Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Owen Woods on July 22, 2011, 11:54:01 PM

Title: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Owen Woods on July 22, 2011, 11:54:01 PM
Yes - we ordered 4th button reedsets as a feature for the sandpipers - although 3rd is also an option.  The stretch issue Pete McClelland may have spoken of might be an issue for someone with small hands, again though, there's an easy solution. We'll happily switch accidentals over to button 2 if required.

I still maintain a wholetone scale on each row (a fourth apart) is the only sensible diatonic layout though.  Fully chromatic with none of the unnecessary repeats  of a b/c, all keys equally difficult/easy, all octaves in same direction and the range of a G/C and a D/G put together. Of course, you'd need a 24 bass system to take full advantage of it... >:E

Cheers,
J

I've seen that on your website and would love to try it. Maybe one day...
Title: Re: The standard British D/G should be '4th note start' extra low scale+accidentals
Post by: waltzman on July 23, 2011, 12:19:15 AM
Hi Michael

ADG layout. Agreed, I have low A and B on the A row, but it is not always the most convenient place to go for them. I'm still low down the melodeon learning curve, so I don't pretend there aren't other options - many better!

Cheers    John

Thanks,

Michael
Title: Re: The standard British D/G should be '4th note start' extra low scale+accidentals
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 23, 2011, 01:26:05 AM
I've seen that on your website and would love to try it. Maybe one day...

Could someone post a URL for the site, or is it somewhere on the Music Room pages?
Title: Re: The standard British D/G should be '4th note start' extra low scale+accidentals
Post by: Andrew Wigglesworth on July 23, 2011, 07:22:34 AM
I've seen that on your website and would love to try it. Maybe one day...

Sorry for the off-topic question, but: could someone post a URL for the site, or is it somewhere on the Music Room pages?

Try Jon Loomes' signature (below his posts)   :P

I admit that I did a web search before thinking to look there.
Title: Whole tone melodion (was .. diatonics)!
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 23, 2011, 07:34:01 AM
I still maintain a wholetone scale on each row (a fourth apart) is the only sensible diatonic layout though.  Fully chromatic with none of the unnecessary repeats  of a b/c, all keys equally difficult/easy, all octaves in same direction and the range of a G/C and a D/G put together. Of course, you'd need a 24 bass system to take full advantage of it... >:E Cheers,J

Not 'diatonic' is it, as whole tone doesn't map to piano white note intervals, but mathematically the tightest possible! So absolutely perfect for all of us who like to phrase our music across pure augmented and diminished chords!  I do believe the 'ALT' scale may be in there too.  If you could file all the 5ths a semitone flat on the bass, and supply one with a #4th start .. you may have a sale  ;)

   google google - here's a rather nice backing track off youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVgrgILWD9c  in AALT (though 'key' doesn't much matter any more)  >:E
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row "diatonic"
Post by: Theo on July 23, 2011, 08:18:06 AM
I've split this into a new topic.
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row "diatonic"
Post by: Steve_freereeder on July 23, 2011, 09:17:47 AM
Here's Jon Loomes' 2-row whole-tone scale layout:
http://www.jonloomes.com/Jon_Loomes/Instruments_files/Loomes%20Chromatic.jpg

In case anyone is wondering, the whole-tone scale is just what it says: each note of the scale is a whole tone apart from its neighbour, so there are only seven notes in a whole tone scale instead of eight. There are only two whole-tone scales possible, one starting on C and one starting on C#, so you get
C D E F# G# A#(=Bb) C
and
C# D# E#(=F) G A B C#
which between them cover all possible notes. You could equally well envisage the two whole-tone scales starting on G and G#, or Bb and B, etc.; they would fall into one or other of the two 'basic' scales.

Conventional diatonic scales 'flip about' between the two whole-tone scales, so to play a scale of G major for example, you 'flip' as follows:
C D E F# G# A#(=Bb) C D E F# G# A#(=Bb) C
C# D# E#(=F) G A B C# C# D# E#(=F) G A B C#

Whole-tone scales by themselves contain no semitone intervals: all notes have equal harmonic weight. The composer Debussy made much use of whole-tone scales in some of his work, which gives his music his characteristic 'fingerprint' sound.

Back to the melodeon idea, this is intriguing. Has anyone actually built one of these yet? I should love to have a go on it........
On Jon's layout, to play conventional major/minor scales there are four basic fingering patterns to learn which cover all possible scales:
1. starting on the push on the inside row: gives you G, B and Eb scales
2. starting on the pull on the inside row: gives you A, C# and F scales
3. starting on the push on the outside row: gives you D, F# and Bb scales
4. starting on the pull on the outside row: gives you E, G# and C scales

Similarly, RH chords all fall into a similar block of four patterns, there are only four patterns needed for any major or minor triad.

Once you've learnt those four basic patterns, you just shift up or down the rows to give you any other scale, or transpose into another key. So if you want to play in F# major or Bb minor, this is the box for you!

One possible drawback, as I see it, is that there are no alternative push/pull reversals, so to play a scale will always involve a lot of bellows waggling, as there is no possibility of cross-rowing to smooth things out. So you would have to be very nifty with your bellows control to get the effect you need.

Perhaps to make the layout even more flexible (and complex!), it should be a four-row layout, with the extra rows being reversals of the basic two-row layout, so you would have the extra 'G-row' starting with G on the pull, and similarly the extra 'D-row' starting with D on the pull. Then you would have the facility for truly playing any scale entirely on the push or pull. But, the end result would then surely be an overly complex version of an instrument which is already in common use: the continental button accordion!   
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row "diatonic"
Post by: Jon Loomes on July 23, 2011, 11:06:52 AM
Yeah, the whole point was to keep the thing space efficient - The 5 row CBA is as close to a perfect squeezebox as anyone's built yet, but it's essentially monotonic - and too big for morris! - and yes, the "loomes chromatic" is strictly speaking bisonoric, not truly diatonic. However, it does let you do all major scales with only 4 fingering patterns (starting inside row push, inside row pull, outside row push, outside row pull - you could even look at that as 2 fingering patterns in the same way that D and Em are basically the same pattern on a conventional box) - Anyway, the idea was to keep the "bounce" that CBAs don't give you (unless you deliberately change bellows direction to get the effect).

Cheers,
J
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Theo on July 23, 2011, 12:14:08 PM
Intriguing idea Jon,  but for me its a non-starter because of the very limited options for right hand chords (quite apart from the need to learn a completely new set of fingerings)
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Jon Loomes on July 23, 2011, 12:45:51 PM
Well, everything's a compromise!  Major and minor triads are now available in all keys, with a bit of thought dim (or at least half dim) should be possible  - you cant make a dim triad, but this is down to context with the LH bass note. the problem comes when you want to make a +9, +11 or +13. Then again, there's still the same number of button options as a conventional 2 row, so for every harmonic possibility removed, another one is added.  And show me a quint box that can do all that!

Fingering is designed to be as similar as possible to conventional D/G, you just change row at the 4th degree of the scale - only other difference then is that the two notes in the same direction (between 6 and 7) is now moved to 7/8ve, changing back to the original row.

It is almost certainly an evolutionary dead end though - simply because no one is going to build one in a million years!  Having said that, I do have a bunch of spare reeds and an empty hohner R/H somewhere....

Cheers,
J
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Theo on July 23, 2011, 01:07:18 PM
Well, everything's a compromise!  Major and minor triads are now available in all keys,
J

Can't see that from looking at your diagram. D for example D and F# are on push A on pull, and Dm D on push F and A on pull?    Am I looking at the wrong diagram?
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 23, 2011, 01:49:44 PM
WARNING - here be dragons!

I'm sat running scanners at the moment and in dull moments have been following this thread. Have downloaded http://chrisryall.net/scalefinder.xls to assist (needs MS Office). As expected some of the harmonic and particularly melodic minors and their modes are extremely fluid in this system.  

eg B melodic (same notes as BbALT) simply gallops up the outer row apart from it's pull C# (nicely on same button as push B inner row

B Harmonic looks quite playable (2 notes inner row but 2 on 'same button').  Basically the scakes need to have notes ½ or 1½ tones apart and its 'characterisic' Bb-C# gap just falls right   :D

From symmetry considerations (massive here) one can say B+Eb+G 'push' and D+F+Bb 'pull' melodics should 'run' on this kit. This reflecting the division of the scales and their modes into whole tone and diminished chunks.  The harmonics generally aren't quite so fluent.  If one were to invert either row reeds I suspect other melodics would fall 'sweet' but I've run out of time to experiment.  

I've been thinking of starting a 'complete bottom up redesign' thread for some time (just for fun  >:E) and will mull Jon's ideas over.  For example the diminished scales for contain all possible major and minor triads within and might form basis of an instrument to suit me or Theo. But the 3 scales overlap notes and we'd end up with a sort of diaphonic CBA as Steve has hinted. It'd just be a different fingering

Hmmmm ...
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Owen Woods on July 23, 2011, 02:10:43 PM

For example the diminished scales for contain all possible major and minor triads within and might form basis of an instrument to suit me or Theo. But the 3 scales overlap notes and we'd end up with a sort of diaphonic CBA as Steve has hinted. It'd just be a different fingering

Hmmmm ...

Like the Atzarin system? http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,4845.0.html
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Jon Loomes on July 23, 2011, 02:12:14 PM
Ah, yes. I'm talking bollocks.  All major and Minor triads are available on the 3 row version, but not the two, which only gives you 1/2 of them. But if you have a three row, you might as well have a cba.... Back to the drawing board!

Cheers,
J
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Andy Simpson on July 23, 2011, 06:50:32 PM


It is almost certainly an evolutionary dead end though - simply because no one is going to build one in a million years!


....that's what they said about the Octochordeophonium..... ;)
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Owen Woods on July 23, 2011, 11:39:36 PM
So for a three row chromatic bisonoric accordion the choices are between BCC#, Atzarin and Loomes (with the third row being a reversal of the first row).

At some point I might compare the three.
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Flanna on July 24, 2011, 09:52:39 AM
I've looked at many different keyboard layouts for small button accordions/melodeons. The only ones that I think are really good are:

Most folk music is easy to play on a diatonic that has a row in the appropriate key.

For a fully chromatic system I would prefer a small CBA to a semitone diatonic box.

I am seriously considering getting a small 3 row (34 button) CBA with a Hayden style free bass. I think this would be a great box for playing all kinds of music, especially Irish traditional. It would have to be specially made, but well worth waiting for (might have to write to Yves Goubert to see if he could make it  8))
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: OwenG on July 24, 2011, 11:09:48 AM
So for a three row chromatic bisonoric accordion the choices are between BCC#, Atzarin and Loomes (with the third row being a reversal of the first row).

Don't forget Marc Perrone's layout. On a G/C/F box, the G on the C row is sharpened, and C on the F row is sharpened and the E on the F row is flattened. Although it removes the ability to play completely on the row, there are only a couple of bits of finger re-programming required. I'm quite tempted by it.
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 24, 2011, 02:26:25 PM
Don't forget Marc Perrone's layout. On a G/C/F box, the G on the C row is sharpened, and C on the F row is sharpened and the E on the F row is flattened. Although it removes the ability to play completely on the row, there are only a couple of bits of finger re-programming required. I'm quite tempted by it.

I am, too!  And the idea of combining it with a Hayden-inspired bass setup intrigues me even more.  The new Castagnari Mas would be a great box for this layout...
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: george garside on July 24, 2011, 03:27:18 PM
So for a three row chromatic bisonoric accordion the choices are between BCC#, Atzarin and Loomes (with the third row being a reversal of the first row).

At some point I might compare the three.

Its always interesting to look at new possibilities & indeeed to try to invent the perfect layout.  I think however that I will stick wi;th the simplicity of the BCC# system as its only 5 against4 sscales   for all 12 keys aand  the many possible reverses minimises bellows travel and whsilt right hand chords are not infinate as on continental there are enough possibilities to make a decent job with.

george :D
Title: Re: Whole Tone two row bisonoric
Post by: Nick Hudis on July 25, 2011, 11:19:40 AM
Am I wrong (and this is of relevance to a recent thread by Flanna too) but didn't the CBA evolve when someone rearranged the reeds on a 3 row diatonic?

It seems to me that where you want lots of flexibility for cross rowing and right hand harmony, the CBA is the logical evolution of the melodeon.  Perhaps one way to go is smaller lighter CBAs.  I have a suspicion that the lack of bounce on a CBA is as much down to playing style as to the inherent characteristics of the instrument.  There is nothing to stop you using bellows changes on a CBA particularly if it is small and light.

Just one reservation about Jon's ingenious layout is that a 24 bass is going to be significantly heavier in the Bass end than an 8 bass and that will affect use of the bellows more than the total weight of the box.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal