Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Flanna on July 24, 2011, 06:11:02 PM

Title: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 24, 2011, 06:11:02 PM
I am really interested in building a small 3 row CBA  >:E

The best place to start would be with a donor 3 row melodeon. So, what 3 row would be suitable?

I am thinking of treble side, 34 buttons in 11-12-11 format and bass side 12 buttons arranged 2 x 6. I would like it to be as compact and light weight as possible. It would be help if it was a model that is easy to fit new reeds to, as they will all need to be changed. What else, oh yes, I only need 2 voices (MM).
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 24, 2011, 06:56:35 PM
An old Hohner Corona II might be suitable. A friend converted the treble side of a Corona III to a chromatic configuration (not conventional CBA) but left the bass as push-pull ADG which we felt helped retain a bit of the melodeon bounce.

The neatest ready-made 3-row CBA I have come across is the Hohner Amati.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: dahlberg on July 24, 2011, 08:37:09 PM
but why`?
there is 5 times more cbas than melodeons.

would be better doing the reversed.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 24, 2011, 09:38:44 PM
but why`?
there is 5 times more cbas than melodeons.

would be better doing the reversed.

Why?

I like the size of my melodeon, but I find that it is not as versatile as my CBA. So, I would like to try a melodeon sized CBA  :P

The Hohner Amati looks neat but it is too big and heavy for me  :(
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Nick Hudis on July 25, 2011, 10:37:20 AM
I believe that both Castagnari and Saltarelle make smallish CBAs.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: nemethmik on July 25, 2011, 11:09:14 AM
A friend converted the treble side of a Corona III to a chromatic configuration (not conventional CBA) but left the bass as push-pull ADG which we felt helped retain a bit of the melodeon bounce.
This is exactly the Schrammel Harmonika, still in use in Slovenia and USA.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 25, 2011, 11:33:27 AM
I believe that both Castagnari and Saltarelle make smallish CBAs.

If you are willing to consider converting an expensive melodeon then there is no smaller, lighter and better made 3-row than the Castagnari Benny. And this would leave you with the lighter weight diatonic bass rather than the much chunkier Stradella bass of the off-the-shelf Castagnari or Saltarelle CBAs.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Larry Anthony on July 25, 2011, 11:59:16 AM
I converted a fairly new Scarlatti GCF to a CBA. I made the reed blocks 1 and 3 interchangeable so that I could try out both the B and C systems. It all worked out a treat.

Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 25, 2011, 12:11:15 PM
I converted a fairly new Scarlatti GCF to a CBA. I made the reed blocks 1 and 3 interchangeable so that I could try out both the B and C systems. It all worked out a treat.

Now, that looks really good. Did you make complete new reed blocks? Where did you get the "new" reeds from?
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Larry Anthony on July 25, 2011, 12:56:36 PM
Well, being a little chicken, I decided to keep the original reed blocks intact in case it didn't work out, so I made new reed blocks, but I could have used the original ones since the GCF tuning would accommodate the larger reeds. I also left out the thirds on the bass side to make it more versatile. When I found that it worked out so well I drilled some diagonal holes in a piece of hard wood, Stradella style, and spliced that in for the bass buttons.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Inventor on July 25, 2011, 01:14:08 PM
Years ago (1965 if I remember rightly) I did the opposite and converted a small CBA to an A/D/G melodeon.  It was a fairly lightweight 2 voice Hohner 31 button 48 Bass (8x6) Amati. In those days you couldn't get A/D/G Melodeons and D/Gs were pretty rare. There is a photograph of me playing this instrument taken by a very good Folk photographer, Brian Shuel on the web. I have no idea how to reach this direct.
But why go to the trouble of converting a melodeon when you can buy small CBAs anyway.  John Leslie of "Accordions of London" (not to be confused with "London Accordions") lists several small 2 voice 31/34 CBAs in his catalogue. He has a Shop near Kilburn (London) tube station with masses of floor to ceiling Accordions and Melodeons of all kinds. He also always has a showroom at Sidmouth Folk Week (next week) at a Hotel along the promenade. It's well worth a chat with him as he has years of experience of people wanting very specific Accordions & Melodeons.
Inventor.  
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 25, 2011, 01:38:14 PM
A friend converted the treble side of a Corona III to a chromatic configuration (not conventional CBA) but left the bass as push-pull ADG which we felt helped retain a bit of the melodeon bounce.
This is exactly the Schrammel Harmonika, still in use in Slovenia and USA.

I've never seen a Schrammel accordion in the US, but I saw them all the time when I lived in Vienna.  However, I never saw a Schrammel player use the bass!
Whatever kind of 12 bass you use, Flanna, the bass rows should be staggered for the Hayden layout.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Larry Anthony on July 25, 2011, 01:51:07 PM
Well, since I cut my musical teeth on a PA, I feel a Stradella bass is more suitable than a Wicki/Hayden.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: nemethmik on July 25, 2011, 02:06:07 PM
This is exactly the Schrammel Harmonika, still in use in Slovenia and USA.
I've never seen a Schrammel accordion in the US
Lou Trebar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G49gjw5iDdo
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 25, 2011, 02:22:05 PM
Lou Trebar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G49gjw5iDdo

Miki, Lou is dead, so "still in use" doesn't really apply, does it?
This is a Schrammel accordion:
http://schrammelharmonika.nonfoodfactory.org/ (http://schrammelharmonika.nonfoodfactory.org/)
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2011, 02:51:34 PM
royal standard made a very small 3 row continental with , I think, 32bass. It was about the size of a honer pokerwork or maybe a bit smaller.  It played very well  indeed & had nice 2 voice tuning.  I have only ever seen the one  but am fairly sure it was normal production model, perhaps privately imported to the UK.

george
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 25, 2011, 03:32:02 PM
royal standard made a very small 3 row continental with , I think, 32bass. It was about the size of a honer pokerwork or maybe a bit smaller.  It played very well  indeed & had nice 2 voice tuning.  I have only ever seen the one  but am fairly sure it was normal production model, perhaps privately imported to the UK.

george

Thanks, George, that sounds like exactly what I would love to try.

Does anyone know more about them? Perhaps the model name?
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2011, 03:39:31 PM
me too! 

george
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Owen Woods on July 25, 2011, 04:22:44 PM
And me! Would make a nice BCC# :P
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: george garside on July 25, 2011, 04:24:56 PM
indeed!

george
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Chris Ryall on July 25, 2011, 05:09:44 PM
Was with Joel Stewart in France and he had a Castagnari 3 row recently converted to CBA (AFAIR by Theo). He's very pleased with it and got the reeds from a wrecked PA.  Has kept the 2-way melodeon bass to avoid temptation to play too legato

Flanna might note that most of the weight of a box is in the reeds and can be cut down by having fewer octaves, and only 1-2 voices. It's then a matter of whether that would suit her style of play.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Theo on July 25, 2011, 05:28:06 PM
I have converted a Castagnari Benny to cba.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Sandy Flett on July 25, 2011, 06:17:38 PM
I have converted a Castagnari Benny to cba.

Is it possible to buy instruments (such as the Benny) without reeds from Castagnari - to save having the expensive Castagnari reeds sitting in a drawer once the conversion using other reeds has been made?
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on July 25, 2011, 07:33:59 PM
Is it possible to buy instruments (such as the Benny) without reeds from Castagnari - to save having the expensive Castagnari reeds sitting in a drawer once the conversion using other reeds has been made?

Why wouldn't you just order the (CBA) layout that you want from Castagnari.  (And: you might even be able to get the keyboard set up as 11-12-11.)
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 27, 2011, 07:03:16 PM
Why wouldn't you just order the (CBA) layout that you want from Castagnari.  (And: you might even be able to get the keyboard set up as 11-12-11.)

I've heard that Castagnari take a long time to complete a custom order. And they don't always get it exactly the way it was ordered. Of course this might not be true but I thought it would be fun to convert an old melodeon first to see what it's like as a CBA. If the layout works well then I'd order one from a small independent accordeon maker.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Theo on July 27, 2011, 09:10:58 PM
A three row hohner, as suggested previously would be the cheapest route.  A trichord would be slightly better than acorona as the basses would not need changing.  In either case you could get a set of pa reeds that would do the treble side
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: george garside on July 27, 2011, 10:08:08 PM
if ordering  a custom Made 3 rOw cOntinental I would wnat to squeeze in  at least 32 sradella - 8x4 counterbass, bass, major & minor & would prefer 40 bass to Include 7ths.  Even better would be  48 12x4 to cover the minor keys even if it meant having only 2 voice bass.  Of course the same design with a decent air hole would also work well as a small BCC#


george
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: dahlberg on July 29, 2011, 11:56:50 AM
http://www.blocket.se/halland/Helt_nytt_dragspel_35157234.htm?ca=1_9&w=3 (http://www.blocket.se/halland/Helt_nytt_dragspel_35157234.htm?ca=1_9&w=3)
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 29, 2011, 03:52:07 PM
http://www.blocket.se/halland/Helt_nytt_dragspel_35157234.htm?ca=1_9&w=3 (http://www.blocket.se/halland/Helt_nytt_dragspel_35157234.htm?ca=1_9&w=3)

Thanks. That looks really interesting. It would be ideal to try small CBA on.
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: george garside on July 29, 2011, 04:09:30 PM
it IS a small C sytem   continental!

george :D
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Flanna on July 29, 2011, 05:23:49 PM
it IS a small C sytem   continental!

george :D

Ahem... Let's pretend that we haven't seen it...  :-X

I'm trying to contact the seller...   ;)
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Peter Stormy Hyde on July 31, 2011, 11:28:25 AM
I am really interested in building a small 3 row CBA  >:E

The best place to start would be with a donor 3 row melodeon. So, what 3 row would be suitable?

I am thinking of treble side, 34 buttons in 11-12-11 format and bass side 12 buttons arranged 2 x 6. I would like it to be as compact and light weight as possible. It would be help if it was a model that is easy to fit new reeds to, as they will all need to be changed. What else, oh yes, I only need 2 voices (MM).

Sorry to “butt in” on this post but it has got my grey cells working, as I have been asked to make a 5 rower C system in the past that I have refused as I did not want to go for the 120 bass. The 5 rows on the treble side I can handle but I would rather not.
But what you want is a far different “kettle of fish”

What you want would fit into my full size instrument (pokerwork size 280mm x 150mm) with stops all round.
I have the idea that this instrument could be made an octave jump (BT) or you might call it (LM) where there is 2 stops on the treble side so that it can be played either both reeds together or in either octave, it could be taken the other way so that you had (TS) or (MH.)
Bass side could be built using stops to cut out the normal low fundamental and the 3rd giving your bass more scope.

I did make a bass similar for a jazz player in the States who wanted a B/C with a bass made up from 12 individual notes (with 3 octaves to each note) and a slide to cut out one octave. Then the next box I made for him he had the same again but with only 2 octaves to each note and a slide so he could turn it into a single voice bass, he had me lay it out so he could make any chord that he needed.

I’m not suggesting for one moment that you order a box from me, but what other ideas might you have to try and make a small CBA that might be useful for the traveling performer who would like a small one, you have obviously put a lot of thought into it and it might be worth my while to make one on speck at some stage?

I would very much like the input of yourself or anybody else that has any more bright ideas.
Peter
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Keithypete. on August 06, 2011, 12:04:27 AM
   I wonder if the red instrument in these pictures might be of interest to you:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/keithypete/with/5593786338/  ? It claims to be a Borsini - I think it would be ideal!

 It is discussed in this thread: http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,6569.0.html
Title: Re: What 3 row melodeon could be converted to CBA?
Post by: Theo on August 06, 2011, 03:01:56 PM
Or this Hohner Organola CBA.  It is about the same size as a Hohner Corona/Corso/Trichord.  34 treble buttons, 24 bass arranged 3 x 8.  It needs a reed overhaul, bellows re-tape and a few other bits of maintenance but it is basically sound.    Or could put B/C/C# reeds in the treble side for George.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal