maybe go to the bar. 
I agree.  You aren't required to play every tune.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on July 22, 2011, 04:24:43 PM
Have you told you fingers, Gary?  (:)
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 22, 2011, 08:02:02 PM
See  posting under Whitby Folk Week - I will be running 2 sessions in the middle earth  "well known tunes at a steady pace"  Mon & Tues 1 to 3pm  - and definately no undue speeding up

george ;)
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Gary P Chapin on July 23, 2011, 05:34:09 AM
Have you told you fingers, Gary?  (:)
The impulse for a pint is pretty strong. We negotiate.  :|glug
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Marje on July 23, 2011, 10:57:26 AM
i just like playing fast.  >:E
but i try to keep a sensible speed at sessions so everyone can join in, whats a sensible spead for a jig like major mackies?

http://www.youtube.com/user/smolt1451?feature=mhee#p/a/u/0/TP3vDCGI-tI



I think that sounds just fine at that speed, it still has its bounce. You wouldn't want it any faster, though, or you'd start to lose some of the drive, and probably some of the notes too.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Theo on July 23, 2011, 11:04:31 AM
i just like playing fast.  >:E
but i try to keep a sensible speed at sessions so everyone can join in, whats a sensible spead for a jig like major mackies?

http://www.youtube.com/user/smolt1451?feature=mhee#p/a/u/0/TP3vDCGI-tI



I think that sounds just fine at that speed, it still has its bounce. You wouldn't want it any faster, though, or you'd start to lose some of the drive, and probably some of the notes too.

I'd normally play it a little slower, but with more emphasis on the first beat of each triplet. Its the Willie Taylor jig style I'm aming for. What Stewart Hardy calls and antelope jig, because the rhythm goes: antelope antelope, antelope antelope, antelope antelope, etc with the emphasis on the 'ant'

I suppose I'll have to put up now and do a recording. ;D

There are a few more notes that I think should be in there, that gypsylad has missed out. :o
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 23, 2011, 03:48:38 PM
I think I'd play it a bit slower too. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it played at that speed, it's got bounce and it's played well, and would be good to dance to.  However I think I'd get a bit bored with playing it after a few times through, because at that speed there's not a lot more you can do with the tune.  Slow it down just a little, and suddenly you've got room to shift the rhythms slightly, to swing it a bit, space for the musicians to start bouncing ideas off one another.

The best session, in my opinion, is where the musicians interact together to transform a straightforward tune into something a bit different.  It doesn't work every time, but when it does it's wonderful, not least because you know it's absolutely unique and can never be reproduced, since it was created instinctively and in an unplanned way by musicians reacting to one another.  To do this, it helps to be playing slower rather than faster*, otherwise all you can do is play the tune together - which is fun, I agree, but less satisfying.

That's what I mean by "too fast".

*it's also necessary to have musicians who are willing to work co-operatively rather than impose their egos, but that's for a different thread...
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on July 23, 2011, 04:01:18 PM
Howard - I think you have for me totally summed up this thread and defined " too fast"!
thank you kind sir!
Q
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 24, 2011, 07:31:34 AM
I'm as close to Howard's position as makes no difference.  Last weekend's pilgrimage to Château d'Ars (was St.Chartier) has simply refreshed my prejudices and it was a pleasure to get into 'boeufs' where the pace was not an issue, and musicians gave each other space to develop something. Yes, we get it occasionally here - a friend stopped going to a good session with me saying that there was a whole non verbal conversation going on between the musicians that he couldn't be part of.

In a previous thread I made analogy between musical expression and "making love" (universally ignored so perhaps "too French" for this forum). The end points are of course utterly different, and should an old crochet like me get lucky with a minim .. well,  there's no risk of unexpected semiquavers toward the end of the year ;)  

But both involve emotion, sensitivity, use of hands in our case.  More important a willingness to listen to things that aren't "said".  As a simple  example - modulation onto outer row melody can be by bauling out "DEE!" or by playing some manner of A7 chord. Within a genuinely receptive grouping simply playing a C# note may suffice 8)  Music becomes a "journey" rather than a destination.  I don't think it carries the metaphor too far to conjecture that there might be a better way than "as quickly as possible"?   :|glug
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 24, 2011, 02:18:16 PM
 I don't think it carries the metaphor too far to conjecture that there might be a better way than "as quickly as possible"?   :|glug

Well said!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: jb on July 24, 2011, 03:26:04 PM
I don't think it carries the metaphor too far to conjecture that there might be a better way than "as quickly as possible"?  
are there similar parallels regarding the optimal number of participants?
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Peter_T on July 24, 2011, 09:36:50 PM
i just like playing fast.  >:E
but i try to keep a sensible speed at sessions so everyone can join in, whats a sensible spead for a jig like major mackies?

http://www.youtube.com/user/smolt1451?feature=mhee#p/a/u/0/TP3vDCGI-tI



Excuse the mild digression, please, but what is that box?
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Lester on July 24, 2011, 09:42:54 PM

Excuse the mild digression, please, but what is that box?

That is Fat Elvis


http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6886.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6886.0.html)
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Peter_T on July 24, 2011, 11:17:51 PM

Excuse the mild digression, please, but what is that box?

That is Fat Elvis


http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6886.0.html (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6886.0.html)

Thank you, Lester.

It was the patterned colouring of the buttons that deceived  me. Bit like dazzle-paint on ships.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 25, 2011, 07:41:58 AM
Nothing wrong with that speed - but it'll tend to come 'square' IMHO. I'd be about 25% slower and try for some 'swing' ;) both are right of course and other than trying to imitate a music box) I can't imagine a lot of benefit or beauty in playing any faster than gypsyylad's clip.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: val huzzard on July 26, 2011, 12:27:18 PM
Yes yes yes. Thanks whoever started this thread. I am very bolshy about this. I run an English tunes session first sunday of month in kelham island tavern in sheffield. I play many of the tunes slow, compared with many and have had people complain and not come back. However, the scope for making the music interesting at that speed is so much the better. I also find playing tunes at a million miles an hour quite stressful.
This should be fun!
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 26, 2011, 03:51:56 PM
. I also find playing tunes at a million miles an hour quite stressful.
 

and often almost unrecognisable!

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 26, 2011, 10:56:06 PM
Yes yes yes. Thanks whoever started this thread. I am very bolshy about this. I run an English tunes session first sunday of month in kelham island tavern in sheffield. I play many of the tunes slow, compared with many and have had people complain and not come back. However, the scope for making the music interesting at that speed is so much the better. I also find playing tunes at a million miles an hour quite stressful.
This should be fun!

Decent session duly noted. Sadly Dolly May is no longer a Sheffield person so less excuse to get over there (about 90 minutes from here)
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: emdee on July 27, 2011, 09:25:29 AM
the 'overspeeding'  of tunes in sessions  does not only apply to English style playing   and may come from the propensity some Irish sesssion players have for going like 'shit off a shovel'.  That s fine for a stage performance as some may be mightily impressed (& others not so!).  The main problem with flat out stuff is that there is a agreat danger of losing all semblence of musicality - phrasing, dynamics etc becoming a blur.  Another  problem is that it puts  many (good) players off joining in  and precludes tthose who just can't play, if thats what it is, at flat out speed.  Having said that theres no harm in a 'daft 10 minutes' of the 'who can keep up or play fastest'  stuff   as a bit of fun either at the end of a session or as a little interlude in the proceedings.

To me  open sessions should above all be inclusive and  incorporate tunes  covering a range of  natural speeds & degrees of complexity so that most people   get a reasonabale chance of  joining in.  I also strongly dislike  a tune being hijacked & speeded up, particularly if somebody newish to session playing has plucked up the courage to start a tune - It should be played at theeir speed even if its a bit slow & shakey - highjacking could easily put somebody off session playing for life.  I also dislike sessions being hijacked for what amount to solo performances  . Thats fine for singaround/playaround formats but not for inclusive sessions.


george


I totally agree! I  also loathe the 'arrogance' of certain musicians who 'exclude' the rest by their bad mannered playing. It's such a shame because many budding session players get put off by this attitude as well as more experienced players.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2011, 09:45:33 AM
Emdee -have sent you a personal message
george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2011, 10:10:09 AM
Another problem with 'fast' playing ( in addition to many/most not being able to join in) is that a great many who think they can play fast can't!  notes  become blurred and some get missed out & the tune becomes unrecognisable. I remember a ?fidler ?playing an unrecognisable tune at high speed in a session so I asked him what the tune was. Looking very pleased with himself he told me it was the stool of repentance. Now thats a tune i like and which I play regularly - yet I didnt recognise it.

It takes a musician og great skill to play a tune really fast  but still with  skullful  phrasing dynamicss and most importantly making every note crystal clear.  The few who can do this do it in a relaxed way and with no apparent effort - I am definately not one of them!.

Jimmy Shands 1934 recordings of The punch bowl etc and the laird of drumblair  & highlevel hornpipe are good examples being fast but crystal clear. ( they are on the1994 cd Jimmy Shand the king of the melodeon men.) John Kirkpatrick comments on the blurb with the Cd "Shands early playing knocks me sideways, the playing is so exiting, quite manic. he's a real virtuoso"   The CD comes up on ebay occasionally.

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Guy on July 27, 2011, 10:28:50 AM

Jimmy Shands 1934 recordings of The punch bowl etc and the laird of drumblair  & highlevel hornpipe are good examples being fast but crystal clear. ( they are on the1994 cd Jimmy Shand the king of the melodeon men.)
george

Thanks George-I didn't know that this cd existed! Download is doing its stuff (from Amazon) as  I type this....

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: strad on July 27, 2011, 11:04:42 AM
At the session I regularly play at we are blessed (cursed) by a whistle player of the mega-speed variety. Unfortunately he has little idea of session etiquette and when he doesn't know the tune he HARMONISES!
His harmonies have very little to do with the key being played which can be anything between Eb and Emaj.
How to deter him is proving a challenge to us all!

Nigel
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2011, 11:57:02 AM
araldite rapid down his whistle when he goes for a pee!

george ;D
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Alan Morley on July 27, 2011, 12:23:42 PM
araldite rapid down his whistle when he goes for a pee!

george ;D

Sounds painful.. :|bl
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Howard Jones on July 27, 2011, 12:38:42 PM
It takes a musician og great skill to play a tune really fast  but still with  skullful  phrasing dynamicss and most importantly making every note crystal clear. 

It should be said that it also takes considerable skill to play a tune slowly, as any errors in timing, phrasing or dynamics are all the more apparent.  A bit like riding a bike.

As an example of Irish music taken at a lovely steady pace, listen to Martin Hayes and Denis Cahill.
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: TomB on July 27, 2011, 12:52:11 PM
At the session I regularly play at we are blessed (cursed) by a whistle player of the mega-speed variety. Unfortunately he has little idea of session etiquette and when he doesn't know the tune he HARMONISES!
His harmonies have very little to do with the key being played which can be anything between Eb and Emaj.
How to deter him is proving a challenge to us all!

Nigel

Pass the word round the other musos to all stop playing as soon as said whistle player starts to play their 'harmonies' and wait 'till the whistling abates before resuming the tune. Ususlly works for me.
Somewhere on the net, but damned if I can remember where, I found the 'rules of session etiquette'. Good thing to print out and hand round. ( I wouldn't need it of course   :||: >:E).
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: xgx on July 27, 2011, 01:10:34 PM
googled  'rules of session etiquette' and found a few to chose from ... thanks Tom
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2011, 01:42:05 PM
session etiqete  should simply be  something on the lines ' look after each other'  which  would bring out all th positives & get rid of the negatives without any need for a detailed 'list' of how to or how not to behave.

george
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Earbrass on July 27, 2011, 02:56:09 PM
In a previous thread I made analogy between musical expression and "making love" (universally ignored so perhaps "too French" for this forum).

or too "Swiss Toni"?  ;)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr3hP0CeiQo
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: smiley on July 28, 2011, 01:12:43 AM
googled  'rules of session etiquette' and found a few to chose from ... thanks Tom

I hope you found this little classic on the topic: http://www.thesession.org/members/display/707
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 28, 2011, 06:30:48 AM
or too "Swiss Toni"?  ;)  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hr3hP0CeiQo

Excellent! Was trying for the same dryness m'self but their delivery was spot on.  ;D

[edit] thread moving on to humour and oneliners, as is our wont. I have an excellent 'pirate' joke ....  :|glug
Title: Re: English tune sessions - playing too fast?
Post by: emdee on July 28, 2011, 11:59:13 AM


I hope you found this little classic on the topic: http://www.thesession.org/members/display/707

Hilarious!!!!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal